ipl-logo

Eugenics Ethical Dilemmas

1693 Words7 Pages

The world has tried to continually, and in some instances, successfully fight injustice, inequality and discrimination brought about by slavery, colonization, and racism. The human race seems to still labor from yet another form of injustice and discrimination being championed by eugenics. Eugenics is defined by many scholars in similarly many ways, but for purposes of this paper, one definition shall suffice. Eugenics is “the study of or belief in the possibility of improving the qualities of the human species or a human population” (Burke & Castaneda, 2007). This paper looks at the practice of eugenics in North Carolina and will present the legal and ethical argument against eugenics both historically and in the present debate.
The science …show more content…

These arguments are based on both legal and ethical reasons. On one hand, those opposed to eugenics dismiss it as a perpetuation of discrimination in that it does not seek justice and widens the inequality gap. Since we live in a society of unequal chances where on one hand we have the rich who can afford all they want while on the other we have the poor who barely afford what they need. The practice of eugenics has a danger of dividing the society into two groups namely; the genetic overclass and underclass. The replacement of the natural law of selection (genetic lottery according to Rawls) becomes replaced by the choice of the science, the inequalities in society become programmed hence not only passing social disadvantages into future generations but also genetically embedding …show more content…

However, with the advent of technology, eugenics has been advanced to even encourage parents to carry out a selection of the kind of babies they want to give birth to resulting in the term “designer babies” through prenatal testing (Asch, 1999). If parents notice that their expected baby might suffer some form of disability they usually resort to eugenics whereby they can choose to terminate the pregnancy. Disability rights advocates oppose prenatal testing that results in genetic enhancement because they view it as discriminatory against the disabled. This holds true because genetic enhancement and improvement of fetuses that would have been otherwise born with some impairment discriminate against existing people with disabilities as it sends a clear message to those living with disabilities that they should never have been born. Prenatal testing and genetic enhancing as a means of eugenics mostly result in selective abortion of disabled fetuses thus sending a very loud discriminatory message to those that are already living with disabilities. This kind of discrimination is very unethical as it undermines the efforts to create an equal world where every human being is viewed as a creation of God and should be respected as such in the eyes of the world (Asch,

Show More
Related

  • Who Killed The Lindbergh Baby Essay

    1355 Words  | 6 Pages

    Eugenics is when people with “perfect” genes are “selectively bred” together to reproduce offspring that would also have “perfect” genes. Only the best of people were allowed to take part in this. This is where the problem comes in. Lindbegr Jr. was diagnosed with a condition that was somewhat close to Rickets that prevented him from developing strong bones. Jr also had a condition that caused him to have overlapping toes.

    Read More

  • Salem Witch Paranoia Essay

    2207 Words  | 9 Pages

    Darwinists in turn, believed biology to be destiny and that if one's ancestors were unfit their children would be as well. Much like in evolution, Spencer assumed that the unfit populations would decline overtime due to their failure to compete, however paranoia led some Americans to speed up this process, introducing eugenics. Eugenics were supposed to improve men, ridding the undesirable traits of the unfit and changing genetic structure to create more fit individuals. The Eugenics movement in America took people of color, the mentally ill or disabled, LGBTQ individuals, and other members of society deemed unfit, and conducted experimentation ranging from forced breeding, involuntary sterilization, or institutionalization on them. Although the movement was eventually stomped out, it violated thousands of

    Read More

  • North Carolina Pros And Cons

    771 Words  | 4 Pages

    In July of 1933, the North Carolina State Legislature formed the EBNC. The EBNC is The Eugenics Board of North Carolina. The board was formed to repeal a 1929 law that had been put in place to provide sterilization for persons that were feeble minded and mentally defective in North Carolinian penal institutes. The EBNC was put in place when the act was ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court because it permanently affects the lives of inmates in a system similar to bartering. There was the perception of fairness to inmates who are being coerced into contraceptive intake or “sterilization”.

    Read More

  • Comparison Of Eugenics Movement And Carrie Buck

    782 Words  | 4 Pages

    The war and immigration played the largest role on the emergence of eugenics. In 1927, the supreme court ruled in favor of the sexual sterilization of a young woman named Carrie Buck. This paper discusses

    Read More

  • Margaret Sanger's Speech On Eugenics

    1586 Words  | 7 Pages

    Margaret Sanger was a birth rights advocate and in her later years, supported eugenics. Eugenics is the belief that all of the good human qualities can be the main characteristics instead of all the bad qualities in the human population. In the speech, Sanger believes that people with mental illnesses should have limited children or no children at all which proves that she supported negative eugenics and sterilization.

    Read More

  • Eugenics Rough Draft Essay

    700 Words  | 3 Pages

    Research Paper Rough Draft- Eugenics The amazing thing about the world today is the rapidly changing society, and the contemporary technology. Something that scientist have been working to perfect for many years is the modernization of eugenics. It is changing the way people are born by selecting specific traits for an individual to be smarter, stronger, more attractive and many other traits. Many parents of the new generation are willing to try the science of eugenics for their child to be customized to them.

