ipl-logo

Deception In Supreme Court Cases

457 Words2 Pages

In this scenario, as a homicide detective, you are faced with a dilemma of having very little evidence against the suspect you believe is involved in the murder of the 9-year-old. Even though there is no Supreme Court law against deception, the question of whether it’s ethical to use deception to obtain a confession is in question, especially when speaking about a crime that is one of the most heinous that a homicide detective will have to work.
An ethical person (detective) in this scenario would continue to work the homicide case and continue to collect evidence to use against the suspect. Even though there is not a Supreme Court case yet on deception against a suspect to obtain a confession, the last thing a detective wants is to have …show more content…

There have even been some states which the lower courts have ruled that using fake evidence to obtain confession is a violation of the suspect’s rights (Florida v. Cayward) (Pollock, 2014, p. 156). The other unethical response to telling the suspect that the death penalty will be taken off the table. This is an area that the homicide detective has no control over. Only the prosecutor can give this type of deal with the suspect and his attorney. The benefits in taking the unethical response is getting the confession, however, is this confession an actual true confession or just a confession from fear. The consequences to this type of deception is the possibility of the confession being thrown out of court and the defendant being set free or even worse, found not guilty.
Most homicide detective should have a good working relationship with the prosecutors that prosecute homicide cases. The homicide detective should tell the prosecutor as soon as possible about the investigation, interrogation, and the outcome of the interrogation. This will allow the prosecutor to be able to defend your actions and find case law if

Show More
Related

  • Lavelle Burt Case Study Answers

    355 Words  | 2 Pages

    His confession was an instrumental coerced confession. The police stated that they had evidence that would convict him, and that he would get a lighter sentence if he willingly confessed. List any extenuating circumstances that might have contributed to this false confession (other than those covered within the definitions of the various types of confessions).

    Read More

  • Tair Rada Summary

    1589 Words  | 7 Pages

    During the six-day long interrogation, Zadorov continuously denied having part of the crime. It was not until the investigators falsely stated that blood of the victim was found on his belongings that Zadorov confessed he may have killed her in a fit of insanity. The investigators claimed that using such method was lawful as the fabricated evidence only served to see how the suspect would react to the insinuation. What he said and did with the illusion was all on him. However, Zadorov also confessed to an undercover informant sharing his cell that he only said that to the investigators in hopes that he would receive a lighter

    Read More

  • Case Study: Strickland V. Washington

    1778 Words  | 8 Pages

    He also spoke on the phone with respondent’s wife and mother. He attempted once, unsuccessfully to meet with them; however, he did not follow up a second time. Additionally, the counsel did not seek out additional character witnesses for respondent. The counsel’s conversations with his client led him to believe he did not need to request a psychiatric examination because he did not believe the respondent had psychological problems. In a state of hopelessness, the counsel decided not to present nor look for further evidence concerning respondent’s character and emotional state, because he believed it would not overcome the evidentiary effect of the respondent’s confessions to the crimes.

    Read More

  • The Supreme Court's Secret Power Summary

    738 Words  | 3 Pages

    The United States Supreme Court is not transparent to the citizens in this country and they fail to publicly reveal reasoning’s to their decisions that they have made. The courts non-transparency make people wonder and uncomfortable for congress has to openly show how they voted one bills Jeffrey L. Fisher razes this type of questions in his article “The Supreme Court’s Secret Power” in The New York Times he raises concern for the Supreme Court and the justice; claiming that they have become too powerful and the people of this country deserve to see how each justice vote due we entrusted them I the position and we deserve to know if they are in good favor.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of The Reid Technique

    911 Words  | 4 Pages

    The police then determine if the suspect is guilty and continuously interrogate, accuse, and even threaten the suspect for hours until they confess, whether they are guilty or not. On many occasions the people who are coerced into false confessions are have severe mental impairments that prevent them from functioning as a normal person with out the impairments would.

    Read More

  • Supreme Court Case Essay

    537 Words  | 3 Pages

    “There comes a time when one must take a position that is neither safe, nor politic, nor popular, but he must take it because conscience tells him it is right. ”(Martin Luther King, Jr.) Most people were racist but now since the civil rights have been established most have stopped being racist and moved on. Three supreme court case decisions influenced the civil rights movements by letting more and more poeple know what the Supreme Court was doing to African Americans,and of the unfair him crow laws:(Dred Scott v. Sanford,Plessy v. Ferguson,Brown v. Board of Education). Dred Scott v. Sanford Is a case that most people felt that Dred Scott had an unfair charge against him.

