Discretion In Criminal Justice
Discretion has a fairly effective role within the justice system, specifically when looking at the sentencing and punishment of offenders. Discretion can have a distinct effect on the outcome of a case. The role of decision making through an individual may provide for a different insight into different cases which therefore means that no two verdicts are reached in the same way. The role of discretion when looking at charge negotiation (or plea bargaining) is to decide whether or not the accused may be granted a 'lesser ' punishment in exchange, they plead guilty. from prosecutors. This is a highly controversial topic within the criminal trial system as it begs the question, does resource efficiency outweigh the actions? In keeping with the …show more content…
In an attempt to confront this issue, the government has implemented a mandatory sentencing regime. A criticism as raised by society in regard to mandatory sentencing is inflicting limitations on a judge 's sentencing ability. This is due to the continuance of the question being asked in regard to if the punishment being inflicted upon offenders is in keeping with the severity of their offence. For example, in order to make a bold statement, the penalty for killing an on duty police officer carries a mandatory sentence of life imprisonment. Premier Barry O 'Farrell stated that "This is about ensuring that there 's the strongest possible message". Although this is arguably a little extreme, the case about making a point stands. Through this message, society now has the potential to grasp how certain matters are treated by the law. One of the issues with mandatory sentencing is that there is no flexibility for any future cases. Mr Cowdery, a retired DPP officer said, "judges needed discretion in sentencing to ensure the punishment fitted with the circumstances of the crime and the criminal themselves". Mandatory sentencing poses a large threat to society, due to the limitation on a judge 's ability to sentence in accordance with the severity of the offence, an individual may receive a punishment much harsher than they may
Gideon V Wainwright Case Summary
631 Words | 3 PagesDefendants asked for leniency and the prosecutor offers a deal and they take it because they are tired of sitting in jail, but few realize that by taking
The Paradox Of Scottish Life Imprisonment By Katrina Morrison
1193 Words | 5 PagesFocus on the practices and policies in place for life imprisonment and if it’s practical. The question they ask is how to reduce an astronomical amount of life imprisonment. The authors go into more detail about life imprisonment in Scotland. Once a criminal is convicted, they have the power to imprison
Role Of Plea Bargaining In Criminal Justice
352 Words | 2 Pages• Plea-bargaining weakens the criminal justice system with the concept that if all cases went to trial the court system would be unable to support the workload. This is a factor that can be disputed by jurisdictions that have ban plea bargaining and continued to operate appropriately. Plea-bargaining is known as the agreement in a criminal court proceeding that is made between a defendant and a prosecutor. Plea bargains typically involve a lesser sentence in return for an omission of wrongdoing. Plea bargains do not forsake the criminal justice system, however they do allow for a speedy exit strategy for prosecutors.
The Plea Bargain Analysis
1216 Words | 5 Pages“95 percent of all convictions result from a guilty plea” according to the documentary called The Plea. One might ask, why there are so many guilty pleas? The answer lies in a criminal court system method called plea bargaining. After a prosecutor decides to file charges through an information or complaint, a defendant may face a plea bargain. A plea bargain is when a prosecutor offers a sentence bargain, when charges are lessened, or a charge bargain, when whole charges are dropped, for a guilty plea.
Discretionary Decision-Making In The Criminal Justice System
342 Words | 2 PagesTo understand, what is "discretionary decision making" within the Criminal Courts, let me explain what is discretion. According to the textbook America 's Courts and The Criminal Justice System discretion is the lawful ability of an agent of government to exercise choice in making a decision. Now, "discretionary decisions in the criminal court process are made on the basis of legal judgements" (Neubauer & Fradella, p132). The "three major subcomponents are legal judgements, policy priorities, and personal philosophies" (Cole, 1970; Smith)". An example would be a prosecutor who refuses to file a criminal charge because in her legal judgement, the evidence is not enough to prove all the elements of the offense" (Neubauer & Fradella).
Mandatory Minimum Sentencing Essay
1434 Words | 6 PagesMandatory minimum sentencing policies were set into action with good intentions, but the law did not turn out as expected. The mandatory minimum sentencing acts were created to provide equality that every offender of the particular crime will serve the same punishment. This ensures that there will be no bias. They were expected to lower crime rates, because people will possibly think twice before committing a crime if the mandatory minimum sentence is five year or if they have been convicted before, they will not want to be incarcerated again for double the time. Judges cannot change the sentence.
