Consuming culture is a topic that has a wide range of topics and themes intertwined within it. It has been widely discussed and researched by many authors and a number of common themes and topics become apparent. The most common theme is that the consumption of culture helps to create identity, either for individuals or groups, via consumption rituals and the consumption of goods, services or experiences. These will be discussed in further detail throughout the literature review.
The creation of a status or identity through the consumption of culture is a topic that can be linked to the research found. The consumption of goods, services or experiences can assist an individual in creating or forging an identity, and it is used as a form of communication
…show more content…
Much like how the use of makeup assists in forging an identity for Chinese women, Belk and Varman, (2012), state that the consumption of the “shopping mall experience” attempts to transform the identities of Indian teenagers. In post –colonial India, much of the young population are attempting to hide or transform their “third world identities.” “ A renewed exposure to the colonial powers of the West through global cultural flows creates a fresh anxiety and desire to mask Third World identities and to emulate the West.” (Belk and Varman, 2012). Indian teenagers are becoming increasingly exposed to Western culture through the media, advertising and fashion industry, which correlates to McCracken’s (1986) research. In Indian culture, the West holds an aspirational position; this is desired by the culture and emulation attempts are made to imitate the Western culture within their own. The consumption of the shopping mall experience by Indian youth is an attempt to form an illusion that they are contemporary and in touch with modern society, and the shopping mall holds a culturally symbolic meaning in India. Shopping malls are creating a new culture within the existing Indian culture, and the experience of consuming in a mall is helping forge identities and communicate these identities to those around them. It helps Indian teenagers to overcome a sense of inferiorness. Belk and Varman (2012), describe the consumption of the shopping mall experience as a “masquerade”, and that although they are still very much part of Indian culture, they are attempting to create illusions, and hide their true identities behind a mask. This is slightly contradictory when contrasted more in depth with the research carried out by McCracken (1986), where he says
Many Indians, like Massoon, became too afraid to wear traditional Indian clothings, such as saris or bindis, in public. Some parents refused to send their children to school in order to protect them and because the children often felt insecure and ashamed of their heritage because of the bullying and bias (Kamen, 1992). A few businesses owned by Indians were forced to close because Indians were afraid to shop in Jersey City (James, 1989). No Indians walked alone, because, according to Vishnu Patel, they were “‘afraid to go out.’” Patel explained that even “‘people who work nights or return late at night are not going to their jobs,’”
The topic discussed in this article focuses on the positive impacts malls have in society. Malls have been around for many years and continue to influence society into buying or shopping for material things in order to satisfy our everyday needs. They are also a way of connecting society by the interaction of shopping in masses brings and creates a fun ambiance for everyone to enjoy. Rhetorical evaluation is analyzing the tone, the aim, and the ultimate purpose of the ideas being brought forth. Evaluation is an important skill to have in today’s society because otherwise we would be led like sheep into accepting eloquent arguments as absolute truths when they could be the opposite.
Within this critical literature review, the article which will be under analysis is “low- income families and coping through brands: Inclusion or stigma?” which was written by Kathy Hamilton in 2012. The article concentrates on the coping strategies used by single parents and low-income families to avoid stigmatisation and threats upon their social identities. Therefore, to avoid stigmatisation these low-income families may take part in conspicuous consumption where families may spend a lot of money on luxury goods to make themselves look better, which can give them a sense of economic power and acceptance within society. However, due to the rise of ‘chav’ culture surrounding single mothers, it can be much harder to move away from stigmatisation,
Every day we use our culture. Whether it be to argue claims, express opinions, or make decisions, culture plays a part in each area. Culture is who we are, one’s identity, its extent is enormous over our views and actions. A person grows up surrounded with culture at a young age. This can affect how they learn and what they learn.
Identity speaks of who we are as individuals but it also comes from two different groups: social and cultural. These groups are connected to power, values and ideology. Social identities are related to how we interact with people and how we present ourselves. Meanwhile cultural identities relate to society in whole such as religion, values, etc. In this paper I will talk about the dominant and subordinate identities.
