Criticisms Of Boarding School
Dear Mr Rusbridger, I am writing with regards to the articles “Acceptable Cruelty” and “ The British boarding school remains a bastion of cruelty” by George Monbiot. After reading the articles, I have two concerns. First, that sending children to boarding school at a very young age may indeed harm their development. Second, that Monbiot’s negative personal experiences have led to him giving an unfair account of boarding schools.
I am concerned to hear that children as young as three, according to your writer, are taken from their families and put in boarding schools. I also agree that taking children when they are very young might harm children’s development or bonding with their parents.
However, after around the age of 10, children become socially independent. They make friends outside their family’s social circles. They are mature enough to spend time away from their families, but not mature enough to make all of their own decisions. Therefore, boarding schools create a platform for children to learn and to grow under responsible supervision.
In both of his articles, Monbiot compares boarding schools to extreme environments. I find this hyperbole unhelpful and feel that it undermines any credible arguments he makes. Boarding schools are not prisons. They are not comparable to nightmaresque abusive children’s homes for pitiful children from troubled backgrounds or orphans. Boarding school students attend these schools as they will provide
Charlotte Geaghan-Breiner's Argument
333 Words | 2 PagesBreiner’s tries to prove is the movement that children need involvements in nature for health issues yet, they have fewer contact to nature than the former peers. In this argument she proves how school yards take effect in any children’s life in order to help them propagate. The evidence she stated to prove her argument was based on quotes she found from other individuals. She starts her argument by stating that children don’t have
Euro-American Boarding School
174 Words | 1 PagesThe Bureau of Indian Affairs removed tens of thousands of American Indian children from their homes in the late 19th and early 20th centuries to assimilate the youth into the dominant Euro-American culture. Although the schools provided education and vocational training, their primary intention was to deprive Indian children of their tribal culture, language, and appearance. There was a significant amount of abuse in the boarding schools with administrators, teachers, and staff often treating students harshly, including physical and sexual abuse and neglect. Moreover, children suffered serious illnesses and disease. Due to these harsh conditions many Indian youth returned home with mental and physical health problems that transcended for
Describe With Examples How Children's Development May Be Negatively Affected By Situations
489 Words | 2 PagesIt might be very difficult for them to build friendships. Events which may impact on behaviour, social and emotional development: • Serious illness or injury to a child e.g. if a child breaks a leg and has to be in hospital for a long stay they become institutionalised and perhaps lose their grip on reality because all they know then is the hospital routine. • Serious illness or injury to a child’s main carer • Death of a close relative • Family break-up: This can cause a child to feel very upset, insecure and abandoned. When their family unit breaks apart their whole world seems to have lost stability and this most likely will have an impact on their behaviour and development • Change of care e.g. entering foster care or residential care • Abuse – physical, emotional, sexual or
Rhetorical Analysis Of Against Schools By John Gatto
1011 Words | 5 PagesIn the “Against Schools” article, author John Gatto describes the modern day schooling system and its flaws. He uses several rhetorical strategies in trying to prove his point. He successfully uses all three types of rhetoric in writing this article, which includes ethos, pathos, and logos. He establishes these strategies very early, and often throughout the article. He believes one issues with today’s schooling system is boredom, and that there is a distinct difference between what it means to be educated and schooled.
Theme Of Losses In The Marrow Thieves
429 Words | 2 PagesMany lost their innocence, their laughter, their lives.” (Dimaline 23) this shows the idea of what the Residential schools have done to the kids who sadly were taken away from their families, and what the government has done to
The Sanctuary Of School Lynda Barry Analysis
563 Words | 3 PagesIn her narrative essay “The Sanctuary of School,” Lynda Barry recounts a story from her childhood that illustrates her relationships at school vs her relationships at home. She tells us how public school was her sanctuary from her unstable home life. It was a stable environment that she depended on. She tells us this when she says ,"[F]or the next six hours I was going to enjoy a thoroughly secure, warm and stable world." Unlike at home, her school was a place she was noticed and cared about.
Essay On Native American Boarding School
1187 Words | 5 Pages“The significance of Native American boarding school was that Americans were trying to assimilate their culture and their way of living.” Many Native Americans today have very different opinions to how their people were placed in Indian boarding school. “Many Native Americans think that it helped their people be more civilized and help them live in american ways. ”While other Native Americans think that boarding schools were a place where they were torchered and a place where they lost their freedom and their culture. “Most people agree that Indian Boarding schools were just trying to help indians be more civilized, but others can see the wrong in the schools.”
