Historians Strengths
Through this investigation I have gained an insight into some of the research methods historians use and the challenges they confront when carrying out historical investigations. In my investigation I read several books and journals written by historians as well as reviews on their work. Whilst researching I found that many of these sources were significantly different from each other. I found that reading books with strong opinions by historians could have strengths and weaknesses. One strength is that I could evaluate and look at the argument from multiple perspectives. Through this exposure I was able to establish the basis of my argument for my investigation. However a weakness is that when creating their own arguments and perspectives
Analysis Of The Return Of Martin Guerre By Natalie Zemon Davis
1354 Words | 6 PagesIn History: A Very Short Introduction, author John Arnold states, “A historian should be like a lawyer: balancing conflicting accounts trying to establish the exact sequence of events, treating ‘witnesses’(documents) with dispassionate and
Summary Of The Objectivity Question By Peter Novicks
627 Words | 3 PagesNovick states that while the typical understanding of a myth is something that is considered untrue or factual. He, on the other hand, views the idea of a myth as being a tool that can back historical objectivity as it works to rid historians and history of bias views of an event (Haskell, 3-4). Haskell states that his problem with Novick’s view of the definition of myth and objectivity. While Novick feels that objectivity shows a flaw, as a historian way of viewing and writing history from an opinionated stance, Haskell states that his view on the way Novick views the “myth of objectivity” is nothing more than a way for historians to “professionalize their discipline, enhance their dignity, and maximize their incomes” (Haskell,
Eisenhower's Domestic Affairs Analysis
398 Words | 2 PagesThis investigation of Eisenhower’s domestic affairs has given me insight into the methods, limitations, and challenges that historians face on a regular basis. I believe that I have learn more about how historians deal with different perspectives and the way time affects the way historians look at certain events. I learned that, when analyzing historical events, an essential skill is the ability to use a variety of sources in order to come to a well-informed conclusion. During this investigation, I had to read material written made by many different people. From the leader of civil right groups to Dwight D. Eisenhower, I had to gather information in order to make a proper judgement on Eisenhower’s administration and its effect on civil rights.
Dr. Bancroft's The Strange Death Of Silas Deane
1122 Words | 5 PagesWhen thinking about history in the past, I have always believed that it was straightforward. I knew that if I wanted to know something, I had to find the sources that contained the information. I had never thought about how that information came to be or why the author chose to include the information that he did. Reading “The Strange Death of Silas Deane,” helped me to see that everything is not as straightforward as it seems, and in order for you to completely have a full picture of something, you need to know all the information that is surrounding it.
Reshaping America's Racial Identity Analysis
986 Words | 4 PagesIn this section, you want to analyze the evidence the author uses in the text. What kind of evidence does the author use? Is some evidence more convincing to you than other kinds? Which ones? Which examples from the text represent strong evidence to support the author's claims?
Primary Sources Of The Stono Rebellion
1514 Words | 7 PagesPrimary sources are eminent for historians to discover events that occurred in the past, without such sources of information, there would be no knowledge of an incident. Some events can have many sources describing exactly what occurred, which is celebrated by historians as this gives a fuller picture of the past. However, some events have only one written surviving source- one such event is the Stono Rebellion. Therefore, historians are reliant on this source for all the information of the revolt, but it has still created controversy due to numerous reasons, such as the identity of the author, and the exact date. Both controversies will be explored later in this commentary.
Andrew Jackson Vs The Historians Analysis
513 Words | 3 PagesIn the journal article “ Andrew Jackson versus the Historians”, author Charles G. Sellers explained the various interpretations of Jackson, from the viewpoint of Whig historians and Progressive Historians. These interpretations were based on the policies of Jackson. The Whig historians viewed the former president in a negative way. They considered him arrogant, ignorant, and not fit for being president. Sellers pointed out that it was not just because of “Jackson’s personality…nor was it the general policies he pursued as president”
Howard Zinn A People's History Analysis
1637 Words | 7 Pages“In that inevitable taking of sides which comes from selection and emphasis in history, I prefer to try to tell the story of the discovery of America from the viewpoint of the Arawaks, of the Constitution from the standpoint of the slaves, of Andrew Jackson as seen by the Cherokees…” (Zinn, A People’s History of the United States, pg. 10). Society as a whole expects historians to be impartial, to report the events of the past as they happened, without incorporating their own thoughts into these events. We choose to believe that they are politically neutral, that they have no bias, and that they report history fairly and that everything occurred the way they say. However, as historian Howard Zinn points out in A People’s History, most historians have succumbed to the disturbing trend of glossing over and sugarcoating some of history’s most horrific events, excusing them as necessary for “progress,” and then moving on.
