ipl-logo

Gnych & Anor V Polish Club Case Study

879 Words4 Pages

Introduction:

The Case report is about Gnych & Anor v Polish Club limited, Canberra High court, (High Court Of Australia, 2015). In 2012, Polish Club Limited being the licensee of a premise allowed Mr Jacek Gnych & Sylwia Gnych to lease and operate a restaurantb which comprised of the first floor with a capacity of fifty seats and ground floor with the entry to the restaurant along with storage area and toilet. Connected to the restaurant is the Mirror hall (which was not included in the agreement initially but was later included on certain terms) with 80 seat capacity which contains a bar where customers are allowed to purchase liquor. However, all the lease agreement papers were prepared and submitted but nothing was ever signed nor finalised. …show more content…

Everyone was told to maintain silence, stand up and following that everyone was told to sit down. Then the Plaintiff’s Lawyer Mr REYNOLDS stood up, introduced himself and his party and was given the chance to speak. Following that he started to describe the case to the judges and explaining and providing references from previous cases and also mentions what Polish Club Limited breached. After that the defendant’s lawyer that is MR CLAY was allowed to speak for the defendant who argued for a while and defended Polish Club Limited. The Honour and the other judges questioned Mr Reynolds, the plaintiff’s lawyer, about evidence and reference provided to make sure whether the claim they are making against Polish Club Limited comply and whether Polish Club Limited breached the law. Throughout the court case Mr Reynolds was asked quite a lot of questions and he replied to most of it with ease providing resources and proof to back his argument.

Test applied:

Firstly MR. REYNOLDS described to the judges all the laws that Polish Club limited breached.
Mr Reynolds did mention that Polish Club limited did breach Retail Leases Act 1994(NSW) SS 6A,8(1),16(1) & 16(2). Jacek Gnych & Sylwia Gnych had a five-year lease agreement and were told to evacuate the leased area before the time period expired. However, since the lease agreements were prepared but never got signed or ever finalised so Polish Club Limited did not breach the Retail Lease Act

Show More
Related

  • Summary Of Australian Competition And Consumer Commission V Ticketek

    1356 Words  | 6 Pages

    Michael Terceiro, 'ACCC v Ticketek - a non-event?' (2012) 64(3) Keeping Good Companies 158-161

    Read More

  • Summary: The Case Of R. V. Wood

    787 Words  | 4 Pages

    v. Wood, 2007). The first issue, was took from the position of the Appellant, as well as the Crown on the DRE and if it should have been heard. The Appellant went to state, the trial judge failed to analyze the admissibility of the DRE evidence in accordance with the tests enunciated in R. v. Mohan, 1994, and the DRE evidence should be excluded (R. v. Wood, 2007). The Crown argues that, even though the trial judge’s Reasons for Judgement did not specifically specify the Mohan analysis, her overall ruling shows she followed the guidelines with Mohan. Furthermore, adding the she considered the DRE protocol, ascertained Sergeant Moschansky’s qualifications, and examined the uses of the evidence (R. v. Wood, 2007).

    Read More

  • Roach 2006 Irac Case Study

    688 Words  | 3 Pages

    Step 2: research –roach v. electoral commissioner (2007) Questions Q1. The individual or group that had their rights infringed-who were they? Individuals who had their rights infringed were prisoners who served more than 3 years in prison.

    Read More

  • Scott V. Watson 278 Md. 160

    951 Words  | 4 Pages

    Id. at 169. For the reasons stated in Part I, supra, the Co-Owners are not Byrne’s landlord. Finally, Scott expressly limited the scope of potential circumstances where a landlord may owe a tenant a duty to protect the tenant from criminal conduct to instances “where landlord knows, or should know, of criminal activity against persons or property in the common areas.” Id. (emphasis added). Byrne alleges no facts that—if true—would have put the Co-Owners on notice

    Read More

  • Analysis Of School Bands Should Not Be Entertainment Adjunct For Sports By Frank Deford

    850 Words  | 4 Pages

    Finally, no decisions or significant details from the court case decision of the high school band members are included. Deford lacks all forms of legitimate proof to his claims and fails to back up his statements with statistical information. Without credible evidence backing up his claims the reader begins to question Deford’s

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Airtastic

    2736 Words  | 11 Pages

    An arguable case must be illustrated, indicating clearly their case has grounds and a reasonable chance of

