ipl-logo

Great Gatsby Book Vs Movie Essay

910 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The great gatsby literary theme essay

The Great Gatsby

There are two The Great Gatsby movies out their, the 1974 movie directed by Jack Clayton, and the 2013 movie directed by Baz Luhrmann. The novel was originally written in 1925, by author F. Scott Fitzgerald. And wasn 't actually noticed as a great book until he was already passed away. If I were to have to say which movie F. Scott Fitzgerald would prefer more, I would say the 2013 film.

I believe the scenes showed in the 2013 movie, directed by Baz Luhrmann, would be more appreciated by F. Scott Fitzgerald. Rather than the 1974 movie, directed by Jack Clayton. I think the 2013 film does a better job, showing the scenes and making them look good. They are more exciting and alive, and show better detail overall from the book. …show more content…

Scott Fitzgerald would definitely like to see details he had in the book in the movie. He would for sure prefer the 2013 film over the 1974 film. In the new movie, the giant party scene. I believe Fitzgerald would definitely admire the detail put into the party scene for the new movie. In the movie scene it starts with Nick admiring the whole entire event. Nick runs into Jordan Baker, whose friend Lucille, speculates that Gatsby was a German spy during the war. Nick and Jordan, curious about their host, set out to find Gatsby. But instead, they run into a middle aged man with owl eyes. Sitting in Gatsby 's library. At midnight, Nick and Jordan, go outside to watch the entertainment. They sit at a table with a handsome young man who says who says that Nick looks familiar. They realized that they served in the same division during the war. The man introduces himself as Jay Gatsby. Fitzgerald would definitely prefer the newer movie, because the party just looks so much more crazy and fun. Just how he wrote it, there 's people dancing and drinking everywhere. Fireworks are going off, people are jumping into pools. Musicians doing their thing. In the older movie all we see is people dancing and jumping into the fountain. We don’t see all the extra detail like thats in the first one. So I believe Fitzgerald would prefer this scene of the newer movie than the older movie cause of the good detail put into

Show More
Related
497 Words | 2 Pages

One huge difference in the setting, in the book the story takes place on the shore of lake Michigan in a brand new apartment building in a small town. On the other hand the movie takes place old, run down apartment in the middle of a huge city. Another example is the characters, in the book there are 16 heirs with eight pairs. In the movie there are 10 heirs and 5 pairs. Also the movie leaves out some huge characters like Theo Theodorakis, Flora Baumbach, and

Read More
651 Words | 3 Pages

I wanted the book and the movie be the same or at least similar. If someone wants to make a movie based on a book, they should be similar. The movie had a complete different

Read More
725 Words | 3 Pages

Party Scene at Myrtle’s and Tom Apartment The Great Gatsby talks about in the book the party room in a different way then it does in the movie. In the next couple pages Im going to talk about the different ways that they talk about the party room. The Great Gatsby film was under the direction of Baz Luhrman’s. The Great Gatsby book was written by F. Scott Fitzgerald. As in this essay I will give my opinion on what one I like better when they describe the party room.

Read More
1805 Words | 8 Pages

Anna Ryan Professor Becky Harris ENG 101 (013) March 10, 2023 What Makes A Great Trailer as Great as Gatsby: A Rhetorical Analysis of the Trailer for the Film The Great Gatsby (2012) Though set in the roaring 1920s, the trailer for the film The Great Gatsby (2012) contains modern thrills, and Leonardo DiCaprio, to transform F. Scott Fitzgerald’s original novel into a suspenseful live action film. Directed by Baz Lurhmann, who notorious for his work with romance drama films, The Great Gatsby (2012) incorporates elements of romance while producing dramatic anticipation unlike any other adaptation of the story. Though based on a novel, the film and the trailer capture a brilliant visual telling of the story of the 1920s American dream, greed,

Read More
486 Words | 2 Pages

The Accuracies and Inaccuracies of The Great Gatsby The 2013 Baz Luhrmann film adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel The Great Gatsby is both historically accurate and historically inaccurate. While the film takes place in 1922 many items featured in this film such as Gatsby’s car were not made until the late 20s or early 30s. Even though there are quite a few inaccuracies, many things are accurate.

Read More
596 Words | 3 Pages

Daniel Aguirre Ms. Tobias English III GT - 6th 12 January 2017 After analyzing both the movie and the novel, I have discovered similarities and differences. Ill try to compare and contrast the two since the movie does not depict the story exactly as how the novel does. Similarities There were still some similarities in the film that tied back to the book. One of the main ones is when Nick walks to Gatsby’s backyard and finds him standing at the edge of his dock reaching out to what was a green light.

