In the play, The Crucible, Arthur Miller is showing how history may repeat itself through his article on McCarthyism, “Are You Now Or Were You Ever”. The Crucible proves a fitting allegory for the Red Scare by highlighting societal actions characteristic to both events: the snowball effect, blind obedience to authority, and damaged reputations. Damaged reputations is a fear that is shared in The Crucible and during the Red Scare. During the Red Scare hinting at any communists remarks raised questions. When Miller was joking about communism, his lawyer began to question his motive. Miller said, “ I Started to laugh until I saw the constraint in my lawyer’s face, and I quickly sobered up,” (“Are You Now” 4). Miller realized he was not speaking …show more content…
Miller said,”The quickness with which Soviet-style regimens had taken over… I believe it stirred up fear in Americans of our own ineptitudes, our mystifying inability, despite our military victories, to control the world...” (“Are You Now” 2). Through these advancements that communists have taken and the doubt they had in their “own ineptitudes”, fear of spies living among pushed citizens to become more aware of communism around them and throw unsensible false accusations. This is similar to how the citizens of Salem accused one another due to their fear of being hung. Throughout the witch trials of Salem in 1692, rumors of the Devil afflicting people through witches that were in Salem and those witches being hung caused an uproar. As neighbors would notice things about each other, accusations would arise, and everyone would deflect accusations against them because they did not want to be persecuted and then hung. When Mary Warren is being cornered by the Court, Abby, and the Girls, she defends herself and turns on Proctor. Mary hysterically screams, “ My name, he want my name. ‘I’ll murder you,’ he says, ‘if my wife hangs! We must go and overthrow the court,’ he says!” (The Crucible 119). This false accusation that Mary Warren pulls out on Proctor is an example of the snowball effect, as Mary warren comes into the court with Proctor to accuse Abby, but fails …show more content…
While researching into the Salem witch trials, Miller found out that “every authority not only confirmed the existence of witches but never questioned the necessity of executing them.”(“Are You Now” 3). While Miller was studying the Salem of 1692, he discovered how the hierarchy in Salem “confirmed the existence of witches” and the people of of Salem had to look up to the authority, because judges and ministers were deemed the physical carriers of God’s judgement. If they questioned the authority, it would be like defying God, which is why they they had to turn a blind eye and conform. This exhibition of blind obedience can be comparable to the Red Scare when the government was spreading propaganda. Miller said that “it was precisely the invisibility of ideas that was frightening so many people,”(“Are You Now” 3). Although people during the McCarthyism era did not know why they had to report communists, it was the potential of the “ideas that [were] frightening so many people,” ideas that could hurt the free world that they lived in. These quotes show how in both eras, the people did not know what they were getting into, but they did it anyways because their authority instilled those ideals into them. The same authority that they were taught to look up to because it
However, newly released archival materials such as the Venona intercepts show the extent of Communist subversion in pre- and post-war America. There were indeed hundreds of Communists working for Moscow, directly or indirectly, in the United States during the Roosevelt and Truman administrations. The problem that plagued Joe McCarthy was that by the time he surfaced with his accusations in the 1950’s, the key Soviet spy networks had all been closed down. For decades, many people believed that anyone who was accused of being a spy for the Soviets in the '50s was in fact just another innocent victim of the McCarthy’s witch hunt. Although it is true that McCarthy’s witch hunt did ruin the lives of innocent people, the fact is there were witches to be hunted and there had been a threat national security presented by communist spying and subversion in the 1940’s.
This was all because people didn’t agree with McCarthy. He assumed that you were a communist if you didn’t believe in the same thing as him. The Kniffen molestation case sent innocent people to jail based on accusations from a step mother who had a history of mental illness, trying to prove a point. And in the David McCallum/ Willie Stucky case, the police thought they had two murder suspects in custody based on incomplete police work, lake of investigation, and coursed
McCarthy “was notoriously difficult on writers and entertainers, many of whom were labeled communist sympathizers and were unable to continue working” (Arthur Miller, Elia Kazan and the Blacklist: None Without Sin”). Both the Salem witch trials and the McCarthy trials “could often destroy a career [or life] with a single unsubstantiated accusation” (Arthur Miller, Elia Kazan and the Blacklist: None Without Sin”). These unsubstantiated accusations and claims in both instances were used as a catalyst for furthering hidden
The crucible by Arthur Miller is an allegory for the red scare in the McCarthy era because fear, Intimidation, and Deception played bigger roles in these Stories. Because of the crucible focusing on the inconsistencies of the salem witch trials and whole cause of McCarthyism was having a witch hunt for people involved in communistic activities it plots a point that through manipulation and disloyalty the trials served as an explanation of how people’s beliefs burns away the outer shells to reveal their true intentions and character beneath and how people see them after all is concluded. “Like the american people, the town folk of salem were willing to believe that there were witches in their town since witchcraft had just been discovered
In the late 1940s – early 1950s, Wisconsin Senator Joseph McCarthy made the grandiose pledge to uncover a communist plot to overthrow democracy in United States. No one was safe from persecutions, and the “witch hunts” for communism began. In response to the mass hysteria over this communist infiltration, Arthur Miller wrote The Crucible. In the play, the people of Salem, Massachusetts in 1692 sought to destroy the devil’s influence by seeking and destroying witches. This began the Salem Witchcraft Trials.
