ipl-logo

Female Genital Mutilation Analysis

1115 Words5 Pages

In an article by Richard Shweder titled "What about 'Female Genital Mutilation '? and Why Understanding Culture Matters in the First Place", the author explores female circumcision and its relation to culture (Shweder, pg.209). While the topic of this article is female circumcision, the author also explores the reasoning behind why it is referred to as female genital mutilation in some cultures (Shweder, pg.209). In this article, the author focuses on the thoughts that cultures who practice female circumcision have about the practice, therefore the theory used is interpretivism. (Shweder, pg.212). The author analyzes the research question "is female circumcision really mutilation?" (Shweder, pg.218). The thesis developed through this …show more content…

Shweder 's article is based on the idea that female circumcision is a practice that many cultures believe in and that their beliefs should not be discounted (Shweder, pg.213). The theory used in this article is interpretivism, this is evident because the ideas in Shweder 's article come from the beliefs of cultures that practice female circumcision (Shweder, pg.209-pg.220). The fact that interpretivism is the theory used in this article is important because it brings in the emic perspective on female circumcision (Shweder, pg.209-pg.220). A part of Shweder 's thesis directly relates to the practice of tolerance to the perspective of those who believe in the practice of female circumcision, therefore the interpretivism theory is important to the entire article (Shweder, pg.219-pg.220). The emic perspective is important to Shweder 's article as it includes the beliefs of cultures that practice female circumcision, this helps him encourage readers of his article to begin questioning statements by the Anti-FGM movement (Shweder, …show more content…

An aspect of the "mutual yuck response" portion of the article is the concept that "medical complications are the exception, not the rule" (Shweder, pg.217). Looking at the evidence is a suggestion made in Shweder 's thesis, therefore the fact that medical complications with the procedure are not as common as people assume them to be supports the thesis of this article (Shweder, pg.217). Shweder makes the point in this section that few girls who receive this procedure actually end up suffering from injury or infection (Shweder, pg.217). This again discounts statements made by the Anti-FGM movement that the procedure causes harm to those who receive it (Shweder, pg.217). The idea of a "mutual yuck response" adds to the article as a whole and supports the thesis because it shows how people view these practices in a way that discounts the meaning of them (Shweder, pg.213). The supporting points in this section support the thesis because they show how women that practice female circumcision think of it as their turn into womanhood and as something that makes them more beautiful, this relates to the aspect of the thesis that states society should look at the perspectives of those who practice female circumcision

Show More
Related

  • Analysis Of Suzanne Kessler's The Medical Construction Of Gender

    366 Words  | 2 Pages

    In “The Medical Construction of Gender” by Suzanne Kessler, Kessler argues that gender is socially constructed. She conducts an ethnography on intersex babies, the doctors and parents involved, and how society puts constraints on genders. Kessler uses different anthropological methods to prove her argument. One method Kessler uses is a humanistic approach when she puts quotations around “true hermaphrodite” and “natural/normal genitalia” (p.52). This shows that while staying objective, Kessler is also trying to humanize these intersex babies by suggesting that there is no such thing as normal genitalia.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Exemisia By Susan Vreeland

    1231 Words  | 5 Pages

    Throughout the 15th century through the 17th century the status of women is exemplified to be that of a subordinate position through the readings of “The Passion of Artemisia” by Susan Vreeland, McKay textbook chapter 13 reading and the DBQ “Did Women Have a Renaissance”. Traditional societal values and ideals, blinded many to the accomplishments and potential of females and continued to perpetuate a culture that valued and identified women with domestic work and motherhood. The institutionalized ignorance and ingrained bias of society helped to propel forward the systematic oppression of women whos minute sphere of influence equaled to less political power and property ownership. Subjected to violence, ridicule, discrimination and

    Read More

  • Engendering The Brain Summary

    580 Words  | 3 Pages

    The chapter summarizes that sex differences in the brain structure and function has a close association to the psychological characteristics, such as sexual orientation. Social experience of humans influences hormones to a great extent. The relation between hormones and sex differences possesses both clinical and social implications. According to medicine, humans with ambiguous genitalia fall under the female sex as it is easier to create female genitalia when compared to male genitalia. Furthermore, surgical procedures used for reconstructuring either male or female genitalia have always worsened the

    Read More

  • A Border Passage Sparknotes

    720 Words  | 3 Pages

    The practice, according to Ahmed, was not generally observed in her society and was seen by women who practiced Islam as a cultural tradition that was not mandated by the religion. Instead of being a religious requirement, circumcision was viewed as a cultural rite of passage for women. In contrast, male Islam routinely performed female circumcision and considered it as a religious need. Men felt that female circumcision was required to preserve a woman's chastity and purity and to keep her from having sex before marriage. Ahmed claims that female circumcision is not an essential Islamic ritual because of the harm it might cause and because of her own experience with it.

    Read More

  • Circumcision Should Be Allowed Essay

    1076 Words  | 5 Pages

    The moment has finally come where Jane had undergone twenty-seven hours of labor and had given birth to a beautiful baby boy. An awe-struck Jack was trying to keep his Bambi-like legs from giving out on him as he was still digesting the events that had transpired in front of him. After several minutes, Dr. Mike walked in to check on the new parents. “Are you guys going to have him circumcised?”. Circumcision is one of the most common procedures in any hospital and one of the most controversial decisions parents make.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Anti-Circumcision

    1071 Words  | 5 Pages

    In recent years, there have been anti-circumcision movements gaining steam that mindlessly compares the circumcision of a boy with the genital mutilation of a woman. Circumcision is where the foreskin is trimmed to make my dong look awesome and reduce chances for STD's. What is done to women is equivalent to chopping the head of a penis off. Before I go on further into this, just know that a lot of the language can be offputting, and the images, even though just drawings, can be NOT SAFE FOR WORK.

