Einhard's Distortions In The Life Of Charlemagne
The Carefully Crafted Legend: Einhard’s distortions in The Life of Charlemagne
Einhard’s The Life of Charlemagne is a famous biography that provides a firsthand account of the deeds and character of Charles the Great. Einhard was a close contemporary to Charlemagne and his court, with Walahfrid Strabo’s preface describing how there “was almost no one else among the many officials of the king’s majesty to whom the king . . . . Entrusted so many secrets.” Despite Einhard’s seemingly well researched and honest biography, there are far too many distortions and inconsistencies in this work to completely trust this work. Einhard’s information on Charlemagne’s birth and early childhood is suspect. He states that there was “nothing written down
…show more content…
In 777 the Muslim governor of Barcelona by the name of Suleiman convinced Charlemagne to campaign against the Omayyad ruled Spain. Perhaps Charlemagne’s pride forced him to follow in his ancestor Charles Martel’s steps, who previously defeated the Saracens. Whatever his motives were, Charlemagne’s “great crusade” came to an embarrassing end. While the catastrophic loss at the Basque ambush was recorded by Einhard the obvious omission made by him was done in all likelihood because this was Charlemagne’s only war that was “completely …show more content…
He briefly mentions a son named Pippin who had a hunchback and attempted to rebel against Charlemagne. Einhard refers to this child’s mother as a nameless concubine. The truth however is the Pippin the Hunchback was Charlemagne’s first born son, and that his mother named Himiltrude could have been a possible lawful wife of Charlemagne. Pippin’s attempted rebellion against his father was not completely unprovoked, Charlemagne “disinherited pippin on grounds of his deformity” after he had healthy sons by another wife and in response created an enemy out of his eldest son.
Charlemagne’s first wife Desideria faced a similar fate. Einhard explains that after a year and for no reason at all, Charlemagne dismisses her. The reason for her dismissal was meant to be a retaliatory insult to King Desiderius who insulted Charlemagne by marching an army into Rome and taking
Alan Forey's Letter To The Spanish
463 Words | 2 PagesAlan Forey wrote and intriguing journal article that questions the authentication of a letter supposedly written by St. Bernard in which he mentions Pedro Henriques the purported brother of King Alfonso. Because of mentioning of Pedro, Forey establishes the theory, that St. Bernard did not author the letter. Forey questions if St. Bernard provided any prior knowledge to King Afonso of Portugal regarding the crusaders siege of Lisbon in 1147. Forey states, the letter known simply as letter 308 is cryptic at best and does not provide any specific details of an invasion by crusaders or of the original author’s intent for writing the letter. Stating, letter 308 first appeared in Brito’s Chronica de Cister in 1602, in which Forey claims that articles printed in that particular chronical are often not genuine.
A Different Outlook On God's Battalions By Rodney Stark
558 Words | 3 PagesA Different Outlook on the Crusades Rodney Stark, author of the monograph God’s Battalions: The Case for the Crusades, displays a different approach than most of what he believes was the cause of the crusades. The monograph displays the events of the crusades in chronological order to get an accurate understanding of what happened and when. The question that Stark is researching is the true cause of the crusades. In his introduction, Stark explains the general view of what historians believed caused the crusades. He explains many different popular interpretations on how and why the crusades began.
How Successful Was James VI & I In Dealing With The Problems Of Multiple Kingdoms
571 Words | 3 PagesHow successful was James VI & I in dealing with the problems of multiple kingdoms? The success of James VI & I in the governing of the three kingdoms is a key point in historiographic debate. Whilst there are elements of James’s methods, in terms of dealing with the problems which arose due to the vast differences of the multiple kingdoms, which could have been more successful; overall the post-revisionist view of James’s success seems to present the most convincing argument. Success must be seen within the context of the time, without allowing the benefit of hindsight and the events which were to follow to paint an untrue portrait of James’s leadership.
How Did The Islamic Empire Gain Power By Conquering Spain
668 Words | 3 PagesThe Islamic Caliphates gain, consolidate, and maintain power by conquering Spain, changing the daily life of the citizens, and establishing a stable government. The Islamic Empire, one of the greatest of its time, gained the power to achieve this label. The power advancements are expressed in Document 3. The evidence describes that Tariq ibn Ziyad ventured with his troops into Spain with the intent to claim it as part of the Islamic Empire and had great success in conquering Spain from 711 to 718 CE (Document 3, Tariq’s Address to His Soldiers, 711 CE).
Why Is Charlemagne A Barbaric Slaughterer Or A Statesman
980 Words | 4 PagesHistorians and Academics of the 21st century each have different opinions on whether Charlemagne was a barbaric slaughterer or a statesman. One modern scholar would defend their opinion in saying that Charlemagne was a brutal murderer who killed thousands of innocent children, families and caused a catastrophe. An opposing side might hold the belief that Charlemagne was a great emperor who unified Western Europe and created innovations that further progressed civilization. Charlemagne, Father of Europe, was a statesman whose intention was to improve the state with his reforms.
How Did William Win Hastings
288 Words | 2 PagesWhy did William win the Battle of Hastings? In this essay I will be talking about why I believe that strategy was the most important factor in the Norman’s victory at the Battle of Hastings. I will also be looking at how the other factors, skill and luck, fit in with their win.