    Read More

  • Compulsory Sterilization Laws

    918 Words  | 4 Pages

    “Eugenics and Compulsory Sterilization Laws: Providing Redress for the Victims of a Shameful Era in United States History,” is an article by, Michael Silver, that addresses the issue of eugenics and involuntary sterilization laws. He specifically looked at the sterilization laws that were practiced in the 20th Century in the United States. Silver brings forth the argument that sterilization laws violate the constitutional rights of Americans of procreation and childrearing. Throughout the article, Silver explains the history of how the laws were created, practiced, and how they affected those that were involuntarily sterilized. As the article progresses, Silver gave examples of how individual states and the United States, collectively as a

    Read More

  • What Is The Use Of Eugenics In Anthem By Ayn Rand

    1003 Words  | 5 Pages

    When a child is born, parents "never see their children," and "children never know their parents" (Rand, Anthem 41). This reduces the flow of communication, allowing the Council of Eugenics manipulate the children born, free from outside influences. If Equality is allowed to talk to his children, he might teach his children about independence or inspire revolutionary acts in them. Because the Council wants to control the population and prevent a rebellion, they try to limit the ability of parents to change their children's lives. The Council of Eugenics can then condition the children to behave in certain ways and think in certain

    Read More

  • The Science Of Eugenics In The Holocaust

    1622 Words  | 7 Pages

    According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, eugenics is: “a science that deals with the improvement (as by control of human mating) of hereditary qualities of a race or breed”. ("Definition of Eugenics by Merriam-Webster") The most common example of this concept would be the Holocaust, which was the extermination of Jewish people and others deemed “unfit” for society in World War Ⅱ. But little do many know, the Nazi’s were not the only people practicing eugenics in the early 1900’s, eugenics was being practiced in the United States long before the Holocaust. The American Eugenics Society aimed to educate American people on the science of Eugenics.

    Read More

  • Why Is Millay Considered A Pacifist?

    1005 Words  | 5 Pages

    Eugenics was meant to improve the human race by scourging the earth of disease and imperfections. One infamous example of this was the Holocaust were the Nazis killed many Jewish people due to the fact they thought Jews were unfit for society along with people with real disabilities. Germans were creating powerful weapons and Einstein wrote a

    Read More

  • American Eugenics Society Analysis

    424 Words  | 2 Pages

    AES’s works were greatly presented at state and local affairs. ‘Better Babies and Fitter Families’ contests, travelling exhibits entitled “Some People Are Born as a Burden on the Rest”, passage of different immigration restriction acts, convincing legislators to label crimes as of bad human hereditary origin, and even clergymen to transform eugenic theory to eugenic theology were continuously done by the new society. With this intended effort of bringing and solidifying bordered lines between classes, the AES has successfully altered then the human thinking and behavior, and concretely imposed an unquestioned distinction between “high grade people” and people of low origin called

    Read More

  • Why Genetic Engineering Is Bad

    724 Words  | 3 Pages

    As technology advances, more things become possible. One of these things is genetically modifying a baby, this is very wrong. Genetic modifying or genetic engineering is altering someone or something’s DNA. Scientists hope to cure diseases with this method but doing this can lead to some harmful effects. This process is very unethical.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Eugenics

    722 Words  | 3 Pages

    Eugenics is the science of using artificial selection to improve genetic features of the population. It is thought that improvement of the human race can be seen through sterilization of people who exhibit undesirable traits and selective breeding. Often called Social Darwinism, the concept was widely accepted during the time of World War I. It quickly became a taboo after World War II when Nazi Germany used it as an excuse for genocide. The thought of improving the human race by manipulating who is allowed to breed can either be appalling or compelling.

    Read More

  • Eugenics Argumentative Essay

    1229 Words  | 5 Pages

    Eugenics The term eugenics was coined in 1883 by Francis Galton. He defined it as the study of “the conditions under which men of a high type are produced” and also as “the science which deals with all influences that improve the inborn qualities of a race”. However, it is not just a field of study and, could be taken as a social movement or policy as well. “Eugenics” may refer to the theory that infers hereditable intelligence and fortune which are possessed by the wealthy, successful and intelligent were made as a result of their good selective breeding, and that the lower classes would remain so because they continued to breed with other poor people from lower social classes or casts. Eugenics could be popular amongst people with a vested

    Read More

  • Summary: The Ethical Dilemma Of Designer Babies

    1192 Words  | 5 Pages

    “Where do babies come from?” Every child at one point or another will ask this classic question. Depending on the age of the child, some parents will tell the story of the stork, or if they feel it is morally wrong to lie to their child, they will just say “when two people love each other.” Sooner or later, either through mischievous friends or eventually from their parents, a child will learn the biological development of a baby. They then believe this is the only way a baby is created- simple and easy.

    Read More

More about Eugenics Ethical Dilemmas

Open Document