ipl-logo

David Hume's Argument For The Moral Permissibility Of Suicide

956 Words4 Pages

Introduction

When considering the various applications of David Hume’s moral philosophy, his discussion on the morality of suicide has a great effect on the discussion of ethics and morality more than two-hundred and fifty years later. Our modern Western society is reevaluating its moral code from the ground up year by year in various social issues, which means that it is also becoming unclear what actions are morally permissible. Thus, a critical analysis of Hume’s argument for the moral permissibility of suicide is rather timely. In his essay on suicide, Hume refutes a three-part claim of Thomas Aquinas, a Catholic philosopher and theologian. This essay shows that Hume believes that suicide can be defined as the killing of self that is intended to remove misery and which may or may not be morally justified. On the other hand, it also shows that Aquinas defines suicide as the intentional killing of self that is “contrary to self love, self perpetuation[, and] natural law” and which is morally impermissible. Simply all that Hume attempts to accomplish in his essay “Of Suicide” is to show that Aquinas is wrong and that suicide may be morally permissible in certain circumstances. Various philosophers over the past two …show more content…

He opines this position by arguing specifically against Aquinas, as mentioned. However, this paper will not focus on arguing that Hume is specifically refuting Aquinas; other critics have argued this idea thoroughly, so I will approach Hume’s opponent as evidently being Aquinas. Hume’s refutation of Aquinas is split into three parts; two of which are solely philosophical, and one that is theological: if suicide is morally impermissible, then it must be a violation of our duty to God, to society, or to ourselves. Hume thinks that suicide does not violate any of these duties, so he concludes that it is morally

Show More
Related

  • The Argument Of Double Effect In Physician Assisted Suicide

    106 Words  | 1 Pages

    The last argument that this paper will look at is the argument of double effect. In the context of terminal illness physician assisted suicide could instead be seen as a vital form of care for someone who is suffering, instead of the failure of medicine. Physician assisted suicide seems to oppose the pro-life view, but on closer examination, its purpose is instead to relieve suffering in imminently terminal cases where it is thought that no other treatment could reasonably hope to do the same. Even though traditionally the role of the doctor is seen as extending life, that role may also encompass the assistance in PAS.

    Read More

  • Delbeke Assisted Suicide Summary

    354 Words  | 2 Pages

    Delbeke discusses how some people believe assisted suicide should not just be up to physicians to perform. Some people feel that, depending on the task, even nurses, social workers and clergy could perform the suicide. A benefit of this would be less responsibility and burden on the physician, but there are more bad factors. If it starts to become acceptable to let non-physicians perform assisted suicide then more people may become involved than necessary. Delbeke provides information that she thinks assisted suicide would become institutionalized and a certain routine would come about.

    Read More

  • Dennis Plaisted Suicide

    1897 Words  | 8 Pages

    In this paper, I will explain Dennis Plaisted’s argument that physician assisted suicide should not be legalized on the basis of autonomy in the case that the state does not value the lives of the terminally ill if they allow the legislation to be enacted. I argue that his argument is unsound because the government does care about its people and wants to allow the terminally ill to have an alternative to suffering. First, I will explain the basis of physician assisted suicide and summarize a few of Plaisted’s arguments against it. Then, I will argue that his claim is unsound since the state is sympathetic enough to allow an alternative treatment to incurable illnesses, and that Plaisted’s theory fails in that for the legislation to work, they

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay: Oregon's Death With Dignity Law

    1554 Words  | 7 Pages

    In the classical world of Greece and Rome, suicide was glorified as a noble death. As early as the second century, Christian teaching condemned suicide, stating it violates the commandment, “Thou shall not kill”, suicide cannot be repented of and lastly, it’s cowardly” (“Suicide.” Encyclopedia of Religion and the Law in America).

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Death By Huttman

    484 Words  | 2 Pages

    Huttmann’s argues in this essay that the person should have the right to choose to live or die if they are suffering from a fatal illness. And the author’s purpose within this essay is both personal and social. The essay starts with one of the audience of the Phil Donahue show shouting “ murderer” after Huttmann shares her story about mac , a cancer patient. Huttmann wrote this interesting introduction so she could draw the audience and show the effect of feeling of justification throughout the latter portion of this essay. That introduction leaves the readers curiosity about why are the people calling her mean names.

    Read More

  • Physician Assisted Suicide Analysis

    2141 Words  | 9 Pages

    Physician assisted suicide is by far one of the most controversial topics that has arose in the last decade. As such, there are many moral and ethical arguments both for and against the act of physician assisted suicide. Because of this, it is important to explore in detail the arguments made both in favor and against physician assisted suicide so that one can better grasp what exactly this sort of act entails. In his book “Understanding Assisted Suicide: Nine Issues to Consider”, Seattle University School of Law professor John B. Mitchell highlights many key points of why physician assisted suicide should be legalized.