Prosecutorial Discretion Case Study
591 Words | 3 PagesProsecutors have the very important job of representing the people in a court of law on both state and federal levels. Prosecutors are under obligation to execute the law on both federal and state levels. However, the discretion that they are afforded under United States law gives them nearly absolute and unreviewable powers to choose whether or not to bring forth criminal charges, and also what charges to bring for cases when the evidence is enough to those justify charges. Plea bargaining is another area in which falls under a prosecutor’s vast discretionary powers, they can choose to bring full charges against the defendant or they can choose to show leniency by reducing the charges or dismissing the charges altogether. The incredible amount of discretion that prosecutors have in the criminal justice system places them
How To Abolish Death Penalty In California
663 Words | 3 PagesThe way to stop people from committing horrific acts is to not say how bad the punishment will be, but to have a more effective police force laying down the
Police Discretion Essay
976 Words | 4 Pagesreveals how many more stops and searches are conducted against racial minorities than would be the case if they were targeted at the same rate as white individuals. These tests were consistent and show that racial minorities would receive disproportionate police attention compared to the white individuals. Furthermore, included within this protection of human rights is the use police officer’s discretion to exercise force. Without a strong exercise of control over an officer’s use of force, citizens would be at the mercy of the police able to exercise extreme amounts of physical control over them with little, or no, provocation, or at a level that is not proportional to the situation at hand.
Discretion In Policing
2561 Words | 11 PagesPolice officers enforce laws, but also held to those same laws they are enforcing on a daily basis. Laws influence how police behave and how to handle some situations. While also telling them how they can and cannot act. Some author’s feel this influence from the law may be why officers, “run roughshod over legal restrictions on such activities as searches and seizures” (Herbert, 1998; Chambliss, 1994; McBarnet, 1979). Officers are rarely supervised while on patrol and if they are, it is by a fellow officer rather than a superior officer.
Effects Of Incarceration On Families
520 Words | 3 PagesA person should be punished appropriately for the crime they committed but the punishment should not include putting strain or forcing them to severe their relationships with their
Ethics In The Criminal Justice System
1279 Words | 6 PagesIn the formal criminal justice process, there are important decision makers that decide whether to keep the offender in the system or dismiss the suspect with no future consequences. Suppose a law was set in place
Annotated Bibliography On Death Penalty
1145 Words | 5 PagesDeterrence and the Death Penalty: The Views of the Experts. The Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology (1973-), 87(1), 1. doi:10.2307/1143970 This article was written by Michael L. Radelet and Ronald L. Akers. They both consulted experts on criminology and criminal behaviour to evaluate the effectiveness of the Death Penalty.
Disadvantages Of Rehabilitation State Prison
1678 Words | 7 PagesHowever, crimes are committed whilst in prison, such as drugs and assaults. Some critics say the ‘three strikes and you are out’ law where repeat offenders get a longer sentence are wrong, as the third strike could be a lesser crime such as public disorder. Nevertheless, if just incapacitation and no rehabilitation some critics say will be costlier to society as they will go out and reoffend and, they are not employed and pay taxes. Rehabilitation is also a punishment which should improve the offender's behaviour and stop them committing crimes. Advocates of rehabilitation state prison does not work; however, critics of rehabilitation state prison does work as the criminal cannot commit a crime against the public while incarcerated (Cavadino, 2007 p 36/56).
Essay On Harsh Punishment
1048 Words | 5 PagesThere is a worldwide trend in the use of penal imprisonment for serious offenses as capital punishment has been renounced by an increasing number of countries. Harsh punishments include capital punishment, life imprisonment and long-term incarceration. These forms of punishments are usually used against serious crimes that are seen as unethical, such as murder, assault and robbery. Many people believe that harsher punishments are more effective as they deter would-be criminals and ensure justice is served. Opposition towards harsh punishments have argued that harsher punishments does not necessarily increase effectiveness because they do not have a deterrent effect, do not decrease recidivism rates and do not provide rehabilitation.
More about Discretion In Criminal Justice
Gideon V Wainwright Case Summary
631 Words | 3 PagesThe Paradox Of Scottish Life Imprisonment By Katrina Morrison
1193 Words | 5 PagesRole Of Plea Bargaining In Criminal Justice
352 Words | 2 PagesThe Plea Bargain Analysis
1216 Words | 5 PagesDiscretionary Decision-Making In The Criminal Justice System
342 Words | 2 PagesMandatory Minimum Sentencing Essay
1434 Words | 6 PagesProsecutorial Discretion Case Study
591 Words | 3 PagesHow To Abolish Death Penalty In California
663 Words | 3 PagesPolice Discretion Essay
976 Words | 4 PagesDiscretion In Policing
2561 Words | 11 PagesEffects Of Incarceration On Families
520 Words | 3 PagesEthics In The Criminal Justice System
1279 Words | 6 PagesAnnotated Bibliography On Death Penalty
1145 Words | 5 PagesDisadvantages Of Rehabilitation State Prison
1678 Words | 7 PagesEssay On Harsh Punishment
1048 Words | 5 Pages