Error Correction: An Argumentative Analysis
Error correction is considered to stand for an important component of language teaching and refraining from giving corrective feedback would deprive students of numerous benefits that result from it. However, not all researchers agree with this statement. The well-known opponent of error correction is Stephen Krashen, who claims it is harmful and absolutely unnecessary. According to him (in Latifi, Ketabi & Mohammadi, 2013), corrective feedback contributes only to the development of conscious knowledge and it is subconscious knowledge that should be promoted. Therefore, corrective feedback has almost no influence on student’s production and class time should not be devoted to it. As stated in Krashen, instead of improving students’ oral skills, …show more content…
Another opponent of corrective feedback is VanPatten. The author confirms (Ellis, 2009) that error correction has only minor impact on students’ oral skills. This view was, however, reviewed by VanPatten in his later works and nowadays the benefits of corrective feedback are widely recognised. Undoubtedly, error correction may be referred to as a chance for student to improve. Winne and Butler described it as “an information with which a learner can confirm, add to, overwrite, tune, or restructure (…) in memory” (in Hattie & Timperley, 2007:82). Also Sadler (in Price, 2010) admits that corrective feedback may be crucial in filling the gap between student’s interlanguage and the standard version the the language. Another asset of corrective feedback may be –surprisingly - the sense of security that it gives to students. It is often classified as a stressful factor, however, some students feel more comfortable knowing all the mistakes they …show more content…
However, probably the most serious threat of lack of correction is fossilization of errors. Han (in Hasbun, 2007:115) refers to such errors as “fossilizable structures [that] are persistent over time, against any environmental influences, including consistent natural exposure to the target language and pedagogic interventions”. Hence, when the particular mistake is not corrected and student repeats it over and over there is a danger that the error will become consolidated and impossible to eradicate. Moreover, in the classrooms where the emphasis is always put on fluency, the students may have problems following the rules of
PSA Argumentative Analysis
391 Words | 2 PagesThe authors of this journal discuss the healthcare systems cutbacks and its impact on the population. Every few years the Ontario government and the Ontario Medical Association (OMA) negotiate their contract called The Physician Services Agreement (PSA) The contract details how much physicians can bill for their services, as well as where health care funding should be invested in or where a cut back could be. In March of 2014, the contract had expired, which has led to negotiations for over the year. Over that year negotiations for the new PSA contract had many conflicts mostly due to the government’s goal try to end the province's deficit by 2017-2018.
Lynn's Argumentative Analysis
259 Words | 2 PagesLynn uses the rulings of appellate courts to disprove the myth among pit bull advocates, that pit bulls are unidentifiable. The author begins the article by addressing the case of Ohio v. Anderson, and that it was decided that a dog owner of ordinary intelligence can determine if they own a dog commonly known as a pit bull. Moreover she addresses that pit bull advocates state that pit bulls are unidentifiable and that there is no such thing as a pit bull, and why this argument is not only invalid but misleading and harmful to society. Lynn states that adoption agencies have tried to create different names to signify variating subgenres of the breed in hopes to get pit bulls adopted.
Reconstruction Argumentative Analysis
131 Words | 1 PagesAs in any war, the Civil War created destruction in different parts of the countries’ structure. For instance, the Union destroyed southern crops, plantations, and entire cities. Moreover, hundreds of thousands of emancipated slaves rushed to Union lines as their masters fled the oncoming Union army (Foner). Therefore, by 1865, the government had the mission to rebuild the South; this is known as the Reconstruction period, where four major tasks has to be address: political, social, economic and infrastructure. The big question is how this process should be done.
H. Res: An Argumentative Analysis
142 Words | 1 PagesI am pleading for your compassion and humanity to avail yourself in co-sponsorship of H. Res. 401 that would provide the compulsory measure to outlaw the inhumane practice against dogs and cats in all of nine countries in Asia engaging in cruel torture. As your constituent, I am haunted all but daily by the screams from the millions of animals crying for mercy of their torturers to just be allowed to die. It was a deep disappointment that the House Republican leadership and Speaker Paul Ryan did not bring H.Res. 30 to the floor for a vote.
Microstamping Argumentative Analysis
451 Words | 2 Pages“Ballistic imaging and microstamping technologies have the potential to reduce gun violence by improving the solve rate of gun-related crimes”(Giffords Law Center). Requiring microstamping and ballistic identification for any and all firearms can help detain and detect the person responsible for any local shootings. Microstamping is a needed adjustment for all firearms. This micro adjustment will enable us to find more evidence that police cannot in crime scenes and help find and track exactly which gun fired the bullet. In a blog posted by Towne Currier he explains the reason for this certain development: “The development of this tool is because of the challenging identification of a firearm due to the multiple sources of randomness present
Draper's Argumentative Analysis
644 Words | 3 PagesRecently gaining popularity in light of the recent election, some Californian residents are calling for secession. The idea of secession is not new, especially in instances of political turmoil. In 2012, after former President Obama’s re-election, individuals from states like Texas and Louisiana began petitions that garnered enough signatures for an office of the White House to respond. However, instead of California seceding and becoming it’s own nation, what about splitting the state into two or three states? Dividing into separate states could ease feelings of unjust representation and help the further development in each state’s needs.
