Controversies Between Policymakers And Education Reform
Controversies between policymakers and education research are credibility, quality, bias and unclear data. Meanwhile, No Child Left Behind (NCLB) and Education Science Reform (ESR) acts transformed American Education with laws; high stakes testing and reporting systems such as, Annual Yearly Progress (AYP) and Highly Qualified Teachers (HQT). Conversely, Science based researches and evidenced based practices continue to overwhelm the educational system policies on what is effective or ineffective. “Multiple accountability systems have left the general public confused about the quality of their local schools” (Borko, Liston, & Whitcomp 2007, p. 99). Extensive studies recommend: principle soundness of academic publication requires policy reform; teacher educators must engage in dialogue about NCLB and ESR influence on K-12 classroom repetition, teacher life, education effort and quality to make education stronger as legislators aim to strengthen bonds between research & policy makers by improving doctoral programs, raising standards, credible research, including establishing a store house of trustworthy works and organizing research that is vetted practical.
This essay purposes to combine three articles into argumentative formation on claimed fiascoes within the American Education system, When Education Research Matters, Hess (2008), NCLB
…show more content…
Although special interest groups may have influence, policy makers should devise regulations to restrain such inspirations. My initial reaction reflected on education research policies and its effectiveness. No doubt, society has evolved into techno-savvy buffs whereas questioning legitimacy of “evidence-based” or “scientifically based” prior to implementation is
Analysis Of Fixing Our National Accountability Problems By Marc Tucker
522 Words | 3 PagesThe current form of teacher accountability, is well known, but has little support. The system we have adapted to, judges our teachers and views them as simple minded. Tucker points out in the report, Fixing Our National Accountability Problems, that having standardized tests judging our teachers is not giving students a better education. Nocera uses Tucker’s quote: “There is no
Summary Of The Smartest Kids In The World By Amanda Ripley
990 Words | 4 PagesOne of the biggest concerning the need for an increase in rigor in instruction in American schools. She discusses that in Poland students must stay in academic classes for an extra year and teachers are paid bonuses to engage in professional development work. She also notes that in Finland they “rebooted their teacher-training colleges, forcing them to become much more selective and rigorous.” In an article written by Sarah Tantillio on Only Good Books, she recognizes the validity of these statements, but comments that in America “the Common Core States Standards, which most states have adopted, they are definitely rigorous, But how they are implemented (and assessed) from state to state and school to school is still a Very Big Question.” Further in her article she points out the large population differences between Finland, Poland, and the United States, and how this affects our education system.
50 Myths And Lies That Threaten America's Public Schools
1621 Words | 7 PagesReflection 50 Myths& Lies To begin, the book 50 Myths& Lies that Threaten America’s Public Schools covered a variety of topics such as why teachers are quickly blamed publicly along with their unions, how to make our schools better, equality of schools, money, and how schools make students college and career ready. With each of these topics were smaller sub-topics such as the importance of money, bullying, teachers’ abilities, and the various choices of schooling. With each topic/sub-topic the authors guided us through each subject uncovering myths and lies that surround them.
Texas Accountability System History
1124 Words | 5 PagesCarnoy, Loeb, and Smith (2003) found a weakness in the relationships between TAKS scores and other outcomes such as high school graduation rates and scores on college entrance exams. Other researchers (Klein, Hamilton, McCaffrey, & Steecher, 2000) analyzed increases in scores in Texas on the NAEP, increases that they state political leaders attributed to the accountability system, and found that Texas score improvements in mathematics at grade 8 are not significantly different from those of other states that did not have strong accountability systems in place. In fact their data show evidence that the achievement gap between white students and underrepresented minorities actually increased. Some argue that the data show that the accountability program actually negatively impacts schools that were already academically behind before the implementation of the accountability system (Fassold,
Common Core State Standards Research Paper
671 Words | 3 PagesIntroduction States love to have has much control over every aspect of government. Many states like Missouri were happy to join the ranks of states implementing the Common Core State Standards because it makes sense in terms of unifying standards for all states so all students will have the necessary skills needed to become successful in college career and life. States like Missouri are beginning to have second thoughts about the standards because they argue that the standards restrict the state’s control over educating children, but they seem to forget the rationale for original implantation which is to have all of the involved states working under the same set of standards in an effort to prepare all students for life after high school. The Rigor the Common Core State Standards Should be Embraced
Education Reform: Investment In Empty Promises And False Claims
1458 Words | 6 PagesAlayna Anderson Dr. Laura Ullrich ECON 215H 1 December 2015 Education Reform: Investment in Empty Promises and False Claims Education reform is a hot topic for politicians. And why shouldn’t it be? Education involves two things that few Americans could vote against: helping children, especially those that are economically disadvantaged, and ensuring a bright and prosperous future for the country. How could someone possibly vote against that?
