ipl-logo

Essay On The Controversy Over Prenatal Genetic Screening

1317 Words6 Pages

The controversy over prenatal genetic screening has become a major issue among today’s society. Prenatal genetic screening occurs during the first and second trimester which allows physicians to diagnose the fetus by examining blood or other tissue to detect abnormalities (Sagerdo). Due to the scientific advancements in today’s society, the idea of genetic screening has been taken to the next level in forming the idea of a “super baby”. In the United States alone, between sixty-five to seventy percent of women have serum screening in order to evaluate the status of the developing fetus (Sagerdo). Often, when a disease is detected due to a genetic test many parents opt to have an abortion. As in any type of controversy, one of two sides are taken and one view point is usually more accepted than the other. In genetic screening, many believe that the negative effects outweigh the positives. Although prenatal genetic screening does offer some benefits, many ethical issues arise which are increased abortion rates, the idea of a “super baby” and religious values …show more content…

In most situations, prenatal testing will assure the parents that their baby is developing normally. Although if a disease is detected while a woman is still pregnant, this allows for procedures to be prepared ahead of time. Also it allows for the parents of the baby to prepare themselves emotionally and to properly arrange the home environment to accommodate for a child with special needs. Prenatal genetic screening can not determine for sure if a condition will be present but can show if the fetus is at a high or low risk. The goal for people who are for genetic screening is to no longer see genetic disorders exist within children. These benefits may be accurate but the negatives out weigh the positives when it comes to the issue over prenatal genetic

Show More
Related

  • Prenatal Breakdown Summary

    713 Words  | 3 Pages

    As a result many couples were given the diagnosis only at birth. But under a new recommendation from the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, doctors have begun to offer a new, safer screening procedure to all pregnant women, regardless of age.” (Harmon, 2007). The nut graph set the rest of the article up to discuss the campaign by parents who are worried about their children with Down Syndrome and their future but also the new advancements giving women of all ages early diagnoses of Down syndrome in the pregnancies and the rate of

    Read More

  • Prenatal Testing Framework

    1097 Words  | 5 Pages

    If insurance provides prenatal screening to prevent genetic disorders money will be saved from not having to care for a disabled child, which can financially crippling. However, the author acknowledges that the cost analysis should not be the sole reason in promoting prenatal screening on a societal level. The article concludes with another reminder that while prenatal screening should be available, it should only be utilized in concurrence with moral beliefs (Botkin, 880). The framework of social justice concludes that socially universal prenatal screening would be beneficial to society as a whole. By the reduction of disparity and the potentially reduced cost to society, this framework suggests that it would be ethical for the government to step in

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Prenatal Screening

    406 Words  | 2 Pages

    Based on the facts the parents receive from prenatal screening, many people are not prepared for babies with bad conditions or a certain gender. In the United States, 67 percent of people decide to abort their babies when they know they have Down syndrome through prenatal screening. A couple more downsides to prenatal screening, even for people who think it is ethical, are that it is not 100% accurate and that prenatal screening itself can also harm the

    Read More

  • Genetic Disease: Designer Babies

    429 Words  | 2 Pages

    I do believe parents should be able to pick genetic characteristics of their children, only if it is absolutely necessary and the parents want to have their own child. Some of the pros to this might be that the parents have a high chance of a genetic disease, so a designer baby might be necessary to reduce or remove that genetic disease. I feel that designer babies should only be designed if it is some genetic disease or something that would harm the baby only to eliminate the disease. Designer babies can prevent genetic disorders, which can create a healthier generation of kids in the future. Therefore this can eliminate genetic diseases for everyone and make future reproduction easier by not having to use designer babies again.[1]

    Read More

  • In Vitro Fertilization In The Movie Gattaca

    1688 Words  | 7 Pages

    In GATTACA, the social norm is to go to geneticists and allow them to fertilize the egg and sperm so that the child will have the least likely chance of diseases and the most likely chance for success. It is understood that the genome is not changed; however, the most successful genes are chosen from the parents’ genome for each trait, “this child is still you, simply, the best of you” (Niccol, 1997). Today’s standards allow in vitro fertilization only for couples who may be infertile. Embryo DNA is also tested for certain diseases through preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD). PGD is intended for couples at high risk of having children with certain genetic disorders.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Designer Babies

    1247 Words  | 5 Pages

    This procedure’s purpose is to switch out genes for more preferred ones, especially to improve the health of the child. Genetic engineering could permit selection of desired physical and pleasurable traits for non-medical reasons, which has created concern in some people. The process of switching out the genes of a fetus to install genes that are more preferred has brought up debate about whether or not parents should be able to alter their babies genes to make them more appealing to the parents interests. There are many different ways of looking at this procedure and in contrast to other scientific procedures it can be for greater good or for unnecessary enhancement that could potentially create problems in society. Designer babies aren’t morally correct or incorrect, but are in between depending on what it is being used for.

