ipl-logo

Erasmus Laid The Egg That Luther Hatched Analysis

450 Words2 Pages

Desiderius Erasmus, the leader of the Christian humanist movement; and Martin Luther, the leader of the Protestant movement; are constantly compared. Erasmus was not powerful enough to spark a revolution alone, so many say Luther planted his seed. However, this is not the case. The two movements were too different to come from the same origin. The phrase “Erasmus laid the egg that Luther hatched” is illegitimate due to their contrasting ideas. The phrase “Erasmus laid the egg that Luther hatched” means that Erasmus’ ideas sparked Luther’s own ideas. Erasmus, one of the first church reformers, wrote works sharing his ideas. According to this phrase, Luther read these works and took them a step further. Luther’s ideas would have to be very similar to Erasmus’, especially when Luther was just starting to reform the church. An example of this would be Luther agreeing with Erasmus’ philosophy of Christ. This would also require Luther to have Erasmus’ …show more content…

Luther started his movement as a monk looking for answers about salvation, unlike Erasmus who started as a Christian humanist. Luther didn’t mean to reform the church at first. Luther first wanted to reform the church by getting rid of indulgences, However, Erasmus’ main target was the clergy and did not mention indulgences often. Additionally, Erasmus’ main belief was the philosophy of Christ, which means that he thought Christianity should guide one through their daily life and not be a system of doctrines. Luther most likely disagreed with this since he supported many doctrines of his time.Furthermore, Erasmus’ strategy was to reform from within the church. After Luther directly went against the pope, it became clear his strategy was to break away from the church. Erasmus was never radical enough to go against the pope himself. Later on, Erasmus said that he disagrees with Luther’s ideas and separated himself from

Show More
Related

  • How Did Martin Luther Contribute To The Protestant Reformation Dbq

    692 Words  | 3 Pages

    Martin Luther and his followers seized the right to read and interpret the bible in a new way, that paid the way for Reformation. Martin Luther challenged the church. He criticized the churches ideas and practices. He sought no revolution, but he tried to persuade church leaders to make reforms. Luther believed that gods free gift of forgiveness did not depend on taking sacriments or performing good deeds.

    Read More

  • Comparing Letter From Birmingham Jail By Socrates, And MLK Jr.

    2030 Words  | 9 Pages

    The pastors were mainly all incompetent individuals and also did not know how to teach what they were to be teaching. So, Luther knew he had to go against the Catholic Church, which caused much disruption during those times, and write out exactly the words every Christian should know. Luther knew that

    Read More

  • Martin Luther Reformation Dbq

    227 Words  | 1 Pages

    Martin Luther Martin Luther was one of two of the greatest leaders of the reformation along with John Calvin. The Reformation was the period in the 16th century (1571-1648) where the was a cultural upheaval the divided the European catholic population. Not only did it create a cultural upheaval it created political and intellectual disruption. Luther believed that the Catholic church was corrupt, his 95 Theses was a list of 95 arguments about the catholic church which he wanted to resolve.

    Read More

  • Protestant Reformation Dbq

    1050 Words  | 5 Pages

    This made Luther create a document called the the 95 Theses. The 95 Theses exposed the church in 95 different ways. Luther took this document very seriously. He even nailed the document to the door of the church so everyone could see.

    Read More

  • Protestant Reformation Dbq Essay

    1281 Words  | 6 Pages

    As Luther is fighting the corrupt Papacy he writes this, “Faith is a living, bold trust in God’s grace, so certain of God’s favor it would risk death a thousand times trusting in it.” Luther writes this to show what true religion is, to show what a truly faithful person should do, believe in their God and give him every bit of faith from someone's person. The Papacy hates Luther not because he is wrong, but because he is right, which means if Luther was right and the masses believed him all the power that was held by the church would crumble into nothing; most importantly though the Papacy members personal power would crumble into nothing. During the early phases of the Reformation, Luther wrote the 95 Theses, which described everything he found wrong with the church at this time. The Theses was the catalyst, which set off the ticking time bomb of corruption and irreverence.

    Read More

  • Protestant Reformation Dbq

    596 Words  | 3 Pages

    While Martin Luther was not the first person to want to change the Catholic Church, he became the first leader of a major religious order to secede successfully from the western Catholic Church. The Protestant Reformation, led by Luther, began in 1517 and ended in 1555. Since Luther’s order broke away from the Catholic Church, the Protestant Reformation should more accurately be called the Protestant Revolution. While lecturing on the Bible, a revelation appeared to Luther and changed his life.

