ipl-logo

Criticism Of NIL In College Sports

1740 Words7 Pages

Ty Mason
Ms.Shasteen
Engl 1302
13 February 2023
NIL
NIL is one of if not the most highly debated topics in the college sports world. While its incorporation in the college world initially came with much applause the applause has quickly faded as flaws and problems pop up. Despite its flaws, incorporating NIL into the college world presents an opportunity to achieve meaningful reform that could help revolutionize college sports and benefit student-athletes across America. Leaving the NCAA along with its players and universities. NIL’s main criticism is how it has punished lower-tier schools for not having the same financial backing that larger schools have. While this is a problem this is not the fault of NIL, instead, it is the NCAA that …show more content…

With the NIL’s lack of rules and regulations, the boosters and collectives are allowed to practically bid on players like they are storage units not knowing what they might get out of the player they got from outbidding the other boosters and collectives of the other powerhouse programs. Sadly “Everything now comes down to how willing are your boosters and how rich are your boosters. You’re pretty much f----- if you don’t have the booster bank. It is simply the world of college sports that we now live in” (Ross Dellenger). Tho through my research, I have seen that there are many possible solutions for NIL, but the most beneficial for both parties pro and against NIL would be to establish a trust fund for college athletes, funded by a small percentage of the revenues generated by college sports. This fund could be used to provide financial support to athletes who come from low-income backgrounds or who face financial hardships. Also, the trust fund could be used to compensate athletes for the use of their NIL, with the funds distributed equally among all athletes. It would help athletes transition to the next part of their lives while eliminating the booster and collectives that plague college sports to this day. This also would help kill off higher-ups being able to influence where a student-athlete chooses to attend by the way of …show more content…

However, a Rogerian approach to this issue can help us understand the perspectives of all stakeholders and find common ground. Despite the need for reform, NIL provides a special opportunity to change the collegiate sports society for years to come and benefit student-athletes across America. While some may have concerns about the implementation of NIL, it is important to remember that this reform is long overdue. The current system has prominent issues, and NIL can be a vital step in addressing these issues. By working collaboratively, we can find solutions that benefit student-athletes, colleges, and the industry as a whole. The incorporation of NIL into college sports presents a chance for meaningful reform that has the potential to impact generations of student-athletes, and it is important to approach this issue with an open mind and a willingness to find common

Show More
Related

  • Essay On Sherman Act

    598 Words  | 3 Pages

    The grant in aids that the students receive are not the least restrictive means of carry out a legitimate business purpose. In O’Bannon, the Court ruled “The athletes accept grants-in-aid, and no more, in exchange for their athletic performance, because the NCAA schools have agreed to value the athletes’ name and likeness at zero, ‘an anticompetitive effect’.” This anticompetitive effect is an anti-trust violation under the rule of reason. Experts also concluded that providing smalls amounts of compensation will not affect consumer interest in collegiate sports.

    Read More

  • Should College Football Be Banned By Buzz Bissinger

    842 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the documentary Should College Football be Banned, Buzz Bissinger author of, Friday Night Lights, purposed that college teams could license out their names privately (Bissinger). This would be a major benefit to collegiate football in America. Not only would it divided the blurred barrier between college sports and college academia, it would provide players with the opportunity to make money while earning education. Too much funding is spent on collegiate sports like football and not enough is being given to benefit the true reason people go to college, for an expensive, but yet worth it education. Privatization of collegiate football could also lead to a higher focus on player’s health.

    Read More

  • College Athletes: Pros And Cons Of NL Deals

    1034 Words  | 5 Pages

    Montrez Brown Mr. Fowler Honors English May 7, 2023 Pros and Cons of NIL Deals College athletes have been a topic of debate for a long time now, especially in the context of brand deals and endorsements. With recent developments of Name, Image and Likeness (NIL) policies college athletes can now earn money from brand endorsement deals, benefits and negatives from the (NIL) deals. The implementation of (NIL) deals for college athletes is a crucial step towards providing them with the rights and opportunities they deserve, as it allows them to monetize the talent while fostering a more equitable and sustainable college sports industry (Bilas). This essay will explore the benefits and negative aspects of (NIL) deals for college athletes and brands. BENEFITS OF NIL DEALS FOR COLLEGE ATHLETES

    Read More

  • Analysis: Why College Athletes Should Be Paid

    1220 Words  | 5 Pages

    For a century the National Collegiate Athletic Association has been around governing the organization for millions of college athlete. In the recent year, though, many people have been asking whether or not college athletes should be paid to play their sports in college, in particular, Division One male football and basketball players. The Paying of college athletes concept is in its resolution and plan, however the history of this issue dates back two decades and has proven both ineffective and discriminatory. The negative inherency of this new potential solution would far outweigh any minute advantages that the opposition will attempt to present as a positive change.

    Read More

  • Brief History And Role Of The NCAA

    796 Words  | 4 Pages

    Fast forward to June 2021, the NCAA saw a need for change again. This time around they approve the Name, Image and Likeness (NIL) policy for student athletes. The NIL policy allows for NCAA D1, D2, and D3 student-athletes to be compensated for their NIL (ncsasports.org,

    Read More

  • Why Do Student Athletes Get Paid?

