Is pain necessary in order to feel pleasure? Does feeling pain mean you understand the world? Even though these are different questions, they are connected; we see in The Giver and in Fahrenheit 451 that pain is necessary to experience true pleasure and to then truly understand the world. We can see this through the characters in The Giver only having shallow feelings of happiness and a limited understanding of the world when they have not experienced pain, Jonas recognizing how he can experience much more pleasure and understand the world because of pain, and in Fahrenheit 451, we see examples of how ridding one’s life of pain and complexity only leads to a dull, emotionless life.
In The Giver, we see how characters in the book seem to have
…show more content…
To elaborate on this, Jonas, after receiving a meaningful and foreign memory of love, asks his parents if they love him. They respond with amusement and say that love is a generalized and meaningless word; Jonas, because he now understands the world differently through memories, feels confused and hurt after this. The community in The Giver has retired the use of the word love because they are afraid of it - love comes with feelings of happiness, individuality, and more, though it also inevitably comes with pain along the way. Since the community in The Giver avoids emotions with depth, they have retired the use of them. Thus, they will never experience true, meaningful feelings of love, happiness, and pleasure, and will never understand the complexity of the world that comes with …show more content…
In Farenheit’s society, people are not content, but they do not seem to know why. People commit suicide, and people are bored, but they mostly seem oblivious to the causes of the problems in their surroundings. They experience what they think is pleasure by burning books and keeping their society protected from conflicts. In Fahrenheit 451, Granger concludes that a life without risks, pain, or books is not one worth living. He came to this conclusion because he, like Montag, lived in a society where books were forbidden and no risks were taken. He is able to explain how ridding one’s life of pain and complexity leads to a dull, emotionless life, as seen through the quote: "‘Stuff your eyes with wonder,’ he said, ‘live as if you’d drop dead in ten seconds. See the world. It’s more fantastic than any dream made or paid for in factories. Ask no guarantees, ask for no security, there never was such an animal. And if there were, it would be related to the great sloth which hangs upside down in a tree all day every day, sleeping its life away. To hell with that,’ he said, ‘shake the tree and knock the great sloth down on his ass.'" Fahrenheit 451, page
In Ray Bradbury Fahrenheit 451 the author is trying to tell how important it is to have knowledge in a society where people are oppressive. In F451 books are banned in society and if you try to access that knowledge, your books will be burnt, and your house will be burned down by the fire fighters that burn down books and building of the owners who hold the books. On page 4 Montag the main character of F451 burns a house down along with books but realizes the old lady is still in the house holding the books Montag feels uncomfortable and starts to question society “there must be something in the books, things we can’t imagine, to make a women stay in a burning house; there must be something here”. This proves that something Is not right within society right now banning books which contains knowledge from people who have experienced life is not a good thing. Oppression is something we see everywhere but in Fahrenheit free though Is essentially prohibited, and activities are tightly organized, this is controlling which is a form of oppression controlling what people can do tightly and organized on page 11 Mildred attempts suicide by
‘’It was a pleasure to burn.’’ A figure who breaks with the standards of their society in Fahrenheit 451 is the old lady. She breaks the rules in attempting to protect her books and will burn with the books. One moment that The Old Lady breaks with the norms of the society she lives in is when The Old Lady refuses to leave her house when Montag and the firefighters try to tell her to get out of the house because of the 451 tanks
One difference between Montag’s society and our society is the way people handle their emotions. For example, in Fahrenheit 451, Mrs. Phelps started crying after Montag read a poem but, she didn’t know why she was crying. “Clara, what’s wrong? ‘I–I,’ sobbed Mrs. Phelps, ‘don't know, don’t know, I just don't know,
In the society of Fahrenheit 451 people do not read books, enjoy nature, think independently or have meaningful conversations. Instead, they drive fast and watch excessive amounts of television on wall-size screens. The main problem is the lack of words and therefore lack of individuality. Books and literature play an important role in the novel, from society’s deprivation of access to books to Montag’s development from passive individual to intellectual thinker. Captain Beatty, being in charge of the firefighter department is quite aware of the effect books can have on people.