    Read More

  • Essay On Gene Editing

    1370 Words  | 6 Pages

    Editing of the human genome in the past has been only a sight seen in dystopia works such as Brave New World. Now, genetic enhancement is a prevalent today and people are beginning to realize the issues that can arise from creating these designer babies. Gene editing can be helpful to eradicate life changing disabilities. Yet, the term disability does not correctly label these differently abled people, as the idea of what is considered disabled has changed overtime. To fully understand the consequences and implications of genetic selection and enhancement of human embryos, society must mature and declare lines of what is and is not ethically moral.

    Read More

  • Essay On The Pros And Cons Of A Designer Baby

    446 Words  | 2 Pages

    Even though nobody is perfect in the world and you thought that designing a baby to try to make it perfect, it does not always work that way. The last con is that only the rich can afford to make a designer baby. This is a con because if the mom can't have babies it would be too expensive to make one and the gay parents will have no baby even if they wanted to. These were just a few cons to having a designer

    Read More

  • Essay On Prenatal Diagnostic Testing

    1114 Words  | 5 Pages

    The prenatal diagnostics and prenatal screening being routine procedures should be considered as advantage of modern medicine. It helps to reveal wide spectrum of fetus abnormal conditions, but not only congenital defects and malformations. Early detection of many of them could help to perform surgical correction and necessary management as soon as possible in order to save newborns’ lives. On the other hand, this method is widely discussed and it has many opponents, and in some countries prenatal diagnostic procedures is not considered now as a screening method. Main ethical issues are terminations of pregnancies in case of malformations, which may be supposed as eugenical abortion, inform consent and problem of decision-making process.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Genetic Engineering Babies

    901 Words  | 4 Pages

    Should or should we not prohibit genetically engineered babies is the question to ask. After years and year of trying to figure out the cure for a disease like a mitochondrial disease, a group of professional on the topic believes that it would greatly benefit the baby ’s outcome exceptionally if their parents has harmful genetics. Most people concern would be how the baby would turn out because there have not been any clinical trials that prove that the genetics that is engineered properly work like they should. I personally believe that the genetics of baby should not be engineered, but I do believe that it should be up to the parent of the children since it is their child in the first place.

    Read More

  • Hearing Impairment Case Study

    1785 Words  | 8 Pages

    Some argue that it is against Christianity. Nonetheless, holy books does not have an explicitly written text about genetic screening. The arguments are only constructed from implications of the holy texts. As the holy texts might hold many different meanings, who can know for sure, if genetic screening is just or unjust way? As this topic is very complicated dilemma and needs a further debates to come to a common consensus, one should consider two outcomes: when it is morally accepted and when it is condemned as unethical thing to do.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Designer Babies

    1095 Words  | 5 Pages

    In the long run, however, it could cause more negative outcomes than positives. Genetically modified babies seem to have positive benefits, but modifying children could potentially harm the child in the future, is an unnecessary procedure, and is overall socially and ethically wrong. Changing a child 's natural genetic structure may seem like a benefit to get rid of a potentially dangerous gene. However, changing the natural genetic structure can still harm the child and future offspring and future descendants of that child. Rebecca Dresser, a Professor of Law and Ethics in Medicine, claims, “As a result,

    Read More

  • Summary: The Ethical Dilemma Of Designer Babies

    1192 Words  | 5 Pages

    In many countries, it is illegal to create a designer baby, but in the United States, there is no law against it (Knoepfler, The Ethical Dilemma of Designer Babies, TedTalk). In his TedTalk, “The Ethical Dilemma of Designer Babies,” stem cell and genetics researcher, Paul Knoepfler, states the long-term risks of designer babies, describing it as “a kinder, gentler, positive eugenics.” He also touches on government involvement in this researcher; “I also think it 's not that unlikely that governments might start taking an interest in genetic modification. So for example our imagined GM Jenna child who is healthier, if there 's a generation that looks like they have lower healthcare costs, it 's possible that governments may start trying to compel their citizens to go the GM route.” I agree with many points Knoepfler makes in his TedTalk.

    Read More

  • Arguments Against Genetic Testing

    84 Words  | 1 Pages

    Thank your for responds regarding my research. The way you present your argument is valid but that is just a few. To add on what you just said, women of modern times are being pressured into terminating a pregnancy because they may feel like it is the only choice after genetic testing results. My question though is, what happens when the happens if the general motive of genetic testing is for the good of humans in a work place? would that be considered discrimination?

    Read More

  • The Benefits Of Genetic Testing

    1022 Words  | 5 Pages

    Today, tests involve the analyzing of multiple genes to determine the risk or possibilities of developing certain and more common diseases (heart disease or cancer, for instance), and some non-medical related purposes. There are many types of genetic testing, including: (1) Newborn screening – a testing used just after birth to identify genetic disorders that could be treated early in life. A blood sample is collected with a heel prick from the newborn 24–48 hours after birth and sent to the lab for analysis. An abnormal result doesn’t indicate that the child is diagnosed with the disorder. Diagnostic tests must follow the initial screening to confirm the disease.

    Read More

More about Essay On The Controversy Over Prenatal Genetic Screening

Open Document