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Kinkel Vs The State Of Oregon

    1013 Words  | 5 Pages

    In the present year of 2016 there has already been 7 school shootings around America. The rhetorical analysis of the court document “Kinkel vs The State of Oregon”. The document was written to explain the arguments of both sides of the court and to justify the decision made by the court and judge Haselton through facts and rhetorical accounts of events that transpired of Mr. Kinkel and his actions of the school shooting. Judge Haselton clearly uses Ethos, Logos, and Pathos within the analysis which is used to his advantage. Judge Haselton was writing to many audiences, the most important and crucial are the defendants and the victim’s family members present.

    Read More

  • Case Of R V Kokopenace

    891 Words  | 4 Pages

    Justice Cromwell and Chief Justice McLachlin perceived this case through a distinctive approach as compared to the majority. As an alternative of viewing the trial as a whole, they decided to concentrate on the functions of the jury which include, representing the community, presenting a protective barrier against unfair/harsh laws, and performing as informative means of the criminal justice system (Pinder, 2015). Without these factors, the trial would be deemed as unfair as the jury is viewed as the foundation of the trial and every matter follows accordingly (2015 SCC 28, para. 24). Cromwell and McLachlin stated the only means of exactly determining if the province abided by section 11(d) of the Charter is to evaluate the Province’s conduct considering the situation and how they tried to recognize the problem – if any. The Justices concluded there was an appropriate link relating the Province’s manner and the absence of diverse representation of the jury as stated in the Charter (Pinder,

    Read More

  • B Pulsey & Anor V State Of B Impulsey

    1503 Words  | 7 Pages

    Thus, the appellants were entitled to awards for aggravated damages. Ratio Decidendi: • A ‘claim for damages for deprivation of liberty is not a “claim for personal injury damages”’. • Using the narrower construction of ‘in relation to’, s 52(1) of the CLA does not preclude an award of aggravated damages if the damages claimed are not in relation to personal injury. V. Outcome Each of the appellants’ appeal was allowed with costs.

    Read More

  • Racial Profiling Case: The Lloyd Rayney Case

    852 Words  | 4 Pages

    Both men were successful in their appeals as a verdict of guilty could not be settled upon as the case was based on improbabilities and circumstantial evidence that could not lead to a definite

    Read More

  • Evidence In 12 Angry Men

    1144 Words  | 5 Pages

    They were interacting face to face with each other and discussing all the facts that they had, sharing different views, and discussing the case. The type of group the 12 jurors were is a problem-solving group as they had a situation and they had to work together to come to an agreement. Culture makes an impact in the group because, everyone has their own beliefs. Most of the men have their own way of viewing, perceiving, and behaving. It’s really difficult for most people to agree on certain things especially when they are close minded and what they believe is ultimately what they think is right.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Court Observation By Tocqueville

    2050 Words  | 9 Pages

    The desk was located at the centre of the courtroom. The fact that the claimant was representing himself immediately caught my attention. He appeared to be perplexed as to what was going on in the courtroom, albeit showing some understanding as to what stage of the procedures he was in. The judge, throughout the hearing, had to repeatedly asked the claimant “do you understand what this means?”

    Read More

  • Identify The Areas Of Law That Are Relevant To The Chosen Media Report.

    478 Words  | 2 Pages

    1. Identify the areas of law that are relevant to the chosen media report, and explain how they are relevant to the matters outlined in the report. This news article reports on the police have charged several individuals according to the offences they have committed, in Kalgoorlie. Criminal Law When physical element and fault element are found in a case, an individual can be proven as guilty in conducting an offence which is against the law been made.

    Read More

  • The Stranger, By Albert Camus

    598 Words  | 3 Pages

    All throughout the trial irrelevant questions

    Read More

  • Reflective Essay: My Job Shadowing Process

    1674 Words  | 7 Pages

    All the other lawyers waiting for their chances were all working on their lop tops. I was told to take notes on everything I saw and heard. I was very fortunate to meet the judge. The judge was very different to what I expected, a blonde female with well manicured nails and she was well dressed. I was really taken up with the advocate and his negotiations with the judge and his conversations on his cell phone with his client.

    Read More

More about Gnych & Anor V Polish Club Case Study

Open Document