Dialectical Analysis: The Man I Killed By Tim O Brien

1547 Words7 Pages
Entry #12- Type 1
“The Man I Killed”

Quote: “Then later he said, 'Tim, it 's a war. The guy wasn 't Heidi – he had a weapon, right? It 's a tough thing, for sure, but you got to cut out that staring. '”(O 'Brien 120).

Response: The allusion to Heidi is important because it shows how the guy Tim O 'Brien killed was not innocent after all. Heidi is a young innocent character with good intentions. However, the quote reflects upon the fact that in the war, there are no more good or bad, there are no rights or wrongs after all. Nobody is innocent like Heidi, they all carry a guilt inside. It is what it takes to survive in the war.
Entry #13- Type 2

Quote: “Later, I remember, Kiowa tried to tell me that the man would 've died anyway. He told me that it was a good kill, that I was a soldier and this was a war, that I should shape up and stop staring and ask myself what the dead man would 've done if things were reversed” (O 'Brien 127).

Response: This idea is really significant, because it represents the plain truth of the war: You either kill or get killed. You don 't really have any other choice. Yet, you cannot just kill and move on. Such serious actions like killing leaves you a terrible memory and feelings of guilt and regret. It is not easy to take someone 's life even if there is a reason for it such as self-defense. Killing creates a terrible long-term impact on the killer, which in this case was Tim O 'Brien.

Entry #14- Type 2

Quote: “There was no

More about Dialectical Analysis: The Man I Killed By Tim O Brien

Open Document