GETTING LOST IN THE GREY “…A man flattened by an opponent can get up again. A man flattened by conformity stays down for good,” said Thomas Watson Jr. (As cited in Mancuso, 160). Conformity is a type of social influence and we can define it as acting like one’s equals whereas the other type of social influence, obedience, can be defined as the compliance to the orders given by an authority figure. In our daily life, these two shape our decisions and they have a significant role in development of individuals and society, as a whole, in all areas of life. However, both can be highly dangerous. The question is which one is worse? It is no better to conform than obey, on the contrary, it’s worse as by conforming not only do we act against our nature, but we also let society define our actions and our ideas since we are afraid of minor penalties of not conforming …show more content…
The opposing views say that everybody is equal and admittedly, according to the laws, that is true. Therefore, we all have the same rights. Nobody has the right to give orders to someone else, nor can anyone force someone to do something. Also one cannot deny that obedience is against people’s free will. We obey, because we have no other choice. Authority’s pressure is something we cannot go against. If we disobey, then we have to face the consequences of our actions and the fear of this can be so strong that it might turn people into non-questioning individuals who are afraid of expressing their own ideas. The Charge of the Light Brigade in the Crimean War can be given as an example of how scared people, soldiers in this case, are afraid of authority. Obeying Lord Raglan’s order was “sheer folly” but although the cavalry commanders were aware of that, they still obeyed the order and their obedience lead to a disaster. More than 71% of soldiers didn’t return (Sutherland 41). This fate could have been avoided if the cavalry commanders voiced their
Disobedience for the most part, is seen as a bad thing. However, in some way disobedience and rebellion can help to bring a favored outcome through a situation. An issue with obeying is that if people obey something blindly it can be problematic for one’s own well-being. For people looking for change in some ways, pushing against the rules is the only way to get what they want. Although to most, disobedience can be viewed as wrong and immoral, in many cases it can be the key one needs to make progress.
Conformity is when someone behaves the way others around them do. The article “Conformity” says “conformity, or acting the way most other people in one’s social group act.” (Harrison). This quote shows
It states, "If a law is unjust, a man is not only right to disobey it, he is obligated to do so." Obligated. People as a whole are obligated to stand up and speak for their rights. If everybody is equal, then one man should not have more privileges over another man. Especially because on man has a different race, color, ethnicity, background, or religion as another man.
The other type on conformity is called informational influence. People assume the actions of others in an attempt to reflect correct behavior for a given situation. This may work wonderful in a beehive where there are thousands of other bees with the same mindset. The Problem with this in today 's society can be explained with the simple Solomon Asch
Since the soldiers were so young and fresh, they had relatively no experience that they could rely on to make the right decisions. They were never
I was full of agony afterward. A positive example of when I succumbed to conformity and followed the crowd would be the time when we had a community yard sale, and the director of the community asked if there were any volunteers who will be donating 50% of their sales towards the Red Cross for a cause of recent disaster relief. After agreeing by some of my neighbors, I had also agreed and felt great. The difference in succumbing to obedience and conformity is that conformity generally occurs within a group of people and changes their attitudes as well as beliefs to match to those of others within that group. Obedience, on the other hand, is the act of following the orders without even questioning as they come from a legitimate
The need to follow orders blinded their possible judgment of the situation and how it could have played out. Not only the need to follow orders, but the need to follow their code, cost them someone's life along with their honor. Fromm's argument of obedience verse disobedience can be seen in multiple instances in A Few Good
When we do something to please authority, we sometimes are not sure if it is for the right reasons. Every person on the earth has authority. However, the United States military branches are excellent examples to display authority. They have rankings such as corporal and colonel who interchange and are always moving up in the rankings. Sometimes what you are ordered to do is not always morally right.
However, there is nothing wrong with fighting against something that feels unjust, but fighting sometimes may lead to destruction within the public. The law shouldn’t be based off of just the people’s opinions but also what the government think is best. It’s acceptable to do what is right but many are afraid to stand up to the the government due to the fact that they have more power.
Individuality vs. Conformity The future is one idea that many authors try to write about, but only a few capture the essence of what society can truly become. Ray Bradbury has created astonishing works about how technology influences people's lives and one’s choices can affect their life. One of his works, a dystopian novel, Fahrenheit 451 is about firefighters who start fires rather than stop them.
Anything is a double-edged sword and so does obedience. Obedience has many functions. Submissiveness to a authentic leader is indispensable to win a war, and also, it provides stability for a country. From another point of view, it will lead to chaos and confusions in an institution without obedience. On the contrary, submission also has some limitations.
In comparison, required obedience to authority and inaccessibility of knowledge gain soldiers the defence of what is invincible ignorance. Soldiers were unable to access the same information as a leader. As a result, the true meaning of a conflict was left in a moral limbo for soldiers. However, if a man found proof of unjust activity during conflict, then it was recommended he stop fighting. If he did not leave, he was held accountable for his actions.
Since we are born we are been constantly shaped and formed in to who we are today. Forces that shape us include our parents or caregivers and the outside environment. Growing up, my parents were very strict and it was their way or the highway. To not get in trouble with my parents, I opted to conform by moving toward them through obedience. Now that I am older, I believe that my conformation through obedience has left me moving away from people.
Obedience is considered as following the orders that are given to you by a superior person, or someone in authority. Growing up, I was always taught to obey my parents, for which it was the right thing to do. Being obedient to a superior, or authority figure has become the norm for many individuals, to say that means obedience comes natural, without questioning, or hesitation. Once obedience is a part of the norm, requirements that are asked of you by a person of higher power isn’t so hard to follow. Though often times, we are given orders by individuals of authority which we disagree with, but because we are to be obedient to that person, we follow the orders that have been given to us.
In most people’s eyes, authority = expertise. That is why when faced with ‘authority’ figures like doctors in lab coats, nurses, policeman and other people in uniform, their brains tend to switch off their decision making capabilities, and rely on these ‘authority figures’ to tell them what to do. One thing to remember, though, is that people respect authority even more when it’s demonstrated, rather than just