Wittgenstein Dualism
By developing his rather ambiguous critique of Wittgenstein into the theory of communicative action Habermas laid foundation for further political conceptualization of his account. As it was asserted in the end of the second part, this theory forms a core of the deliberative model of democracy. However, there is a room to criticize these Habermas's elaborations through Wittgenstein himself. Such a critical analysis was carried out by Chantal Mouffe.
Mouffe uses Wittgenstein to pinpoint the drawbacks of Habermasian investigations and to work out her own concept of democratic society that incorporates some Wittgenstein's insights that were described in the first chapter. For Mouffe, Habermasian account lacks a focus on the political realm as
…show more content…
The dual vision of language that Habermas employs allows a distinction between 'procedural' and 'substantial' to emerge. We have a scheme of an ideal speech situation on the one hand, and manifold practices on the other. According to Mouffe, this distinction 'cannot be maintained and one must acknowledge that procedures always involve substantial ethical commitments.' (Mouffe 1999, 749) When Tully stresses this issue of Habermasian dualism he argues that our judgments are not entirely distinct from our everyday communicative practices. 'One reason for his misunderstanding is the overly sharp distinction he draws between the reflective grounding of speech acts in justifications and the mere de facto acceptance of habitual practices.' (Tully 1989, …show more content…
Mouffe envisage the model of 'agonistic' democracy that, far from imposing a general rational order, maintains both democratic pluralism and a realm of political conflicts and frictions. According to this view, 'the "other" is no longer seen as an enemy to be destroyed, but as an "adversary," i.e., somebody with whose ideas we are going to struggle but whose right to defend those ideas we will not put into question.' (Mouffe 1999, 755) In this respect, Habermasian theory that finds its justification in universalizing the procedures of justifications themselves 'is a conceptual impossibility.' (Laclau and Mouffe 2001,
Declaration Of Independence Vs Constitution Essay
474 Words | 2 PagesThroughout this paper, this material will be further explained and examined through several different ideas and articles. The first idea that will be discussed, regarding the principles presented above, can be demonstrated through the article, The Right of “Free Suffrage” (1776). This article
Essay On The American Revolution
544 Words | 3 PagesProblems in America only grew worse when democracy was being added to the mixture of already complicated politics. In Woody Holton’s book, Unruly American and the Origins of the Constitution, he stated that, “many Americans. . . were growing ‘tired of an excess of democracy,’ a ‘prevailing rage of excessive democracy. . .’ [or] ‘democratical tyranny.’” Democracy was an attempt at home rule among the colonies, but not everyone was happy with this extreme excess of colonial citizens contribution to the government.
Summary Of The Federalist Papers
647 Words | 3 PagesThe documents prefers a Republican Democracy over a Pure Democracy: From this view of the subject it may be concluded that a pure
Hobbes Vs Rousseau Essay
493 Words | 2 PagesHobbes and Rousseau agree that humans are equal by nature and must consent to submit their rights to a central authority. However, their conclusions diverge on the role and the composition of that central authority. Hobbes’s sovereign is that of one individual or a small assembly of individuals whose sole purpose is to provide security to its citizens and in return maintain the power to represent its citizens (Hobbes 227). Conversely, Rousseau believes that the sovereign is based on the concept of the general will which requires active participation by citizens as a community and binds/favors each citizen equally (Rousseau 76). Therefore Hobbes’s Leviathan and Rousseau’s general will are similar in premise by agreeing humans are motivated by self-preservation and utilize contracts to secure self-preservation, though their conclusions differ on the role/rights of the citizens and the sovereign.
Thomas Hobbes's Discourse On Inequality And Social Contract
2000 Words | 8 PagesIn contrast to Hobbes, who argues social bonds form to regulate human nature, Rousseau argues that the formation of the civil state results from and in a “change in man,” that humans must of necessity be denatured in the process of forming society. There are similarities between the two’s philosophies, but it is Rousseau, through his arguments that human nature can be changed, who articulates a political vision more consistent with the claim that humans are asocial by nature. In the beginning, the arguments of both Hobbes and Rousseau are similar. Man in nature is isolated.
Carl Schmitt's Criticism Of Politics
483 Words | 2 PagesHe states that, “the phenomenon of the political can be understood only in the context of the ever present possibility of the friend-and-enemy grouping” (Schmitt 35). Schmitt maintains that in order for politics to exist, there must be a conflict or rivalry between two sides and that conflict exists because the enemies provide the possibility of a violent attack against each other’s state. Schmitt continues this argument by asserting, “the justification of war does not reside in its being fought for ideals or norms of justice, but in its being fought against a real enemy” (Schmitt 49). Here Schmitt is successful in identifying the core of politics and how it distinctly identifies itself in juxtaposition to other spheres, such as justice and economics, which he contends are separate from the pure concept of the
Essay On Dualism And Monism
1457 Words | 6 PagesWhat is the Mind? Introduction To try and explore the ‘mind’ it is necessary to examine if the mind and the brain are separate or if the mind and body are distinct from one another? Is the mind and body separate substance or elements of the same substance? Is consciousness the result of the mechanisms of the brain, wholly separate from the brain or inextricably linked?
Descartes Dualism Essay
1480 Words | 6 PagesThroughout history there has been an abundance of ancient philosophers, including Plato, who explored metaphysics and its relationship to the real world before Descartes’ began questioning the idea. Nevertheless, his views on dualism are very different from Plato’s. As we know, Plato thinks and feels as if the body is just a vessel for the soul, but Descarte on the other hand strongly believes and shows proof that both your soul and body are connected and intertwining. Stating one is not superior to the other, both work hand and hand, affecting each other. Descartes states that “I reflect therefore I am.”
