ipl-logo

Comparing Ralph And Jack In Lord Of The Flies By William Golding

422 Words2 Pages

In the book Lord of the Flies by William Golding there are two boys named Ralph and Jack who have some similarities but have far more differences.Those differences go beyond physical appearance. It is also their mentality. They do very different things that say a lot about them. Jack and Ralph both had darkness in their hearts, but Jack’s darkness manifested itself through his leadership style and behavior. Both Jack and Ralph stepped up to the leadership role, but they both had versatile styles of leadership. Unlike Ralph, Jack has no problem with punishing the boys. At one point Jack punishes Wilfred by tying him up and beating him for no apparent reason. When Roger asks,”What for?” Robert replies,I don't know. He didn't say. He got angry and made us tie Wilfred up. He's been"--he giggled excitedly--"he's been tied for hours, waiting--" (124) This shows how aggressive he is and shows the darkness in his heart. He is also not afraid to belittle someone, unlike Ralph who is more likely to use more constructive criticism . Jack assess the problem directly while Ralph calls meetings and asses it indirectly. …show more content…

They both may want to help the boys but the way they act affects it. Jack becoming a savage and a bully shows that he has the most darkness in his heart. He is a person who uses strength or power to harm or intimidate those who are weaker, like Piggy. “ Piggy spoke, also dribbling. "Aren't I having none?" Jack had meant to leave him in doubt, as an assertion of power; but Piggy by advertising his omission made more cruelty necessary. "You didn't hunt." "No more did Ralph," said Piggy wetly, "nor Simon." He amplified.”This shows how cruel he is to the weak. Jack wants to help the boys but only wants the best. Jack believes in survival of the fittest, while Ralph wants to help everybody. Ralph is a very honest person and the boys respect him for that. He is a very mindful leader and would help everyone unlike

Show More
Related

  • How Did Jack And Ralph Survive In Lord Of The Flies

    640 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout the book, it is clear that Jack and Ralph are at odds on their ideas of survival. They butt heads whenever a discussion goes on. Jack follows the savage path, and Ralph follow the civil path. Both of their confrontations followed different path as they went on. The first confrontation went more smoothly than the second, yet both had their bumps.

    Read More

  • Ralph And Jack's Leadership In Lord Of The Flies

    1231 Words  | 5 Pages

    Rescue is what will truly make the boys happy, seeing their families and parents, getting back to civilization, and school, eating healthy, being clean. This is all what the boys really needed. A second reason why Ralph’s style of leadership was better than Jack’s is because Ralph was concerned about the boy’s safety, and earnestly cared about them. Unlike Jack who only cared for himself like a dictator, which is not good leadership because then boys could get hurt, lost, left behind, forgotten about, and much more things. It's evident in the novel that Jack didn't care for the boys because it says he hated the littluns, and everyone who wasn't of use to him.

    Read More

  • A Symbolic Moment In Lord Of The Flies Quote Analysis

    636 Words  | 3 Pages

    The boys could have easily chosen Jack instead of Ralph, especially given the fact that Jack had previous experience as a leader; he is first seen surrounded by a group of faithful followers, his choir group, that continue to obey him on the island. Even Piggy, who showed support towards Ralph from the beginning, is intimidated by Jack's authoritative demeanor. However, Jack is missing that key characteristic that made Ralph so appealing: the symbol of power and strength. Any sense of leadership that Jack held was overshadowed by the image of Ralph standing confidently with the conch shell in hand. Ultimately, the young boys identified Ralph as their leader based on the power they believed he symbolized.

    Read More

  • Corrupt Leaders In Lord Of The Flies Quote Analysis

    856 Words  | 4 Pages

    After Jack says that he meant Piggy's death, he throws a spear at Ralph with the intent of harming him, showing the tribe he isn't to be messed with. Though Jack is corrupt with power, the boys are fearful of what he will do to those who oppose him and his

    Read More

  • Jack Merridew's Leadership

    1657 Words  | 7 Pages

    As the civilized boys fear Jack every second of the day, Piggy and Ralph have a discussion and want to “ keep on the right side of him, anyhow. You can’t tell what he might do” (Golding 175). At this point, one of their fellow members, Simon, has already been put to death by Jack’s tribe and now the boys have to fear for their lives because of the unknown status of Jack at any time. Golding uses this type of language to represent fear in their voices because it is one of a leader 's most powerful tools for controlling a society. Jack teaches acts of killing and savagery of humans and other living animals, draining out every last ounce of civility the boys had upon their

    Read More

  • Essay On Lord Of The Flies Ralph And Jack's Relationship

    807 Words  | 4 Pages

    No plagiarism detected The relationship between Ralph and Jack was at first very close and secure, but as the story moved on, Jack’s jealousy of Ralph being the leader caused their relationship to become strained, to the extent of hatred and rivalry. The close relationship at first can be represented by this quote “three of us will go on an expedition and find out. I’ll go, and Jack, and, and…”which was written right after Ralph was chosen as the leader of the tribe.