Native American Boarding Schools
967 Words | 4 PagesIn 1870 the United States government decided that they wanted to remodel the Native American Culture. They began with forcing all Indians to live on small, unprotected land which they called an Indian reservation. Their next step was to put our Native children into extremely harsh boarding schools and have them stripped of their culture. They decided it would be easiest to take the culture away from our children instead of adults. In 1877 the Congress set aside $20,000 to reeducate all Native children, their goal was to “kill the Indian, and save the child.”
Argumentative Essay: Year-Round School Vs. Traditional School
443 Words | 2 PagesWhether year-round schooling should be enforced in Florida schools has been a recent debate. Florida schools should not take part in year-round schooling schedules because it makes sports and jobs very hard to get too, also year-round schooling gives teachers insufficient time to prepare for the next school year. Even though year-round school gives students more breaks, there is no proof that it helps students academically. So traditional school is better and should stay in Florida.
Alandra's Lilacs Reflection On Deaf Culture
1751 Words | 8 PagesThis school was very beneficial for Alandra’s education because it used the method ‘Total Communication’ which allowed her to use American Sign Language and learn without being restricted by her teachers. However this upside to Alandra having a beneficial education took her away from her mother Tressa at a very young age. Tress explains this when she says, “I believe that leaving my five-year-old daughter at a residential school was the most traumatic event I experienced as a result of her deafness. I have heard all the reasons and excuses for sending deaf children to a residential school- better education, being with ‘their own kind,’ the amount of language they can absorb, and the freedom to express themselves in their own language. Still, I feel that nothing can replace the child growing up at home if a child’s family provides quality support and the public system makes educating deaf children a priority.”
Social Class School Anyon Summary
1093 Words | 5 PagesI was amazed to read that in the affluent school, some of the children mention they will rather not be rich. Rich meant that they could not work and they will rather work since they liked working. In the executive school, I was bothered by the comment that a teacher stated. A teacher associated low-income children with discipline problems. I think that teacher generalized an observation he
Essay On Native American Boarding Schools
527 Words | 3 PagesThe Native Americans and white people never got along ever since the time the first pilgrims arrived. After losing many wars to the white men Native Americans soon became controlled by these white men to the point where their children were forced into boarding schools. The government stated that the schools would civilize the native children and fix what they called the indian problem. They saw Native Americans as if they weren’t also part of the human race, as if they were less. That wasn’t the worse part either in the boarding schools where the native american children attended they were mistreated and malnourished.
Sigmund Freud's Contribution To Child Development
1501 Words | 7 PagesChild development is an area of significant interest to professionals who deal with children on a daily basis. It is through child development theorists and their theories that we begin to form an understanding of how children develop emotionally and socially to become fully grown adults in society with a moral and emotional compass/. Teachers need to study child development in order to provide developmentally appropriate educational experiences for children. Health professionals also need to understand this area to support children in their physical, social, emotional and cognitive journey to becoming functioning adults in society. Childhood is a concept that is affected by social context and also by history. Here in the West childhood was not always considered to be a fundamental developmental phase in life with children in Victorian times working from as early as the age of four.
Child Abuse Theory
1199 Words | 5 Pageshat have been developing to understand and explain the origins and causes of child abuse. Psychological Theories This theory focuses on the impulsive and psychological traits of the offenders. According to Corby (2000), often the individual abuser may have been abuse in childhood, thus causing abnormalities are responsible for abuse. i. Attachment Theory Bowlby (1951) talks about this theory whereby he explains that the separation of a child from the mother in the first five years may lead to psychological and social difficulties in later life.
Essay About School System
751 Words | 4 PagesWhy the school system is bad - Arshia Education is very important for everyone and it will only get more important. Schooling is just plain bad. It used to serve a purpose, like the heart in a person 's body, but now it is basically just boring students more and more. Nowadays at the end of the day, we all just want to go home.
More about Criticisms Of Boarding School
Charlotte Geaghan-Breiner's Argument
333 Words | 2 PagesEuro-American Boarding School
174 Words | 1 PagesDescribe With Examples How Children's Development May Be Negatively Affected By Situations
489 Words | 2 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Against Schools By John Gatto
1011 Words | 5 PagesTheme Of Losses In The Marrow Thieves
429 Words | 2 PagesThe Sanctuary Of School Lynda Barry Analysis
563 Words | 3 PagesEssay On Native American Boarding School
1187 Words | 5 PagesNative American Boarding Schools
967 Words | 4 PagesArgumentative Essay: Year-Round School Vs. Traditional School
443 Words | 2 PagesAlandra's Lilacs Reflection On Deaf Culture
1751 Words | 8 PagesSocial Class School Anyon Summary
1093 Words | 5 PagesEssay On Native American Boarding Schools
527 Words | 3 PagesSigmund Freud's Contribution To Child Development
1501 Words | 7 PagesChild Abuse Theory
1199 Words | 5 PagesEssay About School System
751 Words | 4 Pages