Cyber Security Dilemma Case Study
SECURITY STUDIES
Cyber security Dilemma
Cooperation under the security dilemma in cyberspace
Prof. Coordonator Radu Ungureanu
Belusica Sabin
1/13/2015
This short essay applies the security dilemma framework to cyberspace and analyzes the severity of the dilemma and questions if it can be reduced and if cooperation is possible in cyberspace.
Table of Contents
Introduction 1
Theory 2
Cyber Warfare 2
CyberSecurity Dilemma 2
Offense Defense 2
Case Studies 2
Defence Budgets 2
Cyber Attacks 2
Analysis 3
Conclusions 3
Bibliography 3
Introduction
A recent contemporary challenge has emerged, determined by globalization and technological advancements, which can cause unimaginable catastrophes. This bears the name of cyber war, a newly
…show more content…
Since the two are interconnected, Waltz’ affirmation applies to this environment as well: “a state will use force to attain its goals if, after assessing the prospects for success, it values those goals more than it values the pleasures of peace.” (Waltz, 2001, p. 160) In addition to this, non-states actors have become important players in cyberspace as cyber-attacks are accessible to almost anyone in the world. As states try to defend themselves against such threats they mimic the traditional spiral model of the security dilemma. we are witnessing the start of a digital arms race in which states, institutions and non-state actors are entering a new battlefield.
By analysing cyberspace and cyber warfare through the framework of the security dilemma this paper aims to understand whether or not is it possible to reduce the security dilemma and cooperate in
…show more content…
E. (2010). National Security Cyberspace Institute. Retrieved January 4, 2015, from Memorandum for chiefs of the military services commanders of the combatant commands directors of the joint staff directorates: http://www.nsci-va.org/CyberReferenceLib/2010-11-joint%20Terminology%20for%20Cyberspace%20Operations.pdf
Jervis, R. (1978). Cooperation Under the Security Dilemma,” World Politics, Vol. 30, No. 2. Cambridge University Press.
Putrich, G. (2014, March 04). FCW The Business of Federal Technology. Retrieved January 05, 2015, from http://fcw.com/articles/2014/03/04/budget-defense.aspx
Waltz, K. N. (2001). Man the State and War. New York: Columbia University
Rhetorical Analysis Of Ambassador Power
1519 Words | 7 PagesThe former U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations, Ambassador Samantha Power, gave a speech on January 17, 2017 on the threat of Russia to the United States. There has been underlying tension between the U.S. and Russia for decades, but there was a period of cooperation between the two nations. Currently the tensions are rising again. The accusations of Russia interfering with the United States’ most recent election, along with other actions done by the Russian government, has put the U.S. on high alert again. The United States has shown signs of both the liberalist and realist state of minds when dealing with international relations and the dilemma Russian has put the United States in.
Joint Terrorism Task Force And DHS Fusion Centers Analysis
1139 Words | 5 PagesIntroduction The Joint Terrorism Task Forces and Department of Homeland Security (DHS) Fusion Centers are two crucial intelligence-gathering programs in the United States. Both programs play a big role in preventing terrorist attacks and other criminal activities, such as drug and weapon smuggling. These agencies are responsible for collecting and analyzing intelligence information to identify potential terrorist threats and prevent attacks. Understanding the history and impact on the United States is essential to ensure effective law enforcement and national security measures. This paper will examine the history of the Joint Terrorism Task Forces and DHS Fusion Centers, the benefits of the programs, the impact of the programs on national security
Word Wars Rhetorical Analysis
788 Words | 4 PagesRhetorical Analysis of Word Wars A strategic narrative is a story that a nation must tell itself, and the world, to wage a war or to maintain a competitive advantage in the international system (Free Speech). The mass impact of technology has captivated this idea and has used it to express the freedom of speech in ways that has never been done before, but also "[pushes] these limits past common decency" (Wickman 27). Two authors debate with this international problem in different styles, but share some of the same concepts and common fallacies on this issue.
September 11th 2001 Dbq Essay
971 Words | 4 PagesIn the years following September 11th, 2001, American military spending has skyrocketed (Document F). The purpose of this document is to exhibit how American resources are being more focused on the military following the attacks. In 2001, the United States spent around 400 billion dollars to support the military. The graph shows a sharp incline from then until 2011, where military spending was up to about 700 billion. This statistic can be connected to the Authorization for Use of Military Force, as America has become more focused on militan efforts due to the events of September 11th.
9/11 Constraints
1309 Words | 6 PagesIt will examine how the current constraints play a role in homeland defense and defense overseas, the tensions between competing interests of homeland security and international support. Finally, how the U.S. can best balance their requirements against the limited fiscal constraints. How We Protect the Homeland Until the terrorist acts of September 11, the U.S. military focused their efforts overseas to fight and win wars; we have since changed the way we do business. The 2014 Quadrennial Defense Review (QDR) emphasizes the Department’s first defense strategy to protect the nation. The Department of Defense (DOD) will deter and defeat attacks on the United States and to support civil authorities in potential attacks and natural disasters.”
What Will America Be Remembered For Essay
563 Words | 3 PagesAs Disrupters The strength of future militaries will be compared to our own; the expansive reach of the US military is the largest on Earth. From conflicts in South America to the Middle East and Asia, the US has always thrived during wartime, gaining much of its power from the aftermath of World War II. By much of the world today our country is seen as democratic invaders; bringing a message of democracy and freedom while still firmly holding our weapons. In this way, our country has shaped the world drastically; influencing both the progress of technology and the equivalent sizes of foreign militaries.