The passage “Grand Mall Seizure” is the mall’s habits from a shopper’s perspective on the mall. Daniel Alarcon explains what it is like to be in a mall with over 500 stores. Alarcon explains that it is chaos, everyone is scrambling around and it is loud. Alarcon says, “Shopping centers that not only served a community’s physical needs, but its civic, and social needs as well.” (Alarcon, 293)
Worldmark Encyclopedia of Cultures and Daily Life. Ed. Timothy L. Gall and Jeneen Hobby. 2nd ed. Vol.
The article “The Science of Shopping” written by New Yorker staff writer Malcom Gladwell, is based on retail anthropologist and urban geographer Paco Underhill. Underhill studies the shopping characteristics through frequently watched surveillance tapes to help store managers improve the setup of their goods and services. Through those footages he evaluated his observations and the statistics to help define his theories with the purpose to make sellers conform to the desires of the shoppers. Underhill, an insightful and revolutionary man, provides a view of science to displaying merchandise and creates a positive experience for both the buyer and seller. I agree that Underhill’s scientific theories; the Invariant Right, Decompression
While in Malcolm Gladwell’s article,”The Science of Shopping”, he shows how retail consultant Paco Underhill’s idea of “retail anthropology,” affect how people shop and the manipulation that can be put on their shopping habits. The shopping experience is heavily affected by the stores that pay attention to how buyers react
Everyone has their own unique cultural identity. Individuality is the genetic code for differences and individuality, and it allows people to perceive certain aspects of the world through a different lens. Everyone has different tastes in music, different behavioral attributes, and different facial features that set others apart. To a great extent, one’s culture informs the way they view others and the world.
This process of recuperation happens in two ways: by converting subcultural signs into mass-produced objects (the commodity form) and by labelling and re-defining deviant behavior by dominant groups (the ideological form). The commodity form benefits from the relationship between the spectacular subcultures and the industries, which is based on ambiguity and the difficulty to distinguish between commercial exploitation and originality, since consumption is an indispensable part of spectacular subcultures and they feed on production and publicity. However, this commercialization and mass production of cultural symbols takes their meaning away from the subculture and makes it available for everyone.
Traditional Western approach to modern psychology The Traditional Western approach has had a great influence on modern psychology. The Traditional Western approach differs quite a lot from the African perspective, but has made a big impact on psychology today. Here are a few key aspects of the Traditional Western approach to modern psychology: • Assumes that psychology is a universal science that is objective and the knowledge is value-free
This can be conceptualized through the studies done on the “project kids” in the East Side Boys and Girls Club (Deutsch & Theodorou, 2010: 239). The writers had found that the youth within this club, made consumer choices based on consumer culture that allowed for them to integrate themselves into a larger society. This was done through a simple act of consuming sneakers that were associated with the Black community (Deutsch & Theodorou, 2010: 239). Therefore, in purchasing these sneakers, the youth mark their differences from those poorer adolescents in the club and place themselves into the larger, wealthier black youth culture. In addition to doing this, the youth ascribe a certain identity correlated to the groups they fall into; therefore they form an identity through consumerism and consumption that does correlate with their present economic status or their purchase
Cultural identity plays a very vital role in cross cultural communication, people from a particular culture communicate with partners and employees from many different cultures and in this situation every individual strives to keep their cultural and individual identity. According to Gardiner and Kosmitzki, identity is defined as “a person 's self-definition as a separate and distinct individual, including behaviours, beliefs, and attitudes” (Gardiner & Kosmitzki, 2008, p. 154). Also, Ting-Toomey defines identity as a "reflective self-conception or self-image that we each derive from our family, gender, cultural, ethnic, and individual socialization process"( Ting-Toomey, 2005). Both definitions bring out the generalisation of cultural identity