Daniel Mendelsohn's Girl, Interrupted: Who Was Sappho
In Daniel Mendelsohn’s article “Girl, Interrupted: Who was Sappho?” he discusses what is known about poet Sappho, and also what is debated about her history. One of her poems he includes in his analysis is the newly constructed fragment 58, now known as the “Old Age Poem.” In the poem, Sappho seems to upsettingly discuss the idea and natural occurrence of growing old. As for my interpretation of the poem, perhaps Sappho is reflecting values of a time period in which youth and beauty were significant to their culture. From this poem we can learn Sappho’s views on ageing, as well as the tension with this subject within the culture of those of her time period. For instance, the speaker acknowledges the terrifying prospect of ageing, but also that …show more content…
What one person may view as Sappho’s intentions and general reflections on cultural values may be different that another persons. There is no way of knowing for sure what the meaning is because it was written so long ago and there are limited resources available to help interpret it. Additionally, small details pertaining to this primary source can significantly change its meaning. The article mentions how a simple “us” in a lyric instead of “me”, can change the entire interpretation, as it changes the speaker. (Mendelsohn 75) Thus, the issue of translating is important concerning the interpretation of this poem. If there were mistakes in the translation, an inaccurate portrayal would change the way people view the poem. Moreover, in his article Mendelsohn mentions how another version of the same poem had included additional lines that added a “triumphant assertion of the power of beauty, of the “finer things”—of poetry itself” (77) to the poem’s ending. These lines completely change the tone and feel, and give the poem a more powerful and appreciative, up lifting tone. The difference in the ending compared to the new version of “Old Age Poem” displays how small changes in a primary source can influence the audience’s viewpoint. Hence overall, the poem can be interpreted in more than one way depending on the person, and translation is significant to establishing
Of Mice And Men Rhetorical Analysis
913 Words | 4 PagesThe novel shows the ways itinerant workers were treated compared to upper class. Intertextuality between the poem and the novel foreshadowed some parts of the text and hinted some factors that may ruin the dream of owning a
Language And Tone In Elizabeth Alexander's 'Nineteen'
1190 Words | 5 PagesThis free-flowing language usage is seen through the three stanzas, as modern and allow ease in terms of reading for
Comparing Gwendolyn Brooks The Explorer And Robert Hayden's Frederick Douglass
605 Words | 3 PagesThere are many ways to interpret a literary text. You can interpret it from different levels, such as the literal level, the rhetorical level, or even the metaphysical level. Readers can also view texts from various critical lenses. This is due to the fact that when authors write texts, they often put in many different aspects of various things that can all be interpreted in any number of ways. Poets such as Gwendolyn Brooks and Robert Hayden are good examples of authors who write texts which can be interpreted in many different ways.
The Song Of Songs And Sappho And The Song Of Songs
742 Words | 3 PagesAncient text The Song of Songs and Sappho’s lyrics/fragments are both texts from the ancient world. Each works touches subjects like love, passion or even desire. There are couple of similarities between Sappho’s fragments and The Song of Songs yet there are also couple of disparities. Both expresses either love or desire towards someone.
Plato's Symposium And The Oppression Of Sappho
1343 Words | 6 PagesThe language in Plato’s symposium and the expression of Sappho’s poetry are similar in that they both deal with homoerotic love. Sappho, the only ancient Greek female author whose work survived, talks from the female point of observation, where as Plato’s work concentrates on the idea of love among males. In spite of the fact that both of their points of view are comparative in courses, for example, their thoughts of physical fascination and want, Plato’s work creates a better understanding of the nature of love then Sappho’s ideas. This understanding will be shown with three arguments and counter- arguments in order to demonstrate the dominance of Plato over Sappho. It will than be concluded with an overview of the main idea and a recap of the three arguments made for Plato.
Has Walhouse Changed The Pronoun By Sappho
213 Words | 1 PagesThe most noticeable liberty that Walhouse took with Sappho’s poem was when he changed the pronoun “she” to “he” in the sixth stanza. I suspect this is due to the historical norms of the Victorian Era where women are not supposed to educate themselves on current events and that those educational magazines such as this one would be read by men only so Walhouse changed the pronoun to suite his audience during this time. This change alters the interpretation of the poem greatly, in Carson’s translation with the pronounce she, the message seems to be that Sappho is either contemplating fleeing her relationship even though she can’t or she has a female lover that she wants to ensnared. Walhouse only left one message in his poem, which is Sappho
In My Eyes He Ang The Gods Sappho Analysis
847 Words | 4 PagesThis poem appeals well to the senses of the reader as for it goes into a plethora of detail surrounding how this woman makes Sappho feel. For example she states “then all at
A Close Reading In Shakespeare's Othello: A Close Reading
1359 Words | 6 PagesOthello: A Close Reading This is an analysis of the lines 260-279 of the third scene of the third act of Shakespeare’s Othello. In an attempt to fulfill the incessant need for comfortable dichotomies, societies tend to be divided into two groups: the ‘in-crowd’ and the ‘others’. These strict dualities, constructed upon the inherent need for adversaries, are often as arbitrary as they are false and based on nothing but fear.
