In this paper I am going to analyze Antigone’s argument for when and why one should break the law. There are so many words that you could use to describe Antigone in the book, The Burial at Thebes. She is a passionate, prideful, and outspoken woman in a time when women were not able to be, especially not to ruler of Thebes, Creon. You could make the argument that love is a good reason to break the law, but I believe that Antigone’s religious faith is what really makes her feel that it is okay to break the law. The book, The Burial At Thebes, written by Seamus Heaney, starts off with a bang. Antigone and her sister, Ismene, are outside talking about the situation at hand. Ismene breaks the news in the book when she states to Antigone that, “Our two brothers are dead” (6). The worst part about it was the rules and laws the Ruler of Thebes put in place. Two people had died, but only one was allowed to be buried by law. Antigone and Ismene’s brother, Polyneices, was denied a proper burial. Antigone states that, “Word has come down from Creon. There’s to be no lying to rest, no …show more content…
“Not for a husband, not even for a son would I have broken the law. Another husband I could always find and have other sons by him is one were lost. But with my father gone, and my mother gone, where can I find another brother, ever” (54)? She states here that she only would break the law for her brother because it’s her last one and that she needs to honor him and the family name. I feel that here she may slightly question what would happen to her in the afterlife, but she still will have to face the gods. In my opinion it is immoral of her to not care as much about her own son and husband. With someone as set in her ways as she is you think that she would be all for saving all of her family. She says that her penalty is up to the gods and that it really is not up to
Antigone: Writing Prompt In the Greek play Antigone,the character Antigone decided to disobey her uncle’s law about burying her brother Polyneices. The law said that no one was allowed to bury polynices and to leave him to rot. Polyneices was also declared as a traitor,while her other brother Eteocles had a soldier's burial with military honors.
Both Antigone and Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. can be viewed as rebels. Despite strict laws being enforced by their governing bodies, each chose to challenge authority in favor of their moral compasses. By objecting to the laws set in place, both Dr. Martin Luther King and Antigone fought for what they felt was truly right and just in each of their given situations. Although each character’s circumstances and actions seem to differ greatly, Dr. King would agree with Antigone’s choices to question authority in order to uphold mutual respect and honor for all individuals, as well as religious values, despite the laws set in place. Religious beliefs were Antigone’s driving force in opposing the law of Creon.
She thinks the burning of her house is to remind her she is getting a new house in heaven and it was God’s in the first place. She says “It was his own, it was not mine.” (Bradstreet) In Edwards’ Sermon he
I am so afraid for you." (Ismene, 88) "I will not ask you, or if I do, you will not come." (Antigone, 89) Antigone's decision to defy the king's decree and bury her brother represents an act of civil disobedience, which challenges the authority of the state and raises questions about the limits of state power. Antigone's actions also represent the tension between personal beliefs and state authority, as she believes that her moral duty to give her brother a proper burial overrides the king's decree.
Even though Antigone’s brother committed a crime, he should still be buried like any other family member that committed a crime. The first thing Creon’s does in Antigone is declare a hash but understandable law. Anyone who attempts to honor Polyneices will be sentenced
Antigone, a play by Sophocles, was written thousands of years before some of the world's greatest rebellions and acts of martyrdom, such as Mohammed in Tunisia in 2010, yet it still portrays the same human nature of defying laws of the land. The main character, Antigone, rebels against the king of Thebes by burying her brother, knowing the harsh punishment for doing so, therefore making her a martyr for her personal beliefs. The news of her death sentence brings outrage to the people of Thebes, including those close to King Creon. In Antigone, Sophocles develops the universal theme of martyrdom and rebellion that is demonstrated through Antigone because of how the characters defy laws and react to her rebellion, which mirrors Mohammed Bouazizi’s case in Tunisia 2,500 years later. There never was, and never will be, a time when every person agrees with the laws and restrictions of the land, and the cases of Antigone and Mohammed Bouazizi are quintessential examples.
A bloody civil war has erupted in Thebes. Each side is A recent attack by Polynices has left the city unconquered. Both Polynices and Eteocles have died, killed by each other. Outside the City gates, antigone tells Ismene that Creon has ordered Eteocles to be buried with full honors, while the body of Polynices is left to rot. Creon has said that any person who tries to bury Polynices will be stoned to death.
Antigone uses both logical and emotional appeals to persuade her sister Ismene that their brother Polyneices should be honored and have a proper burial. During an argument between Antigone and Ismene, Ismene believes that the law should be obeyed therefore she will not help Antigone. Antigone states, “Polyneices, who fought as bravely and died as miserably…no one shall bury him, no one mourn for him… his body must lie in the fields (Sophocles et al.190).” Antigone is trying to communicate to Ismene through the use of an emotional and logical appeal by explaining that he was, left to be decomposed by the birds. In the Greek culture, having a burial is a civic and religious duty which is necessary to proceed to the afterlife unaffected.
When selecting a leader for any hierarchical position, the commonwealth put their confidence in someone who will put their society’s best interest first. Sometimes these leaders take their power too far and begin enacting regulations that oppress certain individuals. The oppressed occasionally find ways to retaliate against this injustice. In regards to this concept of civil disobedience, transcendentalist Henry David Thoreau once said, “Unjust laws exist; shall we be content to obey them…or shall we transgress them at once?” Few people have elected to transgress these laws throughout the course of history.
Her violation of the law only was to satisfy her faith in God, and to maintain the moral that she thought God demanded of her, but not for anyone else’s
She is a forgiving human being and really understanding. By all means, she said these words to her recently committed adultery husband “I do not judge you. The magistrate sits in your heart that judges you. I never thought you but good man, John...”(pg.194). In my opinion, I really think that it takes a lot of courage and comprehension to actually consider forgiving someone when they broke their trust with you.
Or if I have, I shall know the truth in death” (778. 69-70). This shows she is believing in God’s law over mans because even in her last moments of life she is still believing that her burying her brother was the right thing to
When people defend what they believe in or who they love that is sacrifice. In order to be certain that her two brothers she loved had a proper burial and that their souls could rest, Antigone sacrificed her life. Regardless of the potential outcome; even if that means that she was going to have to challenge her uncle (King Creon), she plans on pursuing her quest. Polynices and Eteocles killed each other in battle for control over Thebes, leaving the city to the new King, Creon Jocasta’s brother and Antigone’s uncle. Because of the actions that Polynices took during the war, Creon labels him a traitor and halts any burial process, leaving his body for the animals (222-234).
Antigone believes she should have the right of her brother’s burial. Creon states, “No one shall burry him, no one mourn for him” (Sophocles 2) illustrating that Polyneicis is irrelevant in the city of Thebes. The law in Greek society is a female should not have power or freedom over any circumstance. Antigone demands rights over her brother and will not accept
In Antigone, there was two brothers who shared being the King and one of the brothers, Polynices, wanted to start a war with the kingdom because he wanted to be the main ruler. Polynices and his brother Eteocles fight and they both end up killing each other. Their Uncle Creon, who takes position as King when they are both killed, decides that only Eteocles will have a proper burial and Polynices will be left to rot. Antigone, Polynices and Eteocles sister, thinks that Creon’s decision is unfair and takes upon herself to give Polynices a proper burial. When their other sister Ismene finds out, she is stuck between helping her sister bury their brother and following Creon’s demands.