Hamlet Vs Antigone Research Paper
Whether it be Sophocles or Shakespeare tragedies, they resemble the rendering of human suffering and a man’s destiny. However, a closer look into the features of a tragic drama between a classic Greek tragedy and a Shakespearean tragedy has noticeable differences.
Sophocles tragedies were laid upon the inscrutable power of Fate or Destiny, capable of bringing about havoc and ruin to human life. For example, when Antigone commits a sin in such ignorance that the impression of a sinister destiny that rules her life is paramount. Sophocles tragedies were clearly represented in the plot and easily interpreted by the audience, unlike Shakespeare’s whose takes a different approach. I prefer Sophocles writing over Shakespeare because it is clearer
…show more content…
Something dramatic has already happened before the play begins. For example, in the beginning of “Hamlet” Prince Hamlet was summoned home to Denmark from Germany to attend his father’s funeral. Unlike in “Antigone” the tragedy opens up with Antigone explaining that she will rise up alone against the king and die young. Shakespeare’s plots are known to move in a complex manner. Shakespeare was known to follow the model of Aristotelian tragedy (tragic hero). All of Shakespeare’s play has a protagonist that has a tragic flaw that eventually leads to his downfall. In Shakespeare’s plays, however, the tragic flaws are less recognizable than Sophocles. In Sophocles tragedy’s he had a tendency to exaggerate the flaw, while Shakespeare keeps it more real. Shakespeare loved to make a complicated plot with many sub-plots in order to make the play more real, which is another reason why I prefer Sophocles’ writing over Shakespeare’s because it is easier for me to follow. He used comic relief to set up the plot and emphasized the tragedy, therefore made it more entertaining for the audience. At the end of his tragedies, he leaves the play unfinished and the audience remaining in awe at the absolute destruction of the protagonist, however this could easily leave the viewer
Creon's Pride In Sophocles Antigone
278 Words | 2 PagesAnother form of tragedy is the Shakespearean Tragedy.
Creon Tragic Hero Essay
1287 Words | 6 PagesThe article “The Tragic Hero in Greek Drama” claims that Sophocles, through the tragic heroes in Antigone and Oedipus the King, suggests, “we could do everything right, act on the best information available, and with the best of intentions, yet still commit unspeakable horrors” (“The Tragic Hero in Greek Drama”). Aristotle, a well-known ancient Greek literary critic, created a definition of a tragic hero. His definition is known as the Aristotelian tragic hero, which has many requirements that the character must possess. Creon is the character that best exemplifies Aristotle’s tragic hero because of his virtue, his hubris, and his realization of his fate; however, others may argue that Antigone is a better example of a tragic hero because of
Creon's Tragic Hero In Sophocles Antigone
945 Words | 4 PagesA tragedy is a difficult and rewarding form of drama for the audience, which was made into an art by the Greeks. A tragic hero is a character that of a noble stature, brought down by an act of injustice, has a tragic flaw, has a choice that results in the characters downfall, a misfortune not entirely deserved, and most importantly, the character gins self-knowledge. This skillfully describes King Creon. In the Greek drama Antigone by Sophocles, Teiresias, the prophet, is a foil to King Creon. Teriesias display of stubbornness highlights Creon’s hamartia of pride.
Examples Of Creon In Antigone
821 Words | 4 PagesAccording to A.C. Bradley, Shakespearean tragedy have the following elements “although a tragedy may have many characters, it is pre-eminently the story of one person or at most two. The story leads up to and included the death of the hero. The story depicts also the troubled part of the hero’s life which precede’s and leads up to his death. The hero is a conspicuous person, a person of high degree. The suffering and calamity are exceptional, of a striking kind.
Macbeth Vs Creon Analysis
1189 Words | 5 PagesThe more tragic hero-- Macbeth Norman Cousins says, "The tragedy of life is in what dies inside a man while he lives - the death of genuine feeling, the death of inspired response, the awareness that makes it possible to feel the pain or the glory of other men in yourself." Tragedy is a type of literature, usually a serious play or book, that ends sadly involving events in great loss or misfortune. In the play of Macbeth written by Shakespeare, protagonist Macbeth changes from an innocent thane from Scotland to a king who embraces evil and guilt, leading to his death. In another book-- Antigone written by Sophocles, antagonist Creon, a powerful built but a weary man who directly and indirectly kills his family members, suffers the burden of
Justice And Similarities Between Hamlet And Antigone
754 Words | 4 PagesWhen duty diverges from the law, should it be pursued? In the tragedy, Antigone, written by greek playwright Sophacles, the protagonist Antigone breaks the law of a stubborn king when she buries her traitorous brother Polynices. Then in the tragedy Hamlet, written by Shakespeare, we follow Hamlet who is told by the returning spirit of his father that he was murdered by his uncle and that Hamlet must seek revenge for him. Both deal with themes of justice and the struggle that both Antigone and Hamlet face when enacting it. Both Antigone and Hamlet express themes of self-sacrifice, a thirst for justice, and a case of hubris in the main characters, while ultimately having different goals and showing different views on human nature.
Creon As The Tragic Hero In Sophocles Antigone
884 Words | 4 PagesAccording to the Greek philosopher, Aristotle, a tragic hero has an elevated status in society that makes a decision that will eventually lead to the downfall of that character. This choice will cause the character to receive a punishment that is unjust and exceeds the crime committed. Right before the person receives his or her punishment, the character will gain self awareness and self knowledge of what caused his or her downfall. King Creon and his niece, Antigone, both have the qualities to be classified as the tragic hero of Sophocles’s play, Antigone.
