ipl-logo

Doucet's Feminist Theory

943 Words4 Pages

In “Is the Stay-At-Home Dad (SAHD) a Feminist Concept? A Genealogical, Relational, and Feminist Critique,” Andrea Doucet (2016) argues that as feminist as the concept of stay-at-home fathering seems, the concept is actually informed by outmoded norms and roles. In particular, the author addresses issues of personal choice in work and family care. The author relies on an extensive body of longitudinal data to substantiate her claims. Doucet’s (2016) research parallels an extensive body of literature on the subject of stay-at-home dads, contributing tremendously to burgeoning scholarship in the intersectional areas of sociological research addressing race, class, gender, and power.
As Doucet (2016) points out, media coverage of the increase in …show more content…

Relationality and relational theory, which is “rooted in transdisciplinary and diverse fields,” provides the underpinning for Doucet’s (2016) astute analysis (p. 3). Relational theory focuses on layers of dependence and interdependence, and on the social construction of norms and roles within relational structures. One of the foundational arguments of Doucet’s (2016) research is that binaries, which are also socially constructed, can impede meaningful social justice. Binaries include the most obvious gender binary of male/female, but also extend to more abstract binaries like subject/object. Binaries are indeed part of the established feminist discourse and relevant to Doucet’s (2016) analysis. Yet ancillary research on the subject of stay-at-home dads does not emphasize the importance of binaries, making Doucet’s (2016) contributions considerable, if generally self-indulgent. In fact, research is showing that stay-at-home dads are eroding outmoded binaries rather than reinforcing them, as Doucet (2016) endeavors to claim. According to Mitchell (2008), for example, changes to Canadian law have facilitated fathers’ transitions from a strictly binary work/family to a more integrated life that benefits all members of the …show more content…

1). General audience publications like Smith’s (2009) book The Daddy Shift are also signaling the benefits of the trend towards altered gender roles in households. Research is also revealing the long-term benefits and measurable outcomes of increasing funding for stay-at-home fathering. For instance, in Belgium, government policies to promote stay-at-home fathering have greatly contributed to the proliferation of women in the corporate sector because “these policies start by acknowledging that women 's position in the labour market and society will not be improved unless men take on traditionally female activities, both in the public and the private sphere,” (Merla, 2008, p. 113). Masculine hegemony can be challenged in spheres of public power only when gender binaries are reconsidered across the board. Doucet’s (2016) critique of stay-at-home dad discourse suggests that breaking down gender norms in the family sphere somehow undermines global feminist

Show More
Related

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of A Toxic Work World By Anne Slaughter

    1091 Words  | 5 Pages

    A Rhetorical Analysis from Anne-Marie Slaughter’s A Toxic Work World In “A toxic work World” by Anne-Marie Slaughter wrote September 18th, 2015 in The New York Times, Slaughter, the president of the New America and also an author of the forthcoming “Unfinished Business: Women Men Work Family,” argues that becoming a working parent you aren’t able to maintain a family nor take care of their love ones such as their parents along with working a full time job, having to deal with needing to take off towards your children seeing how your job can be affected by termination on some levels. Slaughter also argues about how the effects of the work place results in either one spouse being a stay at home parent which most likely is the mother in this situation which isn’t how it should be even through some fathers do the same also. She also goes on to say how more of the younger generation coming to the work force with

    Read More

  • End Of Men By Hanna Rosin: An Analysis

    190 Words  | 1 Pages

    In “End of Men” written by Hanna Rosin for “The Atlantic” in 2010, a writer, a co-host of the National Public Radio (NPR) show Invisibilia, Rosin explains how women’s position has considerable improvement professional, educational and social over the years. In this way, the writer states that since the beginning of time as men has been the dominant sex, however, various actions and events have been changing this domain. For instance, while men dominate just two of the 15 job categories, women dominate everything else such as home health assistance and nursing. Rosin quoted from Heather Boushey “Replace the things that women used to do in the home for free” (306). Based on more research she has demonstrated that all women have the capacity

    Read More

  • Gender Issues In America Essay

    767 Words  | 4 Pages

    “Today gender roles in our society have changed considerably in recent decades: there are more women in the workforce, many doing jobs held exclusively or primarily by men, and a growing number of men who choose to stay home with the kids while their partner works outside the home.” (639) Although we’re transitioning away from the stereotypical view of gender roles many issues still exist, such as women to earn less than males from the workforce. But

    Read More

  • A Fatherless America Research Paper

    1574 Words  | 7 Pages

    “A generation ago, an American child could reasonably expect to grow up with his or her father (1). The culture of fatherhood in American has drastically changed since the 1950’s, with a decline of fathers involved in their children’s lives. This journal article questions the role of fatherhood, but also highlights the importance of fatherhood. It raises these questions: Is the role of a father beneficial for the child? Does a father’s physical or emotional absence have harmful effects, or no effect, on the development of the

    Read More

  • Alpha Women Research Paper

    494 Words  | 2 Pages

    Consequently stay at home fathers are becoming a norm. Women working to put food on the table, yet while their men clean it. The roles have switched completely fathers’ cook, clean, do laundry, parent / tutor, and have book clubs. Yet in some aspects women make more money than their significant other. Never the less women are still the “breadwinners” in the household.

    Read More

  • Rosie The Riveter: Gender Roles In Joining The Workforce

    1045 Words  | 5 Pages

    (155). In today’s society, these gender roles are quickly fading away, although there are still some mothers that insist on staying home with her children because they fear the thought of somebody else raising her kids, and missing out on the big milestones of a child’s life. What most of these women may not realize is that they still will be around for these milestones, such as the child’s first words, or them crawling, then walking, because having a job does not consume every minute of the day. They will still be able to spend their time before or after work with their child, in which many of the special moments will take place. There are thousands of single mothers around the world that are forced to raise their child on their own, which means that they must leave their child in the care of someone else, and get a job almost immediately after their child is born in order to earn enough money to support her little family.