Kenneth Patchen's Be Music, Night
1053 Words | 5 PagesI have interpreted these lines in one way, yet there are a million different possibilities. The author puts the words onto the paper, but the reader’s job is to interpret their own emotion, memory or belief and actually apply it to the poet’s words in order to create an
Literary Analysis Of Elizabeth Bishop's 'Exchanging Hats'
1809 Words | 8 PagesThe different key features also plays an important role for example the tone that is being formed by the lyrical voice that can be seen as a nephew or niece. This specific poem is also seen as an exposition of what Judith Butler will call a ‘gender trouble’ and it consist of an ABBA rhyming pattern that makes the reading of the poem better to understand. The poem emphasizes feminist, gender and queer theories that explains the life of the past and modern women and how they are made to see the world they are supposed to live in. The main theories that will be discussed in this poem will be described while analyzing the poem and this will make the poem and the theories clear to the reader. Different principals of the Feminist Theory.
Ode To My Boots Analysis
1122 Words | 5 PagesThis line is intended to demonstrate that although the poet
Paul Lawrence Dunbar We Wear The Mask Analysis
681 Words | 3 PagesMoreover, it helps connect the reader to the poem, since some people were and are
Hermeneutic Vs Rhetorical Reading
185 Words | 1 PagesMoreover, the critic wants to highlight a distinction between the types of interpretations of the story which can be called, the “hermeneutic” approach and the “rhetorical reading.” On the one hand, the hermeneutic interpretation “is guaranteed by the reference of the words to something distinct from them, (…). The “something different” may be the life of the author, or historical facts, (…), or some external code of interpretation” (144). On the other hand, the rhetorical reading “starts with the words and stays with them” (144). It supposes that is generated by the words alone rather than anything external to which they refer.
Sappho And Catullus Comparison Essay
342 Words | 2 PagesReaders can see Sappho’s influence on Catullus by him using the same words that Sappho uses in her poem. For example: Sapho states in stanza four, “speak—my tongue is broken; a thin flame runs under my skin; seeing nothing…” and in Catallus’ second poem, stanza three, he states: “Limbs are pierced with fire and the heavy tongue fails…” The repeated word in this example is tongue, but it is used differently. As readers continue to read and compare their poems they can notice how words and ideas are repeated. After reading and analyzing both of their works of poetry, I gathered the idea of Catallus' work to be more masculine.
How Did The Five Ages Of Man Change The Course Of Time
328 Words | 2 PagesAccording to the poem, there were 5 ages of man in which people changed over the course of time. The first age was the Golden Age, in which people lived happily and in harmony. Everything was peaceful and filled with loving spirits. People did not have to worry about the stressful things too much, and worked together with nature for food and land. Then came the Silver age and the Bronze age, in which people were so much more inferior compared to their earlier ancestor.
More about Daniel Mendelsohn's Girl, Interrupted: Who Was Sappho
Of Mice And Men Rhetorical Analysis
913 Words | 4 PagesLanguage And Tone In Elizabeth Alexander's 'Nineteen'
1190 Words | 5 PagesComparing Gwendolyn Brooks The Explorer And Robert Hayden's Frederick Douglass
605 Words | 3 PagesThe Song Of Songs And Sappho And The Song Of Songs
742 Words | 3 PagesPlato's Symposium And The Oppression Of Sappho
1343 Words | 6 PagesHas Walhouse Changed The Pronoun By Sappho
213 Words | 1 PagesIn My Eyes He Ang The Gods Sappho Analysis
847 Words | 4 PagesA Close Reading In Shakespeare's Othello: A Close Reading
1359 Words | 6 PagesKenneth Patchen's Be Music, Night
1053 Words | 5 PagesLiterary Analysis Of Elizabeth Bishop's 'Exchanging Hats'
1809 Words | 8 PagesOde To My Boots Analysis
1122 Words | 5 PagesPaul Lawrence Dunbar We Wear The Mask Analysis
681 Words | 3 PagesHermeneutic Vs Rhetorical Reading
185 Words | 1 PagesSappho And Catullus Comparison Essay
342 Words | 2 PagesHow Did The Five Ages Of Man Change The Course Of Time
328 Words | 2 Pages