ipl-logo

Death Penalty In The Tell Tale Heart

792 Words4 Pages

Calculated killer or merely delusional? “The Tell-Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe describes a horror story where a killer kills an old man. In this story, the reader is given a first-row tour through a madman’s mind. In an innocent setting at the old man’s house, the madman’s obsession over the old man’s “vulture eye” (Poe, 1843) leads to a cruel murder that is spread out between eight nights. Based on mitigating and aggravating evidence stated in the story and the Eighth Amendment, this killer should be eligible for both a psychiatric hospital and the death penalty. To begin, the mitigating evidence was very clear about the killer’s mental instability. As said in this quote, “The disease… I heard all things in the heaven and in the earth. …show more content…

To some readers, that is exactly the reason why they think the insane killer should be safe from the death penalty. But is that really the case? Is the killer simply an insane killer? One may think that while he is mentally insane, he is also a calculated killer. As stated in this quote, “I put in a dark lantern… then I thrust in my head. Oh, you would have laughed to see how cunningly I thrust it in… It took me an hour to place my whole head within the opening…,” (Poe, 1843) the killer seems to have a great amount of control for a mere madman. To someone who was completely mad, what this killer did would have been insanely difficult to do. But this would have been the impossible test: the killer did this for seven nights, and only on the eighth night did he finally strike. From this piece of evidence, it is obvious that this killer is more than just a madman, and may instead be a calculated killer. This leads us into discussing the possibility of the killer not being eligible for the protection of the Eighth Amendment but being eligible for the death …show more content…

Not only did this killer kill the old man, he was cruel and cold at heart. This can be seen in this quote, “I heard a slight groan… it was the groan of mortal terror… dreadful echo, the terrors… I knew what the old man felt… I chuckled at heart.” (Poe, 1843) The killer knew what the old man was experiencing, even had empathy for him in his mind, but at heart, he was enjoying the old man’s pain. Another disturbing quote in the story that showcases the cruelty in the killer is the following, “I then smiled gaily… First of all I dismembered the corpse. I cut off the head and the arms and the legs.” As if killing the old man was not enough, the killer had to cut the corpse into pieces. Some people may think that such a person cannot be changed, and has to be stopped before they can proceed to hurt

Show More
Related

  • Was Mr. Smith Committed The Legal Definition Of Insanity?

    970 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the trial of Mr. Smith, there is no question of whether or not he committed the gruesome murder of Mr. Johnson; the question is in the sanity of Mr. Smith at the time the murder was committed. You may be thinking, “Why on Earth would you think Mr. Smith was sane? He killed a man because his eye was creepy!” While Mr. Smith did kill someone for what seems like an absurd reason, this does not make him insane. The legal definition of insanity is “a mental illness of such a severe nature that a person cannot distinguish fantasy from reality, cannot manage his/her own affairs, or is subject to uncontrollable impulsive behavior....

    Read More

  • Insanity In The Scarlet Ibis By James Hurst

    1063 Words  | 5 Pages

    People often associate murder with psychopaths and sociopaths, whom out of malice and corruption, brutally torture their victims to death. While this cliché is over portrayed in fictional thriller stories, it is not the case for all murders. Most criminals have reasons. Occasionally, the criminal defendant is found to have been innocent by reason of insanity. There are multiple branches of morality to consider before deeming one accountable for their own actions.

    Read More

  • Mr Smith Who Was The Most Likely Insane

    709 Words  | 3 Pages

    You may think Mr.Smith was most likely insane when he admitted to two police officers that he killed the Mr.Johnson, dismembered the corpse, and hid the body parts under the floorboards. Let's say you think someone is insane what do you think of when you think of insane. I’d believe you would think of someone who has huge mood swings, excessive worrying or anxiety, hallucinations or delusions, and inability to cope with daily problems and activities. You will most definitely see in my essay that Mr.smith was not insane but just a murderous sane man. First of all, Mr.smith was a very intelligent man and planned every single move and procedure of this murder precisely , which is the exact opposite of uncontrollable or impulsive behavior.

    Read More

  • Ted Kaczynski Research Papers

    2669 Words  | 11 Pages

    A person may choose to end the life of another human being for a variety of reasons. Domestic troubles, financial concerns, illogical reasoning, a desire for vengeance, and pent-up rage are all reasons for homicide. A serial killer is distinguished by the fact that the murderer will carry out several homicides over a long period of time. Due to the fear that these killers instill in others, the majority of serial killers are branded as mad and mentally ill by society. Many criminals have managed to evade imprisonment over the years, but very few have been successful in doing so for as long as the infamous Unabomber.

    Read More

  • The Tell-Tale Heart Quotes

    576 Words  | 3 Pages

    And every night he would slip away not being able to do it, why? Because the man’s eye was always closed. The whole reason for the murder was because of the man’s diseased “vulture” eye. Without the motive, the murder couldn’t happen. People suffering from insanity would blame the victim for their own crime which exactly what is happening here.