Essay On Foreshadowing In Romeo And Juliet
782 Words | 4 PagesIn William Shakespeare’s play, The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet, two lovers are bound to death by fate, and the audience is informed of this fact by the large amount of foreshadowing seen throughout the play. In each scene, at least one example of foreshadowing can be seen. This literary device is used to help form the tone of the story and give readers a feeling for what is going to happen next. For example, before the Capulet party, Romeo says that he had a dream, in which he had died, and that his death in the dream was linked to his attending the Capulet party.
Sophocles Impact On Greek Theater
912 Words | 4 PagesAeschylus’s speeches were elegant, while Sophocles speeches were direct and understandable. The last thing that separates Sophocles from dramatists of the fifth century was his self-criticism. Unlike any other dramatist in the fifth century Sophocles left opinions on his own work. This allowed him to correct his mistakes and develop himself as a dramatist. There were multiple great dramatists during Sophocles time, but he was the best due to his uniqueness and
Creon Character Analysis Essay
1136 Words | 5 PagesThe play, Antigone written by Sophocles, presents a tragedy that fits the classical definition, but it is the story of Creon, the king of the main character. Creon starts out as the king of Thebes , Creon’s tragic flaw is his pride and his arrogance which caused him reflecting upon his mistakes making him a broken man, recognizing what he did to his niece, he is a character within Antigone, even though he was portrayed as an antagonist he was the main character since he was. Creon’s tragic flaw, hubris, causes his downfall. Creon will not listen to anyone.
Pity And Fear In Macbeth's Tragedy
1931 Words | 8 PagesIn his work, The Poetics Aristotle reflects on the role of pity and fear in tragedy, stating, “Tragedy is essentially an imitation not of persons but of action and of life; of happiness and misery. Add human happiness or misery takes the form of action… Character gives us qualities, but it is in our actions that we are happy or the reverse… The tragic pleasure is that of pity and fear” (Aristotle, The Poetics). Aristotle is probing one to conclude that tragedy is characterized by the pity and fear one evokes when individuals go against their presumed character and commit detrimental acts. Throughout his play Macbeth, Shakespeare, reminisces on the actions that gravitate an audience to render both fear and pity, which characterize a tragedy.
Importance Of Optimism In Romeo And Juliet
3720 Words | 15 PagesShakespeare's tragedy was so influential that it permeated every inch of literature, cinema, television, and there are a few expressions that borrow from it. Speaking of borrowing, Shakespeare borrowed heavily from “ The Tragical History of Romeus and Juliet” by Arthur Brooke. The story was already there for Shakespeare to use, but he added his writing style to the story and expanded the plot. Especially the for the minor characters. The first quarto version of Romeo and Juliet was received badly until it was reformatted to more closely resemble Shakespeare's writing style.
Antigone Tragedy Analysis
1141 Words | 5 PagesA tragedy is a dramatic work in which the principle character engages in a significant struggle ending in ruin and destruction. In creating his tragedy, Sophocles uses many techniques to create the feelings of fear and pity in his readers. This in turn creates an excellent tragedy. In Antigone, Sophocles does a great job at bringing out
The Similarities Between Hamlet And Antigone
1689 Words | 7 PagesTragedy is a part of life and most people will experience a tragedy in their lifetime. Tragedies are common enough to be presented to children through television shows and children’s books. Small tragedies occur in children’s entertainment. A children’s story may go like a kid loses an item he/she loves and then his/her friends or family help and find the lost item. Imagine if a kid had no support in finding whatever he/she has lost.
Antigone And Lysistrata Analysis
1113 Words | 5 PagesAristophanes and Sophocles both wrote similar arts that have been studied over the years. Antigone by Sophocles and Lysistrata by Aristophanes are two works of art that have many differences but they both assess an important point at the end. Out of all the differences between both of these plays, the one I consider most important is how each play ends according to the type of style it is. Even though the main characters of both of these plays were women, in Lysistrata, both the women and (eventually at the end) the men praise her for her beliefs, while in Antigone, almost everyone goes against what she feels is right which results in her death. The reason why this difference between Antigone (tragedy) and Lysistrata (comedy) is most important
More about Hamlet Vs Antigone Research Paper
Creon's Pride In Sophocles Antigone
278 Words | 2 PagesCreon Tragic Hero Essay
1287 Words | 6 PagesCreon's Tragic Hero In Sophocles Antigone
945 Words | 4 PagesExamples Of Creon In Antigone
821 Words | 4 PagesMacbeth Vs Creon Analysis
1189 Words | 5 PagesJustice And Similarities Between Hamlet And Antigone
754 Words | 4 PagesCreon As The Tragic Hero In Sophocles Antigone
884 Words | 4 PagesEssay On Foreshadowing In Romeo And Juliet
782 Words | 4 PagesSophocles Impact On Greek Theater
912 Words | 4 PagesCreon Character Analysis Essay
1136 Words | 5 PagesPity And Fear In Macbeth's Tragedy
1931 Words | 8 PagesImportance Of Optimism In Romeo And Juliet
3720 Words | 15 PagesAntigone Tragedy Analysis
1141 Words | 5 PagesThe Similarities Between Hamlet And Antigone
1689 Words | 7 PagesAntigone And Lysistrata Analysis
1113 Words | 5 Pages