    Read More

  • Sonora Regional Medical Center: Argumentative Analysis

    336 Words  | 2 Pages

    I work at Sonora Regional Medical Center and this week, I have been working at a pediatric clinic and I have learned certain things about circumcisions and when it should be performed on a baby boy. A circumcision is the surgical removal of the foreskin and, on infants, it is performed within the first few day after birth. It has been found by the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP), that the benefits of a circumcisions in newborns, outweigh the risks of it, but when the boys age more, it does not necessarily need to be done unless there is a medical reason to do so. There are many benefits to a circumcision including a reduced risk of urinary tract infections, a reduced risk of sexually transmitted diseases in men, reduced risk of penile

    Read More

  • Gender Inequality In The Bell Jar

    1804 Words  | 8 Pages

    To initiate, the implementation of gender equality laws will help conclude unequal treatment towards women and create opportunities for women to refuse unsafe work and treatments. Also, without the right to make individual choices for body, women 's prosperity, well-being, and potential in society are restricted and gender inequality is therefore perpetuated. According to the academic article, Sexual Health’s Women’s Rights, “120 million girls worldwide have experienced forced intercourse” (Ngcuka) activities against their own individual soul. Many women are suffering from forced physical and sexual violence because of the limited laws and regulations that allow women to refuse unsafe treatments and practices. According to reports, the “ 32

    Read More

  • Circumcision In Ancient Egypt

    1505 Words  | 7 Pages

    Though the logic is flawed, it shows the religious and moral philosophy behind the surgery. Dating back to the 23rd century B.C., circumcision is the oldest recorded surgical practice in history. With its origins dating back to the ancient Egyptians and upheld for millennia by the Jews, circumcision has become one of the most controversial medical practices to date, with its medical necessity and practicality being debated frequently.

    Read More

  • Are Men Comfortable With Genitals Essay

    520 Words  | 3 Pages

    Why are men more comfortable with their genitals than woman/ Men grow up seeing and touching their genitals. It becomes an essential part of them starting not long after birth. This familiarity with their private parts might help males to feel more comfortable with their genitals. This comfortability will also support a male build confidence of their self-image. Furthermore, by being satisfied with their genitals may help them acknowledge pleasures from masturbation.

    Read More

  • Divine Command Theory Essay

    481 Words  | 2 Pages

    The major flaw with DCT is that it’s arbitrary, meaning an argument can be interpreted many different ways. In order to mover past DCT, human have been practicing ethics because it forces us to practice logic, reasoning, and autonomy. 2. The clitoral excision procedure involves completely removing the clitoris. The clitoris is the area of sexual arousal and eastern cultures remove this because they believe women should only use intercourse for making babies instead of pleasure.

    Read More

  • Circumcision Should Be Mandatory Essay

    1576 Words  | 7 Pages

    Many human beings believe that circumcision is worth it, and it should be made a mandatory procedure. They believe that this procedure provides so many good health benefits and the research article states that it lowers the child’s risk of developing HIV by 60 percent (Kapumba King) and this procedure also helps lower the chance of developing cancer. This procedure also decreases the risk of sexually transmitted diseases later in life. They believe also by making this procedure mandatory that it would help preserve these religious and cultural traditions and pass them on to future generations. Some individuals tend to believe that it is the responsibility of parents to ensure the health of their children and they view circumcision as a necessary step in fulfilling that responsibility.

    Read More

  • Essay On Male Circumcision

    731 Words  | 3 Pages

    INTRODUCTION Male circumcision can be defined as surgical removal of the foreskin from the penis. Circumcision has been practiced in Africa for more than 5000 years, and in Middle East for more than 3000 years. Nowadays it is estimated that 30% of men are circumcised globally with the majority of them from Muslim countries. It is usually carried out for religious reason as well as non- religious reason such as cultural, medical, and social reasons.

    Read More

  • Nature Of Female Circumcision In Fire Eyes By Soraya Mire

    739 Words  | 3 Pages

    The few personal stories from the women who experienced circumcision offer powerful additions to the horrifying nature of genital mutilation and how the poorly done operation forever ruins the women’s hygiene and health. The result of Soraya Mire’s choice to only showcase the graphic parts of female circumcision takes away the cultural meaning and importance of the practice. Soraya Mire’s strong opinion on female circumcision relates closely with the Western approach to viewing external cultures and disagreeing with practices that

    Read More

  • Informative Speech On Female Genital Mutilation

    1861 Words  | 8 Pages

    Informative Speech: Female Genital Mutilation Specific Purpose: To inform my audience about female genital mutilation and where the controversy of it all lies. Central Idea: Female Genital Mutilation is a tradition in certain parts of the world. Most of the time these procedures aren 't carried out safely and the final outcome of the girls that have been mutilated are to work as sex slaves. INTRODUCTION (Attention Getter)This is Kizibianca of kenya, africa. At a mere fifteen years old she was woken up at 5 am and led outside of her hut by the the local traditional brothers and female elders.

    Read More

More about Female Genital Mutilation Analysis

Open Document