ipl-logo

Discuss The Evidence That Can Be Used To Support The Declaration Of Independence Dbq

913 Words4 Pages

From 1815 to 1850 the United States did not fulfill the ideals of the Declaration of Independence, from 1815 to 1850 both African Americans and Immigrants did not have equal political or social rights. The U.S. did not fulfill the ideals of the Declaration of Independence for all people by 1850, during the time of 1815 - 1850 the of people who were accepted in the us were white males who were born people in the United States. White males who were born in the United States got the complete rights that were declared in the Declaration of Independence by 1850. The ideals of the Declaration were not fulfilled because Immigrants did not have equal social rights. In document 4 the evidence that can be used to support my subclaim is …show more content…

In document 4 the evidence that can be used to support my subclaim is “ ‘...but he shall not be free to dine and drink at our table - to serve on a jury - to be a witness in court - to represent us in the legislature - to be a doctor - to join us at a concert, a lecture, the theater, or the church, or to marry our daughters. We are of another race, and he is inferior....” This evidence supports my subclaim because at this time people treated African Americans as if they were inferior. African Americans couldn’t serve on a jury, be a witness in court, represent in legislation, etc. Analysis of Document 2, entitled "Call to Rebellion", a speech spoken by Henry Highland Garnet delivered at the National Negro Convention of 1843 held in Buffalo, New York. Garnet was born into slavery in 1815, he later escaped with his family in 1824 through the Underground Railroad. The speech was a very reliable source considering it was spoken from someone who faced the pain of slavery and faced the discrimination from America. Garnet spoke out against slavery and speaking about how slaves were being treated. Garnet gave true stories about what happened to slaves, slaves had been treated extremely harsh. Analysis of Document 4, entitled “Life and Liberty in America”, written by Charles Mackay was written in 1857-1858, London, 1859. Charles Mackay was an English visitor to America who

Show More
Related

  • Similarities Between Frederick Douglass And Garnet

    615 Words  | 3 Pages

    In NYC, Garnet got an education in science and math. Garnet’s family was pursued by slave hunters in 1829, and managed to capture his sister and send her into slavery. Garnet roamed the streets with a gun, hoping to confront the slave hunters, but he was convinced by his friends to stop. This incident showcased one incident and probably gave rise to others in which Henry Garnet responded to the issues that slavery presented him in radical ways. Later in his life Henry Garnet gave his famous “Address to the Slaves of the US”.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Call To Rebellion And Patrick Henry

    1870 Words  | 8 Pages

    Patrick Henry was a free white man, while Henry Highland Garnet was an escaped slave. Henry’s “Give Me Liberty or Give Me Death” was given in 1775. At this time, England was oppressing the Americans with the Stamp Act (“Patrick Henry”). On the other hand, Garnet gave his speech, “The Call to Rebellion,” when the issue of slavery was very prominent in 1843 (“Henry Highland Garnet”). Because Henry and Garnet were both shaped by their times and issues, they chose to write about and for these issues.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Declaration Of Independence Dbq

    760 Words  | 4 Pages

    Over the course of American history, society has dealt with many flaws, and dilemmas. In Source B, it illustrates that Abigail Adams, John’s wife, wanted the Continental Congress to remember the ladies when they write The Declaration of Independence. In Source C, it rationalizes how slaves didn’t have equal rights as white men, and the petition is trying to give their natural rights back. Furthermore, in Source D, a miniseries that depicted John Adams life, given particular the Revolutionary War. This source allows the viewer to visualize the conflicts that the Continental Congress had, with the colonists, and the British.

    Read More

  • Declaration Of Independence Dbq Analysis

    464 Words  | 2 Pages

    At no point in the history of humankind has there been something about which everyone can agree. Everyone has different opinions, and the founding era in America was no exception to this rule. People felt very strongly about their views on things like the separation from England, the amount of power the federal government should have, and the idea of a national bank. One of the first decisions to be made in the struggle for America's independence was whether or not they should seek independence in the first place. Those loyal to England believed that rebelling against England would lead only to "devastation and ruin" (Charles Inglis).

    Read More

  • Civil War Dbq Essay

    839 Words  | 4 Pages

    Document E raises the question as to why African Americans did not have rights. It remained an obvious question and had not been answered for years due the unjust laws against blacks. Similarly, document H supports the argument of the lack of respect toward African Americans. The 14th amendment gave blacks freedom, citizenship, and voting rights in America which reverted their position in society and questioned the authority of the

    Read More

  • Declaration Of Independence Dbq

    1468 Words  | 6 Pages

    Before signing the Declaration of Independence, Benjamin Franklin, in the Continental Congress, exclaimed to all state representatives that “we must all hang together, or assuredly we shall all hang separately”. Throughout the American Revolution colonial citizens battled relentlessly for land, power, and freedom. Controlled by the British Crown, the colonies were divided by two opposing forces, Loyalists and Patriots, who scattered throughout the colonies and clashed to take over the thirteen colonies. Specifically, the middle colonies experienced the most opposition and conflict throughout the war due to the nation’s capital in Pennsylvania and British headquarters in New York. In between these two largely controlled British Crown states,

