Jefferson vs Hamilton’s Inspiration and Beliefs The Federalist ideas of Alexander Hamilton influenced the future Democratic Republic government, created by Thomas Jeffferson as president, by finding the money management used by America and the beliefs behind negotiation and centralized government. During the late 1700s, Hamilton became the secretary of state and created the plan to bring America out of its debt. As a federalist, many of his ideals included the elastic, or necessary and proper, clause and giving more power to the government, as this affected his plans of taxation, banking, and constitutionality in certain decisions made by the government. These Hamilton inspired ideas changed America’s perspective on nationalism and power of …show more content…
The first ideal made by Hamilton that affected the Democratic Republic government in the late 1800s was their power policies in the central government. Although the Democratic Republic’s beliefs included more power to the people rather than the government, during Jefferson’s presidency, the policy was affected by Hamilton’s policy, including the necessary and proper clause. For example, during the Louisiana Purchase, Jefferson used Hamilton's elastic clause to expand the land and resources for trade. This was technically unconstitutional, as he didn’t go through congress first, but he used the clause created by Hamilton and his ideals for the betterment of his country. This is ironic though, because he later opposed Hamilton’s national bank in 1791, because of the unconstitutionality (Doc 1). His republican ideals didn’t coincide with the ideals taught by Hamilton, but he still wasn’t able to stop the National Bank from pushing through. James Monroe was also a democratic republic, similar to Jefferson, and he also had problems with constitutionality in 1817. His “Hamilton” so to say was John Calhoun, who wanted to expand the manufacturing and roads in America. He had a federalist point of …show more content…
During the early 1800s, America had a conflict with pirates in the Mediterranean sea. The Barbary states were Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, and Tripoli- off the coast of Tripoli was a major battle location (Doc 3). The pirates used blackmail, as they held American soldiers hostage, looking for money from the American government. The federalists were very passionate about NOT negotiating with terrorists in any way shape or form, but Jefferson took a different route as his loving morals wanted to keep his citizens safe. As he negotiated with these terrorists, it caused contention between him and the federalist party/ Hamilton’s party. These conflicts affected the 1807 Embargo Act, as Jefferson listened to Napoleon's ideals and created more disagreement between him and Americans (Doc 4). His closing of the ports created disadvantages for America, and after the contention of the negotiation of terrorists, the federalist ideals were becoming more and more popular. This contention was somewhat resolved by James Monroe's speech in 1823, as he stated where America was compared to other countries. “It is still the true policy of the United States to leave the parties to themselves, in the hope that other powers will pursue the same course” (Doc 7). His belief of isolating America from European countries, helps support the claims of non negotiation as well as creating a more
Looking back on the most recent election driven by partisan rancor, many Americans may be cursing Hamilton and Jefferson, the two men responsible for the creation of political parties. But, without the contributions of Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson the United States economy, principles, laws and shape of the nation would not be as stable. Alexander Hamilton had fought in the revolutionary war. When he started serving as Secretary of the Treasury under George Washington America was drowning in debt. Alexander Hamilton proposed a financial plan involving the establishment of a national bank, the assumption of state debts, creating a paper currency and setting tariffs on imports to increase government revenue.
Jefferson and his supporters change the American political culture but retain most of Hamilton's economic plan. Even though Jefferson wanted to make an even smaller federal government. He repealed many of the takes Hamilton imposed. This allowed Jefferson to reduce the federal employees such as the tax assessor. He plans to fund government operations with tariffs from trading partners, not
Alexander Hamilton was a federalist at the time, and he set out to expand the national government power. This would allow states “to retain their rights and individuality”. But hamilton didn’t think of his version of government without inspiration from the British. He believed that it was the best form of government at the time, “consisted of a strong monarch, an assembly of aristocrats called the House of Lords, and another assembly of commoners called the House of Commons.” This system allowed the people to participate in government via representation in Parliament.
In this Crash Course in U.S. History episode, John Green talks about America's early politics and the conflicting visions of Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson. Hamilton wanted a strong, trade-focused America, while Jefferson favoured an agrarian nation with democracy. Their differences led to two political parties—the Federalists and the Republicans. Hamilton's Vision: He wanted a powerful government supporting trade and manufacturing, allied with Britain. Jefferson's Vision: He preferred a farming-based America, distrusted concentrated power, and admired France.
