Compare And Contrast Malcolm X And Martin Luther King
Malcolm X and Martin Luther King were civil rights leaders trying to give equal rights to African Americans during the 1960s. Both men had ideas involving changing schools, affecting the economy, and retaliating when being discriminated against. Malcolm X's philosophy included segregated schools, black nationalism, and taking a violent approach to end the discrimination of African Americans. Martin Luther King's philosophy consisted of integrating schools, boycotting the economy, and taking a nonviolent approach to the segregation African Americans faced. Both had separate ideas but went about them in very different ways. Martin Luther King's philosophy makes the most sense and was most accepted by people in the 1960s as it enabled both African …show more content…
believed in boycotting businesses as a way to be taken seriously instead of using violence. The text states many of King's nonviolent protests revolved around economic tactics. He took to heart the saying, “‘If you want to hurt a man, hit him in his wallet.’ The Montgomery Bus Boycott, the sit-ins, and the S.C.L.C. campaigns in various southern cities were all designed to inflict financial pain on the white business community. Businesses would then put pressure on the local political authorities to revise their segregated laws.” Boycotting businesses brought change to the civil rights movement. Many businesses lost money because people would not purchase products from businesses that would not hire African Americans. To combat their loss of revenue, businesses had to make changes and hire African Americans. This brought about the lessening of segregation because African Americans and whites started working together more. Malcolm X's vision of economic policies was based on community. He wanted African Americans to support one another and believed in black nationalism. Malcolm thought, “...people must take control of their destiny, empower themselves and not rely on outside forces for help. He was very concerned if black Americans simply demanded more jobs and higher pay at white-owned businesses, then the structure of the economy would not change enough.” This way of thinking did not help gain any trust or foundation but created more of a divide. Also, Malcolm X´s policy technically would take many years to implement, using just African American products and money to fund their
Compare And Contrast Malcolm X And Martin Luther King Jr
457 Words | 2 PagesMalcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr's techniques are very different, but similar. They both want the same thing: negro companies. The way they carry out this, though, is different. Malcolm wants to make his own negro company. Furthermore, Martin wants to protest peacefully by banning products from companies that do not hire negroes.
Compare And Contrast Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X
910 Words | 4 PagesThis is due to the fact that, while violence can be used to justify additional tyranny, nonviolent resistance appeals to the moral conscience of both those in authority and the general public. This was acknowledged by King, who wrote in his well-known Letter from Birmingham Jail that "violence, as a way of achieving racial justice, is both impractical and immoral" (Morant, 2019). Therefore, King's adherence to nonviolence was not only a moral decision but also a calculated one. King's emphasis on coalition-building distinguishes his philosophy from Malcolm X's in another way. King understood that in order to make a significant change, it would have the support of not only Black Americans but also White Americans and other marginalized groups.
Compare And Contrast Malcolm X And Martin Luther King Jr
595 Words | 3 PagesMalcolm X believed violence was necessary for protecting yourself. He also wanted African-Americans to have the same rights as whites, but they wanted to maintain separation. King and Malcolm's viewpoints were both coherent. First, Martin Luther had a philosophy that America should be integrated.
Comparison Of Letter From Birmingham Jail And Malcolm X
2022 Words | 9 PagesDespite this opposition, King's message of nonviolent resistance prevailed and became a blueprint for social change in the United States. As shown from current day, nonviolent resistance was more effective in bringing about lasting social change. His stance was targeted towards the hypocrisy of White Americans, who did not have a significant opinion on the civil rights movement, and the oppressed Black Americans. His argument was able to create a disruption in the status quo and force those in power to address the underlying issue. However, it was also during this period King’s ideas were often questioned by those following behind him as many protestors questioned if such passive disobedience would achieve their goals of
Compare And Contrast Malcolm X And Mlk
724 Words | 3 PagesWhat led up to Malcolm's speech was almost the same reasons for MLK's speech. He also was very determined to get the blacks employed and have an economy. So as a black man, he wanted to stand up for his and every black person's rights. MLK changed history by giving his speech, and by protesting and boycotting. And Malcolm X changed history by starting the black community and getting them jobs and income.
Compare Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X
468 Words | 2 Pages" Malcom X did not like how African Americans were being treated in America, It was a problem and he realized that and knew it needed to change. In relizing this, Malcom X decided to fight for a change for African Americans in America as in paragraph 5 Malcome x stated, “I don't see an American dream I see an American nightmare" Malcolm X would not stop until change happened he did care what it took including violence, Malcolm X would never ask for a fight, but he would never back down from one in paragraph 7 Malcolm X stated “It'll be Molotov cocktails this month hand grenades
Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X Similarities
1336 Words | 6 PagesMalcolm X, a Muslim, believed in the power of self-defense and black nationalism. He advocated for the separation of the races and the establishment of a separate black nation. While Malcolm X and Martin Luther King Jr. had different philosophies and approaches to the civil rights movement, they both shared a common goal of achieving equality and justice for Black Americans. They both recognized the injustices of racism and discrimination and worked to bring about social change through nonviolent
Malcolm X Dbq Essay
498 Words | 2 PagesBasic to the philosophy of nonviolence is the refusal to cooperate with evil. There is nothing quite so effective as a refusal to cooperate economically with the forces and institutions which perpetuate evil in our communities.” (Martin Luther King Jr’s “Nonviolence: The Only Road to Freedom” Document F) This supports the claim that Martin Luther King Jr didn’t preach violence, only retaliation. By attacking the economy but not attacking people or communities.
