ipl-logo

Hesiod's Epistemological Response: Xenophanes

1765 Words8 Pages

2. Epistemological reception (I): Xenophanes The first known philosophical author who uses Homeric examples in his epistemological theory is Xenophanes, a sharp critic of Homer’s and Hesiod’s anthropomorphic depiction of the world. His style of writing is very epic-like since many of his fragments are written in hexameter verse. Moreover, his conceptual apparatus bears many similarities to the language of Homer and Hesiod. These traits are the reason why most modern scholars describe him as a kind of mediator between myth and philosophy. Xenophanes’ criticism is directed against the epic interpretation of two epistemic topics: the difference between men and gods and the problem of absolute knowledge. His arguments concerning the first topic …show more content…

This answer can be found in Plato’s distinction between the constantly changing physical world (presumably described by Homer, Heraclitus and the others) and the eternal world in Timaeus – as well as in the description of human and divine in Phaedrus. The divine level of knowledge is disconnected from the one of humans due to the difference between two types of knowledge: the knowledge of the changing physical world and the pure divine “knowledge absolute in existence absolute” (cf. Parm. 247e). The communication with gods is only accessible to those who receive visions (φάσματα) thanks to divine inspiration and the prophets who use their intelligence to interpret the meaning of these visions (Tim. 71e–72a). This is a wholly different picture compared to Homer’s idea of a direct communication between man and god which is based on the principle of perceptual and epistemological uniformity, connecting the human and the divine level of existence. The Platonic interpretation of communication through divine visions (the only ‘Homeric’ element in his argument) will be further developed and modified by Porphyry and in the theurgy of Iamblichus who once more recurs to Homeric examples of human and divine

Show More
Related

  • Euthyphro And The Crito Analysis

    529 Words  | 3 Pages

    Not completely satisfied by Euthyphro’s definition that, “Piety, then, is that which is dear to the gods”, Socrates pointed out that gods were known to disagree and argue; therefore, they may not have had unified opinion on what is holy. To further frustrate Euthyphro, Socrates continued his argument by asking the following question, “Holy is beloved by the gods because it’s

    Read More

  • Comparing Authority In Apology Of Socrates And Hebrew Bible

    1800 Words  | 8 Pages

    Another structure of authority that show in these works are the messengers who do what their Gods want them to do. Although the Athenians’ and Jews’ lives contrast sharply, the ways they devote themselves to their Gods are similar. First of all, the Greek gods are nothing like the Hebrew

    Read More

  • Odysseus As An Anti-Hero In The Odyssey By Homer

    574 Words  | 3 Pages

    Odysseus, the protagonist of Homer's epic poem, The Odyssey, is a complex character with a range of virtues and flaws. While he is widely regarded as a hero, some scholars argue that he is actually an anti-hero. In this essay, I will examine Odysseus's character and actions throughout the epic, using textual evidence to determine whether or not he can be classified as an anti-hero. One of the key arguments in favor of Odysseus being an anti-hero is his tendency to engage in deceit and trickery.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Kleos In The Odyssey

    1161 Words  | 5 Pages

    The central theme of the Greek epic narrative, kleos (“heroic fame”), has presented many conflicting perspectives within the Odyssey. As the vocaliser of his own fame, Odysseus’ kleos gains both a subjective and objective aspect. Kleos, the far reaching fame “heard among men” is projected through the voice of the bards, not the hero himself. As Walter Marg states, this kleos is “the great desire of the Homeric hero” , and this desire may only be satisfied by the repository of knowledge that is the bard. Hesiod, analysing the epic tradition, further suggests that these muses have the ability to speak “falsehoods that resemble truth”.

    Read More

  • Hesiod's Theogony And Aeschylus Prometheus Bound

    1344 Words  | 6 Pages

    Hesiod’s Theogony was no longer able to satisfy the higher minds among the nation. Thus, inspiring Aeschylus to write tragic poets such as Prometheus’ Bound in order to express his own ideology and pointing the moral of tragedy. It is no surprise that Hesiod viewed Zeus as a glorified olympian hero and Prometheus as a traitor who stole fire and gave it to mankind. Aeschylus’s idea of Prometheus was conflicting to Hesiod, whereby he viewed Prometheus as a god supporting the civilization of mankind.

    Read More

  • Comparing Homer's Odyssey And O Brother Where Art Thou?

    927 Words  | 4 Pages

    It can be seen in the Odyssey through Odysseus’ and his men’s actions, for the most part they respected and feared the gods like every good Greek. The meaning of God is different in O Brother Where Art Thou? compared to the Odyssey, not as many people believe there is a God in O Brother Where Art Thou? , while in the Odyssey the belief was universal.