The Pros And Cons Of Fusion Centers
1001 Words | 5 PagesThe United States currently possess several valuable capabilities within our intelligence to support our homeland security efforts, but we also face a number of limitations as well. Places like Fusion Centers for example, which are operational and resourceful centers within their appropriated state and major cities, are considered an invaluable resource in the fight against terrorism and other threats. These centers were created with the purpose of sharing intelligence and information among numerous agencies to reorganize operations, optimize our ability to fight crime and terrorism, and increase resources by the integration of data from different sources. Fusion centers are channels for applying concepts that can improve our counterintelligence
Patriot Act Of 2002 Essay
999 Words | 4 PagesThis paper will discuss how to balance out civil liberties and security in intelligence activities; mainly surrounding the topic of the USA PATRIOT Act of 2002. With this topic and its perceived downfalls, identifying how to make both sides work efficiently will be discussed. Discussion When asked the question of “how can the United States balance civil liberties and security in intelligence activities?” the thought of the USA PATRIOT Act comes into mind; for two reasons. The first one is it caused a enormous uproar in the community after it was enacted based upon the fact it was perceived to infringe on civil liberties.
DHS Mission Overlaps
670 Words | 3 PagesMission Overlaps within the Department of Homeland Security In the United States, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is primarily responsible for ensuring the safety of the general public. Aside from that, this department seeks to protect the U.S. from terrorists, and it ensures that the immigration and customs is properly managed, and that disaster is efficiently prevented, as the case may be. However, some have called for the shutting down of the DHS because mission areas overlap within this department. In line with this assertion, this paper will identify the possible mission areas or responsibilities that overlap within the DHS and at the same time, this paper will also provide recommendations for possible consolidation.
Homeland Security Definition
1093 Words | 5 PagesWithin the areas of Homeland Security and Homeland Defense lie specific primary missions, tasks, duties, and responsibilities of each. The primary missions, tasks, duties, and responsibilities of Homeland Security and Defense include preventing terrorism and enhancing security, securing and managing our borders, and enforcing immigration laws. Additionally, some primary tasks of Homeland Security also include safeguarding cyberspace and protecting ourselves from natural disasters (DHS, 2014). In order to achieve these goals, there are certain resources that play an integral part in accomplishing the mission. Some of these resources include strategic documents, law enforcement agencies, intelligence agencies, and the Department of Defense
The 9/11 Recession
1350 Words | 6 PagesPurdy, Elizabeth Rholetter, PhD. "Cyberterrorism." Salem Press Encyclopedia. September 2013. EBSCOhost, search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true$db=t60&AN=89677539. Accessed.
Anarchy In International Relations
1610 Words | 7 PagesSince,"anarchy is what states make of it,” all states do not need to stress over their relative power and can focus on achieving long term peace.(Wendt, 79-80). While realist classical perspectives point to solely human nature and the anarchical system as the reason for conflict, Wendt provides an example showing that the self identities of states can lead to peace or conflict. He points to defining situations in context history that help determine a state 's interest. He states, “This seems to be happening today in the United States and the former Soviet Union. Without the cold war’s mutual attributions of threat and hostility to define their identities, these states seem unsure of what their ‘interests’
Cybersecurity Personal Statement Examples
705 Words | 3 PagesCybersecurity has become a growing cause for concern in the United States and indeed countries around the world. On February 9, 2016 President Barack Obama announced his Cybersecurity National Action plan (CNAP) to further the nations efforts to protect government agencies, citizens, and businesses from cyber threats domestic and abroad. However, cybersecurity is not a new issue in fact it is as old as the internet itself. With that said, I keep thinking back to that warm September day stained with the image of an enormous fireball engulfing our small TV set. This horrific day changed the course of history forever along with my future career path.
The Pros And Cons Of Cyber Security
1768 Words | 8 PagesWith computer technologies and the internet has connected the world together with the ability to communicate with people in different countries. As a society, we have become very dependent on computers and when the systems go down we cannot function as well, businesses cannot conduct their business. With the internet connecting the world together, it gives concerns for cyber-terrorism and cyber-attacks. Cyberterrorism is when a group attacks a target with intention of causing harm and further political, social, religious, or other goals. Cyber-attacks are attacks on a target system carried about by different people and may not be associated with a terrorist group.
Essay On Cyberwarfare
858 Words | 4 PagesDecades ago, people felt that cyber war was not a serious threat. However, in recent years, there have been numerous instances of cyber warfare that viewed as significant threats to security. In December 2010, a group calling itself the Pakistan Cyber Army
More about Cyber Security Dilemma Case Study
Rhetorical Analysis Of Ambassador Power
1519 Words | 7 PagesJoint Terrorism Task Force And DHS Fusion Centers Analysis
1139 Words | 5 PagesWord Wars Rhetorical Analysis
788 Words | 4 PagesSeptember 11th 2001 Dbq Essay
971 Words | 4 Pages9/11 Constraints
1309 Words | 6 PagesWhat Will America Be Remembered For Essay
563 Words | 3 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of Fusion Centers
1001 Words | 5 PagesPatriot Act Of 2002 Essay
999 Words | 4 PagesDHS Mission Overlaps
670 Words | 3 PagesHomeland Security Definition
1093 Words | 5 PagesThe 9/11 Recession
1350 Words | 6 PagesAnarchy In International Relations
1610 Words | 7 PagesCybersecurity Personal Statement Examples
705 Words | 3 PagesThe Pros And Cons Of Cyber Security
1768 Words | 8 PagesEssay On Cyberwarfare
858 Words | 4 Pages