The Giver & Adaptation Theory After reading The Giver and watching the 2014 film in class, I have noticed lots of differences and similarities among the two. Most of the movie is correct but at the same time, they made some slight changes from the director’s perspective. I will apply Linda Hutcheon’s Adaptation Theory to analyze the choices that the director made in the movie that is different from the book. The first thing I would talk about is the main character Jonas, exactly like the book, it starts before the Ceremony of Twelve took place. In the movie, they called it the Ceremony of Sixteen which is completely different. According to the Adaptation Theory, the general audience wouldn’t really catch the error because they haven’t read …show more content…
According to the Adaptation Theory, The Giver would be a Constraint. He has the power to transmit memories to Jonas to help him gain intelligence, integrity, courage, and by time he would also receive wisdom. Jonas uses the memories that was provided by the Giver to make particular decisions and actions that he thought would be logical and made sense depending on the circumstance. The Giver in the movie is a lot different compared to the book. He is much friendlier in the book than the movie portrays him. He doesn’t have any altercations with the chief elder in the book compared to the movie. He transmits the memories completely differently in both the movie and film. The book says that The Giver places his hand over his back to pass on the memories but the movie he floats his hands over Jonas’s fist while sitting directly with one another. Many of the memories that Jonas have gotten from The Giver are different from both versions of the story. For example, instead of undergoing the pain from sunburn, alternatively he gets stung by a bee. The particular memory was an old memory from war when horses where using during battle, but most specifically, it is a memory from Vietnam. According to the Adaptation Theory, there is affordances from those specific memories the Giver gave Jonas. Those painful memories would make Jonas in discomfort and feel sadness because the things that he has …show more content…
There are many similarities from this event from the book and the movie. This ceremony in both are pretty vague until Jonas watched it all happen to one the identical twin weighted less than his other twin brother. Jonas recognized that his dad is essentially killing him but his father doesn’t comprehend this. The ending in both the movie and the book, Jonas runs away from the community with Gabriel with him. In the film, Jonas runs away because initially they were going to kill Gabriel but Jonas is saving him. In the book, Jonas takes his time and plans his escape carefully. According to the Modes of Engagement, the movie is telling us that Gabriel in the movie and book still deeply cares about Gabriel and has a strong connection with him. The movie had a scene when Jonas punched Asher in the face or point the finger at Fiona at all which never happened in the book. The Chief Elder doesn’t question Asher to lose Jonas if he sees him with his drone but there are no drones in the book whatsoever. In the book, after Jonas leaves the community by biking away in the middle of the night, not stealing a motorcycle but we only hear things from his viewpoint, and we don’t know for sure what happens back in the
It was now that Jonas was informed of his duty as receiver of memories. Jonas was forced to leave his place of comfort and leave the safe world that he had been in up until this point.
The news leaves Jonas in shock because he didn’t comprehend how the community has the willpower to kill innocent humans. As one can see the community is very secretive to make sure the people from the community don’t find out what it means to be
In the end of chapter 22, it said, “He wept because he was afraid now that he could not save Gabriel, he no longer cared about himself.” (Lowry 218). This piece of evidence shows that Jonas, had he not been trying his hardest to keep Gabriel alive, would have been fine with dying due to the fact he didn’t care about his life or what happened to him. The only thing keeping him alive was his reliance on the fact that Gabe needed him which proves that he relies on Gabe just to keep surviving. In addition there were multiple other quotes proving this such as , “The Giver hugged him.
Though in the movie he was a serious kid, and he followed the rules. He was so serious, he tried to stop Jonas from getting in trouble. Also, Asher refused to go down the arch on the food tray because he didn 't want to break the rules. 2. Jonas’s conflict with the rules in the movie were not as evident in the book.
In the beginning of The Giver, Jonas was missing the quality to that would allow him to fight against the government. However, after becoming the receiver of memory he began to obtain that quality. “He would need those to help him find the elsewhere they were sure existed. They knew it would be a very difficult journey.” We can tell that because he was willing, nothing would be able to stop him from rebelling, even though he could die.
The last extreme change is that we have emotions, feelings and we can see color, Jonas’s society is so much about equality that they don 't want anyone to be different or they fear that the people will have the power to chose what they want to do. Today 's society and Jonas’s have some similarities. Such as, in both children are given comfort objects to help them through rough times. Well just like in The Giver all children go to school in our country too.
In addition, Jonas's like of The Giver, his family, friends, and Gabriel completely changed to Jonas feeling love for them. This knowledge that was transmitted to Jonas changed the way that he felt towards certain people in his
Some of the major differences, such as the changes in Jonas, Fiona, and Asher’s characters in the movie as well as Jonas’s escape, really separate the movie from the book. However, that is not to say that there are not plenty of similarities. The descriptions and portrayals of Jonas’s feelings about the Community, The Giver, and the structure of the Community are very similar between the two stories. While the similarities greatly outnumber the differences, some of the differences are very major and can change the story a
In order to truly know what the movie or the novel did well or awful on, we must first consider the following criteria, characters, plot, and the setting. We shall first compare and contrast the plot of both the novel and the movie. In the movie Jonas
The cliffhanger ending is more powerful because we are left to wonder Jonas and Gabriel’s fate and we don’t have anything decided for us. In chapter 23 Lowry writes, “For the first time he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people signing”(179). Since Jonas had never heard music before it makes us wonder how he knows what it is. He could be dead and be hearing music or he could be having a memory from the Giver but we don’t really know.
He is under sameness and the influence of the community. Jonas is chosen to receive feelings, colors, and emotions from memories. As time goes by Jonas sees the community not as a utopia but a horrible place. Jonas wants to change
Jonas felt anger for his father and the pain he feels for the baby twin. On page 168 in the giver,Jonas realized that they been playing a game of war ( Lowry). Jonas feel sad and misunderstood for the boy in war. Jonas sadly understood that no one know what he is feeling. These are like real life because some careless people don 't think about others and think that everything is just a joke.
They asked Jonas if he understands, Jonas say yes but does mean it. He didn't understand why that didn't feel that way toward him, the way he did for them. The Giver explains that the people of the community don’t feel emotion and feelings the way the two of them did because of sameness. (chapter
Jonas thought that after they received their assignments, him and Asher, his best friend, he thought that they would grow apart and no longer be friends. Throughout the beginning of the book, Jonas kept worrying about how they might grow apart from each other. In the book Jonas thought to himself “...but what would become of me and Asher and the assignments we received”. Jonas did not want them to grow apart because they have been best friends since they were little. This was hard for him because he didn't know what would become of them and what would become of them.
Furthermore without memories, you can not make responsible decisions. On page 130 of The Giver explained that the Committee of Elders comes to him for advice because he has memories. Jonas asks if they ask for advice often and the Giver says, “Rarely. Only when they are faced with something they have not experienced before.” Without memories, Jonas can not make decisions because he has very little experience.