ipl-logo

Ethical Dilemma Case Analysis: The Four Navy Seals

1503 Words7 Pages

In June of 2005 a team of four Navy Seals were tasked with a mission of locating a local taliban leader in the Hindu Kush mountains of Afghanistan. The four Seals were observing the village the taliban leader was believed to be hiding in when they were detected by three goat herders. The soldier in charge Lieutenant Murphy put it to a conference of his men whether to kill them to keep their cover or to let them go, Lieutenant Luttrell was the deciding vote of the group which determined the group would let them go. The decision resulted in ¾ of the Seals being killed and additional 16 american servicemen losing their lives due to a taliban ambush about an hour later(Operation Red Wings) . The moral decision although not obvious can be broken down into Kant’s Categorical imperative versus Consequentialism. Upon analyzation of the moral dilemma it is apparent that in times of warfare and deadly conflicts, those in power must favor Consequentialism over Kant's Categorical Imperative. …show more content…

This states that for an action one must find the maxim or action, make it Universal, imagine it practically carried out universally, and one must will it to be a universal law. When applied to the scenario the maxim would be: one shouldn't kill innocent civilians regardless of militaristic advantages, which passes all four tests of the categorical Imperative. The Categorical Imperative when applied here is not concerned with the actions of the three goat herders regarding alarming the taliban or any harm they could cause the Seals post

Show More
Related

  • Analysis Of Marcus Luttrell And Patrick Robinson: Thesis For Lone Survivor

    104 Words  | 1 Pages

    Thesis for Lone Survivor The “Lone Survivor” by Marcus Luttrell and Patrick Robinson is about a Navy Seal who ends up losing four of his closest “brothers,” along with other close Navy SEALs, in Afghanistan during a single attack against the Taliban. Luttrell is trying to convey the true meaning of brotherhood and glorious sacrifice. He is deserted in a violent, foreign are with only three other men for hours that feel like days, all fighting towards a common goal, to keep each other alive. They are willing to lay down their lives for each other but more importantly, their country.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Navy Seals

    734 Words  | 3 Pages

    Navy SEALs are a special operations group known for doing some very risky things. Navy Seals are the ones who killed Osama Bin Laden, saving Private Ryan, etc. There are a few more popular SEALs for their missions like: Marcus Luttrell, Chris Kyle, Mark Owen, And Chris Heben, there are tons of more but those are the most known. For these Missions they have to be prepared mentally and physically. Navy SEALs are called the best of the best because of what they do and how they do it.

    Read More

  • Who Is Susan Fisher Staples Under The Persimmon Tree

    926 Words  | 4 Pages

    Imagine waking up every morning with the Taliban in rule, imagine waking up not knowing if you or your loved ones would die today, with bombs going off and gunfire ringing in your ears. This is what it's like every day in the book Under the Persimmon Tree, by Susan Fisher Staples. This book takes place in Afghanistan and Pakistan after 9/11 the main character is named Najmah and she is in a family of five living on a farm in Golestan, Afghanistan. Her father and older brother got taken by the Taliban and the mother and younger brother got killed in the bombing. at the end all that is left is Nur and Najmah.

    Read More

  • My Lai Massacre Research Paper

    1185 Words  | 5 Pages

    The My Lai Massacre is one example of what is wrong with the US Government. The men of Charlie Company had been told that an local enemy force

    Read More

  • Five Criteria Of Moral Panics In Australia

    1990 Words  | 8 Pages

    In this modern society, Australian have the culture of drinking alcohol beverages in different special events or occasion for sociability, cultural participation or relaxation (Australian Government National Health and Medical Research Council 2015). The pure alcohol consumption of alcohol beverages was 183.7 million litres in Australia in 2013-14 (The Australian Bureau of Statistics 2015). However, the alcohol was involved in drunken violence. There was the example which were two young men, Kelly and Christie who were died because of the ‘one punch’ alcohol-fuelled violence at Sydney King Cross ( 'Daniel Christie dies following king-hit punch ' 2014). Therefore, the New South Wales(NSW) government introduced the new alcohol laws to

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Harrison Bergeron And The Lord Of The Flies

    725 Words  | 3 Pages

    With injustice and cruelty running rampant in the world, it is unsurprising that people become determined to make things better for tomorrow. The cliché saying that the ends justify the means is often quoted by those aware of the moral greyness of their actions. Commendable yet unreasonable, leaders whose sole purpose in life is to fix what they see as “wrong” with the world fall prey to thinking there is only ally or enemy. In the long run, they harm those they try to liberate.