Essay On Predicate Dualism
1009 Words | 5 PagesThe term ‘dualism’ has a variety of uses if we see the previous literature. In common sense, the notion is that, for any particular area of interest, there are two commonly different classes of things. In theory, for example a ‘dualist’ is one who believes that Good and Evil-or God and the Devil-are independent and more or less equal forces in the world. Dualism compare with monism, which is the theory that there is only one significant type, category of thing and rather less commonly, with pluralism, which is commonly referred to as many categories. In the philosophy of mind, dualism is the theory that the mind and body are, in some sense, totally different types of thing.
Similarities Between Hobbes And Rousseau
1351 Words | 6 PagesThus, both men would evaluate the statement that “in a legitimate state all men are free and there is no inequality,” differently. Rousseau would mostly disagree, holding that the state itself is the impetus for inequality. Hobbes would largely agree, contending that men are equal both in a primitive state of conflict and under a sovereign’s awesome power. These different responses result from the philosophers’ opposing views on fundamental human nature, civil society’s raison d’etre, and government’s inevitable form. --- Rousseau begins his
Compare And Contrast Hobbes Locke And Rousseau
1740 Words | 7 PagesHobbes, Locke and Rousseau have become known as three of the most prominent political theorists in the world today. Their philosophies and innovative thinking is known worldwide and it has influenced the creation of numerous new governments. All three thinkers agree on the idea of a social contract but their opinions differ on how the social contract is established and implemented within each society. These philosophers state, that in order for the social contract to be successful people need to give up certain freedoms in order to secure fundamental protections from the state, henceforth the state then has certain responsibilities to their citizens. Hobbes, Locke and Rousseau all believe that before men were governed we all lived in a state of nature.
How Did Wittgenstein Contribute To Psychology
1436 Words | 6 PagesPhilosophy has long been considered the most difficult degree to earn in the United States. Thousands of people per year attend college with the intention of obtaining a degree in philosophy, however hundreds change their major because of the high stress associated with the degree. Millions of books have been published on the subject yet few fail to give a true indepth analysis of its true hardships. This can be attributed to thousands of “psychology authors” never taking a class on psychology in their lives (quite often not even a Psychology I class in highschool). Including Ludwig Wittgenstein, author of The Blue and Brown Books, who originally went to college to study engineering, however he eventually became one of the leading psychological
Thomas Hobbes Research Paper
1904 Words | 8 PagesThomas Hobbes, one of the greatest 17th century English philosophers, is in several instances hastily and vehemently grouped into the category of ‘defender and advocate of despotism’ by many. Often regarded as a flagbearer of illiberal thinking and absolutism, few see Hobbes for the claims he subtly, nonetheless, effectively promotes; claims that antithetically contain some of the building blocks of classical and modern liberalism. Though Hobbes, through his main work, Leviathan, does promote certain strands of thought that have illiberal elements—like an opposition to democracy, unlimited power of a sovereign, and restriction of freedoms like that of owning private property—he also promotes a multitude of concepts, that in the era of the 17th
Aristotle Vs Rousseau Analysis
1721 Words | 7 PagesIntroduction The assignment will be investigating the democracy of Aristotle and Jean Jacques Rousseau. Democracy in itself can be very different and varies from form to form. The assignment will investigate Aristotle’s view and Jean Jacques Rousseau concepts on state and man, the governess of the state, freedom and man .Each of these topics will be contrast on the views of Aristotle and Jean Jacques Rousseau alongside each other. Each of these philosophers’ key points will be looked and the inner working of out they thought a city should be run.
Essay On Monism Vs Dualism
1225 Words | 5 PagesAn issue in theoretical basis on what should prevail or which is supreme between International Law or Municipal Law (national law) is usually presented as a competition between monism and dualist. But in modern approach there is now the theory of coordination or is also called Harmonization theory that rejects the presumption of the other two theoretical concept, monism and dualism. The monist view asserts the international law’s supremacy over the municipal law even in matters within the internal or domestic jurisdiction of a state. While it is true that the international law defines the legal existence of states as well of the validity of its national legal order, the dualist asserts the international law is an existing system that is completely separated from municipal or national law. That dictates the
More about Wittgenstein Dualism
Declaration Of Independence Vs Constitution Essay
474 Words | 2 PagesEssay On The American Revolution
544 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of The Federalist Papers
647 Words | 3 PagesHobbes Vs Rousseau Essay
493 Words | 2 PagesThomas Hobbes's Discourse On Inequality And Social Contract
2000 Words | 8 PagesCarl Schmitt's Criticism Of Politics
483 Words | 2 PagesEssay On Dualism And Monism
1457 Words | 6 PagesDescartes Dualism Essay
1480 Words | 6 PagesEssay On Predicate Dualism
1009 Words | 5 PagesSimilarities Between Hobbes And Rousseau
1351 Words | 6 PagesCompare And Contrast Hobbes Locke And Rousseau
1740 Words | 7 PagesHow Did Wittgenstein Contribute To Psychology
1436 Words | 6 PagesThomas Hobbes Research Paper
1904 Words | 8 PagesAristotle Vs Rousseau Analysis
1721 Words | 7 PagesEssay On Monism Vs Dualism
1225 Words | 5 Pages