the crucible by Arthur miller is an allegory for the red scare in the McCarthy Era because of the trials, false accusation and the lack of evidence One of the ways that the crucible can allegorically connect to the McCarthy era is the trials. In the crucible if you confess that you are a witch then you had to give up name of alleged witches. According to “what is McCarthyism? And how did it happen?” By Ellen Schrecker and “Hunting the communist” the same thing happened in the McCarthy era trials, if you were accused of being a communist, then you had to give a list of
Political Representation in The Crucible Arthur Miller, the author, wrote The Crucible in 1952 during the Red Scare, an investigation into Communist spies in the U.S. Government. A result of the Cold War with the Soviet Union, numerous citizens, including Miller, were interrogated for being accused of association with the Communist party by Senator Joseph McCarthy. The author used the Salem Witch Trials in his play to represent and criticize the search for Communist party members during the rise of McCarthyism. In The Crucible, Abigail Williams and the other “afflicted” girls compare to Joseph McCarthu and his actions in the 1950s.
After World War II, many Americans were in extreme fear as to what would become of them. The main fear was that the Communists would attempt to take over the world and to destroy precious American liberties. John McCarthy, a republican senator from Wisconsin, became the head of a committee known as the United States Senate Homeland Security Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, or PSI (“Joseph R. McCarty”). This committee became infamous for its unconstitutional investigation and hearings. The Crucible, written by Arthur Miller in response to what are now known as the McCarthy hearings, proves to be an allegory for McCarthyism in that the play contains a similar basis for the ordeal, a similar set of trials, and some similar effects.
During McCarthyism many people had a reason not to sacrifice their career, so they accused others of communists. They did this to protect themselves. “ The FBI had long since infiltrated the Party,
The central argument in Miller’s article, titled “Are You Now Or Were You Ever”, asserts that the McCarthy era (along with the plot of The Crucible) was started by paranoia and unjust convictions of rather innocent people and was aided by the tension between the communist east and democratic west. He develops this argument through an appeal to logos. Miller identifies the arguments used by the accusing group and logically discredits their statements by deconstructing their details and adding factual evidence to help the audience understand the irrationalities of their allegations. One argument in particular was on how the defendants were promoted to reveal their political beliefs but were left to remain mute, further displaying the injustice
With all of the accusations going around, people were forgetting that everyone can have their own opinion. Edward R Murrow, a television host of See It Now bashed McCarthy by saying “’We must not confuse dissent with disloyalty’” (Roberts, 2). Murrow was saying that just because a person disagrees with what the president or a government official says, does not mean they are a communist. The United States has freedom of speech, and citizens can say whatever they want about the government.
The Salem witch trials proved to be one of the most cruel and fear driven events to ever occur in history. Many innocent people were accused of witchcraft, and while some got out of the situation alive not everyone was as lucky. Arthur Miller the author of The Crucible conveys this horrific event in his book and demonstrates what fear can lead people to do. But the reason as to why Arthur Miller felt the need to write The Crucible in the first place was because the unfortunate reality that history seemed to have repeated itself again. In the article “Are You Now or Were You Ever”, Arthur Miller claims that the McCarthy era and the Salem witch trials were similar and he does this through his choice of diction, figurative language, and rhetorical questions.
After continuous pressuring Mary Warren replies with ‘I cannot, they’ll turn on me— “showing us the mob has driven fear into people and how Marry is afraid to tell the truth in the case everyone will turn on her and blame her. Mary’s feeble attempt to recompense backfires, so when Abigail uses the poppet to blame it on Elizabeth, making Mary feel even worse thus she agrees to go with proctor to testify against Abigail in court. Later after agreeing to go to court to support Proctor Mary is asked who is at fault and in fear replies pointing to proctor “You’re the devil’s man!” (act three, page 119). This demonstrates how the fear of the mob and the overwhelming pressure from the Abigail makes her turn from the truth.
In history there have been many major events that have shaped the times we live in. Two of the major events of our time are the "witchunts" of the Salem Witch Trials and McCarthyism. The Crucible is a 1953 play by American playwright Arthur Miller. It is a drama and fictional story of the Salem Witch Trials that took place in the Massachusetts Bay Colony during 1692-1693. Miller wrote the play as a parable for McCarthyism, when the United States government ostracized people for being communists.
Under the pressure of the court Mary breaks and says while pointing at proctor “My name, he want my name. ‘I’ll murder you’ he says, ‘if my wife hangs! We must go and over throw the court,’ he says!” (194). She completely changes her stance and prosecutes Proctor because she is scared of being dissent and wants to conform to everyone else.