The Benedict Option I. Annotation Analysis
Mahmud 1
Sharoze Mahmud
Mr.B
AP Lang and Comp
March 17th, 2016
Columnist Assignment: David Brooks, The New York Times Article 1: The Benedict Option I. Annotation Author's
Purpose: This is a critical review of the ideas expressed in Rod 'Dreher's book, The Benedict
Option. Dreher sees the cultural wars over new realities (such as LGBT) as a threat to Christian faith, and suggests the option of St. Benedict (sixth-century monk) during the fall of the
Roman empire, i.e. withdraw from the mainstream and establish religious
…show more content…
Emotionally Charge Diction: True, pariahs, spear at our throats, threatening, fears, dark age, death of christianity, rights, liberty, narrowness, prejudice and moral, etc. Syntactical Features: Parallelism (the purist and the ironist. Purist; ... in this one. In this world..., liberty versus equality; justice versus mercy, tolerance versus order, etc.); antithesis (pre- emptively surrendering when in fact some practical accommodation is entirely possible; The right response to the moment is not the Benedict Option, it is Orthodox Pluralism, etc.), etc. 2.
Rhetorical Precis & Personal Response a) Rhetorical Precis In his article, The Benedict Option,
Brooks (2017) refutes the Rod Dreher's argument — in his book, The Benedict Option —that the sexual realities of LGBT herald the final death of Christianity, and instead argues: "Rod is pre- emptively surrendering when in fact some practical accommodation is entirely possible". The author uses various techniques to get his point across. He starts by presenting the difference between purist and ironist faith personalities (and including importantly `secular purists'), with the aim of establishing the foundation for his argument that Rod Dreher's suggested solution is
…show more content…
"American culture has tolerated slavery, sexual brutalism and the vermeil.. of the
Native Americans.
Emotion, synactical features, rheorical precis at the end.
Personal Response:
1. I have come to agree with Brook on his views of Christianity. Their is no need for sects of christianity to be segregated. The LGBT community will stay to itself and has shown no
Rhetorical Analysis Of Asyndeton
406 Words | 2 PagesRaghuram Venkatapuram English, Period B7 9/19/16 Rhetorical Analysis Essay Excerpt from “Preface to A Dictionary of the English Language” - By Samuel Johnson. In this excerpt, Samuel Johnson’s feelings about dictionary writers is are very strong, in a sense that he has a direct emotional appeal on the reader about how they, the dictionary writers, are often neglected. In this essay, I will focus on two rhetorical terms - ‘asyndeton’ and, from Aristotle’s Three Appeals, ‘Pathos’ or emotion.
Summary Of Lars Brownworth's Lost To The West
598 Words | 3 PagesContrary to what Diocletian expected, however, the pagans defended their fellow Romans, leading to a remarkable period of religious unity and acceptance amongst the citizens of the Roman Empire (7-8). To this end, the failure of Diocletian’s Christian persecution was a significant factor leading to the eventual domination of Christianity in western society due to the fact that it precipitated the empire’s growing toleration of Christian
Rhetorical Analysis On Declaration Of Independence
1054 Words | 5 PagesRhetorical Strategies Analysis Essay “For the support of this Declaration, with a firm reliance on the protection of divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other our Lives, our Fortunes and our sacred Honor.” Two hundred and forty one years ago, the American colonies began their fight for freedom -- one year later they declared their independence from Britain as the United States of America. Patrick Henry’s The “Speech in the Virginia Convention” and Thomas Jefferson’s Declaration of Independence were the catalysts for this revolution, and the reason for these documents’ fame could easily be attributed to the power within the words.
