Race Hudson
English 11A
DPS Synthesis Paper
31 January 2023
Transcendentalism In The Dead Poets Society And Civil Disobedience
“You must trust that your beliefs are unique, your own, even though others may think them good or unpopular” (Dead Poets Society). Transcendentalism is an intellectual movement that emphasized the dignity of the individual and advocates a simple mindful life. A paper written by Henry David Thoreau called “Civil Disobedience” talks about how your thoughts and ideas are stronger than a higher power’s beliefs and that you should follow your thought and ideas instead of following the herd. We, as a society, are still talking about this later on since it is an important belief everyone should consider in their lives since
…show more content…
For example, when Mr. Keating pushed Todd to think freely and for himself. The scene took place during the school year in Mr. Keating’s English class. Todd at the time was shy and stayed away from participation, so Mr. Keating wanted him to read his poem out loud, but Todd didn’t do it. Mr. Keating then made Todd “`yawp” and describe Uncle Walt, a picture on the wall just saying and not thinking. Todd then went on to tell a great poem through Mr. Keating helping Todd find his inner voice, the class cheered, and Mr. Keating told Todd, “Don’t you forget this”. This demonstrates finding truth on your own because Mr. Keating pushed for Todd to think freely and to find his truth through poetry as he described Uncle Walt the way he saw it, not how others saw it, and discovered his truths that way. Another example of this is when Mr. Keating had his English class rip out the introduction to how to appreciate poetry. This happened on the 1st day of school in Mr. Keating’s classroom when he had Niel read the introductory. Once he was done, Mr. Keating had everyone rip it out, and after some hesitation, everyone did what was told. Mr. Keating wanted everyone to do this so his students could learn to think freely again. This demonstrates finding truth on your own since Mr. Keating didn’t want some guy telling his whole class how to appreciate poetry, he wanted them to learn that for themselves. He wants his students to have their own opinions instead of just living under one opinion forever without thinking about it. One final example is when Mr. Keating had his class go to the courtyard to have his students “find their walk”. This happened during the school day when as a class, they all marched to the courtyard. There, Mr. Keating explains that they were there to learn about conformity, not listening to others' beliefs and
A Soon to Be Transcendentalist What is a transcendentalist? How is Chris “Alexander” McCandless a “true” transcendentalist? A transcendentalist is someone who believes in a philosophy that consists of being a non-conformist, being one with nature, and rejecting materialism. Throughout Krakauer’s novel, Into the Wild, it just occurs that McCandless achieves all of the above.
Nature Is Real Life Society could stress us with fake desires but, “In the woods, we return to reason and faith.” (Emerson 243) In the book, Into the Wild, John Krakauer documents Chris McCandless, fighting to find truth in the nature away from society. Ralph Waldo Emerson's views of finding truth in nature include leaving society, noticing life around yourself, and understanding that nature is filled with truth. Chris McCandless is driven by the transcendentalist ideal of finding self-truth in nature.
Henry David Thoreau, Jon Krakauer, and Chris McCandless embrace Transcendentalism. Mainly Chris’ and Thoreau’s belief about it. Both try to find themselves and the adventure of nature. In Into the Wild, Krakauer has the same beliefs as Chris McCandless and Henry David Thoreau want to find themselves, especially in nature. The first comment of transcendental beliefs is Chris McCandless was finding himself.
For example, when he left Doodle to fend for himself the narrator felt a “streak of cruelty” within himself. This reveals that the narrator was disappointed of failing. The narrator leaves Doodle in the storm as a way to encourage him to run faster. In addition, when the narrator returns and finds Doodle dead he calls him his “fallen scarlet ibis”. This shows that he regrets to leave Doodle alone to fend for himself.
In the short story, “The Scarlet Ibis,” James Hurst, through the characterization of the narrator, demonstrates that it is crucial to meticulously think before performing actions that may negatively scar someone for the rest of their life. After the narrator taught Doodle how to walk and when they were going to demonstrate the great feat they had accomplished, the narrator felt a moment of realization and “...began to cry... They did not know that I did it for myself; that pride, whose slave I was spoke to me louder than all their voices, and that Doodle walked only because I was ashamed of having a crippled brother” (9). Ironically, the narrator reflects on his actions after he performs them rather than doing it before. He not only does this
An example from this part of the story is “But Doodle couldn't keep up with the plan. Once, he collapsed on the ground and began to cry. " Aw, come on, Doodle. You can do it. Do you want to be different from everybody else when you start school?"