    Read More

  • Civil War Dbq Essay

    722 Words  | 3 Pages

    While the American revolution created the United States, the Civil War determined what kind of nation it would be. Fundamentally there was one question left unresolved by the revolution: would the United States, born under the declaration that all men were created equal, continue to be one of the largest slaveholding countries in the world. Between 1775 and 1830, slaves in the north gained their freedom while the institution of slavery became more entrenched in the South; both free blacks and slaves faced challenges during this time period and they responded through religious fervor, political writings, and rebellion. To begin, religious excitement throughout the South is an important attribute to the ideology behind slavery.

    Read More

  • The Evidence That Could Be Used To Support The Ideals Of The Declaration Of Independence Dbq

    554 Words  | 3 Pages

    From 1815 to 1850 there was a rapid change in many things, a few are geographic expansion, economic growth, and political growth. The American society benefited from these changes but, not all groups of society benefit equally. The U.S. did not fulfill the ideals of the Declaration of Independence for all people by 1850 because women and Native Americans did not have equal political, economic, or social rights. The ideals of the Declaration were not fulfilled because Women did not have equal social, political, or economic rights. In document 1 the evidence that can be used to support my subclaim is, “...Father can legally make a will appointing a guardian for his children in the event of his death.

    Read More

  • Declaration Of Independence Research Paper

    447 Words  | 2 Pages

    If I was tasked with writing the Declaration of Independence I would have a multitude of things on my mind. First, I would probably be worried about how I would successfully design something that would truly provide everyone with both equal rights and protection. To find a way to allow people to live without governmental intrusion and control. I would also be concerned on what the British would do when they read it. The Declaration was something that nobody had dared to do before and went against everything that was in rule.

    Read More

  • Arguments Against The Declaration Of Independence

    199 Words  | 1 Pages

    The Declaration of Independence acts as the American Colonies’ formal set of grievances against the King of England. Before citing the injustices experienced, the statement begins with a formal introduction contending that the people have the right to create their own government when necessary. Following is a more philosophical assertion which argues that when a state begins to harm the given rights of the population, it is completely justifiable to begin a revolution to overthrow the subjugator. Next comes the list of complaints directed at the Crown, which range from the abolition of American charters to the dissolution of the Representative Houses. Finally, it concludes with a denunciation of the situation and announce the United States

    Read More

  • How Was The Civil War Inevitable

    714 Words  | 3 Pages

    So when ships arrived in 1619 with African Americans the problem was solved, slaves seemed like a simple solution. Even though the Declaration of Independence states, “all men are created equal” a large group of people was ignored in this statement. While white Americans were free African American

    Read More

  • Arguments Against Declaration Of Independence

    676 Words  | 3 Pages

    Declaration of Independence What are you with or against the Declaration of Independence? well, imp with it! why would you be against it? If the Independence gets signed it will open new doors for America and its citizens.

    Read More

  • African Americans During The Gilded Age

    208 Words  | 1 Pages

    It is stated in the second paragraph of the United States Declaration of Independence that all men are created equal. However, during the Gilded Age, many different crowds of people were not being treated equally. The new immigrants traveling to America had to deal with the pain and sorrow from the multiple challenges that came with Ellis Island. After all of it was over, they ventured out into the country, but had to face overcrowded living quarters, long work days, dangerous jobs, poorly paid jobs, and the threat of disease. During the same time, African Americans had a lot of limits on their rights; including, limited social rights, limited political rights, and limited economic rights.

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Frederick Douglass And Henry Garnet

    615 Words  | 3 Pages

    To begin, both Frederick Douglas and Henry Garnet believed that slavery was wrong and that although there were many freed slaves at that time, people of color were still being “enslaved” by all the injustices taking place in America. Both abolitionists of their time, in their speeches Douglas and Garnet gave a brief history of slavery. Garnet talked about how “two hundred and twenty-seven years ago, the first of our

    Read More

  • Declaration Of Independence Research Paper

    616 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Declaration Of Independence was an image all colonists wanted to live up to. They wanted all men equal, and the government to be fair. The American Revolution was a political upheaval that took place between 1765 and 1783.The Declaration stated all of this and the colonists said it would be. After securing enough votes for the passage, independence was voted for on July 2nd. The Declaration Of Independence, drafted largely by Thomas Jefferson, marked the formation of a new sovereign nation, which called itself the United States Of America.

    Read More

More about Discuss The Evidence That Can Be Used To Support The Declaration Of Independence Dbq

Open Document