ipl-logo

Due Process Model And Crime Control Model In The Criminal Justice System

909 Words4 Pages

A comparison between the Due process model and crime control model
Within the criminal justice system, there are two competing models: the crime control model and the due process model. These two models were constructed by Robert Packer and each represents a particular school of thought. In managing crime, there is the individual i.e. the suspect and there is the society. The due process model is seen to focus on the suspect whereas the crime control model focuses on the society. This paper analyzes these two models and based on the rate of crime in the society, makes recommendations as to which is the best model in criminal justice.
The principle in law that one is innocent until proven guilty has created much discourse. There are those who feel that the moment that one is arrested, there is reasonable belief that they committed the crime. However, there are those who feel that just as the principle states, one is, and should be taken as a victim and the outcome could be either way: guilty or not guilty. In fact, this argument is supported by the many cases of malicious prosecutions and mistaken identities.
The differences
The due process model is pegged on the belief that it would be better if a criminal found innocent goes free rather than have one innocent person in jail. On the other hand, the crime control model argues that it is better to have a innocent person detained, questioned, tried and found innocent then let free than have a society full of criminals roaming

Show More
Related

  • Compare And Contrast The Crime Control Model And The Due Process Model

    339 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the textbook there are two models of justice being explained they are the crime control model and the due process model. The crime control model is where emphasis is being put on reducing crime that is going on by increasing the police and prosecutorial powers. The due process model puts emphasis on protecting the rights of the person. The supporters are concerned about the lawbreaking aspect of it. The supporters see the need to protect the public from predatory criminals.

    Read More

  • Capturing Friedman As An Example Of The Crime Control Model

    1203 Words  | 5 Pages

    The criminal justice system as a network of individual entities operates within two models of criminal justice. The crime control model is oriented towards community protection and swift punishment for crimes whereas the due process model is concerned with legal and equal rights of all citizens including suspects. Both models are reflected at different levels of the criminal justice system where for example the police acts within the crime control model and the courts within the due process model. The 2003 documentary “Capturing Friedman” by Andrew Jarecki is a prime example of the crime control model of criminal justice system that can blur the line between victim and offender. It also highlights the lack of rights for the accused especially

    Read More

  • Causes Of Wrongful Convictions In Australia

    119 Words  | 1 Pages

    Wrongful convictions are a problem that most government officials won’t admit. The United States and other countries such as Australia have been susceptible to these miscarriages of justice. This can arise from a snowball effect of scenarios such as witness misidentification, perjured testimonies, coercive methods of interrogation, prosecutorial misconduct and ineffective counsel. These are some of the reasons that can potentially lead innocent people to be convicted of crimes they did not commit. The thousands of exonerations in the United States has caused concern for other nations to reevaluate their criminal justice system.

    Read More

  • Due Process Model In Local Policing

    138 Words  | 1 Pages

    On the other hand, when local police departments use the due process model they emphasize on the treatment of the offender rather than punishing the offender. Their primary focus is doing the right thing granting offenders a fair chance. Offenders are offered treatment programs through community based alternatives rather than incarceration. Community based alternatives would grant offenders the opportunities to several different programs such as pretrial release and diversion, probation, restitution, community service, work release programs, and halfway houses. The interest of the due process model with local police departments are to develop long term solutions for offenders rather than immediately punishing an individual whether guilty or

    Read More

  • What Are The Flaws Of The Due Process Model

    222 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the United States Constitution, the Fourteenth Amendment, along with the Fifth Amendment, guarantees all citizens the right to due process of the law in all criminal proceedings. If we are to followed what is stated by the Constitution, the United States criminal justice system should adopt and use the Due Process Model. The hypothetical situation that is presented to us in chapter two using the Crime Control Model clearly has many flaws. When the officer pulls up to scene of the crime it is immediately established that the man with the gun is the criminal.

    Read More

  • Due Process Model Vs Crime Control Model

    478 Words  | 2 Pages

    In Herbert Packer's criminal justice scale we get two extremes that come together to form what we know today as the American criminal justice system. The Due Process model is founded upon the presumption of innocence and operates on more than just factual guilt but judicial guilt as well. On the other hand we have the Crime Control model which is essentially the exact opposite of due process in that its founding principle is the presumption of guilt. The primary focus of the crime control model is just that, crime prevention, rather than actual justice for the accused/accuser. Proponents of the crime control model feel that if police officers have spent the time to investigate and arrest a suspect for a crime and the prosecutor has charged

    Read More

  • Adnan Syed Case

    1026 Words  | 5 Pages

    The criminal justice system is meant to protect the innocent, and punish those who are guilty of a crime. However, no system is perfect and as a result, sometimes the innocent become victims of the system that is meant to protect them. How exactly do these innocent people become victims of the system? Sometimes the person gets framed, and the crime scene is staged to point a finger at them. Sometimes, there is no strong evidence against them, yet the use of circumstantial evidence is used by the crown.