There are many common themes that run through transcendentalism literature. In the book Into the Wild, written by Jon Krakauer, Chris McCandless goes on a journey any transcendentalist author would be proud of. The theme threaded throughout the book is that of following an individual's heart to make decisions. McCandless lived his life in an unusual way that veered away from society norms, and surprised most of the people he encountered. One such person was Gallien, “This [the Stampede Trail], Alex announced to Gallien, was where he intended to go.
Chris McCandless, Jon Krakauer, and Henry David Thoreau are some adventurous people that had Transcendentalism throughout their lives. In Krakauer’s book Into the Wild the reader can see that Chris McCandless relates to Henry David Thoreau’s excerpts from Walden by showing Transcendental beliefs. Both of the mean show that they are simple, seek individualism, and love the flow of nature. The way Chris McCandless attempts to live his life in Krakauer’s book Into the Wild is just like the way Henry David Thoreau describes a true Transcendentalist. One of the first transcendental beliefs that Chris McCandless seeks is a simple life.
Chris McCandless was a young and adventurous man, and at age twenty two, he set out to travel on his own in the American wilderness with only a ten pound bag of rice, a plant guide, a rifle with ammunition, and a camera. There’s much debate about this boy and his character, but a frequently asked question is whether he really embodied transcendentalism or if he was just a priveleged boy on an unprepared and reckless mission. Throughout Into the Wild, a nonfiction book by Jon Krakauer, his actions and reasoning are revealed through his adventures and thoughts. By the time Krakauer's journalistic exploration is over, McCandless is proven to just be a man who follows many transcendentalist influences. Chris McCandless grew up disagreeing with
Into the Wild x Transcendentalism While growing up, many young adults realize that they do not agree with what their family’s lifestyle represents and decide that they want to go off on their own and live differently. Similar to this, the main character in the movie Into the Wild, Chris disagrees with most of the things his parents stand for and how they live. Chris McCandless gets in his car after his college graduation and leaves a society that he dislikes to rely on his instincts while traveling the country all the way to Alaska, meanwhile he continuously objects people obsessing and focusing on materialistic things, showing that he embodies transcendentalism. After disappearing, Chris decides that he wants to go to Alaska and live off
In 2006 famous zookeeper and environmentalist Robert Steve Irwin died of a stingray sting while doing what he loved; being with nature. While many mourned his death, he was immortalized for his deep appreciation of nature and his connection with animals. The 2007 film Into the Wild, directed by Sean Penn, details the real life experiences and death of Chris Mccandless and his journey to Alaska. Chris, inspired by the transcendentalist movement, wanted to live and survive with nature alone and so, he did until his untimely death at the hand of food poisoning and starvation. Although many argue that Chris was rash and impulsive, ultimately, Chris Mccandless is a transcendentalist because he lived independently, learned and observed nature, and
Kevin Sun Mrs. Cohen English 2CP --D February 22, 2018 Another Perspective The film Into the Wild is based on the life of Chris McCandless, a young man who rejected the consumerist society of America in order to live a more simple life. Through his travels, Chris carried essays by Transcendentalist philosophers Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau, suggesting that McCandless is impacted by Transcendentalist ideals. Two key tenets of Transcendentalism that clearly influenced McCandless’ choices are the value of simplicity and the importance of self-reliance.
Was Chris McCandless a true transcendentalist? Transcendentalism is a system developed by Immanuel Kant, based on the idea that, in order to understand the nature of reality, one must first examine and analyze the reasoning process that governs the nature of experience. Influenced by romanticism, Platonism, and Kantian philosophy, it taught that divinity pervades all nature and humanity, and its members held progressive views on feminism and communal living. Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau were central figures. In Jon Krakauer’s novel, Into the Wild, McCandless is viewed as a transcendentalist.
Dead Poets Society Transcendentalism is about life in which nature and the soul connect. In the movie Dead Poet Society, one of the characters who shows transcendentalism in Neil Perry. In the movie the students quoted poems and had their alone time with nature. They also relied on themselves and sought the spiritual side of things.
“I went into the woods because i wanted to live deliberately. I wanted to live deep and suck out all the marrow of life.” This meant that you live how you want to live and do whatever you want to be free from conformity in your life. This quote by Henry David Thoreau is what the Dead Poets Society and its members lived by everyday. The transcendentalist members always acted differently and disobeyed many so that they could follow in the footsteps of the original Dead Poets Society.