    Read More

  • The Gods And Mortals In Homer's The Odyssey

    610 Words  | 3 Pages

    The relationships between the Greek gods and mortals have always been complicated. The gods can be generous and supportive, but also harsh and destructive towards the humans. They claim to be all powerful beings with unlimited power and influence, but in truth, they are far more human than they are perceived. They meddle with human lives, not because they are wise, but because of their own selfish reasons. In Homer’s

    Read More

  • Role Of Storyteller In The Odyssey

    1112 Words  | 5 Pages

    In The Odyssey, references to musicians or poets like the author, Homer, are often used to enhance the story and the character of the poem’s hero, Odysseus. Homer inserts himself and his identity as a storyteller into his story this way, creating a comparative relationship between himself and his hero. Homer’s comparative relationship, expressed through the use of the character Demodokhos, the use of deities, and descriptions of Odysseus himself, stresses the importance of storytellers as most fit to understand heroes and their stories. As directed by the poet, storytellers in the poem are most able to provide insight into those they speak about because of the similarities between them and their heroes. Directly embodying Homer and other poets,

    Read More

  • Examples Of Deus Ex Machina In The Odyssey

    805 Words  | 4 Pages

    Odyssey Essay It’s been said, “To erase the line between man and machine is to ensure the line between men and gods.” The Odyssey is an epic poem written in the 8th century by Homer, a Greek poet. There are multiple references to mythological gods and goddesses that appear in a man’s person’s daily life. It was believed that the mighty gods descended down from Mount Olympus to help a believer’s tasks.

    Read More

  • Greek Gods And Goddesses In Homer's Odyssey

    1203 Words  | 5 Pages

    In the epic poem The Odyssey, Homer portrays Greek gods and goddesses as possessing human qualities and faults. Through their actions and emotions, Homer emphasizes the detrimental effects of lust, envy, wrath, and greed in ancient Grecian society. He also never fails to remind readers of the importance of respect for holy figures because of their powerful abilities to create chaos and wonder". Homer wants to prove that gods and humans share a variety of traits, and the only difference is that god don’t allow these flaws negatively to impact their society. To help further his argument, we can compare Greek gods and goddesses to that of Christianity.

    Read More

  • Comparing The Greek Gods: The Resemblance Of Gods And Humans

    760 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Resemblance of Gods and Humans Throughout all religions, gods have always been seen as superior in every way possible. The division between humans and gods has always been prevalent and prominent. However, when the actions and motives of these gods are truly analyzed, it will become evident that the gods of Greek Mythology merely behave as humans with supernatural powers.

    Read More

  • Gods In The Iliad

    1846 Words  | 8 Pages

    For human’s deities are omnipotent, authoritative, dominant and immortal. If there is a need for supplication due to conflict or complication, humans turn towards the divine. Within the Iliad there are various gods who scheme a very significant role in the war of Trojan. The gods are very present, always observing, influencing guiding and most importantly, interfering in the actions of the humans. Athena, Apollo, and Zeus are three very influential divines and their interactions with human characters, along with interference towards the warfare is seen throughout the Iliad.

    Read More

  • Culture In The Iliad

    940 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Iliad by Homer, the Odyssey poem written by Homer and the Prometheus mythology are classical texts that reflect the historical and cultural background of the Greek and Roman literary skills. The Odyssey and the Iliad are Homer’s epic poems that portray Greek and Western culture. The three texts give an insight of the ancient Roman myths, culture and the literature during both the 17th and 18th century. The two texts by Homer and the Prometheus mythology represent a classical period that consisted of the cultural history and the civilization of the Romans and Greece hence known as the Greece-Roman World. Homer’s narratives, the “Iliad” and the “Odyssey”, and Aeschylus mythical story “Prometheus” have cultural and mythological similarities

    Read More

  • Summary Of Erich Auerbach's Odysseus Scar

    473 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the first chapter of Erich Auerbach’s novel Mimesis titled Odysseus’ Scar, the stylistic properties of the Old Testament and Homer’s The Odyssey are contrasted to show the two foundational styles for ancient epic literature. Auerbach starts the chapter with an analysis of Homer’s use of digression with in book 19 of The Odyssey, when Odysseus’s true identity is discovered by Euryclea, to alleviate suspense within the book. He goes on to discuss how the comparison of the Homeric style with the “equally ancient and equally epic style” (7) of the tale of the sacrifice of Isaac in the old testament demonstrates “the genius of the Homeric style” (7). Auerbach then goes on to discuss how the Bible and Homeric representation of Gods differ in that

    Read More

  • Oedipus The King Essay

    1056 Words  | 5 Pages

    In ancient Greek society, the tragedy was a deeply spiritual and emotional art form integral to daily life. Perhaps one of the best examples of Greek tragedy is Sophocles’ Oedipus the King. The work is distinguished by the deep emotion and thought it elicits from the reader. This is in part due to Sophocles’ expert portrayal of Oedipus, who bears all the attributes of an Aristotelian tragic hero. A once powerful king turned blinded pariah, Oedipus is characterized by both his pride and his honorable character.

    Read More

More about Hesiod's Epistemological Response: Xenophanes

Open Document