The Inoculation Theory
Inoculation Theory
The inoculation theory was proposed by McGuire in response to a situation where the goal is to persuade someone not to be persuaded by another. The theory is a model for building resistance to persuasion attempts by exposing people to arguments against their beliefs and giving them counter arguments to refute attacks. The theory therefore offers mechanisms by which communication is used to help people defend their beliefs.
Need for the Theory
In today’s world we are bombarded by information from all angles. There are a number of attempts being made on an everyday basis to persuade us in one direction or another. Therefore there is a need to know how such persuasion attempts can be fought. The theory offers up a way in which
…show more content…
In a normal vaccination, a weakened form of the virus is injected into an individual in order to build resistance to the disease. A similar procedure is used to ‘inoculate’ an individual from attacks on his belief. According to the theory, a weakened or smaller dose of a contrary argument called the inoculation message is given to the people. These individuals who have been exposed to the weaker argument develop a defense system that helps them to retain their beliefs and not change their attitudes when they are confronted with a stronger form of the argument.
Research has proved that the inoculation process is more successful that simply reinforcing original beliefs with stronger evidence.
Application of Inoculation Theory
The original theory of McGuire was expanded by communication scholar Michael Pfau and his colleagues to cover health communication, political communication and corporate advocacy. Their work shows that the inoculation theory has nearly unlimited applications.
Components of an Inoculation Message
According to Pfau, the following are the two major components in an inoculation
…show more content…
While preparing the inoculation message, the arguments that the other side will put forward should be anticipated and ways of countering them should be prepared.
For example, in the credit card experiment, mentioned above Compton and Pfau kept in mind the popular arguments that credit card companies used to lure students. They then came up with statistics and arguments that refuted claims like ‘increase financial security, build a strong credit history, etc.’ that credit card companies were making.
Examples of Inoculation Theory
Research has shown that the focus on promoting methods by which students can resist peer pressure to start smoking has resulted in a substantial reduction of smoking among students. Inoculation theory has also been used to bring down the cases of drunken driving.
The movie ‘The Da Vinci Code,’ was based off an extremely controversial novel of the same name. Before the release of the movie, the Catholic Church took steps to inoculate its followers by sending out inoculation messages that showed that the move was a threat to Catholic beliefs. They anticipated and successfully counter attacked the various arguments that were presented in the
Summary Of On Immunity: An Inoculation By Eula Biss
548 Words | 3 PagesThe word inoculate takes on several meanings, the most well-known being to introduce an antigen into the body to create immunity, but it also can be used to describe introducing something into the mind. On Immunity: An Inoculation by Eula Biss, is in a sense, just that, an inoculation. From pulling information from all different directions to educate and introduce the reader to many different attitudes concerning vaccines. Biss often relates her personal experiences with her son throughout the book, which shows how her primary opinion has developed while writing this novel. She also creates a diverse point of view by displaying the vulnerabilities and worries of a mother, as well as presenting the analytical and rational observations of a non-fiction writer.
Example Of Ethos Pathos Logos
1076 Words | 5 PagesIntroduction Persuasion is an art; and mastering this art requires the manipulation of the rhetorical triangles: ethos, pathos, and logos. “Ethos” deals with the credibility of the author; “pathos” refers to the emotional appeal of the text; and “logos” is the logics behind the argument; and these three fundamental appeals are the basis of persuasion. The rhetorical methods used in the two visuals, "How to Gain or Lose 30 minutes of Life Everyday" and "People Kill with Guns More Than Any Other Weapon," both by Mark Fischetti will be analyzed, compared and contrasted in reference to the broader contexts of each source. How to Gain or Lose 30 Minutes of Life Every Day The purpose of this visual is to show the effects of certain activities or habits can on life expectancy.
Rhetorical Analysis Of Hart And Daughton
520 Words | 3 PagesIn regards to Hart and Daughton, the role of analysis in rhetorical criticism plays an important role in a variety of ways. From persuasion, to structure and form, to syntax, each showcases a significant faction of analysis in rhetorical criticism. Persuasion, relates to several differential logic forms – human and informal, which tie together arguments considered thin, and those considered higher in class. In analyzing, persuasively, it is important that an individual does not immediately classify a reasoning put forth by a rhetor, to be not credible. This is due to the assumptions, or biases people bring with them in daily life; such as, the idea that people have reasons for doing what they do, and the idea that persuasion is generally credible.
Summary Of Blink By Malcolm Gladwell
995 Words | 4 PagesSome of the evidence stated includes the Coke/Pepsi experiment, the kouros incident, the marriage experiment, the President Harding story, the success of
Similarities Between Henry And Ben Franklin
583 Words | 3 PagesPersuasion or manipulation, one lets you select the choice yourself and the other attempts to make the choice for you. Persuasion is the action of cause someone to do something through reasoning or argument. Henry’s Speech in the Virginia Convention and Franklin's The Speech in the Convention both are prime examples of persuasion. There are numerous ways to persuade someone, whether it’s antithesis, restatement, repetition, or rhetorical questions; These are examples of rhetorical devices are exceptional tools for persuading an audience. Franklin uses antithesis as well as logic to persuade his audience to unanimously pass the constitution, while Henry uses parallel rhetorical questions and appealed to the audience's sense of logos and ethos to persuade his audience that we must go to war with Britain.
