ipl-logo

Greed And Grievance Analysis

1156 Words5 Pages

Before indicating difficulties, that may arise out of the presentation of greed and grievance as separated and even contradicting, some possible reasons why that narrative is applied at all will be discussed. Keen states regarding this, that “the tool drives the analysis instead the other way around”. This is not unrealistic, as by a closer examination it becomes clear that most proxies do fit into both lines of argumentation, but were squeezed by Collier and Hoeffler into the greed model, perhaps in order to justify economical interventions, liberalization and investments. One example for this is the proxy peace duration, which was used as indicator for low cost of conflict-specific capital, while it however also could be a proxy for the grievance-approach, …show more content…

The purported causes of civil wars cannot be simply put into two boxes, because by doing this, ongoing dynamics leading up to the conflict are entirely ignored, which in fact causes an inaccurate understanding of the situation. Greed and grievance are probably rather reinforcing then conflicting (Nathan, Boix, other), by disregarding this correlation scholars do not see the whole picture and therefor may give poor policy advices: “A good doctor will need to get some idea of the nature of the disease before rushing to the medicine cabinet to pull out a remedy” (Keen). As for a doctor, it is also crucial for the international community to first understand dynamics and interactions driving/guiding a society into conflict before intervening to prevent this. Any measure, which is based on a decision, which was lacking profound and in-depth understanding of the nature of the conflict provoking environment, may even worsen the situation as it is based on a false diagnostic in the first place. Intervention measures of the IMF can serve as example. The greed and grievance study of 2004, as well as earlier papers of Collier and Hoeffler, were quite influential in financial institutions as the World Bank or the International Monetary Fund. Firstly, this was due to the scholars’ role as World Bank researcher and secondly due to the fact that the results apparently provided evidence for the utility of financial means in the prevention of civil wars. In contrast to that Keen notes that “externally-imposed liberalisation schemes have often been a particular source of tension”. This assumption is illustrated by Hartzell in his paper “Economic Liberalization via IMF Structural Adjustment: Sowing the Seeds for Civil Wars” of 2010. He states that the measures, which were targeted at achieving a more liberal and equal

Show More
Related

  • Zunes Ethos Pathos Logos Analysis

    270 Words  | 2 Pages

    Ethos It is noted in the end of the article, that the author is an associate professor of politics and chair of the Peace and Justice Studies Program at University of San Francisco. I would like to note that, even without mentioning Zunes’ titles and experience, the well-organized text with supportive statistics and historical facts has already made his argument

    Read More

  • Examples Of Greed By Gary Soto

    417 Words  | 2 Pages

    Consumed by greed, author Gary Soto reiterates his first sin with imagery and a plethora of symbols as he is overpowered by greed and must accept God back into his life. To clarify, the sin itself was fueled by greed, which the then six years old Gary Soto was not able to resist. At the time, the author stole an apple pie from a bald grocer “whose forehead shone with a window of light.” (Line 18) It is as if Gary Soto is turning away from the house of God which is adorned with windows to let in His light. The author grins at the grocer and exits, at that moment he has turned his back on the house of God, giving in to greed’s temptation by stealing an apple pie; much like Eve stole the apple from the Garden of Eden.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Greed

    1054 Words  | 5 Pages

    The hate, greed, and ignorance of people have caused suffering for many others throughout the history of mankind. “If you are greedy or angry or ignorant (the three Buddhist poisons), you are condemned to an endless cycle of unhappiness. ”(Arthur Dobrin D.S.W.) Hate and greed have overtaken people and have caused them to make actions that led to a genocide, or a mass killing of people. Ignorance did not help at all and actually kept the genocides going. An example of this would be the colonists and the Native Americans.

    Read More

  • Three Concepts Of Becoming Injustice In The United Sates

    144 Words  | 1 Pages

    “You learn something new everyday” is a saying that is tossed around often times sarcastically, but when deeply explored it really is a true statement. A large amount of people in the United Sates would agree that there are certain aspects of the lives of indigenous peoples such as the Mayans, Aztecs, an Incas that our society can learn from daily. Aspects such as: creating a legacy to leave behind, learning to face injustice, but most importantly practicing civic engagement when possible. The aspects listed above would be tremendously helpful especially in a world where injustice still exists and a divide is on the rise. If people from thousands of years ago could grasp the three concepts of creating a legacy, facing injustices, and practicing

    Read More

  • Summary Of Rent Seeking And The Making Of An Unequal Society

    1061 Words  | 5 Pages

    Rent Seeking by an American Economist In the American Economist Joseph Eugene Stiglitz’ essay, ‘Rent Seeking and the making of an Unequal Society,’ he argues, with the help of examples, that most of today’s economic and political problems are caused by the government. He goes in depth to explain why the government policies are a major factor in creating these problems, as well as the market forces itself. In addition to this, he discusses the relationship between income inequality and societal growth, and how rent seeking contributes to it. The following is main ideas from his essay that help to further prove his point of how rent seeking provides for income inequality, as well as how the government policies help in the making of an unequal society. Firstly, because the government policies shape the market forces, they are able to shape the degree of inequality.

