Richard Shusterman's Definition Of Art Essay
In the following essay I provide a critical discussion of Richard Shusterman’s definition of art. Firstly, I illustrate how Shusterman defines art as experience and dramatization. Secondly, I provide how Danto and George Dickie define art and why Shusterman criticises their wrapper definitions. Lastly, I provide an explanation as to why Shusterman is flawed in claiming that art is ultimately experience.
Richard Shusterman (2012:1) states that it is difficult to point out what is considered to be art and what is not. The problem surfaces when we have to determine how an ordinary object of real life becomes an artwork. According to Shusterman, in order for something to be considered as art it has to be a product of human activity, an artefact. Shoes for example, could be seen as art in aesthetics to a certain someone. For art to be aesthetic it must draw attention or
…show more content…
Shusterman states that even though Dewey’s definition fails to extend to work of art, it does not mean it is not of value, because it serves a purpose, a purpose that Shusterman thinks is very important. Shusterman claims that it is mainly the immense satisfaction brought about by aesthetic experience that makes us attracted to art and its value. It is worthwhile for both the artist and the audience.
Even though many artworks fail to produce aesthetic experience, if such experience were never achieved art would probably have never existed (Shusterman 2002:28). Shusterman seems to believe that Dewey was unclear on how we would begin to define aesthetic experience. He further says that Dewey was not interested in formal definitions of aesthetic concepts.
According to Danto, purpose and intention are what define art. Context is what is most important to him. Something is an artwork if it can be interpreted as giving or offering some sort of perspective about
Elizabeth Sisco: Graphic Design Of Chicano Movement
1218 Words | 5 PagesArt is how an artist expresses their own emotion in their artwork. Artwork can express more than just emotion, it can be used as a memorial, awareness, and even art movement. Art movements are very powerful when used correctly. Art movements are created in different medium in art. Elizabeth Sisco has done a graphic design of Chicano movement.
Comparing The Statue Of Palette Of Narmer And Kouros
646 Words | 3 PagesThroughout history, art has existed. Art has existed throughout the regions and time, as such the marble statue of a Kouros and the palette of Narmer are good examples of art. Kouros in Greek means boy, the statue is made of marble and is nude (no clothes). Palette of Narmer is a palette that tells the story of the Egyptian king Narmer who rejoined Upper Egypt and lower Egypt to be together again.
Ishtar Gate Analysis
866 Words | 4 PagesBabylonian Traits of the Ishtar Gate Artwork means more than what one may see at first glance. There can be hidden meanings of the past or even hints of what their society was like. Each piece of art has something special including traits of the civilization; these traits are seen throughout history. With these traits we can tell what society we are looking at and experience the civilization 's unique culture. An example of a great piece of artwork contributing to society would be the Ishtar Gate in Babylon, this gate is very important within the Babylonian culture and expresses what their society treasured and valued along with the traits that this society had.
Quotes From 'Asher Lev Is Born'
1636 Words | 7 PagesBy placing a strong value on the moment of encounter or interaction with art, the author argues that art is not merely a static object but rather, an interaction between the viewer and the art. This language deepens the reader's understanding of Asher as a character and his deep connection to art but also the nature of art itself as a transformative experience rather than a stationary one. 17 Ladover Ideological quote “ One’s duty in life is to keep one’s miseries
Vik Munniz Analysis
806 Words | 4 PagesVik Muniz: He resolved a fight and he got shot by and man and in return for an apology he got money and came to america. He is wondering if art can change humanity They show a kindergarten classroom and how they watch a video on how he has to go in a garbage landfill and work there.
The Trouble With (The Term) Art By Carolyn Dean
791 Words | 4 PagesWhile reading “The Trouble with (the Term) Art,” written by Carolyn Dean in the summer of 2006, we are taken through an array of different scenarios that lead us to questions what art really is. Dean explores the idea that the word “art” is used far too often and too habitually, and that as we study the non-Western cultures we need to use much more discretion regarding what we call the different pieces of their culture. Throughout the essay, Dean supports her thesis that we too often categorize non-Western pieces as art by using different examples of how certain non-art pieces were deemed as art throughout the course of their history. Dean does this by using four key examples of how these ancient pieces are inappropriately called art to successfully support her thesis and avoid biases.
Research Paper On Starry Night
802 Words | 4 PagesEveryone has their own criteria set when it comes to art. But art is subjective and the artist shows you their views and interpretations. Art is limitless. Our body, mind, and soul is the creation of art.