    Read More

  • Ethical Issues In The Military

    1405 Words  | 6 Pages

    Ethical Issue Facing the Army The purpose of this paper is to briefly and identify an ethical issue facing the Army, identify the root cause and discuss its impact on the force. This research will address the ethical issue using the ethical lenses of rules, values, and outcomes, and will recommend a solution to correct the root cause. The ethical issue identify throughout the research is the abuse of power or position which leads to other underline issues affecting good order and discipline in the organization. Identifying the Root Causes

    Read More

  • The Warrior King

    641 Words  | 3 Pages

    The nature of the enemy was changing and as there was conflicting guidance from MG Odierno to use more force and COL Rudesheim to use more non-lethal methods to combat the enemy, whoever that was. LTC Sassaman viewed COL Rudesheim as the desk jockey who did not really know what was going on in the field, and as a result of the conflict in guidance, discipline started to break down within the battalion. LTC Sassaman did not have a “how to” manual on how to combat insurgency and at the same time stand up a government. LTC Sassaman points out in the case study that the intent of the Soldiers who forced the two Iraqi’s over the bridge were not criminal. The decision by LT Saville to make these civilians jump into the Tigris River as a non-lethal threat describes the permissive attitude allowed that leads to unethical behavior in combat.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Ghosts Of Abu Ghraib By Rory Kennedy

    717 Words  | 3 Pages

    The first scene that these quandaries come to light is where General Geoffrey D. Miller, a specialist in interrogations, was sent to Abu Ghraib to help guards extract more information from the prisoners. The guards at the facility had been trained for years to follow every order they had been given, but this would mark the first time that the United States Army’s orders had directly conflicted with their personal convictions. This fact was stated by the soldiers themselves in the the interviews conducted afterwards. This type of obedience can be explained by Erich Fromm in his article, “Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem”. Fromm states that there are two types of Obedience one that is submissive to an institution or power, and another which an affirmation of your own personal beliefs (Fromm 124).

    Read More

  • Realism Vs. Liberalism In International Relations

    902 Words  | 4 Pages

    Decision makers are no free agents making their own preferable choices rather we are coming from a social settings that informs its subjects about what is appropriate and important. In simple words, what we think comes out of our social condition. The Realist approach that man is power lusty seems, to be a miss-representation of Fear. In the wilderness of the international structure individuals feel insecure (constructing a social belief) against each other hence paving way for a holocaust.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On The Power Of Empathy

    1046 Words  | 5 Pages

    Only those people were not just the enemy, they were sons, husbands, fathers, daughters, mothers, and above all, human. The deaths of people are becoming as meaningful as credits on a movie screen. “-people who die by gunfire are usually only extras, or deserve to die.” We pay attention for a fleeting second and then it is suddenly unimportant.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis: The Case For Torture By Michael Levin

    971 Words  | 4 Pages

    Levin provides life threatening situations to speak out to those who are more strongly opinionated. In this instance Levin states that a terrorist has placed a bomb on an Island and is about to detonate it. The only way to prevent the detonation of the device is adherence to the demands that the terrorist provides (Levin 359). While analyzing the viewpoint and the tone of the writer, it is clear that he is afraid failure to follow the demands of the criminal would lead to the loss of many lives. He affirms that in his personal beliefs this case falls under the jurisdiction to torture such criminals, since it seems to be the only way to save the lives of the innocent.

    Read More

  • Carolyn Nordstrom's 'Shadows Of War'

    664 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout Chapter five of her book Shadows of War, Carolyn Nordstrom shares her views on war in terms of social, physical and mental goals and punishes of such violence. To begin, one of the first goals of war as defined by Nordstrom is a direct result of a threat of loss of control. She explains that it is common for one military to feel the need to destroy another when their control over a certain (land area owned or controlled by someone) is under threat (56). An interesting point that Nordstrom makes is relating to/about (community of people/all good people in the world)'s do not tell the difference between the existence of different violences. As stated by Nordstrom, most people will naturally tell/show the difference between different wars; however, very few tell/show the difference between the experience of violence throughout such wars (57).

    Read More

  • Ethical Decisions In Crimson Tide

    442 Words  | 2 Pages

    Hunter previously states that; “the true nature of war is to serve itself and leave the world destroyed.” While Captain Frank Ramsey, rose through the military ranks, to his current position , he takes Hunter’s advice, but does not seem to listen to it because of their backgrounds. When making an ethical decision, many factors affect the process. In this example, it is pressure from your peers, the men on board, the military, and the people of the united states the swore to protect.

    Read More

  • Garrett Hardin Lifeboat Ethics Analysis

    755 Words  | 4 Pages

    In “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor” (1974), Hardin debates whether rich countries should provide aid to poor countries through food supplies or immigration. Garrett Hardin was a renowned Americans philosopher received his PhD in microbiology from Stanford University. He has written several books and articles that mainly focus on ecology, and throughout his life, has constantly forewarned the world about the risks of overpopulation. Due to his deep understanding of ecology, and due to the intensive research the author has done on this particular topic, Hardin is credible to write an article about this topic. Moreover, Hardin’s main purpose in writing this piece is to persuade the readers, the population of the rich countries and their governments, not to help the poorer countries.

    Read More

More about Ethical Dilemma Case Analysis: The Four Navy Seals

Open Document