Columbus, an Italian explorer, had set sail in 1492 working for Spain. When he arrived to the Americas, he did not know anything about it, so he felt the need to take over and be a tyrant. America should not celebrate Columbus Day because he terrorized the people of the Americas and did not even achieve any of the goals he set out for, to help Europe gain more knowledge. Columbus Day should not be celebrated due to his cruelty which includes rape, him killing and planning to obliterate all Natives. He had killed many Native Americans almost wiping them out in one generation, he set a plan to exterminate the Native Americans and he encouraged his men to rape the Native Americans. Columbus day should not be celebrated because he did not achieve …show more content…
For example, one way Columbus terrorized the Native Americans was encouraging the Spaniards to rape the Native American women and young girls. He wanted to show the Natives that he and his crew can do what they want on that land because they dominate it. Columbus told and “he encouraged his men to rape Native women as young as nine or ten….” Columbus actually allowed his crew to rape the Natives and scar them for life. Another way Columbus had terrorized the Native Americans was by planning to exterminate them all. He wanted to wipe out all of them so he can have the land for himself. Columbus with the help of his crew “...organized an extermination of Native Americans.” Columbus and his men almost killed all Native Americans in one generation. Also Columbus killing many Natives was a way he terrorized them. No matter how minor the Native Americans actions of opposition against Columbus, he would still punish them. Columbus would command his men to torture the Natives because “he punished minor offenses against his domination by cutting off the Natives’ noses and ears.” Columbus killed these Natives slowly so they would feel the crucial pain before they die, which is just horrible. Columbus really explore to terrorize others lives because he did not even achieve any of the goals he intended to …show more content…
For example, one of the objectives Columbus wanted to achieve was to discover something new. Columbus believed he had discovered the Americas, but how did he discover it if people already were civilized there. The truth is that “Columbus did not discover America, because people had lived here for thousands of years.” Even though there are facts stating that Columbus did not discover America people still believe he did. Another objective Columbus wanted to achieve was to convert people to Christianity. When Columbus arrived to the Americas he did not convert one Native American. Columbus had been on the same land with the Natives and yet “not one of them was converted to the Catholic faith, which was supposedly a prime motive of those voyages.” Instead of converting the Natives and being friendly with them he was just oppressive towards them. Also Columbus did not contribute any new information to Europe’s existing knowledge. He set out to gather new information for Europe so that they can improve their education about the world. Columbus did not discover anything new and “...failed to add anything new to the pool of European knowledge….” He just came back with no new information for Europe because what he did was already done. Columbus had failed to accomplish any of his goals, which was really the main purpose of his
The Natives were killed by the European diseases, and after enduring this they were then forced into European law through the Economedia system. Without his discovery, this may have been avoided or handled in a more careful way. Also, Christopher Columbus had many accounts of rape, as well as murder. He wasn’t the only man committing either of these atrocities, but his fame brings these faults
Christopher Columbus is arguably one of the most famous performers of all time. He discovered the Caribbean Islands, Hispaniola(modern day Haiti and the Dominican Republic), Jamaica, Cuba, and parts of Central America and northern South America. During the second Monday in October, Americans from coast to coast celebrate Columbus’s arrival in the Americas. However, does Columbus really deserve a holiday? Is he really the hero elementary school textbooks paint him to be?
Christopher Columbus is not worthy of a recognition of a national holiday. Columbus is not worthy of a national holiday because he threatened and killed people. For example he claimed the indians land as his own. Also he murdered the indians and forced them into hard labor. Also to test how sharp his swords were he cut pieces of of the indians.
Why is a killer, slave trader and rapist honored each year? Columbus is celebrated each year and around the 500th anniversary of Columbus Day many skepticisms were brought to light about Columbus and the terror he brought to the American Indians. Should Columbus Day be abolished and was he a villain? A villain is usually very selfish person that’s purpose is to bring terror to people who are undeserving of that terror. I think columbus day should be abolished because he killed millions of people, he traded slaves, he was a rapist, he was selfish and he forcefully changed cultures but his discoveries shouldn’t be ignored or forgotten because he was important for the exploration of America and the improvement in navigation.