    Read More

  • Tell Tale Heart Sane Or Insane Analysis

    565 Words  | 3 Pages

    While what he did was horrible and insane-like, the narrator did this process very sanely and put lots of thought into it. No absolute insane person would spend days and days watching someone sleep, or acting perfectly normal around victim just so they could tike their kill perfectly, even though watching someone sleep is an insane trait. He was very cautious in this, “But you should have seen how wisely I proceeded -- with what caution -- with what foresight, with what dissimulation, I went to work!” and proved to be quite patient, “It took me an hour to place my whole head within the opening so far that I could see him as he lay upon his bed.’’ So he couldn’t have been totally insane, right?

    Read More

  • In Cold Blood Corruption

    1135 Words  | 5 Pages

    The newsman states that he never killed four people in cold blood, to which the prosecutor replies that “hanging the bastard” is “pretty goddamn cold-blooded too” (Capote 306). In this statement, the prosecutor expresses his belief that it is not morally correct to hang a murderer who has had such a traumatic past without testing for any sign of mental illness or

    Read More

  • The Guilt Of Murder In Edgar Allan Poe's The Tell Tale Heart

    745 Words  | 3 Pages

    In The Tell Tale Heart by Edgar Allan Poe the narrator is guilty of murder because the narrator thinks the old man could never suspect that his caregiver would ever try to kill him, he claims he can recite the story calmly and healthily as he remembers every detail unlike an insane person , and he admits to killing the old man so he is aware he has committed murder. It is important to realize that the narrator is too presumptuous because the old man would never think his caregiver would try to kill him when he expresses this statement “So you see he would have been a very profound old man, indeed, to suspect that at every night, Just at twelve, I looked in upon him while he slept.’’ ( Poe 7).

    Read More

  • An Analysis Of Insanity In The Tell-Tale Heart By Edgar Allan Poe

    557 Words  | 3 Pages

    One sign of the narrator being insane is that he has impulsive behavior. For example, the narrator says, “First of all, I dismembered the corpse, I cut off the head, and the arms, and the legs, or … works as well” (12). This means that he cut off the body without thinking about it beforehand. Furthermore, the narrator also says that he did not just leave the body there, but hid it too. All of this matters because it was a very sudden action

    Read More

  • Why Did George Kill Lennie Mentally Wrong

    711 Words  | 3 Pages

    "You see; I truly believe that murderers are mentally ill… their brains don't work like the rest of ours do. To deliberately kill someone requires crossing a profound boundary. Most of us couldn't do it. We couldn't even think about it. But they can.

    Read More

  • The Tell Tale Heart The Narrator's Insanity Analysis

    945 Words  | 4 Pages

    His problems may have caused him to become a killer and lose feeling for what is right and what is wrong. Also, when the killer was waiting to make his move, he heard the heart beat of the old man, and that sound repeated itself in his brain and jacked him up to kill. The narrator tried to convince the reader that he was not a mad man over and over again. After the murder he tries again to sell us his sanity: “And now have I [narrator] not told you that what you mistake for madness is but over-acuteness of the senses” (Poe 305). He truly believes, with all his heart, that chopping up another human being heightened his senses and made him a better person.

    Read More

  • Serial Killer Nature Vs Nurture Essay

    954 Words  | 4 Pages

    What drives a serial killer to their breaking point? What is it that makes them start killing? Nature and nurture are both key elements. They both play their part in turning a once innocent person, into a psychopath. Which drives a serial killer more though?

    Read More

  • To What Extent Is The Narrator Insane In The Tell Tale Heart

    496 Words  | 2 Pages

    Ultimately it comes down to this, insane or sane? Insane would be the perfect way of describing a person being mad, killing a man for no reason, and laughing at a horrifying death. After having the narrator showing so many things to prove he is insane rather than sane is pretty clear. The author allows a visual understanding of the narrator in the “Tell Tale Heart” from having many specific details about his point of view.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Paranoia In The Tell Tale Heart

    1164 Words  | 5 Pages

    The narrator 's sole reason for such murder is purely in his disturbed mind, as he develops an obsession with the old man 's eye and the plot unfolds from here where his insanity augments with the events of the story. Due to Poe’s illustrative language, various evidence can be presented to confirm the state of mind of the narrator, including, his obsession with the old man’s eye, his precision in committing the impeccable crime and finally the sound of the man’s beating heart solely inside his head. Perhaps it all started with the narrator’s obsession with the man’s “vulture eye” since he believes the eye of being evil, proving the insanity he is gravely trying to deny “I think it was

    Read More

  • Tell Tale Heart Thesis

    760 Words  | 4 Pages

    As a result, the narrator is insane and should not be prosecuted. To start off , the eye drove the narrator to insanity, which led him to take the life of the old man, The narrator does not know right from wrong. In the story, the narrator said that “For it was not the old man who vexed me, but his evil eye”(Poe). This quote from the passage proves that he is insane because he is deciding to kill someone over his “vulture eye”. A sane person would realize that killing someone over a eye is a silly, wrong thing

    Read More

More about Death Penalty In The Tell Tale Heart

Open Document