    Read More

  • Physician Assisted Suicide

    1550 Words  | 7 Pages

    Physician-assisted suicide is a very controversial topic in today’s society. Physician-assisted suicide is defined as an action performed by the physician at the request of the patient to end the patient’s life with certain medical procedures. The legalization of physician-assisted suicide should not be passed in the United States because it is not morally acceptable in the society, leads to misunderstanding of a physician’s duty and increases mental suffering of both patient’s family and doctor. Physician-assisted suicide should not be legalized since the action itself is not justified morally. It is never morally acceptable for the society to give up on its people’s lives.

    Read More

  • John Stuart Mill Assisted Suicide Analysis

    1384 Words  | 6 Pages

    In the following essay I am going to first of all explain what J S Mill means by the statement on mankind’s way of living. I will do this by critically assessing his point of view, whilst adding the perspectives of other Philosophers. Subsequently I will analyze how a defender of Mill’s theory would answer the question of: Should assisted suicide be legal? Finally I will demonstrate my point of view on the question. I will conclude by summing up all the topics discussed.

    Read More

  • Natural Law Theory And Mill's Deontological Theory

    752 Words  | 4 Pages

    Throughout criminal history, there have been various attempts to justify murder. In a widely controversial case, two English seamen, Dudley and Stephens, killed an innocent and helpless boy and subsequently devoured his body to preserve their own lives (“The Crown versus Dudley and Stephens”). This case raises an important moral issue: Is it morally right to kill an innocent person out of necessity for one’s own survival? Three moral theories – Mill’s Utilitarianism, Aquinas’ Natural Law Theory and Kant’s Deontological Theory – provide different arguments on the morality of Dudley and Stephen’s action. However, Kant’s Deontological Theory offers the most well-founded analysis because it absolutely precludes necessity as a reason for murder and cannibalism.

    Read More

  • A Right To Self-Discrimination David Velleman Analysis

    2030 Words  | 9 Pages

    In what follows, I will further explicate the arguments posed in ‘ A Right to Self Termination ?’ I find the view stated in the article is compelling and will argue with Velleman that it is morally wrong for a person to commit suicide on the basis that doing so reduces oneself to a mere means. I will argue that in the case of suicide the act of committing suicide is unjustifiable, we have a value inside us, in all humans that we all must live up

    Read More

  • Deontological Ethics: The Ethical Ethics Of Assisted Suicide

    1252 Words  | 6 Pages

    Assisted suicide is a rather controversial issue in contemporary society. When a terminally ill patient formally requests to be euthanized by a board certified physician, an ethical dilemma arises. Can someone ethically end the life of another human being, even if the patient will die in less than six months? Unlike traditional suicide, euthanasia included multiple individuals including the patient, doctor, and witnesses, where each party involved has a set of legal responsibilities. In order to understand this quandary and eventually reach a conclusion, each party involved must have their responsibilities analyzed and the underlying guidelines of moral ethics must be investigated.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Speech On Suicide

    1502 Words  | 7 Pages

    The issue of suicide has been around for quite a long time since the Middle Ages. Suicide still continues, which hasn’t disappeared, in fact, it has increased over time because due to lack of effort of attending therapy and seeking the help they need to solve

    Read More

  • David Hume Analysis Essay

    1123 Words  | 5 Pages

    Hume Analysis Although both Berkeley and Hume are influenced by Locke’s empiricist notions, Hume, unlike Berkeley, is not trying to defeat skepticism; instead he considers skepticism to be what inevitably results from following Locke’s ideas to their logical conclusion. He is deeply skeptical of causality and discusses the problem of induction, which is unprecedented amongst empiricists. Hume builds his skeptical foundation on the notion of sense perception, which he breaks down into ideas and impressions.

    Read More

  • Camus Two Kinds Of Suicide

    151 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the first part of Camus' essay we see the declaration that the first philosophical question that one must seriously consider is an existential one. And this is the existential question of whether one should live this life. When affirming that life is indeed worth of living, every other question philosophy can muster follows. Camus suggests that suicide amounts to a confession that life is not worth living, and ultimately it is, and he proceeds to know to what degree suicide acts as a 'solution to the absurd'. He distinguishes two kinds of suicide, one is a physical surrender by taking one's life, a conclusion that life is meaningless, the other a metaphysical one by subscribing to hope by taking a leap into faith [1] .

    Read More

  • Essay On Suicide Prevention

    1169 Words  | 5 Pages

    Over the years the issue of suicide has been slowly increasing. It is now the third leading cause of death among young people. The effects of suicide are tragic and felt long after the individual has taken their own life. Some people who consider suicide, however, never make a “serious” attempt at it. For every attempted suicide, there is said to be more than one person whose thought of suicide has never translated into an actual attempt.

    Read More

More about David Hume's Argument For The Moral Permissibility Of Suicide

Open Document