Christopher Columbus was an invader because he forced religion to them, enslaved them, and slaughter them. To begin with, Columbus forced the Native Americans to worship Christianity. He wanted to spread Christianity to the New World (“Columbus Controversy”). Many historians claim that Christopher Columbus was a great missioner and a leader ship while others thought he was an amoral.
Columbus was the first messenger sent to the Americas from a Western civilization and he wrote, “As soon as I arrived in the Indies, on the first Island which I found, I took some of the natives by force in order that they might learn and might give me information of whatever there is in these parts,” (Zinn) which explains how Columbus wanted to take over America and he was willing to constrain the Natives just to do
Have you ever met someone who is not who you thought they were? You should not trust just one source. Textbooks often show just one side of the story. New evidence proves that Christopher Columbus is not who he seems. Due to this information, Columbus Day should be changed.
However, it still happened and destroyed a whole population. The Columbian Exchange shows the arrival diseases like whooping cough and many others to the new world ( Document 6). As said, a mass extinction happened. We still should not praise Columbus as a hero because just one thing he did to the natives was “unintentional”. That one “unintentional” thing still doesn't make up for the numerous other accounts of crimes, torture and slavery on the
Therefore, the history of Columbus in school textbooks doesn’t teach the true history, they teach us what they want us to believe. Unfortunately, the textbooks leave out tragically events that happened to numerous Native American tribes. Created events that never happened and left out important incidents that effected Native
In October of 1492, Portuguese explorer Christopher Columbus landed by ship in the “New World” which is today known as the Americas. Many people believe the holiday that honors him annually in October has great meaning behind it. However, I believe Columbus day should not be celebrated. Christopher Columbus was not the first person ever to discover the Americas, he abused natives on their own land, and the holiday isn’t celebrated in the way it should be. Christopher Columbus was not the first to discover the Americas.
When I was younger I was under the impression that Christopher Columbus was a great man and that he discovered America. We celebrate Columbus day because we honor him for “discovering America”. From this new information that I have learned today, Christopher Columbus is not the man iv have been taught about.
Putting aside all the horrible things Columbus did, he did help colonize North America. He opened up a new world where people could go to freely express themselves, it was the land of the free. People could freely practice their religion and many could start a new life. Another reason why people don't want Columbus day to change is because of his Italian background. Many italian americans are proud of Christopher Columbus because of his italian background.
Instead of finding the Indies he finds the “New World” and creates a settlement of his own and starts to do terrible things. This can be taken as Christopher Columbus being greedy and self righteous than being an explorer for Spain. Christopher Columbus should be considered as a pirate instead of an explorer. Christopher is more of a pirate than explorer is that he became the ruler of the new land he found and was very unfair to the natives and his people.
Bartolome de las Casas is used by Zinn for many of the sources of the cruelty against the natives, but even Zinn admits that "his figures are exaggerations"(). However, Zinn still puts Bartolome under much less criticism than Columbus even though the priest did his share in being cruel to natives; this was most likely because he wanted to make the point that Columbus should not be so heroized. Overall, the monarchy of Europe is truly to blame for sending the greediest men with orders only to extract wealth from the New World. Whether or not America should celebrate Columbus Day is a highly debatable topic, but it should not really be celebrated or called after a relatively cruel man. Columbus just happened to be in charge of the right ship with a gamble that turned out to make him extremely successful, but he did not have anything, besides good seamanship to make him any more exciting than the average
Argumentative Essay Outline I. Claim: Celebration of Columbus Day should be abolished due to Columbus’ harsh treatment toward the Native Americans and fallacies in his exploration. II. Sub-Claims: A) Reason: Columbus’ exploration was not meant to discover America but to conquer and exploit existed American civilizations.