DAPA Argumentative Analysis
633 Words | 3 PagesThe Deferred Action for Parents of Americans is an executive action President Barack Obama plans on implementing in order to try and control illegal immigration. Its main goal is to deport illegal immigrants back to their home country who have a criminal history while providing those with a clean record an opportunity “to temporarily stay in the U.S. without fear of deportation” (). A way to be more conducive to an effective change in immigration policies would be to change the acceptance date to January 1st, 2000. DAPA, or also known as the Deferred Action for Parents of Americans, is an initiative requested by President Barack Obama that “would provide approximately 5 million illegal aliens access to work permits and social security cards”
Foner's Argumentative Analysis
468 Words | 2 PagesAn “American” is complex to define for the simple fact that America is structured through the melting pot theory in which different types of people integrate collectively as one. Individuals from all over the world come to a country like America because it is acknowledged for providing humans an improved and more suitable way of living. People are finally able to experience a more preferably life with better opportunities for themselves and their kids. Started that are placed in different locations are their to recognized the change or accomplishment a leader has provided to this nation. However, many African American individuals have been gone and forgotten about because they have not been recognized for their exceptional challenging changes
Reconstruction Argumentative Analysis
877 Words | 4 PagesReconstruction was an attempt to rebuild the country after the Civil War and tried to end the hatred between the North and South. In Reconstruction, the South was getting ready to come back to the USA after the Civil War. Reconstruction was supposed rebuild the South physically, and it was supposed to change the South’s thoughts on full equality for all races. The South thought that whites should always be superior, and that full equality should never happen. The North thought that equality was what should happen.
Into The Wild Argumentative Essay
462 Words | 2 PagesIn life some feel the need to prove something to others. That they are better, stronger, or even more intelligent. Whatever the case may be people will go through extreme measures to prove themselves. But who do we really need to prove anything to? Is it our parents?
Reconstruction Argumentative Analysis
725 Words | 3 PagesGender, race, and region clearly influence the issue of gun control. In relation to gun ownership, men are five times more likely than women to own guns (Gallup). Moreover, in a survey where participants were asked whether it is more important to support the protection of gun rights or gun control, men support gun rights at a rate of 57% while women do so at 37% (Pew Research Center). Having established that gun rights are more associated with males, there is also a differentiation between race and region. 50% of white men own guns whereas only 34% of non-white men do, and white southern men are the most likely to own a gun at 61% (Gallup).
Amy Tan's Changing Stereotypes
793 Words | 4 PagesAmy spoke "broken" language with her family, but in front of a group she used, as she put it, "Carefully wrought grammatical phrases. " The fact that she uses proper English when she needs to is evidence of never judging a person's intelligence by their use of her English. Many times, we are too close to our own writing to see the problems with it. Feedback is a useful tool to see which parts need to be developed, or which parts aren't clear enough.
Turkle's Argument Essay
880 Words | 4 PagesAs Barnwell observes his students flounder in his conversational project, he realizes, “that conversational competence might be the single-most overlooked skill we fail to teach students,” (Par. 5). Through his personal reflection, Barnwell trivializes the issue as more of a lack of skill rather than a deep psychological issue. He is right, there is defiantly a lack of conversational skill in this generation, however, that is more of a symptom than it is the root of the disease. Barnwell’s solution for teachers is to “have a conversation,” with the students “about a challenging topic” (Par. 14). This is a good solution for the problem posed.
Garretson's Argumentative Analysis
528 Words | 3 PagesFinally, the quality of counterargument expressed throughout Garretson’s essay, has also been effected by her biased stance on vegetarianism, because she has been unable to display and acknowledge opposing views in her piece. It is very important for one to present counterarguments in their writing because it shows that the writer is not narrow-minded, and instead, is fair by considering other perspectives. Additionally, the use of counterargument adds credibility to a writing and makes the arguments that one presents more believable and trustworthy. Since Garretson does not display or acknowledge any opposing views in her essay, her arguments lose a great deal of credibility. There are many different approaches that Garretson could have taken
The Kite Runner Argumentative Analysis
827 Words | 4 PagesHonestly, I didn’t understand why Khaled Hosseini's The Kite Runner was so life-changing until a random conversation, two years after I first read the book. Unusual isn’t it - our favorite books typically stand out as soon as we read them. But the best books are the ones that you have to think about, the ones that mean something special - the ones that cause self-reflection. The time came to write another AP Language argument essay - this one was examining the morality of transcendentalism. I scoffed, “What kind of idiot would run off into the woods to ‘find himself’ rather than have a job, family, and dignity?”
More about Error Correction: An Argumentative Analysis
PSA Argumentative Analysis
391 Words | 2 PagesLynn's Argumentative Analysis
259 Words | 2 PagesReconstruction Argumentative Analysis
131 Words | 1 PagesH. Res: An Argumentative Analysis
142 Words | 1 PagesMicrostamping Argumentative Analysis
451 Words | 2 PagesDraper's Argumentative Analysis
644 Words | 3 PagesDAPA Argumentative Analysis
633 Words | 3 PagesFoner's Argumentative Analysis
468 Words | 2 PagesReconstruction Argumentative Analysis
877 Words | 4 PagesInto The Wild Argumentative Essay
462 Words | 2 PagesReconstruction Argumentative Analysis
725 Words | 3 PagesAmy Tan's Changing Stereotypes
793 Words | 4 PagesTurkle's Argument Essay
880 Words | 4 PagesGarretson's Argumentative Analysis
528 Words | 3 PagesThe Kite Runner Argumentative Analysis
827 Words | 4 Pages