A example why Hamilton is a better view for america is because he wanted a strong federal government. And Thomas Jefferson Believed in a small government, he thinks
Thomas Jefferson, the third president of the United States, was more of a significant figure than Alexander Hamilton due to his accomplishments, such as reinforcing the freedom of speech. Thomas Jefferson was one of the American founding fathers, an author of the Declaration of Independence, a Democratic Republican, and the third president of the United States. Alexander Hamilton, on the other hand, was also one of the founding fathers, a secretary of the treasury, a Federalist, and an analyst of the economic and political weaknesses. Both of them were presidential candidates, however, they had major differences between themselves. As resulted from the conflict, Jefferson had won the election.
Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson were two of the most influential figures in the early years of the United States.(More background info) They both played pivotal roles in shaping the nation, however despite their commitment to American independence, Hamilton and Jefferson had different visions of the future and what they would do to get to their end goal. These differences to their ultimate plans included: How they viewed the people, Their differing political parties, and what they thought the best government was. Their famous feud and conflicting views helped create the mold that would shape the United States to what it is today. Firstly, Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson had fundamentally different views on the people and what
From 1794-1824, Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton had contrasting views on how the government and country should operate. Hamilton focused on fixing short-term financial issues through his Financial Plan by uniting the states under a national bank and creating protective tariffs to establish American manufacturing. Jefferson opposed many of Hamilton's ideas because he feared they would give too much power to the federal government. He encouraged farming and resisted Hamilton's belief in a strong manufacturing system. Both visions fought one another to gain favor, but one was more prominent overall.
This led to him making the federal government stronger and he would side with Alexander Hamilton more than Thomas Jefferson. This favoritism clearly showed through when Hamilton wanted a national bank, but Jefferson believed it was too much of a constitutional stretch.
Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson, both influential leaders in the formation of the United States, possessed differing viewpoints on the strategies for fostering the young nation's growth. Hamilton advocated for a broad interpretation of the Constitution, favoring implied powers for the federal government, while Jefferson insisted on a strict interpretation that limited federal authority. Hamilton believed a National Bank was necessary for economic stability and commerce, whereas Jefferson saw it as unconstitutional favoring the wealthy. Additionally, Jefferson opposed the Sedition Acts, considering it tampered with citizens natural rights, while Hamilton supported them to protect the federal government's stability and authority. These
Alexander Hamilton was a Federalist. He believed that having a strong government creates a strong country. Hamilton was striving to make this country’s national government strong. His way of doing this was to develop a financial plan to re-establish the credit of the US by ending the nation's debts. He wanted other countries to see that this country was strong.
Each one had their own view of how to do this, but it was a main goal of both politicians. Alexander Hamilton was a founding father and leader of the Federalist party. Hamilton wanted America to be just like Great Britain. He believed that in the best interest for the country, the government should be run by elite people with lots of money. Hamilton was The United States Secretary of Treasury, during this time, and proposed many of his reform ideas to Congress.
Thomas Jefferson during the 1790’s-1800’s while working with federalists Alexander Hamilton, his viewpoints were different. During the 1790’s Jefferson was known to be in the democratic-republican party where he progresses an ideal structure of equivalencies between money and weight standards with the American/Spanish currency. Jefferson took charge of the republicans after a conflict created two parties, republican-democratic and the federalist, who empathized with the revolutionary cause in France. While attacking the federalist policies, Jefferson opposed a strong centralized government and granted the rights of states. While Jefferson was in presidency, he cut down on the Army and Navy expenditures, cut the U.S. budget, eliminated the tax
Hamilton wanted to create public credit with a treasury system, a national bank, a mint, and increase manufacturing which would help unify the country. On the other hand, there was Jefferson, who opposed a strong central government. He argued that the “wealthy would gain at the expense of ordinary Americans and that Hamilton’s political economy would corrupt the morality of citizens and undermine the social conditions essential to republican government”(Powerpoint). The country would opt for an approach closer to Hamilton’s views. One of the first acts was the National Banking Act.
Hamilton vs. Jefferson Visions to Reality Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton both had very defined visions of the scope and power of the new federal government, how they saw the future of the economic development, and what the United States society should become. In my opinion Alexander Hamilton had more of an impact on the United States during the 1820’s and on contemporary government when compared to Thomas Jefferson. His policies did not strictly work during that time and many of his ideas are still seen in today’s society. Jefferson’s views and ideas on/of the national bank, higher tariffs, debt assumption, The Federalist Party, and his support of the ratification of the Constitution are all reasons in why his policies and visions came closer to becoming a reality. Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton, molded the gatherings that provoked to the twofold party system under which the U.S. works today.