How Did The Allies Use Propaganda
1977 Words | 8 PagesIt can be said that it is the fastest and most effective way to persuade people into doing a certain action or
Ericsson's Use Of Ethos Pathos Logos
1385 Words | 6 PagesPersuasion: “The act of causing people to do or believe something: the act or activity of persuading people: a particular type of belief or way of thinking” (Merriam-Webster). This concept was used by Orman, Ericsson and Gladwell in each of their writings. Ericsson’s usage of the rhetorical triangle to achieve persuasion evolved through her use of pathos and logos. These two aspects allowed Ericsson to capture her point that everyone lies, and that those lies can take on different forms. When an author appeals to the audiences’ emotions and their imaginative sympathies, they are alluring to the appeal of pathos.
What Is Cognitive Dissonance Theory In Easy A
1145 Words | 5 PagesThis eventually leads her to challenge her self concepts to extreme levels, causing her to either liberate herself from the façade she created or sink into the role. Easy A describes many genuine psychological phenomena and I am going to focus on three of them; Cognitive dissonance theory, how societal and cultural norms dictate our attitudes and thoughts, and different ways of persuasion. The cognitive dissonance theory is the feeling of unease that is felt when we act in opposition to our attitudes, which causes a shift of attitude in order to be consistent with our behavior. Easy A depicts strongly the theory of cognitive dissonance on numerous occasions.
How Facts Backfire
1091 Words | 5 PagesThe author states that the one of the many flaws in a democracy is the fact that people have the right to vote without having knowledge on the subject. He understands that people make decisions based off their morals, not on the knowledge they have on a subject. Keohane adds that as a self-defense mechanism people, when they are faced with a mental conflict that occurs where their beliefs or assumptions are contradicted by new information; this is called cognitive dissonance. He goes on to explain the theory of motivated reasoning, which is where people have two facts presented to them where one fact contradicts their principals, and they end up choosing the fact that is closest to their ideals. According to Keohane people with higher self-esteem are more likely to acknowledge new information than people with insecurities.
Similarities Between The American Revolution And The 2016 Presidential Election
470 Words | 2 PagesPersuasion: The American Revolution and the 2016 Presidential Election Throughout history, persuasion is a tactic used by influential people in order to gain something. In both the American Revolution and the 2016 presidential election, persuasion was used to acquire a number of things: the trust of the people, their vote, their encouragement and overall, their faith. The ideas of democracy, freedom and liberty that political speakers alike employed in both of the aforementioned events helped persuade the American people. The American Revolution contained rhetoric in an abundance of its literature that features the radical ideas of democracy, freedom and liberty.
Anti Vaccination Suicide
192 Words | 1 PagesPartner Summary The article “Should Anti-Vaxers be shamed or Persuaded”, is about how Anti-vaccination protesters should not be bullied or shamed into agreeing with the opposing viewpoint. The author distinguishes the difference between, bullying them into submission, and persuading them to the right side. Though not a parent, the author believes that kids should be vaccinated except in rare cases.
Ethos Pathos Logos
1110 Words | 5 PagesBy using manipulation, the reader will be harmed as the information acquired through the crafty paper will distort previous knowledge and point of view and shape it to the writer’s advantage. Therefore, it can potentially change the reader’s future acceptance to other claims and opposition to already acquired knowledge. In addition, when or if the reader realizes the trickery, the feeling of being deceived can damage his trust about reading other related, and even unrelated, papers. However, by using persuasion, the reader will have a better understanding of the writer’s claims and is most likely to gain some new constructive knowledge from reading the text. Also, persuasion can potentially give the writer a stronger credibility and establish a regular audience attracted by the evidence, trustworthiness, and appeal of the writer and
The Iliad Rhetorical Analysis
697 Words | 3 PagesConvincing someone on believing that one persons’ opinion is more correct than someone else’s is a very large aspect of life now. Persuasion can become very useful when deciphering with other people in someone’s everyday
Elaboration Likelihood Model Of Persuasion Essay
817 Words | 4 PagesThe theory has split persuasion in two ways: the central route and the peripheral route. The central route implies a high content elaboration and persuasion that will most likely lead to a permanent change in attitude; thus, leading to decision-making.
Social Judgement Theory: The Art Of Persuasion
805 Words | 4 PagesThese days with social media, and other rising technological advances, one might find it impossible to resist the urge to want to protest and debate with all the issues going on in the world today. It sounds easy enough to post your side of an argument on anything someone shares but going about it affectively to really get the opposing side to agree with you is something else entirely. By using the Social Judgment Theory, and understanding one’s ego involvement with an issue, people might just be able to figure out the “Art of Persuasion”. Social Judgement Theory is a “Self-persuasion theory proposed by Carolyn Sherif, Muzafer Sherif, and Carl Hovland” (Daniel O’ Keefe, 2016). It is defined as “The perception and evaluation of an idea by comparing
More about The Inoculation Theory
Summary Of On Immunity: An Inoculation By Eula Biss
548 Words | 3 PagesExample Of Ethos Pathos Logos
1076 Words | 5 PagesRhetorical Analysis Of Hart And Daughton
520 Words | 3 PagesSummary Of Blink By Malcolm Gladwell
995 Words | 4 PagesSimilarities Between Henry And Ben Franklin
583 Words | 3 PagesHow Did The Allies Use Propaganda
1977 Words | 8 PagesEricsson's Use Of Ethos Pathos Logos
1385 Words | 6 PagesWhat Is Cognitive Dissonance Theory In Easy A
1145 Words | 5 PagesHow Facts Backfire
1091 Words | 5 PagesSimilarities Between The American Revolution And The 2016 Presidential Election
470 Words | 2 PagesAnti Vaccination Suicide
192 Words | 1 PagesEthos Pathos Logos
1110 Words | 5 PagesThe Iliad Rhetorical Analysis
697 Words | 3 PagesElaboration Likelihood Model Of Persuasion Essay
817 Words | 4 PagesSocial Judgement Theory: The Art Of Persuasion
805 Words | 4 Pages