Read More
659 Words | 3 Pages

The term oikonomia is defined as the law of the house. The economist is the person who will take on the job to create the laws of the house. As we see today, our economy is a massive makeup of various ways to manage our society. Whether managed properly or mismanaged, the economist influences their economy strongly. Economy in general can function in many different ways, as we see in the literature works, “Gimpel The Fool”, “Where Are You Going?

Read More
305 Words | 2 Pages

It can be suggested that Williams demonstrates that power is something to be desired rather than purely a tool for control because the protagonist Blanche is shown to be a symbol of vulnerability. At the exposition, Blanche is dialogue would suggest a sense of vulnerability when she says, “I’ve got to keep hold of myself.” This vulnerability would be detected by audiences because it suggests that Blanche seemingly has no control over her situation or the fears that seem to be oppressing themselves upon her. This demonstrates that power is presented by Williams as something to be desired because Blanche’s almost despondent tone suggests that she needs to have some power to replace this vulnerability and weakness. Furthermore, it is the use of

Read More
668 Words | 3 Pages

Casandra Salazar Ms. Tobias English III GT 12 January 2017 The Great Gatsby After reading and watching The Great Gatsby, I gathered the dissemblance and alikeness in both the book and motion picture. As written in “The Great Gatsby”, the first example of similarity is that the book has the same theme to the “Roaring 20’s”. In the written book, Fitzgerald described the parties as huge and dramatic, where as in the movie, the directors did a fantastic job translating Fitzgerald’s words into a lavish visual spectacle of booze, sequins, and confetti.

Read More
1718 Words | 7 Pages

The main party scene is a great example of this contrast in music in the two movies. The 1974 past version uses the song called “Jordan’s Tango” by Nelson Riddle which is a song produced with ragtime and jazz components of the 1920’s to get crowds of this time moving. While this song was played in the movie there was a huge carnival tent popped out in front of J. Gatsby’s mansion, while this tent was more appropriate for this time it didn't really connect to the viewers because it was more seen as a precipitly placed circus tent. While in the 2013 present movie version, the party scene was larger, grander, and bombarding the viewer with the feel of a party. The party was boisteriously flowing out of Gatsby's mansion, as implied by the book, and draped all of its attendees with alcohol and glitter.

Read More
1804 Words | 8 Pages

Such as the fact that Nick never meets Tom and Myrtle’s downstairs neighbors, the McKee’s, directly, how Daisy gave Gatsby his name because he introduced himself as Jay Gatz, and how Myrtle never purchased the dog directly though it is still present in the movie. There is also the fact that Gatsby and Nick are not introduced the same way as they are in the book. In the book Nick is sitting at a table with Jordan and Gatsby and mentions that he hasn’t seen the host. Nick still mentions that in the book, but Gatsby mentions Nick over without Jordan in sight changing that small piece of the storyline. The other minor difference that you pick up in the movie that you do not see throughout the book is that Daisy looks like she knows Gatsby is poor when she meets him, which changes the way their relationship is perceived.

Read More
968 Words | 4 Pages

The 1925 novel, The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald is considered to be an American classic and is one of the most widely-read books in modern America. There have been several film versions of the novel, most recently a 2013 version that was directed by Baz Luhrmann. Although, both the book and the film effectively portrayed the energy of the 1920s, the characters in the book and the film were not so well-aligned. In particular, the characters in the novel are complex, well-rounded people, whereas the movie tends to paint many of the key characters as simplistic archetypes. Unlike Daisy’s nuanced character in the novel, Luhrmann portrays her as the helpless victim of the film.

Read More
853 Words | 4 Pages

Based off the book, the movie is extremely similar. However, the flaws exist. Some of the scenes became over the top and extravagant. The scene at Myrtle and Tom’s apartment seemed slightly overdone. The book never said that the party became wild and out of control, just that Nick and the others drank to the point of intoxication.

Read More
1242 Words | 5 Pages

The entire plot of the movie “The Great Gatsby,” directed by Baz Luhrmann, is pretty much very accurate to the novel of the same name written by author F. Scott Fitzgerald. They both center around a man named Jay Gatsby who throws extravagant parties in hope that one day his love Daisy will wander in. Of course like all movies that are based off of books they all have their similarities and differences. Whether they be very small or very noticeable, sometimes even changing the entire story completely, they are still there. Sometimes the purpose of this could be that the director wants to add their own little twist to the story or it could be that they are going for a much deeper meaning or symbolism.

Read More
803 Words | 4 Pages

In The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzerald expresses a negative view of the 1920's and the American Dream. He does this using the characters, setting, and symbolism. One character Fitzgerald uses to show his view of the 1920s is Nick. Nick doesn't have much of an effect on the story, he just observes everything as it happens and makes silent judgements of those around him. The reader experiences the story through his eyes and sees the world the way Nick perceives it.

Read More

More about Great Gatsby Book Vs Movie Essay

Related Topics

Open Document