    Read More

  • The Importance Of The Fifth Amendment

    480 Words  | 2 Pages

    As a police officer with over 19 years experience I have seen this time and again. With that being said, I would rather an individual say nothing as opposed to lying. Under the current justice system the state must prove its case and all the defense has to do is raise the possibility of reasonable doubt in the case presented by the

    Read More

  • Twyla's Phone Calls: A Case Study Of Serial Killers

    427 Words  | 2 Pages

    A friend of mine, Twyla Johnson, of Des Moines, Iowa needs your help. Twyla 's sister was murdered in 1975. No one has ever been held accountable for this murder. The detective on the case in 1975, now retired, has told Twyla the names of the persons believed to be guilty. He went to the prosecutor 2 times, but it was said there wasn 't enough evidence to convict.

    Read More

  • Reflection On Monster By Walter Dean Myers

    243 Words  | 1 Pages

    Before reading the book Monster by Walter Dean Myers, I disagreed with the statement “Lying to save yourself from being convicted of a crime is an okay thing do.” Reading this book has made me slightly change my mind. Before I read this book I believed that it was never okay to lie to save yourself. Now I believe that is is sometimes okay to save yourself. In the book Steve lied to make himself seem more innocent.

    Read More

  • What Was Jeffrey Dahmer A Disorganized Killer

    1324 Words  | 6 Pages

    He knew he had acted wrongly and consequently knew he would soon serve a harsh punishment for the actions he had committed. For that reason, instead of attempting to conceal the evidence of his murders he decided to help the investigators find the remains of the victims in order for the families to be notified of what happened with their loved one. This may have been an attempt for a lighter punishment or it may have been an aspiration to help the police and the victim’s families. He described to the detectives a graphic portrayal of what he did to each victim as well as how and where he hid the victim, helping with the body identification process. After being convicted, the leads for the story took up four thousand pages of police records (Fischer 189) and his court trials were the most expensive in court history, costing more than $120,000 (Schwartz 216).

    Read More

  • Essay On Wrongful Convictions

    1225 Words  | 5 Pages

    Wrongful convictions are one of the most worrisome and tragic downsides to the Canadian Criminal Justice System. As stated by Campbell & Denov (2016). “cases of wrongful convictions in Canada call into question the ability of our criminal justice system to distinguish between the guilty and innocence” (p. 226). In addition, wrongful convictions can have devastating repercussions on the person, who was found guilty, effecting their personal/public identities, beliefs and family lives. This essay will be examine some of the common factors that apply to the conviction of an innocence person.

    Read More

  • The Credibility Of Eyewitnesses In Criminal Investigations

    441 Words  | 2 Pages

    This clearly sows that the memory is an active process and is expected to alter an opinion based on understanding society (Simple Psychology, 2014) .   
Eyewitness testimony is unethical as the evidence that is supplied can be provided by someone with stress or anxiety issues this can assist by distraught the image of the suspect. Wrongfully sending an innocent individual to prison. Bloods worth’s case displays it is unethical as there was no psychical evidence nor appearance matched that supported Bloodsworth was responsible for the murder and rape of the victim. Three eyewitnesses were able to identify the perpetrator out of the five and this was based from evidence that he was spotted with the young girl hours earlier before the crime was

    Read More

  • Police Operational Strategies

    1267 Words  | 6 Pages

    Problem-oriented policing, also known as operational strategies, have five core elements: preventive patrol, routine incident response, emergency response, criminal investigation, and problem solving. In addition to the five core strategies, there is also a lone ancillary operation strategy, support services. Law enforcement officers use this to help prevent crime by being pro-active and responding to calls. The first of the core operational strategies is the prevention patrol. Prevention patrol is an active response and most dominate operation of police strategy.

    Read More

  • Ethical Issues In Interrogation

    999 Words  | 4 Pages

    “Courts have permitted the interrogators to tell the suspect that if he confesses his conscience will be comforted or they will inform the suspect’s cooperation to the court” (Richard 2008). It is unethical to promise and give hope to the suspect that will not be met in order to obtain a voluntary confession which are induced. During interrogation someone may walk in and hide his identity like being a police officer, while acting like someone else and promise the suspect that he or she is here to help and they are in good hands. Doing this is violating the rights of the suspect and should be taken into consideration, because it inflicts the mind of a suspect. If the suspect is going to confess it should be voluntary not being forced to “voluntary

    Read More

  • Critical Analysis Of The Murder Of Roger Ackroyd

    1730 Words  | 7 Pages

    All characters are accused and redeemed of guilt but the murderer is still elusive. Much to the shock of the readers of detective fiction of that time, it turns out that the murderer is the Watson figure, and the narrator, the one person on whose first-person account the reader 's’ entire access to all events depends -- Dr. Sheppard. In a novel that reiterates the significance of confession to unearth the truth, Christie throws the veracity of all confessions contained therein in danger by depicting how easily the readers can be taken in by

    Read More

More about Deception In Supreme Court Cases

Open Document