Representation matters- as Jim Morrison said, ‘Whoever controls the media, controls the mind.’ In ‘Bowling for Columbine’, representation is important as there are many stereotypes surrounding gun violence which attribute to the way it is handled in real life. Throughout the film we see how pre-existing prejudice clouds our judgment and contributes to mistreatment of different groups of people, a fact which Moore explores throughout ‘Bowling for Columbine’ to push his anti-government beliefs specifically surrounding gun violence.
Point #1: Bowling for Columbines’s representation of the idiotic and violent white male American.
The idea that white males are idiotic and violent is an idea not limited to America. Being what is historically considered
…show more content…
Experiencing prejudice makes these minorities more socially aware and considerate, prejudice being something white men are not on the recieving end of. ‘Bowling for Columbine’ interviews many men that fit this description, with all those supporting gun freedom for America being white men or at least white. One of the first scenes interviews James Nichols, brother of Terry Nichols or the Oklahoma City bomber, who tells Moore that he has a ‘.44 magnum under [his] pillow’ and then proceeds to cock it and put it to his own temple. This is clearly an idiotic thing to do, and the lack of hesitation he has hints at a penchant for violence. Moore uses footage of Charlton Heston to further create this link of violence and white men- five term president of the National Rifle Association in America, an organisation founded in 1871 to promote rifle shooting and oppose gun laws. In the week following the …show more content…
Windsor Police are quick to report to Moore that the only shooting they can recall occuring in Windsor was carried out by a man from Detroit, with several citizens confirming they cannot recall any Canadian perpetrators within the last few years. Moore then goes on to New York city and interviews locals about their thoughts on Canadians and gun violence- many reported factually incorrect statements such as ‘Canadian’s dont watch as many violent movies’, suggesting that these are the reasons the rate of gun violence is lower in Canada. Moore cuts back to Canada, showing us several young boys waiting for a horror movie showing. These statements from American citizens prove that while gun violence rates are lower in Canada, American’s are reluctant to admit that it’s because of stricter gun laws, instead making excuses for themselves such as saying the poverty rate is higher in the United States- again, inherently incorrect as unemployment rates in Canada were up 1.76% in comparison to America as of 2002. ‘Bowling for Columbine’ suggests that the lower rate of gun violence is due to their left-wing government that allows for better health care, school systems and elderly care. Mayor of Sarnia Mike Bradley acknowledges this fact about the right-wing American government saying ‘they pick on the people that can’t support themselves and at the same time they’re turning around and giving
Tim Wise’s article contains a lot of emotion and it is though the clever tactic of appealing to Logos and Pathos that Wise makes the reader really consider what he is speaking about. There is even an ethos aspect to his argument. Since Wise is a white man shaming his own race, this removes bias which in turn gives him credibility. Now to examine the Logos aspect of his argument. By using the statistic “in past two years, thirty-two young men have either carried out a mass school shooting or attempted to do so, and of these thirty-two, thirty were white teens,” Wise is using the logos aspect of a claim to really make the reader consider the gravity of the situation and take into consideration his appeal to begin profiling these kids (69).
For example, white males are considered mentally ill when they are accused of mass shootings, while people of color are considered as thugs or terrorists, the news media reinforces the narrative that the lone wolf is an aberration. (Butler 1). Adding on, Butler argues that mass shootings are not racial issue; the issue is what the shooters skin color have to do with the mass shootings. Contradicting from Butler’s
Whites walking down Main Street with an AK-47 are defenders of American values; a black man doing the same thing is Public Enemy No.
In his essay, “A Pedagogical Response to The Aurora Shootings” (235) Henry Jenkins analyzes shocking events involving public shootings in society. His main objective is to discuss why violence is a prominent factor in our popular culture and how the media inflames the issue. Jenkins does pose his belief that violence should be critically debated in order to research the main cause of violence within people. He also states that people must step out of the “media effects” assumption of violence and expands the scale to the meaning of what violence represents in movies and books. Jenkin states, “To be extra clear, I do not think media is where this debate should be focused” (236).
Dave Cullen’s journalistic portrayal of the infamous school shooting in Columbine reveals the raw truth of Dylan Klebold and Eric Harris’ murder spree while uncovering misconception surrounding it. Cullen dives deep into the heart of motive and recovery, offering a newfound understanding of both the victims and the killers. The tragedy at Columbine was planned as a series of explosions that would have killed nearly 2,000 students. The bombs failed, however, so the shooters abandoned their plan and went on a spree through the school instead, using semiautomatic weapons they acquired at a gun show, where background checks can be bypassed.
