English Only Movement Essay
Unfortunately, the drawbacks of the English-Only movement only begin there. Along with the proven academic limitations of a unilingual education, discouraging other languages and cultures through establishing an official language would serve to devalue non-English tongues. Passing legislation such as the ELA further encourages Anglo-conformity by prioritizing English and simultaneously relegating other languages to a lesser status in American society. Swarthmore College linguist K. David Harrison spoke to NPR on the issue:
People really do value their languages and ... the decision to give up one language or to abandon a language is not usually a free decision. It 's often coerced by politics, by market forces, by the educational system
…show more content…
Ratifying legislation such as the ELA conveys to the public that there is a supreme form of speech among the 350 languages spoken in the United States. As a result, it is simply not possible to assert one language as dominant and ‘better for communication’ without inherently demeaning all the others, as the English-only movement attempts to do. This deprecation of different languages pressures immigrants and citizens to assimilate by learning English and reject their mother tongue. As many Americans disregard their foreign roots in order to better fit in society, the nation grows further from the diverse democracy it was intended to be, which is anything but unifying.
The arguments in favor of the English-Only movement present some truths that I will concede to. I agree that immigrants who learn English are met with a myriad of economic and social opportunities they could not take advantage of prior to learning the language. I also agree that a common language can be unifying. But when this common tongue is forced upon a country that is home to hundreds of different cultures among its citizens (and where English is mostly spoken already), legislation such as the ELA pushes assimilation beyond the threshold necessary to communicate in our
The New Bathroom Policy By Martin Espada And Richard Rodriguez
550 Words | 3 PagesEven after what Espada had just experienced, he proceeded to address the crowd with a microphone in hand and speak against the state and people like the man he had just encountered. Espada believes that the “English Only” idea is harmful and we must fight against policies and ideas that go against non-English speakers. However, there is a multitude of ways to approach policies like “English
Blumenfeld's English Only Laws Divide And Demean
1036 Words | 5 PagesIn ““English Only” Laws Divide and Demean” Warren J. Blumenfeld discusses the laws that make the official language in the United States English, only. His purpose is to persuade the reader to sign the petition he created which is directed to the Iowa House of Representatives and more to abolish the “English only”. Although Blumenfeld does an exceptional job appealing to the emotions of his audience by using personal stories, he does a poor job presenting evidence and facts to persuade the reader to agree with him. Blumenfeld may have personal credentials, but he does not have many source credentials, also, he does not provide counter arguments for the arguments that are made against his.
Why Do Non Immigrants Judge
300 Words | 2 PagesLos Angeles Times Writer Anna Gorman in her Article “Immigrants’ children grow fluent in English” argues “there is no way English is being threatened by immigrants. . . . The switch to English is taking place perhaps more rapidly than
What Are The Barriers In The Devil's Highway Urrea
742 Words | 3 PagesVery few, if any, immigrants have the chance to learn English before traveling to the U.S. Because of this barrier, it is nearly impossible for organizations such as the Border Patrol to warn, aid, and communicate with them as they travel to the U.S. Although there are helpful signs along the border, they are written in English and are therefore indecipherable. Furthermore, the language border hinders an immigrant’s ability to survive in American society once they arrive. English is the written and spoken language in almost every city, thwarting immigrants’ opportunity to find jobs and interact with others. As they struggle to communicate, they become ostracized and do not fit in.
Anti Progressive Movement Essay
1691 Words | 7 PagesThe early 1900s were a time of widespread social and political change in America. During this time, many Americans adopted new, more modern ideas about labor, cultural diversity and city life. Some of these Progressive ideas were brought about by the need for reform in the workplace due to the grown of large companies and rapid industrialization. Not everyone supported the ideas of the Progressive Movement, however. Anti-Progressives, especially in the South, preferred traditional, rural lifestyles, and a slower, simpler way of living.
African American Vernacular English Essay
479 Words | 2 PagesThe destruction of its blended cultures, even through things viewed as small or unimportant as destroying the way a sentence is structured or a word pronounced because it is dissimilar to the way one majority group has deemed as “proper,” should be of great concern to every citizen who values his or her continued American
Analysis Of Jake Jamieson's The English-Only Movement
556 Words | 3 Pages(265). by this Jamieson is saying that only people that know the language will be able to apply the first amendment. He says that the majority of people in the USA already speak English and by making it the official language is not going to change the unity of this country, which people that believe in the English-only act believe it will make a change. The only thing that the English-only act will cause is fear instead of
English Should Be America's Official Language
1146 Words | 5 PagesPeople who speak English can find superior jobs as opposed to those of a non-English speaker. English is already spoken all over the world. Having it made official that America 's main language is English, the nation would benefit more from it than less. Having English as the official language of the
Compare And Contrast Richard Rodriguez And Anzaldúa
701 Words | 3 PagesRichard Rodriguez and Gloria Anzaldúa are two authors who both immigrated to America in the 1950s and received first hand experience of the assimilation process into American society. During this time, Rodriguez and Anzaldúa had struggled adjusting to the school system. Since understanding English was difficult, it made adjusting to the American school system increasingly difficult for Rodriguez. Whereas Anzaldúa, on the other hand, had trouble adjusting to America’s school system due to the fact that she didn’t wish to stop speaking Spanish even though she could speak English. Both Rodriguez and Anzaldúa had points in their growing educational lives where they had to remain silent since the people around them weren’t interested in hearing them speaking any other language than English.