    Read More

  • Comparing Lord Of The Flies And The Finest Hours, By Craig Gillespie

    1502 Words  | 7 Pages

    In Lord of the Flies, there are two distinct roles played by the main leaders of the island, Ralph and Jack. Ralph personifies civilization while Jack personifies savagery. This is because Ralph is very orderly and only wants to be rescued while Jack believes it is necessary to hunt and kill. Jack is more bloodthirsty and fails to follow Ralph’s rules as he has different opinions about the priorities. Jack questions

    Read More

  • Ralph And Jack's Leadership In Lord Of The Flies

    571 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the Lord of the Flies written by William Golding is a novel focused on conflict. Conflict is very shown throughout the book using the two characters Ralph and Jack’s by incorporating their leadership skills. Ralph is more precise and wants things to get done. He wants to make sure the group of boys are safe with shelters, food,or water. Although, Jack is the type of leader to focus more on controlling the other boys and hunting to gain respect.

    Read More

  • Essay On Ralph In Lord Of The Flies

    434 Words  | 2 Pages

    Although Jack expresses strong desire to become chief, the boys elect Ralph as a leader, suggesting an air of charisma that made him worthy of his position. He believes a leader has to “think, be wise… grab at a decision”, someone who can look after others and keep the group in

    Read More

  • Power Corrupt In Lord Of The Flies

    1511 Words  | 7 Pages

    Piggy is fat, brilliant, lacking in social graces, and wears glasses, in other words the outsider on this island. Due to Piggy being such an foreigner, Jack feels that he is above Piggy, and feels better when he causes Piggy pain and sorrow. For example, “‘You’re talking too much,’ said Jack Merridew. ‘Shut up Fatty,’” (21). In this scene you can see power in Piggy’s lack thereof.

    Read More

  • Essay On Lord Of The Flies Ralph And Jack Relationship

    574 Words  | 3 Pages

    In chapters 6 and 7, there are more signs of Jack and everyone else disobeying Ralph, implying the further strain of Jack and Ralph’s relationship.    In Chapter 8, Ralph angered Jack simply by calling him and his hunters cowardly and ineffective. In response, he unsuccessfully tries to impeach Ralph then permanently runs away into the forest, with many others joining him. A small provocation from Ralph causing Jack to form his own separate group shows how volatile the tension in their relationship now is. It can also be seen that Jack now fully rejects Ralph’s leadership in favour of his own.

    Read More

  • Ralph In William Golding's Lord Of The Flies

    213 Words  | 1 Pages

    Ralph also gives an idea of building huts. Meanwhile Jack focuses on hunting. Instead of helping out with the others wth building shelters , he refuses and takes on the idea of every man for himself. Also Jack is vicious with

    Read More

  • How Is Ralph Successful In Lord Of The Flies

    736 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the book Lord of The Flies by William Golding, we realize that Ralph is not the stronger person but he does understand people more than what Jack does. Ralph uses his good qualities to help their society survive on the island. We all know that young kids like the boys need good leadership and stability so they have a better chance of living longer till they get saved. If they get saved. Ralph then goes and creates rules that all the boys need to follow by in order to keep everything under control.

    Read More

  • Jack And Ralph In Lord Of The Flies

    857 Words  | 4 Pages

    Especially one as dire and consequential as the boys are put in. Ralph and Jack take it very different ways. While Ralph tries to keep the peace and fails his attempts to sustain civilization, Jack quickly hops on the well-I-guess-we-are-stuck-here train and forms a small tribe of choir boys who stab pigs with sharp sticks. Both have the qualities of a leader. Ralph focuses on the diplomacy and peace but Jack is closer to a savage, ready to survive rather than thrive which is the start of both boys conflict.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Ralph And Jack In Lord Of The Flies

    773 Words  | 4 Pages

    The first difference between Ralph and Jack is that they have different ways of organizing things on the island. Ralph wants to lead everyone to work together to get off the island in a civilized order. Jack also wants to lead everyone but not in the same, properly ordered way as Ralph. When they first meet on the island, everyone who was stranded on the island wanted to be organized into some type of governing body so that they were ordered.

    Read More

More about Comparing Ralph And Jack In Lord Of The Flies By William Golding

Open Document