The Doklam Standoff: Whose land is it anyway? China or Bhutan? Let’s begin this by understanding, Where is Doklam? Who owns it? How does China come into picture? Doklam is a miniscule kingdom of Himalaya in Bhutan. Hence, one can reasonably assume it to be owned by Bhutan right? Well, NO! In the history of claiming lands and seas, China has always been in the forefront. Be it with the South China sea dispute or with our very own Arunachal Pradesh, China believes it owns surely some part of any neighbouring land or sea and has historical records over disputes with its neighbouring nations.
This brings us to the second question, what does China want out of Doklam? Let’s breakdown the Doklam conundrum, Doklam is a trijunction
…show more content…
To which, India also advocated Bhutan’s stance and requested the Chinese military to immediately halt any construction to avoid any further conflict.
Since, both the parties made their respective claims of owning the territory, it soon spiralled into a stand-off between the Indian and the Chinese troops over Doklam. What exactly lies at the crux of the Doklam dispute? The dispute is not just about the territory size or road construction in Doklam. Bhutan shares about 470 km mammoth land with China in the west and north while India encompasses Bhutan for 605 km in the east, south and west. Before China assumed control over Tibet in 1959, the question of a limit was not as noteworthy for Bhutan for it had kept up and opened social and religious trades with its two neighbours - India and Tibet. The total area of land that falls under the land conflict between Bhutan and China is about 4,500 sq km. Before China took over Tibet in 1959, the boundary was not as significant for Bhutan for it had sustained and opened cultural and religious exchanges with its neighbours - India and
…show more content…
The Himalayan kingdom has always continued to be a culturally rich and happy nation instead of harbouring any geostrategic or political ambition. In my opinion, China is silently envisioning to become the ‘indisputed’ power in Asia so it can reasonably claim hegemony over most of its Asian counterparts. With respect to Bhutan, Doklam provides a wider boundary for China in the border. Constructing and building roads in Doklam is an easy way to connect with the Chumbi valley, near the Doklam plateau.
Chumbi valley and Doklam are strategically important since China’s easy access to these will lead to heavy military deployment near the border which is a matter of great concern for India. But since, India and Bhutan share healthy diplomatic and cultural ties and along with it having signed a formal Friendship Treaty, India has stepped up its military convoy and as a loyal friend helped Bhutan save its land. But, what really is in store for India? What does India stand to gain by coming in way of its another very strategically important country like China?
What economic or trade implications can this incident lead
At the same time, the author presents the idea that not only does the issue address disregard for Indian sovereignty in the US, but internationally as well. The dispute does not end
In 1950 and 1959 there were two major events that contributed to the current conflict between China and Tibet. An event in 1950 was when the Tibet and China conflict started because it was when China had invaded Tibet. Also, the uprising in Lhasa in 1959 was when thousands of Tibetan citizens had died because of China’s conflict. Evidence of this is, in Document 2 it states ‘In 1950, the Chinese People’s Liberation Army, known as the PLA, invaded Tibet to “reunite it with the Chinese Motherland.” ’ An example for the event in 1959 is, when in Document 3 it says, ‘1959 March - Full-scale uprising breaks out in Lhasa.
In the two-step dance with China, the European nations raced to carve China into mercantile spheres of influence. The U.K fought repeated opium wars. Nonetheless, the U.S maintained a more nuanced, enlightened open door policy built upon free markets. Additionally, the administration in the U.S pursued a relatively peaceful policy Vis a Vis China based upon shared interests in trade and political stability (Nathan & Gilley, 2003). China has since loomed large on Vietnam’s international decision making.
Despite the ongoing territorial tensions, both
In the book, My Side of the Mountain, there are many conflicts in it. They include a boy who lives in the woods and survives on his own. One of the conflicts is about an old lady and strawberries. This conflict happens when Sam is making his bed. This conflict makes me think about how Sam handled the conflict, how I would have handled it, and how God would have handled it.
