ipl-logo

Constitution Of The United States: Argument Analysis

1566 Words7 Pages

Spencer Kersey
5/8/2016
7th Period
Which side has the biggest BUT?
First of all, to get this off my chest, I would like to allow the view of the argument to be known. The view that will be provided today is the obvious, but correct answer which is also known as the confederate view which says that seceding is 100% correct no matter what anyone says or thinks. As many know the topic of secession would have to be in the constitution for it to be wrong, but this isn’t the case. Before the constitution was made and put into commission there was the Articles of Confederation which was a very loose agreement that didn’t say anything about states from the Confederation seceding from it since it was more like a written and signed alliance between …show more content…

To start off with we know the side of John C. Calhoun was because of his quote at a dinner, which was to honor the memory of Thomas Jefferson, with Andrew Jackson. After Andrew Jackson made a toast saying, “The Union must and shall be preserved,”(Andrew Jackson) John C. Calhoun got up and toasted saying,” The Union next to our liberty most dear.”(John C. Calhoun) This shows that if John C. Calhoun was living during the times of the secession crisis that he would be on the right side of the Confederates. We know how the people that lavished in his memory, but what did Thomas Jefferson think of the issue himself. First of all I think you know what side he was on since he was smart and always thinking ahead for, not the United States of America, but the actual states and people inside the United States. We know that the one and only Thomas Jefferson was a Confederate because of his actions and this quote he made in a letter not meant for the public eye to read and he says,” States should separate from our companions only when the sole alternatives left, are the dissolution of our Union with them, or submission to a government without limitation of powers.” As you can see here, many of the writers of the constitution, writers of the Declaration of Independence, and the leaders of the United States of America believed in secession. They all say this, but as Jefferson says,” Only when the sole alternatives left.” This means that states should not secede from the union unless their hand is forced by a leading group within or outside of the union which in the case that caused the civil war was the

Show More
Related

  • How Did Texas Fight In The Civil War

    352 Words  | 2 Pages

    “This is a union of equal states, and no state can force another state either to remain in it or withdraw from it. ”(C) I hold that… the Union of these States is perpetual… No state upon its own mere motion, can lawfully get out of the Union. The argument between whether a state could leave the US without permission was one of the main reasons that the Civil War began.

    Read More

  • DBQ Essay: The First Secession

    514 Words  | 3 Pages

    Secession Essay The Southerners felt they had to secede from the Union for many reasons. They wanted to make their own Confederate government so they could do what they wanted. Like for instance, have control of slavery in their territories. The state South Carolina was the first to secede, on December 20, 1860, followed by Mississippi, Florida, Alabama, Georgia, Louisiana, Texas, Virginia, Arkansas, North Carolina and Tennessee.

    Read More

  • How Did James Buchanan Prevent The Civil War

    1014 Words  | 5 Pages

    Breckinridge. President Lincoln was the president during the Civil War. When he entered office, seven states had already seceded from the Union, and the Confederacy had been formed. The Confederate constitution was drafted. When he read it, Lincoln denied that the states had ever possessed independent sovereignty as colonies and territories.

    Read More

  • The Killer Angels Analysis

    740 Words  | 3 Pages

    We established this this country in the first place with strong state government just for that reason, to avoid a central tyranny.” (p. 65). The South looked at the North as a tyrannical government. The North on the other hand looked at the South as trying to tear the country into two. The Union army fought to keep the country together as one, because if the South would win the war it would have split the country into two for good.

    Read More

  • Lincoln Racist Dbq

    867 Words  | 4 Pages

    Lincoln talks about the union in Document G and said the following: “But you say that sooner than yield your legal right to the slave—especially at the bidding of those who are not themselves interested, you would see the Union dissolved.” If the South successfully separated from the North the Confederacy would no longer be under the control of the Union and Lincoln’s access to freeing the slaves would minimal. This “new nation” that Lincoln was trying to create and put into effect had a strong foundation based upon Constitutional rights which declare that all men are created equal. Yes, maybe Lincoln at this point wanted to keep the Union together, which can most definitely be perceived as racist too but slavery on the back burner for the time being, but in the end, he encouraged and defended the rights of all humans.