9/11 Memorial Museum Research Paper
692 Words | 3 PagesHistory is a novel idea that has been a continuous idea throughout our time in class. We have gone over what history means to us, the students; as well as the authors and filmmakers we have studied. For me, before this class, History merely meant what we
Primary Sources On The Positive Outcomes Of Mccarthyism
462 Words | 2 PagesA historian is an expert in or student of history. Historian need to use perspective, interpretation, secondary and primary sources and articles. For my investigation I used secondary sources, perspective and interpretation. The sources I encountered were bias because they were taken from a Americans point of view. It would have been drastically different if it was from a communist or soviet perspective.
The Return Of Martin Guerre Summary
425 Words | 2 PagesIn the humanities conception, history is described as the study of how people process and document the human experience as a function of culture, religion, economics, and overall human affairs. Psychology, the study of the human mind and its functions, is in essence, the driving factor of history, as it serves as the explanation for what causes humans to participate or perform certain actions within a given context or culture. In combining both history and psychology, Natalie Z. Davis provides two possible versions, not just one narrow perspective. In this sense, Davis provides a holistic historical interpretation, not limited to
Trouillot Silencing The Past Analysis
624 Words | 3 PagesTrouillot helps us grasp the idea that it is important to know that the most honest historians will try to tell the story as accurately as possible from the data. At the same time, many parts of the past get “silenced”, being forgotten about, pushed aside or passed over. Trouillot gives beneficial information that can be applied to our own studies about how this selective “silencing”
New Historicism In Slaughterhouse-Five
1106 Words | 5 PagesHistory does not always convey the absolute truth. It offers only one side of the story. The strong and powerful voices always drown out the sounds of the weak and beaten. The winner’s word will always be taken over the loser’s. The content that lies within the textbooks was not written by the defeated.
Documentation Of History In The Nineteenth Century
490 Words | 2 PagesDocumentation of history is a reflection of the values and morals of the time, compared and contrasted with the issues of the past, by people closely connected to those values and morals. History has been spoken and written down for millennia by both ordinary and extraordinary people. American history is merely an extension of that tradition, with three defined periods of documentation: the Puritans, in the sixteenth century, a closely knit religious sect; the patricians, men educated using what the Puritans would consider pagan texts, defying the Church’s hold upon them; and the professionals, people trained and educated for the process of researching and teaching about history, who used all manner of documents for their scholarly analysis in a way to affect change. The Puritans fled to America to establish their own community, entrusting their clergymen and political leaders, true men of God, with the recording of their history.
The University Of Rhode Island Historiography Review
516 Words | 3 PagesThese are not the only reasons that historiography is important when forming a stance on a specific topic. Historiographical research helps develop a fuller understanding on a topic and creates a more educated interpretation. Similarly, when historiography is included in a paper, it gives that paper more credibility and the writer more perceived authority on the topic by displaying this thorough understanding of the topic. Furthermore, by evaluating the past research that has been done on a topic, it helps the writer avoid potentially plagiarizing a source that they might not have known about otherwise and give the writer a chance to formally recognize the scholarship and authors that have previously written on a
More about Historians Strengths
Analysis Of The Return Of Martin Guerre By Natalie Zemon Davis
1354 Words | 6 PagesSummary Of The Objectivity Question By Peter Novicks
627 Words | 3 PagesEisenhower's Domestic Affairs Analysis
398 Words | 2 PagesDr. Bancroft's The Strange Death Of Silas Deane
1122 Words | 5 PagesReshaping America's Racial Identity Analysis
986 Words | 4 PagesPrimary Sources Of The Stono Rebellion
1514 Words | 7 PagesAndrew Jackson Vs The Historians Analysis
513 Words | 3 PagesHoward Zinn A People's History Analysis
1637 Words | 7 Pages9/11 Memorial Museum Research Paper
692 Words | 3 PagesPrimary Sources On The Positive Outcomes Of Mccarthyism
462 Words | 2 PagesThe Return Of Martin Guerre Summary
425 Words | 2 PagesTrouillot Silencing The Past Analysis
624 Words | 3 PagesNew Historicism In Slaughterhouse-Five
1106 Words | 5 PagesDocumentation Of History In The Nineteenth Century
490 Words | 2 PagesThe University Of Rhode Island Historiography Review
516 Words | 3 Pages