People say it is not the guns; it is the people-, tremendously true, but guns do actually play a factor, they are the tool people use in the mass shootings, the United States has the highest gun owner rate and the highest mass shooting rate; the article written by Emma Gonzalez, “Famous Speeches: “We Call BS,” Emma Gonzalez Speech To Gun Activists”, and another article written by Bloomberg, “Issue Overload: Guns in America”. These two articles differentiate in multiple contrasting ways but are also similar in many different ways, the way the articles perspectives are written and the goals of the articles. The article by Emma Gonzalez and the passage written by Bloomberg compare to each other in numerous ways. The two articles similarities
Coates suggests the idea that white Americans depict African Americans to be evil and aggressive. “Why were our only heroes nonviolent? I speak not of the morality of nonviolence, but of the sense that blacks are in especial need of this nonviolence” (Coates). During the Civil RIghts Movement a time of great violence, it was preached to Black protesters to be non-violent. This suggests that the only way for violent white people to take Black Americans seriously is if they do not fight back.
According to the author “when white man feels disempowered, they are primed to resort to gun violence to reassert their sense of authority” meaning that the increase in mass shootings over the last few years are a respond to the expansion of women and minorities rights .In the article Wuertenberg implements the use of pathos by bringing in mass shootings from the past years in order to create awareness of the fact that “mass shooters have routinely expressed white-supremacist views or motivations.” He goes back to the first mass shooting and explains how the victims of those were chosen in a racist matter. Evoking emotions like courage, anger, disgust among on his readers. He also creates a trustful environment since he is going against his own race to face the truth that have been hidden for many years.
Jordan Grant McCrady, 1 English 102 16 January, 2023 A Columbine Martyr April 20, 1999, was a day of absolute terror and devastation, as two troubled teenagers set out, after months of planning and preparation, to terrorize their high school just weeks before graduation. The Columbine shooting has gone down in history as the most deadly school shooting in American history with a total of fifteen killed (including twelve students, a beloved teacher, and the two perpetrators), twenty-four injured, and hundreds traumatized beyond repair. Years of investigating and speculating have caused mass confusion and hysteria regarding the incident. Countless conspiracy theories have been adopted, media outlets worldwide have picked up the story, and
The Breakfast Club challenges these stereotypes by showing that each character is more complex than their stereotype suggests. For example, Claire is shown to be intelligent and caring, Andrew is shown to be vulnerable and sensitive, and Allison is shown to be creative and thoughtful. The film also shows that stereotypes can be harmful and limit people's potential. For instance, Andrew's desire to be a wrestler is overshadowed by his father's expectations, while Brian's academic success comes at the cost of his social life.
Minorities feel the pain, the joy and the sorrow as a citizen yet they are not seen the same as their White counterparts. Their reputations are not as glorified. African Americans are scary, Asian Americans eat dogs, Arab Americans are terrorist while White Americans are humans who make mistakes. People of color are seen as villains beyond the screen and with America being a global power the image is being absorbed all over the world. But when it comes to White Americans, they are these beautiful people who, no matter the situation, have a logical reason for every action they make.
The documentary explains why America is prone to gun related deaths, and attempts to persuade the viewer to believe that journalistic media is to blame. "Seeking to explain the fear and paranoia that lead American to arm themselves, Moore casts a wide net, but he avoids some easy targets. Moore dismissed the notion that violent video games play a major role, nothing the popularity of such games in such nations as
Canada is talked amongst other countries throughout the world as a safe, secure place to live. Majority of people do not know the heinous crimes that take place in Canada daily, especially whilst using a gun. Canada does not come close to the United States when comparing mass shootings, death by a gun, or homicides using a gun; although, the gun crimes in Canada are not improving. While Canada has more stringent gun laws than the united states, gun control in Canada should still be improved for citizen’s safety. Canada is often praised for having more efficient gun laws than the United States, but most people do not know that Canadian laws too, have much room for improvement.
Lulu Asselstine Mrs. Olsen LA 8 5 November, 2017 Stereotypes and Perspectives When looking at a bunch of bananas in a grocery store, people tend to choose the perfect spotless bananas, since stereotypically food that is perfect looking, with no flaws, taste better. However, people soon realize that when you start to eat bananas that have more spots and are imperfect they turn out to be sweeter and better. This connects to stereotypes because people who follow stereotyped will always eat the perfect bananas; however, people who choose to look through another perspective can realize that the imperfect bananas are better. This connects to The Outsiders because Ponyboy realizes this after he talks with two Socs, kids from a rival group named Randy and Cherry. In The Outsiders, S.E Hinton presents the idea that teenagers can break through stereotypes if they look at life through another perspective; as shown in the book when Ponyboy starts to talk to Cherry and Randy and realizes the stereotypes about them are false.
Thesis 1: Charlton Heston is directly responsible for the large amount of gun ownership in America and is thus responsible for the large amount of gun related violence in America. If he stopped his rallying then gun violence would drop. Response: I disagree with this statement because Charlton Heston only promotes legal ownership of guns, and he does not support any form of violence and only encourages guns be used for self defence.