Merry Wiesner-Hank Book Review
1009 Words | 5 PagesIt could be considered that at first look, Merry Wiesner-Hanks investigates an alternative view of the early modern world in terms of the history behind Christianity and Sexuality in the Early Modern World. Wiesner-Hank’s viewpoint moves on from her earlier studies in women and gender in Europe and instead investigates Latin America, Asia, Africa and North America within her renaissance studies of “how Christian ideas and institutions shaped sexual attitudes and activities from roughly 1500-1750”. This in depth examination of the concept of sexuality and the way that it is underpinned by religious life and institutions is divided into six chapters. Her chapters explore the context of sexuality within history, including women’s history, legal
Rhetorical Analysis: Give Me Liberty Or Give Me Death
793 Words | 4 PagesLi 1 William Li Mr. McMurtry AP Lang & Comp, Gold 5 29 September 2014 Rhetorical Analysis: Give Me Liberty or Give Me Death Exordium: First Paragraph Introduction Show respects to opponents Narratio: Second Paragraph Rhetorical questions metaphors to invoke audience rethinking about their position stating facts Partitio: The end of second paragraph POV Confirmatio: Third Paragraph Refutatio: Fourth Paragraph Peroratio: Fifth Paragraph
Rhetorical Analysis Of Chief Red Jacket
827 Words | 4 PagesThe speech that was read by Chief Red Jacket to defend the religious beliefs of his people is a powerful piece of literature that is underrated. The speech describes the feelings that were caused by the religious intolerance from the Americans. Currently, the United States have started to appreciate the impacts of the Native Americans and other minorities in history. However, a piece of history that has been quite hidden is the religious intolerance of Native Americans. Chief Red Jacket utilizes repetition, pathos, and rhetorical questions to convince the Americans to tolerate the religion of the Native Americans.
Charlemagne's Impact On Western Europe
862 Words | 4 PagesIntroduction: Around 1000 AD, Western Europe experienced a significant transformation that led to a period of prosperity and growth. This period marked the beginning of Christendom, which became the foundation of Western European identity. Several factors contributed to the rise of Christendom and the subsequent prosperity and growth of Western Europe, including the reign of Charlemagne, the Pillars of Islam, the Gregorian reform, and the influence of Francesco Petrarch. This essay will examine these factors and their impact on Western European history.
An Angry God Ethos
864 Words | 4 PagesIn 1741, Jonathan Edwards delivered a sermon called “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God” to a congregation in Enfield, Connecticut. This sermon was so influential and poignant that today it has transformed into a piece of literature that many study in classes. This bit of literature is so utterly jam-packed with the use of rhetorical appeals, often referred to as ethos, pathos, and logos. These three appeals are derived from ancient Greece, or more precisely, the Greek philosopher Aristotle. Ethos appeals to the audience’s sense of trust, pathos, to their sense of emotion, and logos, to their sense of logic.
More Than A Carpenter Summary
894 Words | 4 PagesMore Than a Carpenter I. Introduction More Than a Carpenter is a Christian Apologetics and Inspirational book written by Josh McDowell with later contributions by his son, Sean McDowell. First published in 1977 by Tyndale House Publishers, the work has sold more than 27 million copies worldwide, and remains to be one of the bestselling books about Christianity and Evangelism. The author, Joslin “Josh” McDowell, is an American Christian apologist and evangelist born in Union City, Michigan in 1939. He has authored or co-authored more than 100 books about Christian Apologetics since 1960, once of which being his highly influential book, Evidence That Demands a Verdict.
Rhetorical Analysis Of Sinners In The Hands Of An Angry God
873 Words | 4 PagesRhetorical Analysis "Fear is an instructor of great sagacity and the herald of all resolutions. "- Ralph Waldo Emerson. “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God,” was a sermon written and delivered by American reverend Jonathan Edwards in 1741, and was an outstanding example of the potentially dominant convincing powers of the use of Rhetoric. The sermon, even when read silently, is effective in projecting a specific interpretation of the wrathful nature of God and the sinful nature of man.