The Trauma Of 1066 By Elisabeth Van Houts
1303 Words | 6 PagesIn her essay, The Trauma of 1066, Elisabeth van Houts draws parallels between contemporary historiography on the Norman Conquest of England and the collective sentiments of shock and horror shared by European nations after emerging from the first and second world wars. With this seemingly unrelated analogy, van Houts is trying to articulate how traumatic of an event the Conquest would have been for those living through it, both English and Norman alike. In consideration of the lack of English literature surrounding the first generation after the Conquest in 1066, it has been suggested that the English were at first too unsettled to attempt to write histories on the events and nature of their conquering. As a result, Norman perspectives unsurprisingly
Compare And Contrast Martin Luther King Jr And Joan Of Arc
880 Words | 4 PagesJoan of arc and Martin Luther King Jr. were both larger than life personas that fought for a purpose that was bigger than either of them. Both were persecuted for their fight against injustices and breaking the “rules” of society. However, Joan of arc was for practice of heresy and Martin Luther King Jr. was a preacher who spoke out against common societal ideas. Jehanne d’Arc was born on January 6th, 1412 in the village of Domry, France to parents Jaques d’Arc and Isabelle. Growing up, Jehanne d’Arc spent her time as most any other girls/women during that would- tending to the household and her family’s fields if need be.
Dr Alfred Andrea Research Paper
176 Words | 1 PagesI went to listen to Dr. Alfred Andrea speak about Murder, Mayhem and Massacre by Madmen. Throughout Dr. Andrea presentation, there were many key points that were made about the myths of the crusade. One point was, that the Europeans were not quite sure on what to call the crusade, because it was an ever-evolving phenomenon. Some of the typical names for the crusades were, Crozada/ Cruzada (early 13th century). Peregrinatio, Pascagoula Generale, Iter Crusis and lastly the Negotium Jesus Business.
Similarities Between Pippin And Charlemagne
261 Words | 2 PagesPippin continued to preside over Church councils and lead the army during campaign seasons. The reform movement set down by his father and Boniface continued to push forward, with the Church’s power continued to grow. Nevertheless the Church continued with its missionary project in Germany and helped create Bavarian Laws. Pippin and Charlemagne also share an interesting similarity. They both were anointed as king on two separate occasions.
Charlemagne In Jeff Sypeck's Becoming Charlemagne
1713 Words | 7 PagesIrene was the wife of emperor Leo IV, with the death of her husband she became co-leader with 10 year old son Constantine VI. Although the thought of a mother/son co-rule sounds peaceful and arming, after much frustration on Constantine’s part, left Irene banished from the courts by her own son. Although Irene does not quite directly help Karl onto the throne, she opens diplomatic relations with Karl, emperor of the west and is a key figure to the picture that makes up Charlemagne, also referring to global context understanding Irene also shows that Karl is not the only emperor with the desire of power and land. She also symbolizes a women escaping the stereotypes of men in power, as she rises through the men surrounding her.
Primary Source Analysis: The Black Death
1968 Words | 8 PagesElizabeth Licklider EH101-01 The Black Death March 22, 2018 The Black Death Part 1- Primary Source Analysis What is a primary source when used by historians? Give a brief definition in your own words.
Summary: The Life Of Charlemagne
922 Words | 4 PagesPrimary Source Paper 2 The Life of Charlemagne was written by Einhard a little after Charlemagne death in 814. Einhard wrote the biography to make sure that Charlemagne’s legacy would not be forgotten. He would list many points in this biography, but I’ve decided to only point out three of them. These three chapters are his deeds, his family life, and his life with the Christian religion.
How Did The Crusades Change Over Time
261 Words | 2 PagesThe Crusades were a series of military campaigns during the time of Medieval England against the Muslims of the Middle East. The period of the Crusades is primarily concerned with warfare and the art of assault and conquest. To begin with it seems fitting to establish the kind of warfare that was being fought before the Crusades, and to establish how they changed gradually over time. The key change in style of fighting was evident in the shift in the primary element of an army from infantry to cavalry. During this time in a region almost utterly alien to their native countries, those who took the Cross encountered different obstacles and challenges to their goal.
The Tragic Hero In Einhard's The Song Of Roland
1639 Words | 7 PagesOnce one compares this account to the events told in Roland approximately 300 years later, it becomes clear that
More about Einhard's Distortions In The Life Of Charlemagne
Alan Forey's Letter To The Spanish
463 Words | 2 PagesA Different Outlook On God's Battalions By Rodney Stark
558 Words | 3 PagesHow Successful Was James VI & I In Dealing With The Problems Of Multiple Kingdoms
571 Words | 3 PagesHow Did The Islamic Empire Gain Power By Conquering Spain
668 Words | 3 PagesWhy Is Charlemagne A Barbaric Slaughterer Or A Statesman
980 Words | 4 PagesHow Did William Win Hastings
288 Words | 2 PagesThe Trauma Of 1066 By Elisabeth Van Houts
1303 Words | 6 PagesCompare And Contrast Martin Luther King Jr And Joan Of Arc
880 Words | 4 PagesDr Alfred Andrea Research Paper
176 Words | 1 PagesSimilarities Between Pippin And Charlemagne
261 Words | 2 PagesCharlemagne In Jeff Sypeck's Becoming Charlemagne
1713 Words | 7 PagesPrimary Source Analysis: The Black Death
1968 Words | 8 PagesSummary: The Life Of Charlemagne
922 Words | 4 PagesHow Did The Crusades Change Over Time
261 Words | 2 PagesThe Tragic Hero In Einhard's The Song Of Roland
1639 Words | 7 Pages