Elie Wiesel, a young and naive Jewish boy in the novel Night, is unfortunately entangled in the dark, inhumane atrocities of the Holocaust during the period of World War II, losing his family in the process. To his demise, he turns the last of his hope to God in search of any sign of progress in the favor of the Jewish prisoners, gaining nothing in return for his once undying fidelity. Throughout his experience in various camps, Elie encounters both individuals akin to himself and those with vastly different perceptions of society. Due to these clashing ideologies, his mindset began to diverge in two: questioning higher powers and self-preservation. His people were in a forced regression of dehumanization as the Nazi Germans enact a policy …show more content…
During the public hangings, Elie had traumatizingly listened to the outcries of reactions from the prisoners as they searched for the Lord in vain. At the beginning of the story, Moishe the Beadle explains to Elie how “Man comes closer to God through the questions he asks Him…Man asks and God replies. But we don't understand His replies. We cannot understand them” (Wiesel, 5). One's link to Him is able to be strengthened through prayers and questions that are directed to God. Elie utilizes this concept to highlight his point of challenging God—Why should he respect and bow down to someone who turns a blind eye to the torment of their most loyal followers? “‘For God’s sake, where is God?’ And from within me, I heard a voice answer: ‘Where He is? This is where— hanging here from this gallows…’” (Wiesel, 65). Compared with the quote above, Elie takes Moishe’s advice into consideration, displaying how he had “received” God’s answer in the form of death, struggling to clearly comprehend the messages and voices in his head. Because of his gradual isolation from religion, Elie perceives Him as a burden to his life and individuality. The more he expects a sign of hope, it’s immediately replaced with, what he deems as, the intensified gullibility and eradication of imprisoned Jews. As others begin to suspect the absence of divinity within the darkness of their current lives, he acknowledges the fact that there’s no bother in having any more hope. The weight of Him had brewed just enough to push Elie to the point of experiencing the “death” of God in the cold eyes of the hanging bodies. This conflagration of emotions ignites a strong incentive for his dissonance to faith, all while he reluctantly refuses to completely give up a large portion of his identity. Shortly after witnessing the cruelty
(64), they cried. People wondered how God could allow such an act to occur. The fact that there was no divine intervention to stop this tragedy made many doubt God’s existence. Elie heard a voice within him respond, “Where He is? This is where–hanging here from
Elie’s faith was taken from him in the concentration camps. His struggle to believe in god continued through the book as he experienced cruelty. One of the cruel acts was the hangings of two people, a boy and a man. The young boy’s death becomes a symbol for god’s death in the book. After the pipel’s death the SS forced Elie and the rest of the camp to stare at the face of the corpse before they were able to eat dinner.
“The two men were no longer alive. Their tongues were hanging out, swollen and bluish. But the third rope was still moving: the child, too light, was still breathing.” Elie remembers the voices of the prisoners around him asking “For God’s sake, where is God?” Elie says “And from within me, I heard a voice answer: Where He is?
God had not helped Elie even after he would sing his praises, “We needed to show God that even here, locked in hell, we were capable of singing His praises.” Elie was tired of God’s silence, he did not show him mercy with all that he endured. The destruction, the death, the conditions ruined his faith and any hope he had
Elie Wiesel experienced a large amount of tragic events during the holocaust which make loose faith. Elie was talking to his dad about how if he would put his life along the line just for his religion. Then he puts into perspective about how he had to question God himself, asking these different questions. Then later on in the book there was a child hanging and, well, he just then was questioning God even more. God was maybe where
Elie’s explains to the readers that during the hangings that he and some fellow inmates wonder, “Where is God? And from within me, I heard a voice answer: Where he is? This is where - hanging here from this gallows…” (Wiesel 65) Originally Elie was a very religious student, he studied and prayed all day and all night long.
At one point, Elie uttered, "Oh God, Master of the Universe, in your infinite compassion, have mercy on us. . .”(p.20). Grounded by the idea of faith in his God, that He is everywhere, and that His divinity touches every aspect of his life. However, he was forced to witness the brutal reality of evil and suffering that the Germans were doing to the Jews. When he began to question his faith in his loving God, “Never shall I forget those moments that murdered my God and my soul and turned my dreams to ashes”(p.34).
Elie wanted to believe in god but how would he believe in him if he hadn't shown them that he was there to let them free from their
Eliezer says, “Where is he? This is where-hanging here from these gallows...” (Wiesel 65). This is where he loses all hope because he does not believe God would hang a child. He mentions his loss of faith multiple times because of all the awful events he is put through.
He stated “For the first time I felt anger rising with in me, why should I sanctify his name? The almighty, the eternal and terrible master of the Universe, chose to be silent. What as there to thank him for” After witnessing countless hangings, victims of starvation, and hopeless corpses, he did not have a shadow of a doubt that God was not attendant and he would not answer Elie’s prayers. What was the point in praying if God would only let you suffer? Can you really blame Elie for not believing in God; when all he has ever been told is God will never give you anything you cannot handle?
and Elie hears a voice in his state “Where is He? Here He is-He is hanging here on this gallows....”. This event had a deep impact on Elie himself, as it was an event that caused him to start to doubt and lose his faith, through his time in these camps he was praying and had hope in his god, the god that was always there for him. But as time went on and Elie watched people die around him, innocent people he lost his faith. How could the god he believed so strongly abandon his people like this and leave them to
Elie during the beginning of the text is seeking to push his knowledge of this topic with a teacher that is very proficient in Jewish mysticism, Moishe the Beadle, about many different things in order to venture more into the world of these teachings. Elie was struggling with how to properly hear God’s real answers to the questions he had; he talked to Moishe about it and Elie brought up the question, “and why do you pray?” (5). Moishe replied that he prays to the God within him “for the strength to ask him the real questions” (5) This response almost certainly deepens and further intertwines Elie’s connection with God considering he and Moishe the Beadle used to have conversations like that every
Elie continued to be angry at Him. Thousands of prisoners were repeating the prayer “Blessed be God’s name…” (Page 67). But Elie was concerned why should he bless Him? Everything inside Elie opposed it.
When Elie says ‘For God’s sake, where is God?’ and from within me, I heard a voice answer: ‘Where He is? This is where-hanging here from these gallows…” (Wiesel 65) this is when we realize that Elie has lost his faith in god. Not becoming atheist but dropping the notion that god is wonderful and amazing and should be worshiped day in and day out and should be sacrificed for and prayed to and begged forgiveness of.
The central theme of Night by Elie Wiesel is the dehumanization and loss of faith in humanity during the Holocaust. The memoir illustrates the atrocities committed against Jews, including forced labor and executions in concentration camps. Eliezer and his father are subjected to severe physical torture, hunger, and disease throughout the course of the book while living under Nazi rule. As they struggled to survive, they witnessed unspeakable acts of violence against the other individuals in the camp which dehumanized and degraded them. Eliezer and other Night characters change as a result of these experiences, like losing faith in God and beginning to doubt the existence of humanity.