Cultural Relativist And Feminist Critique Of 'Friends Or Foes'
Reitman, Oonagh. "Cultural Relativist and Feminist Critiques of International Human Rights—Fiends or Foes?." Statsvetenskaplig tidskrift 100, no. 1 (1997), 100-110.
The journal entitled “Cultural Relativist and Feminist Critiques of the International Human Rights –Friends or Foes”, written by Oonagh Reitman is a good fully equipped critical journal since the author put the focus on the discussion about the similarity between two branches of international human rights, the cultural relativist and the feminist in term of their critiques towards the international human rights and also present the fact of the clash between these two critiques when talking about women’s human rights. This critical review paper will provide a summary of the journal
…show more content…
The fear of Feminist perspective is that cultural relativist perspective will hinder the implementation and recognition as well as the enforcement of the rights of women as the human rights (Bunting 1993). The most suitable evidence is the practice of Shariah Law in some Muslim majority states, especially in the Middle East. Women in the community which ruled by Shariah has fewer right than women in the Western countries (Friedland 2014). The proof we can see based on Q 4:11 and Q 4:176 that woman will only get or have only a half much than her brother inherit (Al-Manteeqi 2016). Shariah law has violates a lot of women’s rights. It is written in Shariah law than women can be beaten, wives cannot have the same portion of divorces right like what their husband does, female rulers are frowned, raping female detents is permits, and …show more content…
Reitman clearly explains and elaborate the arguments well, from the introduction to the concluding section. The beginning chapter has clearly shown the whole thing that the author will discuss. Once again, this is a well-organized article with very clear and comprehensive arguments and explanations. I agree with the arguments of the opposition between two branches of international human rights, the cultural relativism and the feminism, towards the international human rights itself particularly in term of universality. However, I see that the cultural relativist may cooperate with feminist to achieve their intention against the universality but I see this more into Cultural Relativist vs (Feminist vs human rights). Because the practice of cultural relativist based on tradition or religion is against or opposing both universal human rights and the rights of
Women's Equality In The 1920s
1468 Words | 6 PagesReligious traditions believed that God made women weaker than men. Many people did not approve of feminists’ innovative ways such as encouraging women to stand out from the crowd and pursue reformation in politics. It is hard for a woman in disadvantaged conditions to receive gender equality in such a patriarchal
Un Charter Dbq
796 Words | 4 PagesThese human rights 'instruments', as they are called, have fixed how many rights apply to particular groups of human beings such as women or children. They have also come up with new ideas that were not part of the thinking of those who first drafted the Universal Declaration. The link between human rights and other pillars is clearly evident all the way through the UDHR. First, it allows, in the Preamble, that the credit of the unchallengeable rights of all people is the groundwork of freedom, justice and peace across the world. Secondly, it expands the UN Charter’s stated purpose of encouraging growth by giving economic, social and cultural rights the in the same degree of safety that an individual finds for civil and political rights (Marshall
Dbq Essay Religion
879 Words | 4 PagesSince 1979, the Iran’s laws have been based on Islamic law, called Sharia. Though there are elected positions in Iran’s government, the ultimate power is held by religious leaders who ensure that all government actions are in line with their interpretation of the Quran and Sharia Law.” and it also states that, “The grim statutes [laws] that I would spend the rest of my life fighting stared back at me from the page: the value of a woman's life was half that of a man… The laws, in short, turned the clock back fourteen hundred years, to the early days of Islam's spread, the days when stoning women for adultery and chopping off the hands of thieves were considered appropriate sentences ....” Till this day women in Iran are still badly affected by these Iran
Snapshot Of Health And Social Care Report
2602 Words | 11 PagesSince, the eighteen century women have been seeing as property, object and goods (Popple, 2015, p.64). However, today the feminist theory represents the perception that the society and the state is still patriarchal were men persist in dominant positions and women are in subordinate positions. Fact is, accordingly to Bryson (1993) cited in Popple (2015), male power get still physical and psychological demonstrated with domestic violence, sexual abuse or other types of control to minimize women. (Popple,2015, p.65.). It can be argued that the feminist theory
The Myth Of Latin Woman 'And A Look Behind The Veil'
928 Words | 4 PagesThese texts along with the article “Veil of Ignorance” by Leila Ahmed share a common issue, which is misjudging women based on
Analysis Of Cultural Relativist And Critique Of International Human Rights
1347 Words | 6 PagesReitman then examines the combative relationship between the two groups. Cultural relativists believe feminists are ‘protecting a Western notion of equality’ (Reitman 1997, 107); that the universal rights they claim are based on the perspective of Western, white middle-class women without regards to women of other culture. In turn, feminists accuse cultural relativists of ‘protecting a male version of culture’
Second Amendment And Women's Rights
1491 Words | 6 PagesWomen have been treated as an evil creature in the countries of Islam; men cannot control their sexual desires at any sight of the seductresses. That is why they were required to cover every piece of skin if they were to venture out of their prison (home). They would also suffer from physical violence if they were in the streets and this happened. The women of old China were oppressed as well, however not as severely as the Islamic women were oppressed. If they were to have a child out of wedlock, they were demoted to the “outcast table”; if they had homes, they were ransacked.
