I enjoyed reading your literature review and I can see you have obviously put a lot of work into this. My goal is to provide you effective feedback about concerns/suggestions I have as a reader. Although I will provide critical feedback, the objective is to give you ways to rethink for draft 1.2
You start the introduction with an engaging attention-getter that states “Political music has been prevalent in society since the 1800s, beginning with slave hymnals”; this statement shows the significance/importance of the research issue. After that you even introduce a broad view about the research topic by stating “According to recent publications…”. However, one important element that was left out is the thesis statement. But why is it relevant? Because, first, it represents the main trend or theme that you have identified in the research articles, second, it creates a focus on a lit. review main idea and third, it helps the reader to understand the main idea of the essay. So,
…show more content…
As an example you second paragraph; it starts ““Shostakovich 's Fifth Symphony: A Soviet Artist 's Reply...?” was written by J. Daniel Huband in June of 1990. The article first explains that for a piece…” and ends “The author explains in depth the importance of the musical markings of a piece, and how well they portray the composer’s message and feelings.”. Do not forget that a literature is not a paper in which you analyze a work but a paper that a paper compiles the research that has been published on the topic by scholars and shows trends between articles. I suggest you a different organization. Add topic sentences to your paragraphs, which a usually the first sentence in the paragraph, as the one I suggested above. It will help readers understand the main point of the entire paragraph. After the topic sentences, you can show how the sources are connected under the topic sentence, and instead of summarizing the sources, synthesize
Graphic Organizer Body Paragraph Task: This question explores the ideas of fairness -- what is “just” by asking you to think about punishments and rewards that made up Hammurabi’s Code. Body Paragraph Baby Thesis (Restate the question, introduce topic)
Beyond any doubt, your thesis is well defined and precise. The particular text that was analyzed and the author’s name are clearly stated, providing to the reader background information on your paper. Your audience is well-established, you stated a sufficiently narrowed audience, proved how the intended audience you provided could help the author achieve his purpose, and moreover you explained why foreign and educational policy makers are the intended audience. Therefore, you related the audience with McGray’s purpose, which is one of the keys to a successful rhetorical analysis. In my opinion, positioning the thesis at the beginning of the paper is not a very good strategy because your reader might forget about the main idea at the moment he reaches
The analysis I made was based on Douglas McGray’s article “Lost in America”. You did a great job starting your introduction in a creative way using a question as attention-grabber. It is an effective strategy to grab the reader’s attention. You briefly summarized the article’s main points; it provides readers a brief explanation of what will be further analyzed. You also established a very solid thesis statement with a purpose, audience and rhetorical device being analyzed.
Outline Introductory paragraph - Basic information and thesis -Author, title of work, etc. -thesis: what article is about, view on topic Body Paragraph 1: Pathos Main idea-
The reading “Popular music and the civil war” explained the heavy influence that music had leading up to and during the civil war. Music was used to express the way Americans, those in the north or south, were feeling during this time. Through their lyrics, writers and singers were able to convey their feelings on topics such as being separated from loved ones, losing someone, patriotism for the confederates or the union, and anything else that related to war time. Many of these songs appealed to the Americans because they could easily relate to what the lyrics were saying. Therefore, songs were being greatly produced during this time because people were purchasing the music, whether that was by going to see the performance of it, or buying
Thesis Statement (Main Argument/Preview of Points): Outlines your argument/theme. Law should usually be followed, but there are certain circumstances such as if you love someone, a law crosses your morals and if the law is unfair or unequal. BODY PARAGRAPH #1: This first paragraph should focus on how conflicts support theme. I. Topic Sentence: States the literary element and introduces how it supports your theme.
Our weaknesses and tendencies while composing documents are clearly revealed in the tutorial. As we compose work that frequently relies on the ideas of others, the benefits of understanding our tendencies are indispensable while avoiding plagiarism. Personally, I have decided to capitalize on summarizing and direct quotations, while marginalizing my use of paraphrases. I believe that summarizing requires more analysis of the sources intent, allowing me to effectively continue to strengthen my analytical skills. I intend to utilize short direct quotations in order to provide clarity to my perspective and analysis of the
Summarizing is an advantage because it helps the reader understand what the author is talking about. Not to mention that the use for summaries is to provide the reader with the content of what the speaker is using.
1. Copy a short passage that you found to be interesting and explain why you found it interesting/why it is an example of good writing. “If evenings at the fair were seductive, the nights were ravishing. The lamps that laced every building and walkway produced the most elaborate demonstration of illumination ever attempted and the first large-scale test of alternating current.
The purpose of the abstract is to give the reader a brief explanation of what is to come in a following article, paper, or any other academic work. The abstract is not to be confused for a summary, as it is meant to be a short, but an objective portrayal of the academic work.[1] They are important because it is the first thing the reader reads, making it a first impression. In most cases, it is the preshow of the in-depth work. It gives a chance for the reader to determine if they should continue reading the work, as it is the right material they were searching for, and if it is the right work the abstract briefly explains what they will find in the
In " The 3 Effects of the Five Paragraph Theme" by Kimberly Wesley, she discusses the problems with using five paragraph theme (FPT). In this article, the writer argues that by using FPT will limit the students idea that can be represented in the paper. Students are trying fit the specific FPT requirements, and they cannot write any deeper or include new ideas. Student's tend to think not following the FPT will lead to bad grade. Therefore, students would not including more information, because it can be risk taking.
Genette explains that one of the reasons why a paratext is written is because of its importance. I believe that this is the reason behind the initial preface on pages 4 and 5. The author is attributing “high value to a subject by demonstrating its importance … and the usefulness of examining it (Genette
Music Appreciation Essay Music today is something we can easily take for granted. Through class I have learned several important influences in music. The most significant composer in my opinion was Ludwig van Beethoven. I feel his works broadened music and took it to a whole new level.
This time I have connected the paragraphs together. I had a better thesis statement. I had good topic sentences in each paragraph. The topic sentences were connected to the thesis. I had also used quotes better after using quotes I have cited them properly and explained the quote better.
Reason to listen: I think it’s safe to say that all of you have listened to or heard music at one point of your life, but did you know music influences and manipulates us more than we know? III. Thesis Statement: Today I am going to tell you about an aspect of human culture that appears just about everywhere you go: music. IV. Credibility Statement: Being a big music lover, I was curious about how much music really affected me, and hence my research began.