African American Civil Rights: Dr. King Vs. Malcolm X
809 Words | 4 PagesCivil rights for African Americans are beneficial for the United States as a country either using violent or nonviolent methods to achieve this goal. African American civil rights have been fighting for over many years and the most used civil rights movement's methods have been by non violence used by Martin Luther King Jr. and violence used by Malcolm X. Dr. King and Malcolm X both respected civil rights movement leaders have used violence and nonviolence to their advantage to achieve the goal of African American civil rights. Both respected leaders conducted many acts to achieve the same reward with contrasting methods, even with Dr. King is Christian and Malcolm X a Muslim. America should have confronted the inequalities of the 1960’s by creating a peaceful protest and movement, but if civil rights and peace for are not given, then violence protests should take place in a certain amount of time.
Malcolm X Dbq
898 Words | 4 PagesWhile the two had a common goal of ending racial discrimination and achieving equality, Martin Luther King Jr. has the better approach of nonviolence and peaceful resistance. King explains his approach in a way that would be the best solution to problems confronted by the Black community, as in Document 5, He states, “Nonviolent direct action seeks to create such a crisis and establish such creative tension that a community that has constantly refused to negotiate is forced to confront the issue. It seeks so to dramatize the issue that it can no longer be ignored.” His strategy of nonviolent resistance, which included boycotts, sit-ins, and peaceful protests, put pressure on political leaders and the public to address the systemic inequalities faced by black Americans. This is deemed to be successful as his approach lead to the passage of landmark civil rights legislation, including the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
Peaceful Protest Vs. Retaliation: Which Civil Rights Philosophy Was Best?
1602 Words | 7 PagesThe occurrences mostly served as attention gatherers for the issue, but usually resulted in a negative impact and impression for the people trying to gain freedoms. Those who wished to not cause harm and where discouraged by violence would steer away from Malcolm X’s philosophy, and would find guidance in the practices of another civil rights leader of the time, Martin Luther King
Malcolm X Dbq Analysis
563 Words | 3 PagesMLK and Malcolm X both wanted equality but in different ways. Martin Luther King believed in nonviolence to end segregation. However, Malcolm X believed in segregation; where African Americans would govern themselves without bothering the whites. But which idea was better for society? Malcolm X’s philosophy offers a variety of solutions for
Philosophical Differences Between Martin Luther King And Malcolm X
1512 Words | 7 PagesMLK’s “I have a dream” speech promoted the idea of integration. He believed that the races were created equal and that blacks should be respected as American citizens. Malcolm X followed Muslim principles and believed that he would protest “by any means necessary.” He would do whatever needed in order to obtain freedom for African-Americans whether it be violence or nonviolent. Malcolm opposed integration and believed that blacks needed to fend for themselves in the fight against whites.
Similarities Between Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X
525 Words | 3 PagesMalcolm X didn’t agree with what King’s views, he believed that MLK’s dream was not a dream but a nightmare. Martin Luther King Jr’s approach to civil rights and equality was non-violent protesting, sit-ins, and getting as much people together as possible while not using violence. However, Malcolm X’s approach to this was almost the opposite. He was against the views of whites and he was willing to do whatever was needed to achieve
Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X Comparison Essay
1125 Words | 5 PagesMalcolm X pushed for the idea of being able to build own shops, and business, Malcolm X knew this would bring in income and stability for the black communities. Malcolm X expressed his beliefs in his book “The Last Years of Malcolm X: Evolution of a Revolutionary,1967. Malcolm states, “..(W)e have to learn how to own and operate the businesses of our community and develop them into some type of industry that will enable us to create employment for the people of our community so they won’t have to constantly be involved in picketing and boycotting other people in other communities in order to get a job” (Document G). Malcolm X justified the reason to start building communities, instead of protesting for the right to be able to go into a white-owned store. King was engaged in nonviolent protests,
More about Compare And Contrast Malcolm X And Martin Luther King
Compare And Contrast Malcolm X And Martin Luther King Jr
457 Words | 2 PagesCompare And Contrast Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X
910 Words | 4 PagesCompare And Contrast Malcolm X And Martin Luther King Jr
595 Words | 3 PagesComparison Of Letter From Birmingham Jail And Malcolm X
2022 Words | 9 PagesCompare And Contrast Malcolm X And Mlk
724 Words | 3 PagesCompare Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X
468 Words | 2 PagesMartin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X Similarities
1336 Words | 6 PagesMalcolm X Dbq Essay
498 Words | 2 PagesAfrican American Civil Rights: Dr. King Vs. Malcolm X
809 Words | 4 PagesMalcolm X Dbq
898 Words | 4 PagesPeaceful Protest Vs. Retaliation: Which Civil Rights Philosophy Was Best?
1602 Words | 7 PagesMalcolm X Dbq Analysis
563 Words | 3 PagesPhilosophical Differences Between Martin Luther King And Malcolm X
1512 Words | 7 PagesSimilarities Between Martin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X
525 Words | 3 PagesMartin Luther King Jr And Malcolm X Comparison Essay
1125 Words | 5 Pages