    Read More

  • Criminal Justice System In The Brothel Boy By Norval Morris

    983 Words  | 4 Pages

    The due process model stresses law and is designed to “[protect] the rights of individuals and [reserve] punishment for those who unquestionably deserve it… even though some guilty defendants may go free because the evidence against them” is inconclusive (Cole, DeJong, & Smith, 2014, p. 24). Nevertheless, the goal of the crime control model is to repress crime and stress order. This model “values efficient case processing and punishment over the possibility that innocent people might be swept up in the process” (Cole, DeJong, & Smith, 2014, p. 24). “The Brothel Boy” is an example of the crime control model. The natives wanted someone to pay for the crime that was committed, and Police Magistrate Blair felt that pressure.

    Read More

  • Ethics In The Criminal Justice System

    1279 Words  | 6 Pages

    In the formal criminal justice process, there are important decision makers that decide whether to keep the offender in the system or dismiss the suspect with no future consequences. Suppose a law was set in place

    Read More

  • Three Major Components Of The Criminal Justice System

    265 Words  | 2 Pages

    Out of the three the courts are the most harmful to the criminal justice systems. Once the police have done their investigations and arrested all offenders involved it will be up to the court to decide whether the person is guilty or not. This is where the problem comes in. Many people have been judged wrongly in the courts.

    Read More

  • Procedural Justice Theory Model Of Law Enforcement

    2794 Words  | 12 Pages

    This theory became the framework in which a majority of modern-day policing derives from. It is broken into two areas that cover the quality of decision making by officers as well as the quality of treatment of individuals (Aiello, 2020). The model was designed for municipal law enforcement to structure their daily duties, into being community oriented, which is known as community policing. Also, this theory affects the way that people perceive police due to the officer's decision making and treatment of the public. The various levels of law enforcement differ in jurisdiction and location; however, they also vary in public perceptions of police.

    Read More

  • Criminal Justice System Research Paper

    566 Words  | 3 Pages

    Origin and History of the Criminal Justice System The Criminal justice system is a system that was made to control crime and make punishments to whoever break a law or rule. The beginning of the criminal justice system of the United States goes all the way back when the United States still belonged to the Great Britain. Americans were under Great Britain laws and rules and most of the laws were unfair. After the Revolutionary War and the United States became independent and they needed to create their own types of system to run their country.

    Read More

  • Criminal Justice System Essay

    721 Words  | 3 Pages

    There are three components that make up the criminal justice system – the police, courts, and correctional facilities – they all work together in order to protect individuals and their rights as a citizen of society to live without the fear of becoming the victim of a crime. Crime, simply put is when a person violates criminal law; the criminal justice system is society’s way of implementing social control. When all three components of the criminal justice work together, it functions almost perfectly. For a person to enter the criminal justice system, the process must begin with the law enforcement.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Confessions

    724 Words  | 3 Pages

    Thesis: Police interrogations can occasionally lead to false confessions due to misclassification, coercion, and contamination. I. The phrase “Innocent until proven guilty” is a popular statement among law enforcement and government employees, but this statement is not always upheld, as various errors, such as misclassification, are a major cause of false confessions. A. Misclassification errors are caused by “investigator bias,” where the investigator goes into the interrogation believing the suspect is guilty. (Keene)

    Read More

  • South African Criminal Justice System

    1483 Words  | 6 Pages

    The criminal justice system is that subsystem of the national legal system which determines the circumstances in which and the procedure according to which individuals may be punished by the state for conduct that is defined as a crime. For the sake of convenience, a distinction is normally drawn between the substantive aspects of the criminal justice system and its procedural aspects. The study of criminal law generally focuses on substantive law; namely, the principles of law according to which criminal liability (guilt) is determined, whilst the law of criminal procedure, together with the law of evidence, focuses on the manner in which this is done, together with the way in which offenders and suspected offenders are to be treated by the

    Read More

More about Due Process Model And Crime Control Model In The Criminal Justice System

Open Document