Essay On Feminism In Islam
2077 Words | 9 PagesFor many, feminist movement is about giving women liberty, equal opportunity and control over their own destiny. C. ISLAMIC FEMINISM In many Muslim countries, the “f” word (feminism) has sparked tensions, conjuring images of domineering, family-hating woman; similar to other labels such as “Muslim” conjuring images of subjugated woman in the mind of the West. Although these stereotypes are true in a specific historical context, these may not be so when compared to a larger reality. Thus, this does not justify the hostility that follows.
What Is The Women's Rights Movement Still Relevant Today
1501 Words | 7 PagesThe issue of women’s rights and how different societies and cultures deal with it had been on the table for many centuries. In the United States of America during the 1800s, women began to move toward and demand getting equal rights as men, they decided to speak up and fight for their stolen rights. In the 1960s, continued working toward their goal, women broadened their activities through the women’s rights movement which aimed to help them in gaining their right to receive education, occupy the same jobs that were once titled only for men, and get an access to leadership positions. The women’s rights movement has a great impact on women today, although it started a long time ago, but it did not stop and women are reaping their fruit today,
Feminism Without Borders Summary
798 Words | 4 PagesShe explains the cruciality of transnational feminism, where it is dependent upon building solidarity across the divisions among women. Overall, Mohanty believes in illuminating the historical aspects of nations and how they led to the social construction of women. Mohanty’s text was exceedingly interesting to read since it expanded my perceptions
Essay On Feminist Critique Of International Human Rights
1594 Words | 7 Pages“Cultural Relativist and Feminist Critique of International Human Rights- Friends or Foes?” The journal, “Cultural Relativist and Feminist Critique of International Human Rights- Friends or Foes?” by Oonagh Reitman have the aim to know deeper about the two critiques towards the universal Human Rights by the two major theory, which are the Cultural Relativism and Feminism, how they see the universal Human Rights theory. The Journal address for the workshop discussion matter regarding to the similarities on critique of International human rights that made by the Cultural relativist and the feminist. “ Human Rights is the right that given and held by human simply because they are human, and it does not classified nor held by certain groups or not the subject to variation in culture”(Donnelly 1989: 109-110) From the introduction in the journal, the writer defines how the feminist and the cultural relativist express their idea of Universal human rights. The idea of Universal human rights from Donnelly were being reserve by Relativist, they argue that the human rights itself root from culture and due to the variation of culture, making the human rights not universal.
Feminist Legal Theory
1204 Words | 5 PagesThe concept is particularly significant for the minority groups, females and to the poor. In reference to the Feminist Legal aspects, women must be treated equally as men regardless of different aspects including race, gender, national origin, ethnic group, religion and capabilities without any discrimination and biasness. In context of modern equality feminist legal theory, women are entitled to have equality before the law and should be discriminated based on gender. Finally, it determines that with enhancing globalisation and improvement of human rights discourses, equality and dominance in feminist theory started to be
Essay On Human Rights Failure
1036 Words | 5 PagesIntroduction In this article, Eric Poser has elaborated several reasons which made human rights a failure in international legal regime. The most highlighted issues are hypocrite policies of US and EU which has directly questioned credibility and integrity of their law and justice. The second reason is role played by Russia and China, the two major economic powers who in order to sustain their power, are involved in human rights violations. The third most important reason is standardized model of Universal Declaration of Human Rights which is ideal but not practical in various countries.
Cultural Relativist And Feminist Analysis
1081 Words | 5 PagesThe feminist and cultural relativist have the same critique but different goal. Feminists do not refute the theory that the international human rights is universal, but feminism critique about the practice of international human right, while Cultural relativist critique both the theory and practical of International Human Rights. Feminists argue that the universality that been said in the International Human Rights have not been realized in daily life practices, Feminism assumed that the right only owned and protect the men. Feminism felt like women are not the part of “human” category that stated in the Human Rights. Feminism believes that if the international human rights are truly universal, then the rights is not only for men but also for women which means there must be the right guarantee for women and the rule for their protection.
More about Cultural Relativist And Feminist Critique Of 'Friends Or Foes'
Women's Equality In The 1920s
1468 Words | 6 PagesSummary Of The Onion Case
1196 Words | 5 PagesUn Charter Dbq
796 Words | 4 PagesDbq Essay Religion
879 Words | 4 PagesSnapshot Of Health And Social Care Report
2602 Words | 11 PagesThe Myth Of Latin Woman 'And A Look Behind The Veil'
928 Words | 4 PagesAnalysis Of Cultural Relativist And Critique Of International Human Rights
1347 Words | 6 PagesSecond Amendment And Women's Rights
1491 Words | 6 PagesEssay On Feminism In Islam
2077 Words | 9 PagesWhat Is The Women's Rights Movement Still Relevant Today
1501 Words | 7 PagesFeminism Without Borders Summary
798 Words | 4 PagesEssay On Feminist Critique Of International Human Rights
1594 Words | 7 PagesFeminist Legal Theory
1204 Words | 5 PagesEssay On Human Rights Failure
1036 Words | 5 PagesCultural Relativist And Feminist Analysis
1081 Words | 5 Pages