Jeff Koons
416 Words | 2 Pages2011 The article presents the author's insights on the subjective opinions of people who are involved in art when it comes to good art, bad art and questions of quality. The author says that these people have different beliefs when it comes to a good work, in which some may state that Jeff Koons is a first-rate artist and some may not. He also compares artists' work aesthetics including Piet Mondrian to Ellsworth Kelly, Henri Matisse to Balthus, and Rembrandt Harmenszoon van Rijn to Corot. Schäfer, Martin Jörg.
How Does Art Affect Society
1410 Words | 6 PagesArt is when the artists and the people express themselves, their passion and their feelings, and convey sentiment. Art can affect people in unique ways and unlock their mind. Art can interpret in many different ways. Art can have a special meaning. Art has shown what society is going through at any given moment over the years.
Is Art A Waste Of Time? By Ryhs Southan
997 Words | 4 PagesArt is like a language, ideas and thoughts that may not be able to be articulated any other way. The big debate is whether artist artwork is a waste of resources and time, or if it is good for the world with all the creativity and the beauty it has. Art is more than justifiable to enjoy it. The enjoyment of art gives modern
Book Review: Art Worlds, By Howard Becker
1462 Words | 6 PagesArtists who have it should cherish it and share it with others, because not everyone has it. Sharing arts with others would bring prosperity to our society. Therefore, the art industry remains creatively due the gift motivation. Finally, from the Hyde’s
Roger Scruton Why Beauty Matters Summary
700 Words | 3 PagesIn his documentary film “why beauty matters” English philosopher Roger Scruton introduces the idea of beauty is disappearing from our world. The philosopher implies, that Art has become ugly, as well as our physical surroundings, manners, language, and music. Nowadays, the main aim of art is to disturb and break moral taboos. It has now lost its initial duty and is used to show solely the ugliness of our world, instead of taking what is most painful in the human condition and redeeming it in the work of beauty. What according to Scruton is the main purpose of art.
The Mirror And The Lamp Analysis
1994 Words | 8 PagesIt provides a condensed history of the evolution of critical theories and discriminates between them with the aid of a simple diagram. The essay begins with the definition of modern criticism which is to exhibit “the relation of art to the artist, rather than to external nature, or to the audience, or to the internal requirements of the work itself”. This one and a half century old theory of art competed against innumerable theories such as the mimetic theory, the pragmatic theory, etc., all of which have been thoroughly discussed in the essay. Abrams quotes theorists such as Santayana and D.W. Prall to show the unreal and chaotic nature of these alternate theories.
Art: The Role Of Co-Creation In Art
1204 Words | 5 PagesMost art requires an audience, a fantastic performance but with no audience, does not bring about the message of the performance. The role of an audience is very prominent in the arts scene, be it being a spectator or a participant. However, audiences’ role in arts has significantly changed over the years. Audiences does not want to appreciate art just by viewing, they want to be involve in the process of art creation. Based on an article written by Ben Walmsley, Walmsley (2013) mentions that the trend now is that audience wants to “engage with the arts in a more participatory way”, so as to achieve a more immersive and fulfilling experience (p.1).
Importance Of Art Essay
789 Words | 4 PagesThat is to say, not everyone can relate to a specific work of art on everything but there are always plenty more of them for they to appreciate and relate to themselves. Moreover, everything in this world is related to each other and art is one of them. Which proved the point that art is essential in building a successful country. The contributions of art are huge despite what people think of it.
More about Richard Shusterman's Definition Of Art Essay
Elizabeth Sisco: Graphic Design Of Chicano Movement
1218 Words | 5 PagesComparing The Statue Of Palette Of Narmer And Kouros
646 Words | 3 PagesIshtar Gate Analysis
866 Words | 4 PagesQuotes From 'Asher Lev Is Born'
1636 Words | 7 PagesVik Munniz Analysis
806 Words | 4 PagesThe Trouble With (The Term) Art By Carolyn Dean
791 Words | 4 PagesResearch Paper On Starry Night
802 Words | 4 PagesJeff Koons
416 Words | 2 PagesHow Does Art Affect Society
1410 Words | 6 PagesIs Art A Waste Of Time? By Ryhs Southan
997 Words | 4 PagesBook Review: Art Worlds, By Howard Becker
1462 Words | 6 PagesRoger Scruton Why Beauty Matters Summary
700 Words | 3 PagesThe Mirror And The Lamp Analysis
1994 Words | 8 PagesArt: The Role Of Co-Creation In Art
1204 Words | 5 PagesImportance Of Art Essay
789 Words | 4 Pages