As Montag leaves the city and his old life behind, drifting in a river, a sudden peacefulness rushes over him; he feels "as if he had left a stage behind and many actors. He felt as if he had left the great séance and all the murmuring ghosts" (RB 133). The people in Fahrenheit 451 have always been present but not there, alive but not truly engaged; they live careless lives, raising careless kids doing careless things and wasting their lives watching TV. In this quote, people's true colors shine through; they go out in cars driving at mad speed and kill people and animals without a second thought; they ignore death, avoid deep questions, overdose and die on pills; they divorce and abort children like its nothing, they are genuinely empty inside. They have been conditioned that nothing matters as long as they remain happy, but no human can go out and ignore death or feelings and stay happy.
In Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit 451, Montag's society views books as a sign of peril and doom. Books can inspire rebellious ideas that could jeopardize the stability of society, according to the government, which has converted its citizens that they must be destroyed. People are encouraged to spend their time and energy on careless entertainment and pleasures like watching television, playing sports, or eating fast food in this society. Montag lives in a society that places a high value on conformity and compliance to authority. As a result of furnishing access to knowledge that can undermine governmental authority and power, it reinforces the notion that books are dangerous.
Throughout the book, we see how gaining knowledge is important for the growth of society. In a society where we are constantly starring at a screen, have our airpods in, or sitting in our rooms, we are isolated from the real world. Fahrenheit 451 is a book following the life of Montag,
In Fahrenheit 451 distraction and ignorance are hallmarks of the culture in which Montag lives. Montag’s culture encourages conformity and everyone acting in the same mindless ways. Self-expression is frowned deeply upon, and anyone who thinks for themselves is thought of as “weird” and “odd.” Mindless entertainment and thoughtless lifestyles are considered normal, and anyone who dares to think for themselves or question the status quo is deemed a threat to society, as they may cause others to face the difficult questions their society is protecting them from. Montag’s society is organized to snuff out personal thought and opinion, exactly the things Montag searches for to find answers to the very questions his society condemns.
Both our society, and Fahrenheit 451 lack natural surroundings and the ability to listen and think. (SIP-A) The society in Fahrenheit 451 is disconnected with nature and they never get the chance to think or to comprehend their thoughts in the silence of nature. (STEWE-1) Being in nature is so important because it gives you time to think with yourself, you are able to listen and respond without any distractions.
The society in Fahrenheit 451, unlike the one we live in, is very controlling and have many rules most would deem dehumanizing. In the novel Fahrenheit 451, by Ray Bradbury, the protagonist Guy Montag seems to be in a perfect world but as you keep reading you learn that nothing is more far from the truth. In the society, owning books could get you killed. Also, speeding is not only ok, it is highly encouraged and you could get yourself in trouble if you don’t! It seems everyone is living as if they are a vessel lacking a soul and mind.
He didn’t know love or any deep concern of anything. As the book went on Jonas felt love. He felt it for Gabriel, the Giver, Fiona. Before Jonas felt love Jonas thought it was a meaningless and useless word. Like the rest of the community.
Would you give up love and true happiness for a life without pain? In the dystopian novel The Giver, written by Lois Lowry, strong emotion is sacrificed for a peaceful environment. The depicted community at first appears to be a utopia, where hate and discrimination are abolished, but the emotionless society is quickly revealed to be dystopian as the story continues. They live in a world of sameness; there is no hunger, suffering, or war, but also no color, diversity, or sensuality. The protagonist, a twelve-year-old boy named Jonas, uncovers the truth about his community when he is assigned to be the Receiver of Memory, and acquires the memories from the past from an elder called the Giver.
Jonas felt anger for his father and the pain he feels for the baby twin. On page 168 in the giver,Jonas realized that they been playing a game of war ( Lowry). Jonas feel sad and misunderstood for the boy in war. Jonas sadly understood that no one know what he is feeling. These are like real life because some careless people don 't think about others and think that everything is just a joke.
The Giver then told Jonas he would be glad to share that memory with him. He transmits the memory of a christmas morning, grandparents and love. Jonas liked the memory and wanted to be able to feel it all the time. When Jonas got home he asked his parents if they loved him, They were a little fluster about the word love and told him to pay attention to his precision of language. His father told Jonas that the word love is absolutely meaningless.
Imagine a world without love. Jonas, the protagonist, in The Giver in in such world until had to until he ran away. Comparing Jonas’s society to ours reveals that society his society is a dystopia. While Jonas’s society has no emotional connection, no individuality, and has sameness, our society (on the other hand) has love, singularity, and .