The New Bathroom Policy At English High School, By Richard Rodriguez And Martin Espada
806 Words | 4 PagesIn the essay, “The New Bathroom Policy at English High School”, Espada witnesses the hostile actions thrown to students at school who speak a language other than English. The students have spoken in Spanish to each other and the lunch people overheard them and automatically assumed that the students were talking unpleasant thoughts about them. They told the principal of the school and she agreed to prohibit Spanish at lunchtime. This shows that people don’t have the freedom to be able to speak their second language in public without wondering constantly if there would be any hostile actions towards them. I also believe that people shouldn’t be forced to learn English and they should be able to learn English when they want to.
Assimilation In America
301 Words | 2 PagesFor many new immigrants coming to America, it is difficult to adjust into the new society. Many come to America without the basic knowledge of English, the new immigrants do not have the ability assimilate to American society because of the lack of possible communication between the immigrant and an native. Non-English speaking immigrants that come to America face harsh challenges when trying to assimilate to U.S. society because immigrants are often segregated into ethnic communities away from natives, Americans do not know basics of words of other well known languages, and the lack of government funding education programs. Assimilation into a new society is difficult enough, but when the society pushes any new immigrants to separate part
Argumentative Essay On Brown Vs. Board Of Education
529 Words | 3 PagesI believe this was an important step to take but more could be done in this area, especially in rural areas where there are predominantly English speaking students. Many schools don 't have the proper resources to handle students who cannot speak or understand proper
Speaking In Tongues Analysis
1764 Words | 8 PagesAccording to Jarmel and Schneider (2010), by the year 2025, one-third of students attending public schools will not know English when they start Kindergarten. How will schools adapt to this? Will teachers and/or students be limited on what they can teach/learn throughout the school year because of time restraints? In a documentary Speaking in Tongues, directed by Jarmel & Schneider (2010), four students who range from Kindergarten to eighth grade, showcase their experiences about attending public school around the San Francisco area to become bilingual. The four students Durrell, Jason, Julian, and Kelly are taught in English and also in a second language such as Mandarin, Spanish, Chinese, and Cantonese.
No Comprendo Analysis
438 Words | 2 PagesBut even when they didn’t learn English themselves, their children grew up speaking it. Thousands of first-generation Americans still strive to learn English, but others face reduced educational and career opportunities because they have not mastered this basic skill they need to get ahead. According to the 1990 census, 40 percent of the Hispanics born in the United States do not graduate from high school, and the Department of Education says that a lack of proficiency in English is an important factor in the drop-out rate. People and agencies that favor providing services only in foreign languages want to help people who do not speak English, but they may be doing these people a disservice by condemning them to a linguistic ghetto from which they cannot easily escape.
Foreign Language In Schools Essay
1086 Words | 5 PagesForeign language should not be required at the elementary level because students need to focus on the core subjects, like math, reading, science and history. That is a lot for a young student to handle and expecting them to learn a language should make it more difficult for a student. The core subjects are more essential in everyday life and can lead to more jobs in the future. Students also might have trouble learning the rules of English along with another language. English and other languages have some similar grammar rules, so they could get them confused when trying to learn the grammar rules of English and learning another language.
More about English Only Movement Essay
The New Bathroom Policy By Martin Espada And Richard Rodriguez
550 Words | 3 PagesBlumenfeld's English Only Laws Divide And Demean
1036 Words | 5 PagesWhy Do Non Immigrants Judge
300 Words | 2 PagesWhat Are The Barriers In The Devil's Highway Urrea
742 Words | 3 PagesAnti Progressive Movement Essay
1691 Words | 7 PagesAfrican American Vernacular English Essay
479 Words | 2 PagesAnalysis Of Jake Jamieson's The English-Only Movement
556 Words | 3 PagesEnglish Should Be America's Official Language
1146 Words | 5 PagesCompare And Contrast Richard Rodriguez And Anzaldúa
701 Words | 3 PagesThe New Bathroom Policy At English High School, By Richard Rodriguez And Martin Espada
806 Words | 4 PagesAssimilation In America
301 Words | 2 PagesArgumentative Essay On Brown Vs. Board Of Education
529 Words | 3 PagesSpeaking In Tongues Analysis
1764 Words | 8 PagesNo Comprendo Analysis
438 Words | 2 PagesForeign Language In Schools Essay
1086 Words | 5 Pages