    Read More

  • Hook Up Culture

    685 Words  | 3 Pages

    Men and women differ in how they negotiate work and family in terms of balancing autonomy and intimacy (Seidman, 152). To provide further evidence, Kathleen Gerson, author of “The Unfinished Revolution,” divides women into two groups: those who prioritize family (traditionalists) and those who prioritize independent economic stability (self-reliant). Gerson observes that majority of women, across race and class, prefer to be self-reliant. These women still aspire to be in intimate relationships but expect career support from their male partner. These findings are unlike those from previous generations and are rooted in the entrance of women into the work force.

    Read More

  • What's Holding Women In The Workplace Analysis

    1127 Words  | 5 Pages

    During World War II, while men were off at war the women were responsible for taking over men’s duties while still maintaining a balanced family life. Thus began, the rise of women in the workforce, a time when high quality childcare was offered, and women were competing in top jobs such as defense plants, and war related organizations. While men were away at war the women learned to juggle the multiple tasks of being housekeepers, meal makers, balancing finances, and fixing the car. In today’s society, women are unrepresented in these high ranked corporate level jobs, and are held highly to the same standard of being able to “do it all” by herself as if the men are still at war. The article “What’s Holding Women Back in the Workplace?” helps

    Read More

  • Women In 'Annie Get Your Gun'

    1195 Words  | 5 Pages

    With so many opportunities, women can have choices on either becoming a homemaker or have a career that they wish to pursue. Even in some instances now; however, stay-at-home mothers are being criticized and judged by

    Read More

  • Family Structure In The 1950's

    697 Words  | 3 Pages

    Because of these strict beliefs, cultural norms birth rates were down considerably compared to today, for many women wanted to await child birth; until they were financial secure or stable. Additionally, “we never read (or heard) about family violence and almost nothing about singlehood, cohabitation, stepfamilies, or one parent families” (Jones, ASID, IIDA, IDEC and Phyllis Sloan Allen, 2009, p. 74). However, in the 1970’s people began to expand their horizon’s, and soon ventured out to explore other cultures; causing challenges towards the social movement on their views of a traditional family structure. This is why, “since the 1970’s three of the major shifts have occurred in family structure, gender roles, and economic concerns” (Jones, ASID, IIDA, IDEC and Phyllis Sloan Allen, 2009, p. 74).

    Read More

  • Analysis Of 'Why Women Still Can T Have It All'

    924 Words  | 4 Pages

    Women and the battle to maintain a work-lifestyle balance has been consistently debated and toyed with by society for ages. Anne-Marie Slaughter, Professor of Politics and author of “Why Women Still Can’t Have It All” explains the continuous hardship of balancing a career and a family; as well, Stephen Marche, writer and author of “Home Economics: The Link Between Work-Life and Income Equality” combats Slaughter’s article and the many gaps present in society. Slaughter and Marche compare and contrast the differences of the leadership gap between men and women, the strategies of maintaining a work-balance lifestyle in regards to family, and the type of dialogue representing men in articles written by women. Anne-Marie Slaughter and Stephen

    Read More

  • Mexican Family Culture

    1701 Words  | 7 Pages

    Women and children are socialized to be submissive to male authority and the women’s role is clearly taking care of the home, the husband and the children (Coltrace, Park & Adams,

    Read More

  • David Popenoe On Gender Roles In Children

    1624 Words  | 7 Pages

    David Popenoe, in his article Parental Androgyny, states that men and women are biologically different, and can therefore not equally take on the same social roles in the home. He claims that parental androgyny, specifically dad acting in the place of mom, and men being motherly towards their children, is bad for children and for a lasting marriage based on biological differences (6). Popenoe’s argument is that men and women have their social roles and these roles should not be switched or tampered. Men should not be the primary caregivers of their children because that is the woman’s biological job. I disagree with this argument because there is scientific evidence that men can be just as “motherly” as women when the need arises (Brooks).

    Read More

  • Gender Roles In A Doll's House By Henrik Ibsen

    1061 Words  | 5 Pages

    According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the number of stay-at-home dads increased by almost one million between 1989 and 2012 ("'The Future of Men' Explores Evolving Gender Roles). Additionally, men in the 21st century are even more comfortable marrying working-class women in order for them to be of some help in the household as opposed to the 19th-century men who bared all the financial responsibilities to themselves. Secondly, history has always denied women the fair chance in employment, legal employment for women in that era was very limited. For example, the protagonist Nora worked odd jobs such as embroidery and needle and her caretaker Annie Marie who had an illegitimate child but was forced to leave her child and take up a job with Nora’s family.

    Read More

  • Modern Family Case Study

    1217 Words  | 5 Pages

    In many societies and depending on their cultures, men and women are seen equally and may share the same roles in the household or even a stay at home father and the mother being the breadwinner. In modern family, Phil and Claire share the responsibilities with both working and both looking after the kids. The gay couple, Mitchell and Cameron who has an adopted daughter, together they learn what roles they should take on but not being gender specific when raising their daughter and the dynamics in the household. In many families today, dual earning families increased and not just the male who goes to work but females as well and follow their dreams like furthering their careers. “In the 21st century within households two pay-checks have become essential for most families to maintain even a modest standard of living in order to provide” (Walsh, 2012:11).

    Read More

More about Doucet's Feminist Theory

Open Document