Social influence can take different forms. Majority and minority influence research has studied how groups influence the attitudes and behaviours within society of individuals and groups while also promoting an ingroup and outgroup attitude that comes from Social Identity Theory (Tajfel & Turner, 1979). Majority influence is a normative influence where people ‘conform’ to the majority (Cialdini and Goldstein, 2004) attitudes, beliefs, and behaviours to group norms and it has the power to reward or punish. Minority influence occurs when an individual or small group reject the majority norm (Cook, 2011) and seek change by making the majority reconsider their views with new concepts and ideas, which is an example of informational influence. These …show more content…
He investigated the effects of minority influence on a majority with the blue/green experiment (Moscovici et al, 1969). The experiment placed four genuine participants with two confederates and they were all asked to identify different shades of blue while the confederates mistakenly identified the slides as being green. Moscovici found that the participants opinions were influenced by the confederates’ minority view. This is an example of normative social influence, when we conform because of the need for acceptance by others or to adhere to social norms. One criticism of Moscovici green/blue experiment were of a participant of the study facing a majority/minority and does not look at being part of a majority or minority and simulating the real challenges they face, especially the minority (Martin and Hewstone, 2008). Most of the research by Moscovici and others is based on experiments conducted in controlled conditions using incidental groups, participants of this group are brought together for a short time and have minimal commitment to each other or the group in general. Due to this the studies could not recreate the determination of minority groups who face greater opposition and have a greater commitment to their …show more content…
The commitment of a member also impacts the ability to affect change; a minority member is usually committed to their goal. The tasks that are involved are also important, the more a member acts towards this goal and the more motivated they are to continue which is known as social energizing. When a majority member acts, most try to conform to the minimum standard of the majority position. Being part of the majority and agreement with the majority position can translate into action (Allport, 1935). However, this is not always the case, there can be a gap between agreement and action. When this occurs the majority members may believe that this past behaviour is sufficient to ensure normative compliance to the majority group and then idle, especially if the tasks to conform are trivial. This is also known as social loafing (Karau and Williams, 1993). Williams, Cheung and Choi (2000) studied this commitment on how social exclusion had an impact on conformity, when participants were ignored in an online video game they were more likely to conform on a perceptual task. When people’s sense of belonging is threatened they have an increased motivation to belong to a group and are therefore more likely to conform to the majority over the minority.
Martin et al (2015) recently put forward the theory of expecting future interaction (EFI) in a group affects the minority influence. They found that minority members express more opposition to the group, which produces conflict, when
Conformity is essential to life. Humans live in a society that functions as a whole. If there is a mistake, the entire system may fail. So, we are obligated conform to social norms and laws to stay together as a whole. There’s several types of conformity; Normative conformity,which is to give into group pressure because a person wants to fit in with the
In chapter 6 I learned more on how social influence impacts our everyday relations. There are three levels of social influence and they are by conformity, compliance and obedience. The first section talks about conformity, and it is the lowest level because we voluntarily adapt our behavior to match others. Now there are two variations or reasons outlined by the book to conform to those around us and they are “normative social influence,” and “informational social influence”. The former is our response to feel a greater sense of belonging in the group while the second deals more with us trying to be right by sometimes going with what others say to be right too.
Conformity and Nonconformity in Society Many societies try their hardest to ensure the total conformity of their citizens, whether it be through incentives or by creating fear. However, it rarely succeeds, as there are always a few who don’t conform to the unspoken societal rules that have been set. When this happens, societies usually try to assimilate the nonconforming and place them into their fitting roles in society, with this being a main concept of Ken Kesey’s novel One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest.
Meadow Scanio p.8 In society everyone wants to fit in to belong, but the more people try to conform on the outside the more they will question society as a whole on the inside. Bradbury uses this idea in his book Fahrenheit 451 which creates the main conflict in the story, Montage’s struggle against conformity. Montage questions why he is burning books while he tries to fit into the thoughtless society and keep up the appearance that nothing has changed, allowing conflict to form in his life because of his fight to realize right and wrong. Bradbury uses montages job as a firefighter to show how he fits into society because firefighters make up the image for the world they live in.
As a result of the segregation from other races, Asian Americans have typically kept to themselves and are focused on becoming successful. In addition to the political absence of Asians extending beyond other races, the persistent model minority myth is an accepted truth within the community itself. While the stereotupe is a complete myth, it has been so embedded that even Asian Americans start to believe it, making them and other believe that Asians are the only minority that have endowed the key to success in America. Asians are not only placed in the shadows, but they also choose to stay; many are too comfortable with their successful personal lives, to the extent of neglecting the matters of other Asians ethnicities. Additionally, Asians are perceived to be traditionally passive, giving an almost filial piety towards white people in hopes of having the same privileges.
Even though there are numerous individual opportunities and benefits for not conforming to society, internal, subconscious desires compel individuals to forego their individualism and assimilate to
The term “model minority” was first used by sociologist William Petersen in a 1966 The New York Times article titled “Success story: Japanese American style”. The article focused on how Japanese culture allowed the immigrants to overcome discrimination and succeed in American
Many evidence support the view that there are biases in the criminal justice system against members of minority groups. One of the issues with discriminatory practices is that legal apparatus for antidiscrimination law is based on intentional discrimination. Many issues of overrepresentation of minority group individuals at all levels of the justice system have profound effects not only for those who are accused and convicted but also for the victims of crime. Victims from racialized communities, knowing that members of their community are unfairly treated under the law, may feel both personal pressure and community pressure to not report crimes committed against them or testify in court. Slavery, and the concomitant violence committed against
How did Orlando 's mock psychiatric study support Zimbardos findings. Conformity: Yielding to group pressure The influence a group has over an individual Reffered to a majority influence Compliance is a form of social influence Following the majority even if views arnt shared to fit in Conformity is a unambiguous task Informational social influence Identification in conformity Comformity to assigned roles Individuals alternate their general behaviour and opinions both privately and publicly. Being a member of a group is highly desirable.
One of the most significant advantages of conformity is that it can promote social unity within a group or community. When individuals conform to social norms and shared values, they are more likely to feel a sense of belonging to others in their group. This, in turn, can lead to greater cooperation and collaboration, which can be crucial for achieving common goals and addressing shared challenges. For example, in a workplace setting, conformity to a set of shared values and norms can help to build a sense of team spirit and foster a positive work culture. Similarly, conformity to a set of social norms can promote a sense of unity and shared identity among members of a particular culture or society.
Whilst conflict is inevitable Harding provides insight in describing conflict “as the beginning of consciousness”. Realistic group conflict theory (RGCT) offers a behavioural approach to conflict resolution demonstrated in Sheriff Robert Cave’s experiment. RGCT asserts that a real or imagined threat to one’s group interest often leads to conflict. Initially the situation presented with a competitive edge as the groups clamoured for the scarce resource .
We have a driving need to be a part of the group and to belong. Even if the group is wrong, we will conform to
It results in people conforming to decisions they would not normally make. These people generally set aside their own beliefs and conform to the rest of the group. Real life examples of this could be the fact that many people, especially in school, follow the opinions and actions of those who are considered to be “popular”. In conclusion, Asch’s experiments prove that people are extremely determined to fit in instead of stand out, at least when it comes to social situations.
Social influence theory refers to the change in behavior caused due the influence from one person to another. This change may happen intentionally or unintentionally depending on the relationship of the person with his surrounding people and the society as a whole. Social influence has three areas which are conformity, compliance and obedience. Conformity is where the change of behavior, values, and beliefs happens to fulfill the belonging and esteem needs and the approval of certain groups.