    1622 Words  | 7 Pages

    Since it’s founding over a century ago, the NCAA has developed from a minute form of extra-curricular involvement offered to students, to a dominant entertainment industry nationwide. The growing success of this program has promoted a genuinely competitive nature, deteriorating the previous category of “amateurism”. Being that it has become such a popular program, the demand for student-athlete dedication has become exuberant. The development has established sports as the central focus for student-athletes as practices and competitions amount to 40+ hour workweeks for them. Such a heavy involvement in addition to school prevents the student-athletes from being able to work, leaving them unable to form an income to afford living expenses that scholarships cannot cover.

    Read More

  • Student Athletes Paid Argumentative Analysis

    961 Words  | 4 Pages

    Yet, the term “student athlete” seems to always hold these talks back. There is certainly a strong possibility that athletics within the NCAA and its member institutions will no longer be considered either amateur or educational (Smith), but until then athletes will struggle and do what is necessary to survive. The NCAA may still have the edge in this vigorous debate, but it is only a matter of time until their unfair treatment of student athletes comes to an

    Read More

  • Essay On Should College Athletes Be Paid

    730 Words  | 3 Pages

    As the NCAA revenue continues to climb, pressure to pay student athletes is growing(“Why college athletes deserve compensation” 1).Former NFL player Michael Bennett told ESPN, “Heck yeah college athletes should be paid(Reasons Why Student Athletes Should Be Paid” 2).He says “NCAA gets paid, Rose Bowl gets paid, everybody gets paid except the people making the product(“Reasons Why Student Athletes Should Be Paid” 2). There is an extreme amount of attention brought to curtain sports around the world, and that is Football, and Basketball(“Why College Athletes Should Be Compensated” 1). These sports alone generate Billions of dollars every year for just such a short period of time, and this revenue that is being brought in from not only these two sports, but the other sports that other 4-year universities may have, is not being used in the right ways(“Why College Athletes Should Be Compensated” 2). The money that is being brought in every year seems to never find the student

    Read More

  • Should College Athletes Be Paid Essay

    1139 Words  | 5 Pages

    Universities offer thousands of scholarships to athletes; however, outside of school, students struggle with finances. California State University News Program (The Orion) declared that “most college athletes do not have time for a part-time job because they are balancing practices” into their already busy school schedules (Sanchez). It’s difficult for students to create a stable financial platform with the inability to have a job, creating a financial burden from the start of their college experience. Knowing the struggle for money, the NCAA made the executive decision to make NIL a possible outlet for athletes. The implementation of NIL not only allows students to have the finances to support themselves, but they can also use the money to better set themselves up for their future careers.

    Read More

  • College Athletes Should Be Paid Analysis

    1317 Words  | 6 Pages

    It includes only those funds that end up in the NCAA 's bank account.” The FCAA being the organization that would collect and distribute the capital. This research paper described why college athletes should be paid. They make personal sacrifices, and take risks in order to produce revenue for their schools.

    Read More

  • Should College Athletes Be Paid Essay

    1056 Words  | 5 Pages

    The first reason high school athletes shouldn’t be allowed to benefit from NIL deals in high school and college is because of too much pressure. For evidence, the article “Could NIL dollars flow down to Michigan high school athletes?” by Hugh Bernreuter states “Adding the pressure of NL compensation isn’t fair to the student. They

    Read More

  • Essay On Should College Athletes Be Paid

    715 Words  | 3 Pages

    NIL contracts are a great way for athletes to get noticed by professional leagues like the NBA. There are many instances of athletes getting recognized from their sponsorships. When Overtime Elite presented the opportunity to a group of student-athletes, they “jumped at the rare opportunity” in the hope that it will help with “making an even bigger leap to the NBA” (Huddleston 1). This means that student-athletes have an opportunity to make a bigger name for themselves and have a better chance at competing in professional sports. Players with NIL deals can get even more recognition through social media pages run by their sponsors.

    Read More

  • Analysis: Should College Athletes Get Paid

    1508 Words  | 7 Pages

    In today’s era, college athletes receive no compensation for their extremely high levels of play. These athletes have been playing their respective sports for many,

    Read More

  • Annotated Bibliography: Should College Athletes Be Paid

    904 Words  | 4 Pages

    Should college athletes be paid? Annotated Bibliography Benedykiuck, Mike. “The Blue Line: College athletes should be paid.” Dailyfreepress.

    Read More

  • NCAA Paid Case Study

    1676 Words  | 7 Pages

    The fight for payment of college athletes has not been quick one as more and more issues keep popping up. The NCAA has never allowed payment of its athletes, but small steps towards the overall goal has questioned the NCAA’s past. Its’ decisions has stayed constant since its founding in 1906. The first issue in this decision would not occur until 1952 when the NCAA ruled to give The University of Kentucky the ‘death penalty’ for paying their athletes. This ‘death penalty’ is a one year program ban from participation, the harshest penalty the NCAA can give.

    Read More

More about Criticism Of NIL In College Sports

Open Document