Clarisse’s Question
“Are you happy?” This is the question that forces Guy Montag, the protagonist of the dystopian novel Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury, to deeply question his society’s fulfillment with life. In Montag’s society, people consider a happy life as one that is simple and free from individuality and personality. Montag’s wife, Mildred, represents the majority of society in the way that she spends her days mindlessly consuming media through her television walls and seashells. Throughout the novel, Bradbury uses character realizations, drug usage, and artificial relationships to paint the society in Fahrenheit 451 as overly unhappy.
Bradbury uses Mildred’s overdose of sleeping pills as an example of how careless and unphased their
…show more content…
One night, after their conversation, Clarisse asks Montag, “‘Are you happy?’”. Montag says to himself, “Happy! Of all the nonsense… Of course I’m happy. What does she think? I’m not?” (8) Montag is shocked by Clarisse’s question and views it as an absurd thing to ask. He is confused as to why she would ask that because the idea of questioning one’s happiness was something very odd and suspicious to him. People in Montag’s society rarely talk about their emotions with one another, and always perceive themselves and others as happy. They are too distracted with their television and seashells that they fail to realize their unhappiness. After the two part ways, Montag laughs about the question for a while, before he stops and begins to deeply reflect on himself.
“He felt his smile slide away… Darkness. He was not happy. He was not happy. He said the words to himself. He recognized this as a true state of affairs. He wore his happiness like a mask and the girl had run off across the lawn with the mask and there was no way of going back to knock on her door and ask for it back.”
…show more content…
She covers up the void she feels from her missing relationships by further immersing herself in her artificial life. Mildred asks Montag to buy her another television wall: “‘How long before we save up and get the fourth wall torn out and a fourth wall-TV put in?’ ‘That's one-third of my yearly pay’ ‘If we had a fourth wall, why it'd be just like this room wasn't ours at all, but all kinds of exotic people's rooms. We could do without a few things.’” (18) Mildred is so addicted to virtual reality that she is willing to give up her relationship with her husband for it. Instead of expanding her relationship with her husband, she begs Montag to spend his money on another television wall so that she can feel more connected to her artificial family. Mildred wants to immerse herself in her television because she can achieve instant satisfaction from it without putting forth any effort. Improving her relationship with Montag would require hard work and for her to deal with complicated emotions, which is something that Mildred is not willing to do. Mildred may think that she is satisfied, but her lack of a meaningful relationship causes her to feel unhappy, which she covers up by immersing herself even more in the artificial stimulus. Not only is she unconcerned about her relationship with her husband, but she is also unphased when her
When Montag meets Clarisse he thinks that he is happy with the perfect job and wife, but then she asks him “Are you happy” (7). At first, he thought that she was crazy for asking him such a question. He couldn’t stop thinking about it and realized that he wasn’t happy. he wanted to know what would make him happy. He started collecting books even though he knew that it was wrong and against the law.
When Clarisse asked Montag this question she walked away to actually make him think if he was truly happy, not just answer the question like a machine. Moments after Clarisse he actually realizes that he isn’t happy. “He felt his smile slide away, melt, fold over and down on itself like a tallow skin, like the stuff of a fantastic candle burning too long and now collapsing and now blown out. Darkness. He was not happy.
She spends time thinking, exploring, and engaging in conversation. These actions make her an outcast. The first hint of Montag’s doubts about his society emerge when Clarisse asks Montag, “Are you happy?” (Bradbury 7). Montag is taken aback by this question, as it is something he has never contemplated previously.
Montag continues to do this without thought until he meets Clarisse who asks him, “Are you happy?” At first Montag thinks about this, but then agrees that his thoughts of not being happy are crazy. The second group is supreme ordeal. Later in the
and Clarisse’s relationship grows, Clarisse starts to question Montag’s whole life, starting with his relationship with his wife to his occupation. This affects Montag as despite the questions generally being simple-minded, he begins to dig deeper into his responses and how he truly feels. Montag responds, “Happy! Of all the nonsense. He stopped laughing,” when Clarisse asks him if he is happy, a simple question which he never truly thought about (Pg.8).
Clarisse asks him, “Are you happy?” (7). Montag initially dismisses this silly question because, of course, he is happy. Why would he not be? He watches television and burns.
In order to make Montag realize that he does not actually know anything about himself, Clarisse asks him if he is happy. For instance, “she seemed to remember something and came back to look at him with wonder and curiosity. " Are you happy?" she said.”
He was not happy. He said the words to himself. He wore his happiness like a mask and there was no way of going to knock on her door and ask for it back" (Bradbury 9). Here, Montag realizes the fictitious illusion of happiness that society has put him under, thanks to Clarisse’s inquisitions.(STEWE-2) When Montag meets with Clarisse again, he continues to wonder about his previous thoughts and his beliefs.
Mildred cares more for the price for the TV than she cares for Montag. “‘It’s really fun. It be even more fun when we can afford to have a fourth wall installed. How long you figure before we save up and get the fourth wall torn out and a fourth wall- TV put in/ It is only two thousand-dollars.’ ‘It’s one-third of my yearly pay’” (18).
Clarisse looks through Montag as if he was a clear window and simply tells him that he's not happy. Montag denies the fact that he isn't happy, until he thought deeper and longer about his happiness. ¨He felt his smile slide away, melt,
He refuses to question the dystopian societal rules and values and does the same thing every day. As the story progresses, Montag meets Clarisse Mclelen, a young woman living across the street, and she influences Montag to fall into a spiral of doubt and questioning. She asks Montag if he’s happy, and without hesitation, he says yes. Entering his fireproof house, he thinks to himself, “Of course I'm happy. What does she think?
When Montag reaches his home, Clarisse asks him, “‘Are you happy?’” (7). At first, he obviously thinks he is happy, and just rules it off as a silly question. Although he thought it was silly, he still kept thinking about it. (STEWE-2): Even as he steps inside his own house, he knows “He
Before Montag met Clarisse, he never thought about reading books, and he was never curious about how things were done before (history). Clarisse makes Montag question his surroundings, such as his society, and happiness. Everything started with a simple walk in the neighborhood to Clarisse’s house, followed by the question “"Are you happy?,"” introducing Montag's first internal problem, himself (7). After his first encounter with Clarisse, Montag seemed to have a crisis over his happiness, “Of course I'm happy. What does she think?
" Montag is really not sure because he later realizes that he really wasn 't happy when she asked that. I believe he shows his pessimistic side through all the characters except Montag and Clarisse and through the plot of the
She is the first person who challenges Montag and gets him to truly think. She triggers Montag’s questioning of life, what he is doing, and his relationship with his wife Mildred. Upon their first encounter Clarisse begins asking Montag questions, questions about a time when firefighters put out flames not started them, a time when life was a bit slower. She asks, “Are you happy?” once Clarisse is home Montag responds, “Of course I’m happy.