    Read More

  • War And Contagion Dbq Analysis

    411 Words  | 2 Pages

    In both cases the community or world as a whole must step in before things get too bad and stop both wars and contentions before they end up too widespread and large of a problem to fix. Basically, both war and contagions become very hard to overthrow once they effect a certain amount of people and spread to a certain amount of land. Both can not be escaped by indifference to the problem or hiding from it, these solutions work for a little while until the problems are too big to contain, and then it 's too late. People in the position to help would benefit more from stepping in and stopping both a war or a contagion right ways because not only does it cost less money but cost less lives if a smaller power is taken out before it can become large scale and

    Read More

  • Their Own Words: Resilience Among Haitian Survivors Of The 2010 Earthquake

    1702 Words  | 7 Pages

    The fighting is caused by the lack of resources, but if the resources were not lacking and instead were used so that all people had access to the supplies less fighting would occur. For example, after not using the supplies resourcefully following Hurricane Katrina in 2005, the government learned that they must “...encourage and ultimately require State and local governments to pre-contract for resources and commodities that will be critical for responding to all hazards” (“The Federal Response” par 5). The planned use of the resources ensures that the people will have what is essential at the correct time. This could ultimately fix the fight for scarce resources because the existing need for them is mitigated.

    Read More

  • 9/11 Conflict Theory

    1210 Words  | 5 Pages

    On September 11, 2001, numerous individuals entered the United States of America and hijacked four airlines in order to carry out suicide attacks against various targets located in the nations most prestigious cities: Manhattan, New York and Washington, D.C. (Kean, H. Thomas et al., 2004). Two of the four hijacked flights were intentionally flown into the North and South Towers of the World Trade Center in the heart of the Manhattan’s Financial District; the third flight was headed towards Washington, D.C while the fourth one crashed in Pennsylvania (Kean, H. Thomas et al., 2004). The attacks that occurred on September 11, 2001 are often referred to as “9/11” which resulted in triggering a major initiative in the United States of American to combat terrorism (Thomas A. Gilly., 2009).

    Read More

  • The Role Of Pride In The Civil War

    307 Words  | 2 Pages

    Wars stem from pride. Whether if it’s to expand, secede or defend, it all stems from pride. Pride for one’s country (nationalism), culture and way of life. In the case of the Civil War it was fought to protect the Southern way of life. This was agriculture and free labor.

    Read More

  • Carolyn Nordstrom's 'Shadows Of War'

    664 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout Chapter five of her book Shadows of War, Carolyn Nordstrom shares her views on war in terms of social, physical and mental goals and punishes of such violence. To begin, one of the first goals of war as defined by Nordstrom is a direct result of a threat of loss of control. She explains that it is common for one military to feel the need to destroy another when their control over a certain (land area owned or controlled by someone) is under threat (56). An interesting point that Nordstrom makes is relating to/about (community of people/all good people in the world)'s do not tell the difference between the existence of different violences. As stated by Nordstrom, most people will naturally tell/show the difference between different wars; however, very few tell/show the difference between the experience of violence throughout such wars (57).

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Injustice In Out Of My Mind By Sharon Draper

    719 Words  | 3 Pages

    Injustice is the lack of fairness in justice directed towards an individual or group. There are numerous accounts of injustices in our society today, some may be observed as directed towards criminals, races, and those with special needs or disabilities. In the novel Out of my Mind by Sharon Draper, the main character Melody suffers from a disease called cerebral palsy. This disease prevents her from speaking and being able to control her own movements. She has a photographic memory, but because of her disability she is prevented from speaking her mind and many doubt her ability to think on her own.

    Read More

  • Morton Deutsch's Theory Of Conflict Resolution

    1011 Words  | 5 Pages

    He contends that when an individual or group is denied its major requirement for identity, security, acknowledgment or equivalent investment inside of the general public, extended conflict is inescapable. To determine such conflict, it is essential that needs that are debilitated be distinguished and along these lines rebuilding of connections or the social framework happen in a way that needs of all people and groups are suited (Burton John, 1991,p82). For instance, this model can be helpful in the cases of African conflicts, for example, that of Darfur, Burundi, Dr Congo and Rwanda conflicts, where there are limitations on opportunity and support of its nationals in political and monetary

    Read More

  • Justice In An Unjust World By Ruti Teitel

    1608 Words  | 7 Pages

    Justice in an Unjust World Genocide in Rwandan, a refugee crisis in Syria, and civil war in Yemen. These are just a few of countless injustices throughout the world. It appears that our global society has no problem creating injustice, but by examining the responses to these injustices, it is evident that we have significant difficulty achieving reconciliation and assigning culpability after the fact. This complicated task, “transitional justice,” has been extensively studied by Ruti Teitel. Teitel explains that transitional justice in our current worldwide stage of globalization has shifted to “steady-state justice”, focusing on “non-state actors” associated with globalization instead of “state-centric” obligations, and maintaining “peace

    Read More

  • Just And Unjust Analysis

    609 Words  | 3 Pages

    When addressing the difference between just and unjust laws for the clergymen Martin Luther King Jr. stated, A just law is man-made code that squares with the mora law or the law of God. An unjust law is a code that is out of harmony with the moral law. To put it in the terms of Saint Thomas Aquinas, an unjust law is a human law that is not rooted in eternal and natural law.

    Read More

  • Glaucon Justice And Injustice Analysis

    633 Words  | 3 Pages

    Glaucon discusses being justice and injustice. How people act in given situations and why they were to do it. What really brought me in was the opening page when I read what this story would be about, it said "Glaucon tells the story of a shepherd named Gyges who discovers a ring with the power to make him invisible, and then uses this power to cut all sorts of ethical corners and set himself up with a very comfortable life." That statement alone had me thinking about what that really meant because to me, I am living a comfortable life and am following most ethical corners. It is crazy to think that someone has to, "Cut all sorts of ethical corners" in order to achieve a very comfortable life.

    Read More

More about Greed And Grievance Analysis

Open Document