    Read More

  • Religious Reform Dbq

    822 Words  | 4 Pages

    People were unhappy with the way the clergy were treating their people and it was clear that corruption was throughout the Catholic church. The state of the Catholic church, while significant, was simply a backdrop for Martin Luther in his early life. Ironically, he was on the side of the Catholic church in his early life; he was “a university professor of theology and a member of the Catholic clergy,” (Dutton, 390). This close integration with the church made it surprising that he was the one to lead a religious reformation. However, it was his knowledge of scripture that made his message so

    Read More

  • Protestant Reformation Dbq

    607 Words  | 3 Pages

    Instead, Luther went for the roots of the theological aspect of the church. He claimed that the church was not teaching the correct materials and that he was. In his book “95 Theses,” Martin Luther attacked the theory of the selling of indulgences, stating that only God had control of souls in Purgatory, and no human figure himself. It was Luther’s statement about how scripture and faith were the only assets needed to attain Heaven that really put the church authority over the edge. He was not planning on breaking from the church with thus statement, but the pope had enough and finally decided to excommunicate his from the church

    Read More

  • How Did Martin Luther Impact On Religion

    134 Words  | 1 Pages

    Martin Luther, a German professor and monk, made a large impact on society in the fifteen hundreds. His new ideas of Christianity changed the concept of how religion was viewed and practiced in the 16th century. Within his Ninety-five Theses, he questioned the authority of the Roman Catholic Church and brought to light the corruption surrounding the church while stating how Christianity should be practiced in different ways rather than what is being taught. It is important to understand his stances on religion to explain how different groups reacted to his ideas. While some parts of Europe accepted his ideologies into practice, others reject Luther for many different reasons.

    Read More

  • Comparing The Works Of Martin Luther, John Calvin And King Henry VIII

    682 Words  | 3 Pages

    Martin Luther was a german theologian who brought on the reformation by demanding changes in the Catholic Church (“Martin Luther”). Martin grew with a father that was a miner and grew up working and being very religious (“Martin Luther”). One year later he followed out his promise by leaving everything behind and being ordained a monk (Martin Luther, World History Ancient and Medieval Eras). Many people believe Martin spoke badly about the church because he was corrupted by temptation. Martin Luther was ordained a monk in 1507 and did this hopefully find inner peace however, temptation made

    Read More

  • Martin Luther And John Calvin Comparison

    304 Words  | 2 Pages

    Among the religions and beliefs during the 16th century, there were different opinions on how to run society and the government. Martin Luther and John Calvin were two leaders in the Protestant Reformation who wanted change in the Catholic Church. Although Luther and Calvin were similar in the political authority and ecclesiastical, they differed on religion and society. Luther and Calvin were both Protestants who believed the Catholic Church was corrupt due to the selling of indulgences and the preaching of salvation.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast The Protestant And English Reformation

    1085 Words  | 5 Pages

    Starting from the statement that Christians receive salvation through faith and the grace of God. Luther also stated, “The churches rituals did not have the ability to save souls. ”Also Luther talked about how the Church and the Pope make errors often. This had gone from a need for reforming indulgences to a whole

    Read More

  • Protestant Reformation Dbq Essay

    663 Words  | 3 Pages

    Reformation LEQ Throughout the sixteenth century, Protestant Reformations were a common theme among a vast majority of European countries. The Protestant Reformation that took place in Germany was led by Martin Luther, a former Catholic Monk. His reasons for Reformation were solely religious based, which was very different than the Reformation that took place in England. The English Reformation was led by King Henry VIII, but unlike Luther, his reasons for Reformation were personal.

    Read More

  • Protestant Reformation Dbq Essay

    880 Words  | 4 Pages

    He took the words of God, and made them his own, changing their meaning. After these sudden changes, Martin Luther said, “The main reason I fell out with the pope was this: the pope boasted that he was the head of the Church, and condemned all that would not be under his power and authority. He said, “..although Christ is the head of the Church, there must be a physical head of the Church upon earth.” (Document 5, Luther). As Luther said, this could not be tolerated.

    Read More

  • Essay On Martin Luther's Impact On The Protestant Reformation

    939 Words  | 4 Pages

    Before Luther rebelled against Catholic practices, he has achieved many works

    Read More

More about Erasmus Laid The Egg That Luther Hatched Analysis

Open Document