    Read More

  • Essay On North And South Secession

    798 Words  | 4 Pages

    As the tensions between the North and the South keep growing, we have to look at the secession of the Southern states and if this act will help or hinder the debate brought about between the two territories. One of the first things we need to inspect is the differences between the two. Then we need to get down to the core and see why there are major issues between the North and the South. Finally, after we go through the facts, I will present my opinion on whether or not secession is necessary and if it is or isn’t the right route to take in order to resolve the conflicts separating the United States.

    Read More

  • Essay On The Causes Of The Civil War Dbq

    587 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to Document E and F, John C. Calhoun, of the South, thinks that states have the right to secede from the union if they're unhappy. While Abraham Lincoln think our union is perpetual and will last forever. The states do not have the right to secede if they're unhappy because the union never ends and never changes, says Lincoln. This caused South Carolina to secede, then followed by South

    Read More

  • An Example Of Andrew Jackson As A War Hero

    568 Words  | 3 Pages

    As a democracy, we expect our leaders to care about the we want as a union. However, this isn 't what we always get. For example, Andrew Jackson could be considered one of these self serving leaders. To some, Andrew Jackson represents a war hero but others would say he was an arrogant and unbending person. Impoverished and uneducated he would rise from orphan to war hero leaving thousands of Native Americans dead in the wake of his political ambitions.

    Read More

  • How Did Slavery Cause Secession

    1451 Words  | 6 Pages

    This essay will explore the reasons as to how and why secession occurred and whether slavery was the main

    Read More

  • Us Constitution Dbq

    1375 Words  | 6 Pages

    Since its inception in 1787, the U.S. Constitution has been considered as the oldest and most influential document. It laid down the principles and foundation which helped shape U.S. as a nation, and the more than one hundred countries that used it as a model for creating their own Constitution (Constitutionfacts.com, n.a.). But the circumstances during its creation were critical. The American War of Independence (1775-1783) against Great Britain had ended with the signing of the Treaty of Paris that gave sovereignty to the U.S. in 1783.

    Read More

  • Differences Between North And South Dbq

    868 Words  | 4 Pages

    The tariff negatively affected the South’s economy and positively impacted the North’s economy which added tension between the two regions. Senator Henry Clay speaks of how ridiculous the idea is, by stating in his speech, “she [South Carolina] can defeat the execution of certain laws of the United States, I for one, will express my opinion that I believe it is utterly impracticable…”(doc A). The idea of a state seceding from the nation impacted the later monumental threat of secession by many Southern states in 1860. In Document H, the presidential election of 1860 map shows how divided the country was. Most of the North and Western states voted for Lincoln while the Southern states were divided between Breckinridge and Douglas.

    Read More

  • Dbq Civil Rights Act Of 1860

    1024 Words  | 5 Pages

    “The lack of… nationality, I believe, is one of the great evils of the times…” Senator John Sherman stated on February 10, 1863. The United States had been split into sections from the beginning, and it created a lack of unity and togetherness. In Document A, the reader can acquire from the reading that South Carolina (and later many other states) seceded from the Union because of states’ rights. Document A states that an amendment (specifically the

    Read More

  • The South Secession

    1059 Words  | 5 Pages

    The South’s Secession The south seceding was a big turning point in history. It marked a new chapter, and not a very good one. The south seceded with a number of “grievances”. These “grievances” included a number of disagreements on major issues.

    Read More

  • Compromises Between 1820 And 1860

    1121 Words  | 5 Pages

    Clay wanted to keep the nation together. Henry Clay, a Senator, was someone who wanted to keep the nation together, so he gave a speech to the Senate in 1833 about how South Carolina cannot secede and become an independent state, and doesn't want to. “I say it is impossible that South Carolina ever desired for a moment to become a separate and independent state” (Doc A). For the people that were against slavery, they held anti-slavery conventions, talking about how awful slavery is and even called slave

    Read More

  • How Did Abraham Lincoln Deserve To Be The Great Emancipator

    695 Words  | 3 Pages

    President Lincoln stated that: “if I could save the Union without freeing any slave, I would do it,..., and if I could save it by freeing some and leaving others alone, I would do it.”. This quote clearly shows that the freedom of slaves was not his concern and unnecessary if it did not help the Union; as the result, slavery still exists if there is no war. Free slave from bondage should be a Great Emancipator’s primary goal and he will do his best to achieve it no matter what, but president Lincoln’s thought differed from that because all he cares was the Union. Although he had many times admitting himself an anti-slavery but his words and thoughts obviously prove that he is

    Read More

More about Constitution Of The United States: Argument Analysis

Open Document