Rhetorical Analysis: We Shall Fight On The Beaches
983 Words | 4 PagesRhetorical Essay Analysis World War II is a time of great struggle for humanity, especially for those within the midst of the battlegrounds. During the June of 1940 in an attempt to boost his citizen’s morale and confidence, Winston Churchill, then Prime Minister of the United Kingdom (UK), gave his speech “We shall fight on the beaches” at the British House of Commons. The rhetorical purpose of this speech is to convince the people of the UK that they have a fighting chance against the Axis forces, even if the worst comes to show. In order to gain people’s support, Churchill employed the rhetorical strategies of historical evidence and emotional appeal.
Summary Of James Cone's A Black Theology Of Liberation
1204 Words | 5 PagesJonathan T. Stoner Dr. Veli-Matti Kärkkäinen HT501: The Church’s Understanding of God and Christ in Its Theological Reflection June 9, 2016 CRITICAL RESPONSE # 3: James Cone’s A Black Theology of Liberation James Cone’s black liberation theology was his response to what he and many in the black community saw as the bankruptcy of the theology of white theologians, which was blind to black suffering while knowingly or unknowingly propping up the white-supremacist theology that had been the status quo in the United States since our nation’s founding. In A Black Theology of Liberation, which was his follow-up to God of the Oppressed, he fleshed out his black liberation theology that was rooted in the experience, cultural heritage, and distinctive
Millenianism's Influence On Jesusian
2068 Words | 9 PagesThe pope paced back and forth for several minutes in deep thought, while warming his icy hands with his warm breath. Finally, turning and smiling, he agreed that this was an important project and that the money would be provided. But he warned us that the emperor had recently instituted another crack-down on what he calls atheism, so everyone must be careful to hide their Christian identity. I told him that we were aware of that, and showed him the fake letter, allegedly from the emperor, giving us protection from harassment.
Rachels And Benedict's Views On Morality
198 Words | 1 PagesRachels and Benedict disagree about how relative is morality.in one hand Rachels express that morality is not relative, because from his point of view what is right or wrong cannot be based in one society code; it is clear that what is approved in one culture can be disapproved in other, so there is no absolute true nor a single standard to follow. Rachels state that there are some moral rules that all societies will have in common, because those rules are necessary for society to exist. According to this he think that there is some universal codes that have to be maintain for a healthy balance. Benedict in the other hand believes that morality is relative.
The Experience Of Five Christian Indians Analysis
1384 Words | 6 PagesRachael Goodson Professor Kathrine Chiles ENG & AFST 331 15 February 2018 William Apess In the nineteenth century, America was at one of its peaks of racial debate, with people starting to question whether it was right for the African Americans to stay enslaved, or if it was time to start the process of freeing the slaves and allowing them to live a better life. However, most people did not even question how the Native Americans were being treated or forced to change almost every aspect of their lives to “please,” as if they could ever be, the white people. William Apess’ The Experience of Five Christian Indians is an example of some of the harsh ways that Indians were treated before and even after they were “forcibly” converted to Christianity.
More about The Benedict Option I. Annotation Analysis
Rhetorical Analysis Of Asyndeton
406 Words | 2 PagesSummary Of Lars Brownworth's Lost To The West
598 Words | 3 PagesRhetorical Analysis On Declaration Of Independence
1054 Words | 5 PagesMerry Wiesner-Hank Book Review
1009 Words | 5 PagesRhetorical Analysis: Give Me Liberty Or Give Me Death
793 Words | 4 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Chief Red Jacket
827 Words | 4 PagesCharlemagne's Impact On Western Europe
862 Words | 4 PagesAn Angry God Ethos
864 Words | 4 PagesMore Than A Carpenter Summary
894 Words | 4 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Sinners In The Hands Of An Angry God
873 Words | 4 PagesRhetorical Analysis: We Shall Fight On The Beaches
983 Words | 4 PagesSummary Of James Cone's A Black Theology Of Liberation
1204 Words | 5 PagesMillenianism's Influence On Jesusian
2068 Words | 9 PagesRachels And Benedict's Views On Morality
198 Words | 1 PagesThe Experience Of Five Christian Indians Analysis
1384 Words | 6 Pages