Ancient China, bound by the Himalayan Mountains, the Gobi Desert, the Pacific Ocean, and the steppes to the north, was geographically isolated from other agricultural regions on the continent. The Yellow River Valley is often referred to as the Cradle of Chinese Civilization, however Chinese culture also developed in the Yangtze River and Huia River Valleys. The only real agricultural area, the North China Plain, accounted for just 12% of the country. They domesticated animals, established farming; growing millet, wheat, other grains, as well as soybeans and cabbage. They also fashioned weapons.
Imperialism In the 19th and 20th centuries, various powerful nations sent colonizers to dominate weaker nations and expand their influence. This domination is called imperialism, which is still practiced today in moderation. Among the many countries shaped by imperialism were India and China. These two large countries were both colonized by the British who were one of the greatest imperialistic powers at that time.
The Yuan (Mongol) dynasty ruled Asia, and when the Yuan Dynasty invaded Tibet in 1253, Tibet was incorporated into the Yuan Dynasty and Tibet has been a part of the Chinese territory ever since. (Source H). The vast expansion of the Mongol Empire dominated Asia right through the 1300’s and through the collapse of the empire Tibet remained a part of the new Chinese territory and is called the thirteen province of modern day China that came about in the early 20th century. (Source I). The size of political importance of China outweighs the concern over the general well being of the Tibetan people.
The regions of the Middle East and China experienced many shortcomings and lost much in the areas of stability, security, and influence. The culture and society of Asia was moreover sewn together by the Mongols’ conquest and with this new empire and the nations which were under its reign were subject its many failing and critical flaws (Abu-Lughod 207). While much infamy and fear surrounded this vast Asian empire, its rule for time it had existed provided stability and set up routes towards other regions of the world, enabling the flow of international commerce. The lasting societal effects of the Mongol empire however, meant as the reign of the Mongol empire waned and dwindled, Asia in its entirety had become isolated and cut off from the much needed commerce and capital it needed to remain as capable competitor in international markets. The society of China suffered especially, having relied on the Mongol empire’s stability as its position as practically a protectorate, this massive nation’s position, influence, and wealth plummeted (Abu-Lughod 211).
The transition of power in China changed the dynamics of post-World War II relations. For the United States, the so-called “Loss of China” was a a catastrophe, not only because the US supported Chiang Kai-shek in the last few years, but also because it seems to be a victory for the Soviet Union and the global Communism. For China, in 1949 started for the first time in its history the possibility to build foreign relations without being “suppressed by unequal treaties” by western powers. But China‘s relations to other countries remained very complicated and complex.
Taiwan, an island located on the Pacific Ocean southeast of China, is often times incorrectly associated as a part of the Republic of China Many people don’t have any knowledge about Taiwan or believe that Taiwan belongs to China. This is not true. Taiwan has had a democratic government that is independent of China. This misconception is very disrespectful to individuals and the whole nation. The issue of the relationship between Taiwan and China often times leads to heated discussions and violent fights between people from two places.
It also would make them harder to defeat. Because India was a main part of the British Empire, they wanted to have a quick way to transport goods back home. The quickest way then was via the Red Sea. India had useful resources that the British needed.
Bhutan IAS project Bhutan, also know as the Kingdom of Bhutan, is a country in South Asia located in the Eastern Himalayas. It is a landlocked country which means it is almost entirely surrounded by land having no coastline. It is bordered by Tibet Autonomous Region in the north, by India in the south, the Sikkim State of India; the Chumbi Valley of Tibet in the west, and Arunachal Pradesh state of India in the east. The region of Bhutan is the second least populous nation after the Maldives. It’s capital is Thimphu as well as being the largest city.
Ben Gurion states the essential problem in Israel/Palestine: “we and they want the same thing: We both want Palestine. And that is the fundamental conflict.” (Shlaim, 2001, p. 18) For both Israelis and Palestinians it is nationalist conflict, there is a clear reason in the action of both parties, a territorially secure state. Yet, both Israel and Hamas seem to accept that negotiation is the eventual end through which to meet their nationalist ends (Hroub, 2006; Shlaim, 2001).
In this paper, I have attempted to present an understanding of Pakistan-India conflict by using constructivism theory of international relations. There are many reasons other than strategic reason causing this conflict like differences in ideologies, norms and beliefs. There are also cultural differences between these two nations. 2. Pakistan-India Conflict an overview South Asia is considered a region of great importance in the world.