Standardized Testing Dbq
1130 Words | 5 PagesThere are also much better ways to test a student’s capability to learn; a 2006 Center on Education Policy conducted a study and found that a curriculum that follows state standards and uses the test data as feedback led to higher scores than those that prioritized test-taking skills. When teachers are more focused on teaching material rather than test strategies, their students benefit from it (“Do Standardized Tests Show an Accurate View of Students’ Abilities?”). Several alternative methods to state assessments for measuring a student’s academic success include comparing high school graduation rates and the number of dropouts, offering advanced placement courses, and looking at the percentage of the former students that are admitted to colleges. State assessments are more harmful than helpful to students; they are a large cause of test anxiety and a majority of teachers can never fully prepare their students. Although state assessments are an easy way to be able to see the growth of students, that does not mean that they are the best
Standardized Testing Argumentative Essay
1229 Words | 5 PagesStandard testing is a very controversial and important subject because it deals with the progression of the American education system. The practice of these assessments has been highly scrutinized not only for the way it has changed the format of classrooms, but also for its accuracy, pressure, and abundance. In 2001, standardized testing became federally mandated through the No Child Left Behind Act by former president George Bush Jr. According to research from the Council of the Great City Schools, students have been taking “an average of 113 tests from pre-kindergarten through 12th grade” (K. Hefling). These numbers have increased to the point where parents have opted for their children to not attend standardized exams.
Standardized Testing Rhetorical Analysis
769 Words | 4 PagesKane, director of the Center for Education Policy Research at Harvard University, compares this occurrence to be equivalent to saying, ”because there are some players that cheated in Major League Baseball, we should stop keeping score, because that only encourages people to take steroids”. As the third argument, people against these test say that, high stakes testing places too much pressure on students. Norman says he that these test can sometimes constitute cruel and unusual punishment, but surely there is a middle ground between the practices and full-scale abandonment of standardized testing can be found. “Those who argue against standardized testing are not only misguided, but are also leading U.S school and students in the wrong direction” (Augustine). Jessie B. Ramey disagrees.
Education In America Has Been Such A Key Point In The Federal Government
921 Words | 4 PagesThe Hechinger Report mentioned a “modest degree of improvement” in early 2016. This can also be attributed that many school districts are more focused on exceling in the yearly examinations and teach year-round on how to pass the test and not on how to understand the information being taught. The higher the percentage of passing students, the more recognition the school receives under the Every Student Succeeds Act grants. Consequently, the over enthusiasm of a school district in Atlanta, Georgia showed evidence of teachers who were inflating test scores in order to obtain better numbers for the district. This seemingly high success rate came attached to bonuses for the 11 teachers involved.
The Failure Of American Public Education Summary
188 Words | 1 Pagesn “The Failure of American Public Education” (February 01 1993), John Hood explains the sundry perspectives on the American education system. Hood tactfully uses cause and effect to demonstrate the viewpoints of a myriad of individuals regarding American schools and their approaches to effectively educating students; he explains how “free-market thinkers believe that applying market competition to the public schools will solve many of America’s educational problems” (Hood) ; “critics believe that public education reforms fail because they are compromised or sabotaged by the education lobbies—teacher associations, administrators, and the legislators in their pockets” (Hood) and “many conservatives believe that American public education is in
Comparing The Charter School Expansion Act And No Child Left Behind
740 Words | 3 PagesI found this important because it almost as if standardized testing has become about business and politics, not education. For example, When Congress increased this year’s budget for the Department of Education by $11 billion, it set aside $400 million to help states develop and administer the tests that the No Child Left Behind Act Mandated for children in grades 3 through 8. Among the likely benefactors of the extra funder were the four companies that dominate the testing market—three publishers and one scoring firm
Incentive Summary
449 Words | 2 PagesIn my opinion, public educational curriculums and accountability guidelines should be established at the state and local levels where parents/guardians play an integral role in the decision making process. I do not believe standardized tests alone are an accurate measure of a student’s knowledge; their classwork, projects, and literary works also represent a student’s talent and capabilities. In agreement with Robert Schaeffer, a representative for the National Center for Fair & Open Testing, that federal mandated programs such as the No Child Left Behind and The Race to The Top high-stakes tests foster the temptation to cheat because they serve as means to both punish and reward students, teachers, and principals based solely upon test scores (Schaeffer,
The Argument Against Standardized Testing In Texas
1597 Words | 7 PagesThe state of Texas has been in a constant struggle within itself over just how to evaluate education, and standardized testing in Texas has been a major influencer in terms of the state’s standards for over thirty years. Though these methods of testing have been utilized for decades, resentment to the tests have been continuously rising among educators, parents, and students, but not everyone agrees. Despite government officials trying to quell these protests with changes to administration, and the way the test itself is formatted and formulated, there seems to have been little to no improvement made and those opposing the tests have started calling for an end to all standardized testing. For one to truly understand this ongoing struggle, one must first look at standardized testing’s beginning, then how government today is trying to fix the broken system, and finally consider the opinions of notable figures in the testing world.
More about Controversies Between Policymakers And Education Reform
Steve Boss Analysis
1499 Words | 6 PagesAnalysis Of Fixing Our National Accountability Problems By Marc Tucker
522 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of The Smartest Kids In The World By Amanda Ripley
990 Words | 4 Pages50 Myths And Lies That Threaten America's Public Schools
1621 Words | 7 PagesTexas Accountability System History
1124 Words | 5 PagesCommon Core State Standards Research Paper
671 Words | 3 PagesEducation Reform: Investment In Empty Promises And False Claims
1458 Words | 6 PagesStandardized Testing Dbq
1130 Words | 5 PagesStandardized Testing Argumentative Essay
1229 Words | 5 PagesStandardized Testing Rhetorical Analysis
769 Words | 4 PagesEducation In America Has Been Such A Key Point In The Federal Government
921 Words | 4 PagesThe Failure Of American Public Education Summary
188 Words | 1 PagesComparing The Charter School Expansion Act And No Child Left Behind
740 Words | 3 PagesIncentive Summary
449 Words | 2 PagesThe Argument Against Standardized Testing In Texas
1597 Words | 7 Pages